You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cant see the wood for the trees, SP on transfers
November 16 2026 6.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cant see the wood for the trees, SP on transfers


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Maine Eagle Flag USA 15 Oct 18 3.17pm

Did anyone else listen to Parish on FYP speak about the transfer policy and recent signings?

Someone rolled out a stat about the 7 most recent signings basically not playing for the club regularly yet. Jach, Rakip, Sorloth, Meyer, Guaita, Kouyate, Ayew.

First thing he said was we sometimes sign players to make sure we have an 11 on 11 in training.........

I was wondering if I heard that correctly, but he actually said that.

He initially stated he was absolutely thrilled with recent transfer business, that we couldnt have done any better. Old Steve then backed off a bit and said that some mistakes were made.

Most comedic moment was when he was listed all the positives behind each player, and said about Sorloth after a short pause "he had a good game at West Brom". Says it all really. Sorloth should have gone out on loan immediately, he is absolutely nowhere near Premier League level.

How anyone can look at our attacking options and think we did well on that front in recent transfer windows is beyond my comprehension. Kouyate and Meyer were good signings, make no bones about it, but in terms of forwards we are seriously lacking, again.

Never thought I would say this but I think we really could use Bakary Sako right now, he would definitely be starting.

When oh when will we properly manage our squad and ensure the manager has quality and diverse options in all areas of the pitch?

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 15 Oct 18 3.24pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Did anyone else listen to Parish on FYP speak about the transfer policy and recent signings?

Someone rolled out a stat about the 7 most recent signings basically not playing for the club regularly yet. Jach, Rakip, Sorloth, Meyer, Guaita, Kouyate, Ayew.

First thing he said was we sometimes sign players to make sure we have an 11 on 11 in training.........

I was wondering if I heard that correctly, but he actually said that.

He initially stated he was absolutely thrilled with recent transfer business, that we couldnt have done any better. Old Steve then backed off a bit and said that some mistakes were made.

Most comedic moment was when he was listed all the positives behind each player, and said about Sorloth after a short pause "he had a good game at West Brom". Says it all really. Sorloth should have gone out on loan immediately, he is absolutely nowhere near Premier League level.

How anyone can look at our attacking options and think we did well on that front in recent transfer windows is beyond my comprehension. Kouyate and Meyer were good signings, make no bones about it, but in terms of forwards we are seriously lacking, again.

Never thought I would say this but I think we really could use Bakary Sako right now, he would definitely be starting.

When oh when will we properly manage our squad and ensure the manager has quality and diverse options in all areas of the pitch?

He also said something like, buying squad players who weren't that upset when they don't get picked for thd first team....or words to that effect. ...
He did come out with some bizarre comments. ..lots of stuttering.
One thing that tickled me was when he said everyone should support the team and how he's hardly missed a home or away game in the last 8 years. I think if I was getting a free seat in the directors box, I wouldn't miss too many either...

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 15 Oct 18 3.27pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

He also said something like, buying squad players who weren't that upset when they don't get picked for thd first team....or words to that effect. ...
He did come out with some bizarre comments. ..lots of stuttering.
One thing that tickled me was when he said everyone should support the team and how he's hardly missed a home or away game in the last 8 years. I think if I was getting a free seat in the directors box, I wouldn't miss too many either...

Or you could look at it that his seat cost him quite a few million in the first place.

 

premier fan Flag BR4 15 Oct 18 3.29pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

He also said something like, buying squad players who weren't that upset when they don't get picked for thd first team....or words to that effect. ...
He did come out with some bizarre comments. ..lots of stuttering.
One thing that tickled me was when he said everyone should support the team and how he's hardly missed a home or away game in the last 8 years. I think if I was getting a free seat in the directors box, I wouldn't miss too many either...

LOL - I think you'll find he's stumped up enough cash for his seat.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 15 Oct 18 4.41pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Did anyone else listen to Parish on FYP speak about the transfer policy and recent signings?

Someone rolled out a stat about the 7 most recent signings basically not playing for the club regularly yet. Jach, Rakip, Sorloth, Meyer, Guaita, Kouyate, Ayew.

First thing he said was we sometimes sign players to make sure we have an 11 on 11 in training.........

I was wondering if I heard that correctly, but he actually said that.

He initially stated he was absolutely thrilled with recent transfer business, that we couldnt have done any better. Old Steve then backed off a bit and said that some mistakes were made.

Most comedic moment was when he was listed all the positives behind each player, and said about Sorloth after a short pause "he had a good game at West Brom". Says it all really. Sorloth should have gone out on loan immediately, he is absolutely nowhere near Premier League level.

How anyone can look at our attacking options and think we did well on that front in recent transfer windows is beyond my comprehension. Kouyate and Meyer were good signings, make no bones about it, but in terms of forwards we are seriously lacking, again.

Never thought I would say this but I think we really could use Bakary Sako right now, he would definitely be starting.

When oh when will we properly manage our squad and ensure the manager has quality and diverse options in all areas of the pitch?

We should of attempted to get one striker of proven quality over all of these transfers if what he said on FYP was correct. If this had happened in Jan they would be a regular by now. Seemed a lot of straw clutching in that interview, trying to find any positive of a poor policy.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 15 Oct 18 5.18pm

Originally posted by premier fan

LOL - I think you'll find he's stumped up enough cash for his seat.

I know, my comment was a bit tongue in cheek. But if you listen to the podcast, he's saying what a good fan he is by going to all the matches abd other fans should do the same...

 

Kant Flag exeter 15 Oct 18 7.11pm

“I think you'll find he's stumped up enough cash for his seat.”

He took a financial risk for sure, but he’s now well up on the deal!

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 15 Oct 18 7.15pm

Originally posted by Kant

“I think you'll find he's stumped up enough cash for his seat.”

He took a financial risk for sure, but he’s now well up on the deal!

You find get my point....have you listened to the interview. He's comparing himself with 'normal' fans, most if who haven't got the time or money to attend every game home and away...

I give up on this one...

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 15 Oct 18 7.15pm


Originally posted by Kant

“I think you'll find he's stumped up enough cash for his seat.”

He took a financial risk for sure, but he’s now well up on the deal!

Risk v reward.

Jordan risked it. Look how that ended for the club.

Goldberg risked it. Look how that ended for the club.

Damned if you do, damned if you don’t!

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 15 Oct 18 8.24pm

My favourite comment was when speaking about Jach. He said something along the line of "he's been capped for Poland...' like that means something.

For example, Frazer Campbell was capped for England... Players get caps for all kinds of reasons, not all about talent.

Some people also think all international caps are equal or quote that a player (like Rakip) has played in the Champions League and it is akin to Messi.

Even if Jach was a regular for Poland what would that mean in the grand scheme of things? One of the best Polish defenders? Sorloth is a Norwegian international, so what?

If it means something to just be an international player then let's just go and buy more Welsh players or other home nations because it must mean they are class.

Or maybe I should just Google Faroe Island internationals?

(This post is written partly tongue-in-cheek though my sentiments are genuine)

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 15 Oct 18 8.46pm

Oh please

The signing of jach was done on the inclin of that scout that since chose to leave. They’ve all been under the remit of finding some gems. Obv the scouting system has been revamped since.

Sorloth was our managers choice and he has said so

Ayew May still come good

The way you are talking is that of someone who has already pre determined that they do not like Parrish.

The guys a f***ing palace god and some signings will be f*** ups. He can’t just say that can he? You don’t get many chairmen or managers admitting to that kind of stuff

Back him, even thru bulls*** answers, because I assure you, once he’s gone, unless some Chinese rich dick fancies us as his next monopoly chelseesque venture, it’s all downhill again when Parrish leaves.

 

.TUX. Flag 15 Oct 18 9.25pm

Originally posted by robdave2k


Risk v reward.

Jordan risked it. Look how that ended for the club.

Goldberg risked it. Look how that ended for the club.

Damned if you do, damned if you don’t!

This.

The bottom line is that we are still very much a tin-pot club in one of the biggest leagues on the planet.
Attracting 'quality' will always be a struggle.
The move to a new stadium would've been ideal in this regard but sadly..........

 


Buy Litecoin.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 15 Oct 18 10.25pm

Steve Parish has only ever had one approach. Spend as little as possible.

I have said from day one that it is a recipe for disaster, hoping that I am wrong every season.

As I have said before, Parish mistakes luck for judgement.
Right now he has all his fingers and toes crossed that Wickham comes back and scores goals and that Ayew suddenly stops being bang average relegation fodder and steps up.

The fact is that we have to sign another quality striker because Benteke might not be back for months and is likely to be crap anyway and Sorloth will never be good enough. This is what happens when you do things on the cheap.

 

Jacey Flag 16 Oct 18 10.03am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Did anyone else listen to Parish on FYP speak about the transfer policy and recent signings?

Someone rolled out a stat about the 7 most recent signings basically not playing for the club regularly yet. Jach, Rakip, Sorloth, Meyer, Guaita, Kouyate, Ayew.

First thing he said was we sometimes sign players to make sure we have an 11 on 11 in training.........

I was wondering if I heard that correctly, but he actually said that.

He initially stated he was absolutely thrilled with recent transfer business, that we couldnt have done any better. Old Steve then backed off a bit and said that some mistakes were made.

Most comedic moment was when he was listed all the positives behind each player, and said about Sorloth after a short pause "he had a good game at West Brom". Says it all really. Sorloth should have gone out on loan immediately, he is absolutely nowhere near Premier League level.

How anyone can look at our attacking options and think we did well on that front in recent transfer windows is beyond my comprehension. Kouyate and Meyer were good signings, make no bones about it, but in terms of forwards we are seriously lacking, again.

Never thought I would say this but I think we really could use Bakary Sako right now, he would definitely be starting.

When oh when will we properly manage our squad and ensure the manager has quality and diverse options in all areas of the pitch?

Poor deluded Steve also quoted as saying we will be OK in the next five fixtures and will surprise a few people.
It will truly surprise me if we get one point against those top sides.

 

becky Flag over the moon 16 Oct 18 10.32am

Originally posted by Jacey

Poor deluded Steve also quoted as saying we will be OK in the next five fixtures and will surprise a few people.
It will truly surprise me if we get one point against those top sides.

Why? This is Palace - we've done it before, played like a championship side against worse sides, then turned up on the day and played like a world class team against top 6 opposition.

I'm with Steve on this one - reckon we could come out the other end with a surprise point or 3.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Bangell Flag Oxford 16 Oct 18 11.12am

Listening to him say that we buy players just to have 11 vs 11 in training, or we buy players who will be happy to sit on the bench, I found myself hoping that he was making bulls*** excuses rather than actually describing aspects of our transfer policy.

 

steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 16 Oct 18 12.27pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

He also said something like, buying squad players who weren't that upset when they don't get picked for thd first team....or words to that effect. ...
He did come out with some bizarre comments. ..lots of stuttering.
One thing that tickled me was when he said everyone should support the team and how he's hardly missed a home or away game in the last 8 years. I think if I was getting a free seat in the directors box, I wouldn't miss too many either...

To be fair, he did used to go before he purchased the club, he sat in the directors seat next to where my season ticket was in the main stand.

 

PatrickA Flag London 16 Oct 18 3.14pm

In my view we seem ok when buying solid consistent professionals such as Mcarthur, Dann and Tomkins.
We seem to struggle when we shell out big money which is big commitment with our resources.
We have tried to distance ourselves from clubs such as Brighton and Burnley who would never have purchased Benteke or Sakho but the jury is out as to whether we have had value.
They are I think around 27 years old so there’s still time.
However, the expenditure on them seems to have restricted our flexibility in recent windows .

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Oct 18 4.07pm

Originally posted by steph_eagle

To be fair, he did used to go before he purchased the club, he sat in the directors seat next to where my season ticket was in the main stand.

Apropos the Directors Box I am informed there is a waiting list for those who wish to avail of such a facility, perhaps many loyal supporters, and perhaps the reason is that corporate guests are the priority! I have heard about a loyal supporter whose car park space in the Directors Car Park is to be revoked from next season perhaps for the same reason.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 16 Oct 18 4.15pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Listening to him say that we buy players just to have 11 vs 11 in training, or we buy players who will be happy to sit on the bench, I found myself hoping that he was making bulls*** excuses rather than actually describing aspects of our transfer policy.

Couldnt agree more. Listening to the chairman of a Premier League side say we sign players to make the numbers in training, and try to make it sound as if Sorloth is doing really well for us, all sounds a bit deluded.

Seems to be going around lately. RH keeps saying we are putting in good performances, when it seems pretty clear we are totally unable to break down moderately well drilled defenses. If you get a goal at Selhurst, its game over, even if its in the first minute.

Listen carefully to what SP said when asked about our overall strategy on transfers, and its kind of clear; we dont have one.

Lack of "joined up thinking" runs through our club all over the place. Benteke had an abysmal season last year (not a few games, an entire season), Wickham is questionable to get back to his former levels, and Sako walked. So we sign Alex Sorloth, who couldnt cut it in the Eredivisie in Holland, and Ayew who has had about 1 shot on goal in 5 games.

Our second biggest goal threat after Zaha is our left back. And some folks wonder why we cant score any goals at home.

January will be a big window for us to solve our striker issues, unless Wickham can miraculously come good. Solving issues in transfer windows is not Steve's forte however. Seem to remember Freddie Ladapo being the only fit striker at the club not so long ago.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cant see the wood for the trees, SP on transfers