You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Investment required?
November 16 2026 6.31am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Investment required?


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
davehuggins Flag 14 Jan 19 7.48pm

Listening to RH interview after the Warford game he said Palace are looking for free or loans only (bargain basement) deals as we don't have the funds available. I find this a bit depressing to say the least, how are we ever going to progress? So does this mean we need more new investment?

 

leejaneagles Flag 14 Jan 19 7.57pm

They can stick their stadium where the son don't shine if this is the real reason for no investment but I highly doubt it's the case and just an excuse.

I think we're some of the better fans out of the Premier League lot and would understand if a big shiny Academy had just been built in South Croydon and we signed a load of Chelsea/Tottenham/Arsenal under 16 talent with the clear direction of putting a Youth infrastructure in place.

That isn't the case though. They have grand ideas of a stadium plan that will never happen and if it does, how are we going to fill it either in a relegation Prem scrap with hardly any wins at home or more likely down in the Championship.

Tottenham are a great example of how to do it - buy the players to attain your target and then focus on the Stadium and freeze the funds.

Tottenham have never had ambitions to win the league (despite what their fans think) but consistent top 4 finishes was the priority. Once they attained that after spending big on the likes or Lloris, Eriksen etc, they moved onto the Stadium.

Typical Palace though, our ambition is comfortable 10th consistently and we aren't quite there yet, spend another 2 years getting that in place and fine, do your stadium but stop trying to run before you can walk.

 

sotac464 Flag Berkshire 14 Jan 19 8.03pm

I do wonder what the Americans were brought in for,our last few transfer windows have been shocking. We badly need quality signings who can go straight into the first team. This squad minus Yohan has been together for 2-3 years.

I think the Americans get an easy ride, as the Palace fans vent there frustrations at Parrish.

We also seem to be the only club who abides by ffp. Everton for instance were always buying at the lower end of the market.  Farhad Moshiri comes in and they start signing £50 million pound players.

 


My equalibrium unbalanced me. Paul Draper Brighton 19/2/2018

davehuggins Flag 14 Jan 19 8.04pm

Yep, depressing outlook if no new arrivals to strengthen

 

leejaneagles Flag 14 Jan 19 8.17pm

Someone needs to sort that FFP thing as well, you're right.

A little bit like my rant above (don't worry I won't go that long on this) I think FFP is an excuse but if it is actually true, can we hire an experienced football Accountant to figure out how literally every other team bar possibly Cardiff get away with it?

I know the correct solution is to make every other club copy Palace and actually follow the rules but as that seems impossible can we start cheating it ourselves please? We signed Benteke and Sakho for relatively big money (around 50 mil staggered over separate transfer windows) and it's somehow crippled the club for at least 3 Windows. Why?

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 14 Jan 19 8.41pm

Don't really need anyone.

 

sotac464 Flag Berkshire 14 Jan 19 9.04pm

Just listened to that interview and he categorically states that we are in for free transfers and loans only.

I honestly don't think we'll get anyone then, because if they are sitting on the bench of another club, they're not going to be any better than what we've got.

 


My equalibrium unbalanced me. Paul Draper Brighton 19/2/2018

davehuggins Flag 14 Jan 19 9.09pm

My point exactly, do we have any ambition to go further?

 

Kant Flag exeter 14 Jan 19 9.22pm

Originally posted by sotac464

I do wonder what the Americans were brought in for,our last few transfer windows have been shocking.

I believe they were ‘brought in’ by SP and Co because they wanted to sell some of their shares in our club. And personally I wouldn’t blame our owners for cashing out and securing their financial futures.

The American investors are just that; investors. They are not sugar daddies. They have no secondary agenda. They have no affiliation to the club. It’s purely financial. They have invested their money to reap a return and make a profit.

Any proposed transfer must therefore satisfy this business objective. And given the relatively modest rewards for finishing higher up the table it is my guess that their strategy will be to spend the minimum amount to avoid relegation. After all, where’s the incentive to shell out tens of millions of pounds simply to finish 9th or 10th when the extra prize money for doing so won’t even come close to covering those costs, let alone generate a return.

In this context RH’s bargain basement comments make perfect sense.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 14 Jan 19 9.26pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

My point exactly, do we have any ambition to go further?

Our ambition is the fault of failing to score quite easy opportunities at this moment in time, but we have been fairly consistent in creating good opportunities in this league and that is a good base for the clubs ambition for now.

Luck has been against us, many clubs below would love to have just luck to worry about.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 14 Jan 19 9.29pm

Originally posted by Kant

I believe they were ‘brought in’ by SP and Co because they wanted to sell some of their shares in our club. And personally I wouldn’t blame our owners for cashing out and securing their financial futures.

The American investors are just that; investors. They are not sugar daddies. They have no secondary agenda. They have no affiliation to the club. It’s purely financial. They have invested their money to reap a return and make a profit.

Any proposed transfer must therefore satisfy this business objective. And given the relatively modest rewards for finishing higher up the table it is my guess that their strategy will be to spend the minimum amount to avoid relegation. After all, where’s the incentive to shell out tens of millions of pounds simply to finish 9th or 10th when the extra prize money for doing so won’t even come close to covering those costs, let alone generate a return.

In this context RH’s bargain basement comments make perfect sense.

Quite so.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 14 Jan 19 9.47pm

I also saw someone mention on Twitter at the weekend because the way FFP works we have a fairly hefty sum too play with in the Summer window (Don't ask me how )

 


Pro USA & Israel

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 14 Jan 19 9.49pm

Originally posted by Kant

I believe they were ‘brought in’ by SP and Co because they wanted to sell some of their shares in our club. And personally I wouldn’t blame our owners for cashing out and securing their financial futures.

The American investors are just that; investors. They are not sugar daddies. They have no secondary agenda. They have no affiliation to the club. It’s purely financial. They have invested their money to reap a return and make a profit.

Any proposed transfer must therefore satisfy this business objective. And given the relatively modest rewards for finishing higher up the table it is my guess that their strategy will be to spend the minimum amount to avoid relegation. After all, where’s the incentive to shell out tens of millions of pounds simply to finish 9th or 10th when the extra prize money for doing so won’t even come close to covering those costs, let alone generate a return.

In this context RH’s bargain basement comments make perfect sense.


I agree this seems to be the strategy. However could be argued this is being managed too finely and it runs the serious risk of a bit of bad luck leading to a very expensive relegation. Would seem more prudent to fund a mid-table squad to make this scenario very unlikely rather than an annual possibility.

 

davehuggins Flag 14 Jan 19 9.51pm

So true, how expensive would relegation be and we flirt with it most seasons

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 14 Jan 19 10.18pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster


I agree this seems to be the strategy. However could be argued this is being managed too finely and it runs the serious risk of a bit of bad luck leading to a very expensive relegation. Would seem more prudent to fund a mid-table squad to make this scenario very unlikely rather than an annual possibility.

You make it sound so easy. So, who do you buy, how much do you spend, how much salary do you offer, how do you convince them to come to Palace? Then, how do you guarantee that you get results? Fulham have just spent a fortune and I mean a fortune on new players and what gave the got to show for it?

Do you think there is some sort of entitlement that comes with spending money?

Finally put yourself in the owners shoes. Do you think that spending another say £100m will put us in Europe, because if there is no guarantee, then why would they do it and if we got there how would we cope with it (Burnley). Unless you have a philanthropist owner pulling the purse strings, which clearly the Americans are not, then they will do just enough to try and protect their investment and nick as much money out as they can. It’s the way of the world and I don’t know why anyone thinks football should be any different to other businesses. Our biggest problem as fans is that football is our passion, not our business. Massive difference between the two.

 

davehuggins Flag 14 Jan 19 10.26pm

Some good points in your post, Fulham went crazy and imported to many players at once that is for sure. We need to invest in the strength of the squad and mostly on a finisher. I am not advocating spending 100's ml just not buying rubbish we have wasted money on in the window 12 months ago (joke IMO)

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 14 Jan 19 10.33pm

How hasn't everyone worked out that the model is high salaries for the board members until the inevitable relegation?

SP's PR abilities aren't that good. The forever tomorrow stadium, lick of paint to and some new seats to make it seem like something's going on and absolutely no investment in youth should've put everyone onto him ages ago.

Most of the staff in key positions are not qualified for their roles, they're just former palace favourites to prevent any real criticism. Wake up people!

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 14 Jan 19 11.57pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

How hasn't everyone worked out that the model is high salaries for the board members until the inevitable relegation?

SP's PR abilities aren't that good. The forever tomorrow stadium, lick of paint to and some new seats to make it seem like something's going on and absolutely no investment in youth should've put everyone onto him ages ago.

Most of the staff in key positions are not qualified for their roles, they're just former palace favourites to prevent any real criticism. Wake up people!

The development plan for Selhurst Park/ Crystal Palace Football Club is pure fantasy. We're just rolling along until the wheels fall off and tv money dries up. I'd still expect to see minimalist interventions from the board to prolong a return on their respective interests but they're all dipping their snouts not investing in the future of a football club. Expect very little and you won't be disappointed!

Edited by Henry of Peckham (15 Jan 2019 12.19am)

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

JoeViper Flag bromley 15 Jan 19 12.59am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

How hasn't everyone worked out that the model is high salaries for the board members until the inevitable relegation?

Does SP take a salary? Does anyone know what he pays himself?

 


One of the biggest mysteries in life is that loud stupid people normally don't have even the slightest inclination that they are stupid.

Wilbraham413 Flag 15 Jan 19 2.02am

How is it financial fair play if the top 6 clubs can buy whatever players they want, but no one below them is allowed to do it?

"Fair Play" would be forcing the same salary cap on all 20 teams, so City would be dumpster diving for free transfer bench players the same way that we are. Liverpool debates whether to buy Ronaldo or Messi, and we debate whether to buy a crippled 40 year old from Lyon, or a Torquay bench warmer, or the top goal scorer from the Eastern Macedonia League. Fair play!

Honestly, FFP is the biggest load of crap I've ever heard of, and I don't even understand what it's supposed to accomplish, other than to keep the bottom feeders from ever having a chance to get better.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Investment required?