You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jimmy Mac
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jimmy Mac


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 30 Mar 19 8.14pm

I wonder if all the Meyer must start in place of Jimmy Mac will be so vocal after today’s performance.After being inafective in the first half,giving the ball away or passing backwards ,he was rightly replaced by Jimmy for the second half who didn’t put a foot wrong and in my opinion was a major reason we went on to win a game without playing well .He should only be used as a sub when the game is stretched when we need a plan B please note Maine Eagle!!

 

Robk Flag 30 Mar 19 8.37pm

I actually thought Meyer did ok in the First Half and was unlucky to be taken off... thought that one of the others would have gone before him.. Technically he’s very good and perhaps should play on the left with Wilf who’s on the same wavelength as him...

 

Painter Flag Croydon 30 Mar 19 9.15pm

Originally posted by Robk

I actually thought Meyer did ok in the First Half and was unlucky to be taken off... thought that one of the others would have gone before him.. Technically he’s very good and perhaps should play on the left with Wilf who’s on the same wavelength as him...

You must of been watching a different game. He hardly touched the ball. We were so much better after his departure.

 

Alex1991 Flag Ashford 30 Mar 19 9.32pm

Very surprised he started today, it was never going to be his day. Had he come on after 60 minutes it might have been very different. If I was him I'd have felt a bit stitched up because Hodgson got that decision very wrong.

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 30 Mar 19 10.21pm

McArthur clearly a better player. Hope Max lives up to his billing and wages soon.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 30 Mar 19 10.25pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

McArthur clearly a better player. Hope Max lives up to his billing and wages soon.

I felt a bit sorry for Meyer. He didn't play badly and didn't give the ball away cheaply unlike some. However McArthur is a niggling combative individual and he was what we needed in the 2nd half.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 30 Mar 19 10.39pm

Originally posted by Pete53

I felt a bit sorry for Meyer. He didn't play badly and didn't give the ball away cheaply unlike some. However McArthur is a niggling combative individual and he was what we needed in the 2nd half.

McArthur is a much better player than has been suggested by many on here. Meyer, on the other hand, has had excuse after excuse made for him.

Would really like him to succeed but looks an absolute luxury. He can’t beat a player, doesn’t seem to find space and looks lazy and offers so little when the opposition have the ball.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 30 Mar 19 10.48pm

I have said many times

Meyer is fine as a super sub but isn’t strong and aggressive enough to start

McArthur is hugely influential and well worth his place

 

Mathers Flag 30 Mar 19 10.49pm

There is no question that McArhur is one of the best/ most consistent performers at the club.

If Roy persists with the 4-3-3 then the best midfielders are Luka, Kouyate and Macca. Unfortunately he is losing his marbles so consistently plays Schlupp despite the fact he hasn’t a clue how to play CM.

Meyer could be quality but he will take 5+ games starting as CAM to really bed in and we aren’t able to offer that guarantee.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 30 Mar 19 11.16pm

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

I wonder if all the Meyer must start in place of Jimmy Mac will be so vocal after today’s performance.After being inafective in the first half,giving the ball away or passing backwards ,he was rightly replaced by Jimmy for the second half who didn’t put a foot wrong and in my opinion was a major reason we went on to win a game without playing well .He should only be used as a sub when the game is stretched when we need a plan B please note Maine Eagle!!

Seeing as you mentioned me....

Roy may not be doing it deliberately but he is on a stitch up of Meyer, there is no other explanation.

The whole team, the whole performance was crap first half. Meyer had some neat touches, and on one occasion he harried and won the ball back well, and launched an attack.

He was playing much, much better than Schlupp.

Second half things opened up and while I will admit MacArthur actually affected the game when it became a but more stretched, but this is EXACTLY when Meyer should have been out there.

Once again though Roy stitches him up and hooks him at half time (he never makes subs at half time), like starting him in physical away games.

Max Meyer was one of the most highly touted young prospects to come out of Germany in years. Please dont expect me to believe he has become a sh&t player overnight. Hodgson has a lot to answer for destroying the guy's confidence and not letting him get into any kind of rhythm here.

The way Hodgson has managed him has been nothing short of very, VERY poor. You can say all you like that he hasnt taken his chances but any player coming from a foreign league, especially one who isnt the strongest physically, needs a proper run of games and some stability.

Roy hasnt got a clue how to bed in new signings, except ones on loan that we cannot buy anyway, they start every week.

Kouyate should be starting for one.

Mark my words, Meyer will leave Palace behind and go on to become a very high class and highly regarded player in the game. He is too good for the way Hodgson sets us up, it completely doesn't play to any of his strengths.

So why the F did we sign him?

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

matthau Flag South Croydon 30 Mar 19 11.20pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Seeing as you mentioned me....

Roy may not be doing it deliberately but he is on a stitch up of Meyer, there is no other explanation.

The whole team, the whole performance was crap first half. Meyer had some neat touches, and on one occasion he harried and won the ball back well, and launched an attack.

He was playing much, much better than Schlupp.

Second half things opened up and while I will admit MacArthur actually affected the game when it became a but more stretched, but this is EXACTLY when Meyer should have been out there.

Once again though Roy stitches him up and hooks him at half time (he never makes subs at half time), like starting him in physical away games.

Max Meyer was one of the most highly touted young prospects to come out of Germany in years. Please dont expect me to believe he has become a sh&t player overnight. Hodgson has a lot to answer for destroying the guy's confidence and not letting him get into any kind of rhythm here.

The way Hodgson has managed him has been nothing short of very, VERY poor. You can say all you like that he hasnt taken his chances but any player coming from a foreign league, especially one who isnt the strongest physically, needs a proper run of games and some stability.

Roy hasnt got a clue how to bed in new signings, except ones on loan that we cannot buy anyway, they start every week.

Kouyate should be starting for one.

Mark my words, Meyer will leave Palace behind and go on to become a very high class and highly regarded player in the game. He is too good for the way Hodgson sets us up, it completely doesn't play to any of his strengths.

So why the F did we sign him?

Your last point only makes sense if you are correct in your assumptions

 

Username Flag Horsham 31 Mar 19 3.32am

Originally posted by Alex1991

Very surprised he started today, it was never going to be his day. Had he come on after 60 minutes it might have been very different. If I was him I'd have felt a bit stitched up because Hodgson got that decision very wrong.

When exactly is his day going to be?

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Username Flag Horsham 31 Mar 19 3.36am

Originally posted by Pete53

I felt a bit sorry for Meyer. He didn't play badly and didn't give the ball away cheaply unlike some. However McArthur is a niggling combative individual and he was what we needed in the 2nd half.

He didn't give the ball away because he barely did anything. Wasn't offering himself as an option at all.

The worst moment was when he, as the 'playmaker' of the three in midfield had the opportunity to play in Wilf on the counter, and instead chose to pass the buck and rolled it 2 yards to his left to Schlupp who a) is clearly not as good a passer and b) had a much worse angle to attempt the final pass and it promptly rolled straight through to the keeper.

If he's not going to open a team up in moments like that, what is he there for?

He's looked great coming on when space has opened up, but his performances as a starter have nearly all been poor.

Edited by Username (31 Mar 2019 3.37am)

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Neilsym26 Flag Bromley 31 Mar 19 7.10am

Originally posted by Mathers

There is no question that McArhur is one of the best/ most consistent performers at the club.

If Roy persists with the 4-3-3 then the best midfielders are Luka, Kouyate and Macca. Unfortunately he is losing his marbles so consistently plays Schlupp despite the fact he hasn’t a clue how to play CM.

Meyer could be quality but he will take 5+ games starting as CAM to really bed in and we aren’t able to offer that guarantee.

100% Agree with this, I hate jumping on players but Schlupp is terrible in midfield, he is such a passenger. He has 1 or 2 moments in 5 or 6 games, No where near good enough. He dosent seem to want to make space, show for the ball or press quickly enough. Meyer/Macca Koutaye and Luca ( who could do with a kick up the arse sometimes).

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 31 Mar 19 8.03am

I may be wrong but I don’t think Roy is involved in transfers. So he tries to fit the players in he gets given.
His handling of Meyer has been very odd. Yesterday’s game many things happened that should have been ironed out at Beckenham.
Playing Meyer for one half made no sense. Having said that, bringing on Macca for Meyer definitely worked.
Modern day football is very complex and I’m not sure I fully get it. I like watching it though and I like watching Palace win.
Yet again we missed so many chances nearly all in the second half.
Still, much better than not having the chances like the first half.

 

the.universal 31 Mar 19 8.42am

Meyer is not that good for us. Some fans love him because he is technically very good and looks silky on the ball, however where is the end product?

Players like McArthur, Luka, Kouyate are far ahead of him in midfielder terms, hence why they get played a lot more.

Meyer is a luxury player, not solid enough to play as a centre mid, not really a wide player and does not work hard enough to play in the type of number 10 role we sometimes play.

And he’s tiny. Nothing wrong with that, there are some great small midfielders, but these tend to be the absolute creme de la creme technically, and also very good at shielding the ball and using their strength. Meyer is not in that class.

I think he’d benefit from a move away from the prem.

A rich man’s Owen Garvan.

 


Vive le Roy!

Neilsym26 Flag Bromley 31 Mar 19 9.04am

Originally posted by the.universal

Meyer is not that good for us. Some fans love him because he is technically very good and looks silky on the ball, however where is the end product?

Players like McArthur, Luka, Kouyate are far ahead of him in midfielder terms, hence why they get played a lot more.

Meyer is a luxury player, not solid enough to play as a centre mid, not really a wide player and does not work hard enough to play in the type of number 10 role we sometimes play.

And he’s tiny. Nothing wrong with that, there are some great small midfielders, but these tend to be the absolute creme de la creme technically, and also very good at shielding the ball and using their strength. Meyer is not in that class.

I think he’d benefit from a move away from the prem.

A rich man’s Owen Garvan.

To be fair it's not as if Meyer has had a decent run! Must be quite frustrating for a top player!!

 

the.universal 31 Mar 19 9.12am

Originally posted by Neilsym26

To be fair it's not as if Meyer has had a decent run! Must be quite frustrating for a top player!!

You don’t get given a run, you have to earn it. So far Meyer hasn’t earned it with his displays.

People were saying similar about Sorloth. Then the penny dropped that he’s not very good.

 


Vive le Roy!

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 31 Mar 19 9.17am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Seeing as you mentioned me....

Roy may not be doing it deliberately but he is on a stitch up of Meyer, there is no other explanation.

The whole team, the whole performance was crap first half. Meyer had some neat touches, and on one occasion he harried and won the ball back well, and launched an attack.

He was playing much, much better than Schlupp.

Second half things opened up and while I will admit MacArthur actually affected the game when it became a but more stretched, but this is EXACTLY when Meyer should have been out there.

Once again though Roy stitches him up and hooks him at half time (he never makes subs at half time), like starting him in physical away games.

Max Meyer was one of the most highly touted young prospects to come out of Germany in years. Please dont expect me to believe he has become a sh&t player overnight. Hodgson has a lot to answer for destroying the guy's confidence and not letting him get into any kind of rhythm here.

The way Hodgson has managed him has been nothing short of very, VERY poor. You can say all you like that he hasnt taken his chances but any player coming from a foreign league, especially one who isnt the strongest physically, needs a proper run of games and some stability.

Roy hasnt got a clue how to bed in new signings, except ones on loan that we cannot buy anyway, they start every week.

Kouyate should be starting for one.

Mark my words, Meyer will leave Palace behind and go on to become a very high class and highly regarded player in the game. He is too good for the way Hodgson sets us up, it completely doesn't play to any of his strengths.

So why the F did we sign him?


You still cannot give any praise for Jimmy though can you?

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 31 Mar 19 9.40am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Seeing as you mentioned me....

Roy may not be doing it deliberately but he is on a stitch up of Meyer, there is no other explanation.

The whole team, the whole performance was crap first half. Meyer had some neat touches, and on one occasion he harried and won the ball back well, and launched an attack.

He was playing much, much better than Schlupp.

Second half things opened up and while I will admit MacArthur actually affected the game when it became a but more stretched, but this is EXACTLY when Meyer should have been out there.

Once again though Roy stitches him up and hooks him at half time (he never makes subs at half time), like starting him in physical away games.

Max Meyer was one of the most highly touted young prospects to come out of Germany in years. Please dont expect me to believe he has become a sh&t player overnight. Hodgson has a lot to answer for destroying the guy's confidence and not letting him get into any kind of rhythm here.

The way Hodgson has managed him has been nothing short of very, VERY poor. You can say all you like that he hasnt taken his chances but any player coming from a foreign league, especially one who isnt the strongest physically, needs a proper run of games and some stability.

Roy hasnt got a clue how to bed in new signings, except ones on loan that we cannot buy anyway, they start every week.

Kouyate should be starting for one.

Mark my words, Meyer will leave Palace behind and go on to become a very high class and highly regarded player in the game. He is too good for the way Hodgson sets us up, it completely doesn't play to any of his strengths.

So why the F did we sign him?


This post is b@llox from start to finish

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jimmy Mac