You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace threaten ruin with or without Roy (article)
November 16 2026 5.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace threaten ruin with or without Roy (article)


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 06 Feb 20 11.55am

[Link]

This is a pretty good assessment of our current state. I can't see that there is a longterm vision for our football. Trying to get Roy to stay on for another year simply delays having to deal with a lack of direction. I don't think we're relegation fodder but will be soon if we don't have some sort of first team strategy.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 06 Feb 20 12.33pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

[Link]

This is a pretty good assessment of our current state. I can't see that there is a longterm vision for our football. Trying to get Roy to stay on for another year simply delays having to deal with a lack of direction. I don't think we're relegation fodder but will be soon if we don't have some sort of first team strategy.

Thanks FS. Don't disagree with that. We are heading for (or even in) the proverbial. Interesting that RH is currently second favourite to be the next prem manager to leave/lose his job.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Feb 20 12.52pm

Interesting article. I assume that Parish will have read it and it's a shame that he's unlikely to respond

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 06 Feb 20 1.01pm

Yeah, that article sums up where we are, and how we got here, perfectly. We're going to hell in a handcart and Parish is steering it.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

PatrickA Flag London 06 Feb 20 1.01pm

Difficult to disagree with much in this article.
I think Parish understands the long term issues and a couple of years ago identified 2 courses of action,
1) the building of the new stand with increased capacity and revenues
2) Achievement of Category A status and the ability to attract a quality of young player to progress to the first team.
However, for whatever reason at the moment the club appears rudderless and to put it kindly are treading water - or are going backwards if one wants to be critical.
Inevitably this leads to speculation.
So far I’ve heard,
‘Hodgson is unhappy not getting more players in the transfer window’
‘The club identified players but Hodgson turned them down’
‘Hodgson does/ does not want to stay (take your pick)’
‘The owners agreed/disagreed with the budget for the window (again take your pick)’.
There is little communication from the club and Parish is as quiet as he has been during his whole tenure.
I’ve little doubt he is a fan and is seeking to act in the club’s best interests but it is difficult to see a way forward at present.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 06 Feb 20 1.07pm

Good accurate assessment. We have run to a standstill due to deploying 'now' outdated workarounds, patches & fixes. You can only stick plasters on a gaping wound for so long ...

Something has to change, but what? It'll be Roy walking in the first instance whether we stay or or go down. We can't buy a win or a goal ... and with this bunch of players and Roy's exhausted system, I'm starting to think we could be the club that no one expected to go down ...


 

Bangell Flag Oxford 06 Feb 20 1.44pm

Just came on here to post that article myself. Completely correct.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Feb 20 1.50pm

The piece nicely articulated how I feel. Parish is making it up as he goes along, no coherent plan apart from chancing that Roy’s effective but ultimately dull football keeps Palace in the Premier League.

If I was Hodgson , if we stay up then I would turn down the contract extension because how much confidence can you have in Parish’s promise of meaningful transfer funds ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Feb 20 2.04pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

If I was Hodgson , if we stay up then I would turn down the contract extension because how much confidence can you have in Parish’s promise of meaningful transfer funds ?

He could always ask for a contract extension until the end of the transfer deadline day so that he could walk away if our transfer business was up to recent standards

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 06 Feb 20 2.06pm

I agree with nearly all of that. very insightful for the most part.

Although I put more blame on the owners not backing our managers for the 'merry-go-round' of which they make reference.

All managers(bar Warnock) stretching back to Holloway have left under rumours of not being backed in the transfer window. Even with Pulis I thought there was this rumour flying about. Allardyce was backed in January to fix glaring holes in our squad, but was never promised the funds in the summer, DeBoer said that they didn't buy the players he wanted and we all know what is happening with Hodgson.

Couple that with the mismanagement of players contracts (i.e. Benteke) and the problems lay squarely at the owners feet. Whereas the American owners situation is not helping they cannot take all of this blame as this was happening long before they came onto the scene. They are fully justified in not wanting to fund this continuing mismanagement.

I've said it before, but SPs Fear of another administration has led to bad decisions (see Contract offers). He's been burnt when spending money, and each time it hampers him more. he's looking after pennies, instead of making Pounds.

Edited by CrazyBadger (06 Feb 2020 2.07pm)

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Feb 20 2.45pm

Parish isn’t equipped to make football based decisions, plus he surrounds himself with acquiescent people (yes men). Eventually that’ll catch up with him.

There were attempts in January to buy from lower down the pyramid than we have been doing but they didn’t happen. If they don’t in the summer then we’re screwed. It’s as simple as that. I won’t even feel satisfied if we sign 3 very experienced top notch Prem players in their twilight years because it’s just delaying the inevitable, which is no doubt as part strategy of Parish’s while hoping a buyer comes in.

The article spells out we’re here by spending big and not much else and I’ve been saying for a long time that it’ll end in a bad way if we don’t implement any plans managed by football people with experience in these situations.

 


COYP

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 06 Feb 20 3.24pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Parish isn’t equipped to make football based decisions, plus he surrounds himself with acquiescent people (yes men). Eventually that’ll catch up with him.

There were attempts in January to buy from lower down the pyramid than we have been doing but they didn’t happen. If they don’t in the summer then we’re screwed. It’s as simple as that. I won’t even feel satisfied if we sign 3 very experienced top notch Prem players in their twilight years because it’s just delaying the inevitable, which is no doubt as part strategy of Parish’s while hoping a buyer comes in.

The article spells out we’re here by spending big and not much else and I’ve been saying for a long time that it’ll end in a bad way if we don’t implement any plans managed by football people with experience in these situations.

I agree; it's emperor's new clothes with Parish and a CEO who runs a business like that is inevitably destined to fail. The best managers employ the best people they can afford for their roles and take into account their contributions. Only those with oversized egos surround themselves with nodding dogs.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

The Dolphin Flag 06 Feb 20 4.10pm

Jeez - that is a great article and a fair assessment of where we are and what is happening.
Not a pretty sight!

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 06 Feb 20 4.25pm

Wdell written piece that details what I have felt over the last season and this. I will be very pleased if we manage to stay up this year.

Like every Summer I'll be hoping the club gets its act together. Whether we stay up or not this Summer threatens to be a defining time for the club.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 06 Feb 20 4.36pm

Ownership - there's probably enough money in the club for the American "owners" just to walk away with what they've put in ... and a little more for their trouble. Parrish is unusually quiet this season.

Infrastructure - there isn't any foreseeable chance of the ground being developed to boost the chance of attracting a new owner. Partly attributable to red tape but there has been no commitment to spend money.

Overrated - Wilf reckons he's worth nearly twice as much as he's currently paid but his transfer value must be dropping every week after less than sparkling performances on the pitch. Enough has been said often about Benteke and Sakho.

Plan A - we still get served the same boring tactics at every home game and have been crying out for a consistent striker to score goals for years now. There is no Plan B on the pitch.

Masterly inactivity or just chaos - even Roy has got the hump over the lack of transfer activity. We had an opportunity to move players on and get some in last month but did virtually nothing about it.

I am left with the impression that no one wants to be at Palace anymore. When was the last time the crowd was singing and rocking in the aisles? It looks bad all round.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

chris123 Flag hove actually 06 Feb 20 4.39pm

Difficult to disagree with any of it, sadly - would add our squad is 22 strong post window - there may be a reason, but it's totally beyond me.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 06 Feb 20 4.39pm

I've been one of the more patient fans in most regards, but it is hard to back the hierarchy when you look at the facts over the last few seasons. In the short-term it is imperative we find buyers to get the Americans out as Roy has previously publicly stated they are the barrier to spending, but as to the long-term plan that is something for which I hope someone is on top of!

The only one thing I would say is that although we have only won one game in the last 10 we did draw six with a severe injury list including no full-backs and no right winger, plus Tosun should be back after Everton. What will be telling is how the squad respond once everyone is fit. I do think we will stay up, but I think that is almost solely down to Roy & Ray rather than testament to Parish or the board's support.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Feb 20 5.15pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Ownership - there's probably enough money in the club for the American "owners" just to walk away with what they've put in ... and a little more for their trouble. Parrish is unusually quiet this season.

Infrastructure - there isn't any foreseeable chance of the ground being developed to boost the chance of attracting a new owner. Partly attributable to red tape but there has been no commitment to spend money.

Overrated - Wilf reckons he's worth nearly twice as much as he's currently paid but his transfer value must be dropping every week after less than sparkling performances on the pitch. Enough has been said often about Benteke and Sakho.

Plan A - we still get served the same boring tactics at every home game and have been crying out for a consistent striker to score goals for years now. There is no Plan B on the pitch.

Masterly inactivity or just chaos - even Roy has got the hump over the lack of transfer activity. We had an opportunity to move players on and get some in last month but did virtually nothing about it.

I am left with the impression that no one wants to be at Palace anymore. When was the last time the crowd was singing and rocking in the aisles? It looks bad all round.

Only if there’s a buyer. There isn’t £50mil at the bank or cash in hand, and even if there was, their share may be worth more. Probably not, but possibly. For them to walk away we’d have to sell Zaha and give them all the money, plus another play or two. Then without a rebuild of the team we and Parish will be back to the early 2010’s, or worse probably.

 


COYP

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 06 Feb 20 6.17pm

I do agree with the article but will try to put up a few counter points because I think some of it amounts to 'accepted wisdom'.

The article says we have no strategy. Then it points out we have high wages but low transfer spend.

I think high wages and low transfer spend can be a strategy (and is ours). And if we pick the right players, it can keep us up with lower risks than trying to pick the stars of tomorrow. We instinctively think it's easy to buy a 21 year old for £10m and sell him at 25 for £50m. Maybe it's not. Maybe you just buy lots of 21 year olds for £10m.

What really happened, what has been a truly awful thing, is the signings of Benteke and Sakho. Immense asset depreciation, immense wages. Insufficient benefit of any kind.

The rest -- and the intrinsic structural flaws that the club must address -- should all be seem in the context of those two horrific decisions. (Both of which I personally blame the yanks for in large part).

Now onto another counter point. I suspect our finances may be slowly improving. We aren't spending, that's true. And may be our coffers are filling with premier league riches. Yes we had an awful last set of accounts, but I'm optimistic about the next set...especially if we can finish in the top half of the table this term.

Now, let's just imagine we get 1 youth player (I like Pierrick) come through, and two talented youngsters are bought. It wouldn't be everything, but it would mark a shift. And a change of narrative.

Up the Palace.

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (06 Feb 2020 6.17pm)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Casual Flag Orpington 06 Feb 20 6.23pm

I was talking to Tony Cascarino today, he’s writing an article for one of the posh papers, can’t remember which one he said he works for, about Palace and how the fans have turned/are fu*ked of with the current regime/tactics. He was saying that the West Ham and Man Utd problems were obvious and public , but from the outside looking in we are fine, but our fans know it’s not.
Also said Roy was bang in trouble last Christmas, but we went on a good run that saved his job. Said to keep an eye on Kevin Campbell’s boy at Stoke, who he reckons will be a top player.
Also that the fella that owns Bolton was who brought Luka to Palace, think he was an agent at the time.
Right nice fella he was, see him about loads but never spoken to him, asked him if Dean Saunders was going to be back on talksport and ended up chatting for 10 minutes.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace threaten ruin with or without Roy (article)