You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 21 2026 10.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Some Questions for our Leftie, Liberal friends (LOCKED)


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
W12 11 Mar 20 6.27am

(....and Tories)

What is the difference between Nation and Country?

If division is bad, why is diversity good?

If a country’s division/diversity is a strength, is national unity a weakness?

Can you have socialism without national unity?

How will the European People be treated when they are the minority in Europe?

Who has the power to turn mass immigration on and off, the bankers or the workers?

How do bankers and property owners benefit from mass immigration, and how do struggling native workers who wish to buy a home to start a family benefit from mass immigration? Which group benefits the most?

If mass immigration hurt bankers and property owners instead of hurting workers and families, how long do you think it would take for mass immigration to stop?
Is everyone unique, or is everyone the same? What does this mean for “equality”?

Why should we want or expect Equal Outcomes, when difference, hierarchy, unequal outcomes, and inequality, are natural side effects of the reality of uniqueness?

Is it not true that when people are both free and unique, outcomes will differ? Which are you willing to do away with; freedom, uniqueness, or both?

Is there any measurable evidence in physical reality for equality of any kind?

Is the theory of evolution based on everyone being equal and the same, or on difference & inequality & the hierarchy of the fittest?

If being divided with diversity is a strength, and being united as a people makes you weak, then is it true: the less we have in common the more we get along?

Is man a part of nature, or apart from nature?

Does life have a biological foundation, or not?

If half the people are below average intelligence, how can democracy produce anything other than mediocrity? What can we do to limit the impact of this?

If diseased, deformed, below average IQ people outbreed healthy, well-formed, intelligent people for a few hundred or thousand years, what will the future look like?

Is [Forced Diversity + Forced Equality + Unintegrated MultiCultures + Unstoppable Mass Immigration + Democracy] the recipe for sustainable long term peace & stability? Or is it the recipe for unsustainable decline, conflict & disintegration?

Does multiculturalism solve more problems than it creates? What problems does it solve?

What problems are solved by importing non-western multi-cultures into the western world?

Was Aristotle correct, that democracy is only possible within homogeneous ethnic groups because despots always reign over highly fragmented societies?

Will mass immigration into western countries and communities bring peace & stability or conflict & dis-integration?

Which is more important for a healthy society: racial and ethnic diversity, or high social trust?

Which is more important for a country: sustainable self-sufficiency or globalism?

Do above average individuals and below average individuals exist, or does equality exist?

Does man complete woman, or does woman complete man?

Is it reasonable or evil for a woman to want her great-granddaughters to look and think like her?

Which is a greater measure of success for a society: economic growth, or the number of new families formed?

Is massive immigration into western countries from non-Western countries sustainable or unsustainable?

There are only 4 million Irish in Ireland — but 1.2 billion Africans in Africa, 1.4 billion Chinese in China, and 1.4 billion Indians in India — why then are Africans, Chinese and Indians who’re moving to Ireland called “minorities”?

When should mass immigration into the West stop; soon or never?

There are 10 million Swedish People in Sweden; if 10 million non-Swedes move to Sweden, what will we call it then?

Due to mass migration and birthrate pressure, the native British are due to become a minority in Britain this century – why is this good for the British?

Why is diversity being forced upon all white-majority countries and only white-majority countries?

If a diversity of tribes in the same geographic space is a strength, why does it require so much time, energy, money, and force, to implement and manage?

Can your country have both open borders and a welfare state, or can you only pick one?

Is mass immigration having a negative impact on the unity and cohesion of your nation?

What percentage of Latvia’s population should be of the Latvian ethnic group?

Why do you think the mainstream media didn’t report on the 257 bombings in Sweden that occurred during 2019, compared to the 0 in Poland and 0 in Hungary?

Why do you think we never hear about the 9.2 million African slaves living enslaved in Africa today?

As a H2O water molecule is to an ocean, what is the smallest possible unit of society: Is the individual a miniature version of society, or is the family unit a miniature version of society?

What is the difference between being nice and being kind, and which is more important?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Mar 20 6.36am

Some thought provoking questions there.

I don't normally join in with threads about race or religion but I have often wondered when people go on about diversity being good, why it is good as I don't think that I have ever heard an explanation

 

palace777 Flag belfast 11 Mar 20 6.41am

My God,someones been up all night googling, couldn't you get to sleep?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 11 Mar 20 7.33am

Are you in self-isolation W12?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 11 Mar 20 8.07am

I think I'll wait for WE to respond to this first.

Edited by Midlands Eagle (11 Mar 2020 9.38am)

 


One more point

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Mar 20 8.50am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Some thought provoking questions there.

I don't normally join in with threads about race or religion but I have often wondered when people go on about diversity being good, why it is good as I don't think that I have ever heard an explanation

A few black teenage girls did a feature on bbc tv London news. Must’ve been Tuesday yesterday. They highlighted they don’t have any white friends. They could but don’t. They ventured into Havering, the whitest London borough. They went into some day centre event for the retired and they said the reason they aren’t mixing with ethnic minorities is because of socio economics or something it sounded they had the answer ready for.

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Mar 20 9.44am

Originally posted by Badger11

I think I'll wait for WE to respond to this first.

Edited by Midlands Eagle (11 Mar 2020 9.38am)

That will be a lot of highlighted replies.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 11 Mar 20 9.51am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

A few black teenage girls did a feature on bbc tv London news. Must’ve been Tuesday yesterday. They highlighted they don’t have any white friends. They could but don’t. They ventured into Havering, the whitest London borough. They went into some day centre event for the retired and they said the reason they aren’t mixing with ethnic minorities is because of socio economics or something it sounded they had the answer ready for.

Bit of a random point, but I have been pondering, there are a only few black women/girls in my department, none of whom I think work in the same team, but who insist on all sitting together at lunch.

It's strange, as I do not know all of them well but a few I have regular dealings with and they are all lovely and sociable yet create quite a visible division with their eating habits, or when socialising/not working. Is there really such a cultural divide between them and the rest of the office and is this a microcosm of society as a whole?

Brings me back to Muhammed Ali's quote of 'Black birds like to fly with blackbirds, bluebirds fly with bludebirds etc.".

Edited by Nicholas91 (11 Mar 2020 9.51am)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Speronilover69 8=D~~ Flag Horsham 11 Mar 20 9.53am

Diversity isn't necessarily good or bad, it's the economic benefits that come with it. The agricultural industry in this country, for example, would really struggle without immigration (because immigrants do the jobs that British people won't do). Not to mention the NHS, civil engineering, etc.

Personally I like living in a country where there are people from lots of different cultures, but you don't have to. If you would rather live surrounded by British people you are entitled to your opinion. There's no right or wrong answer as far as culture goes. But one thing that cannot be refuted is the economic benefit to this country that immigration provides

Edited by Midlands Eagle (11 Mar 2020 9.59am)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Mar 20 10.03am

Originally posted by Badger11

I think I'll wait for WE to respond to this first.

Edited by Midlands Eagle (11 Mar 2020 9.38am)

You will be waiting a very long time!

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Mar 20 10.05am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

You will be waiting a very long time!

You type slowly then ?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Mar 20 10.11am

Originally posted by Speronilover69 8=D~~

Diversity isn't necessarily good or bad, it's the economic benefits that come with it.

The case that you have made seems to imply that diversity is a necessity not that it is good.

There are still 1.3m people unemployed and presumably claiming benefits so couldn't a case be made for some or all of the long term unemployed filling some of the positions currently being taken by immigrant labour?

Some of the more skilled jobs like nursing are only filled by immigrants because the UK Nursing Council make it so difficult for British people to get into the industry.

You need a university degree plus funding for your training to get into nursing in this country whereas in the Philippines one needs to do well at school before going to nursing college so the entry standards are much lower

 

Speronilover69 8=D~~ Flag Horsham 11 Mar 20 10.58am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The case that you have made seems to imply that diversity is a necessity not that it is good.

There are still 1.3m people unemployed and presumably claiming benefits so couldn't a case be made for some or all of the long term unemployed filling some of the positions currently being taken by immigrant labour?

Some of the more skilled jobs like nursing are only filled by immigrants because the UK Nursing Council make it so difficult for British people to get into the industry.

You need a university degree plus funding for your training to get into nursing in this country whereas in the Philippines one needs to do well at school before going to nursing college so the entry standards are much lower

A case could be made for that. However, convincing British people to pick fruit in a field, for example, is easier said than done. It's long, grueling hours which British people would rather not have to do. The only way to get British people to do the jobs that a lot of immigrants are doing would be to pay them more - which would increase the price of our produce. The same could be said for pretty much any industry (removing immigration will increase the price of goods and services and be detrimental to our economy).

I find it funny how 'right-wingers' always claim to prioritize the economy above all else but will happily ignore the needs of the economy when it suits them

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Mar 20 11.18am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Some of the more skilled jobs like nursing are only filled by immigrants because the UK Nursing Council make it so difficult for British people to get into the industry.

You need a university degree plus funding for your training to get into nursing in this country whereas in the Philippines one needs to do well at school before going to nursing college so the entry standards are much lower

This is something I have direct, current and personal experience of. If anyone really wants to know how and why please PM me.

That the NMC (Nursing and Midwifery Council) have raised standards by making nursing a degree course is beyond doubt. That they have done so is, partly at least, to ease the pressures on doctors and prepare the NHS for it's future. That the move from bursary funding to student loans has reduced the numbers applying for the courses is true. Hence the £5000 per year grant announced by the Government in December which will probably be confirmed in today's budget. This should help encourage more to enter the profession, whose loans are very unlikely ever to be paid back in full anyway. Raising the status, and salaries, of graduate nurses is going to be the real answer though, in my own opinion.

The idea that it's easier in the Philippines is though very wrong. It's a 5 year course there, and not 3 as it is here, but the standards are not so high, hence the need for a 6 month adaptation if they join the NHS. The key sticking point though is money. Entry is easy. The nursing colleges are commercial enterprises and if you can pay their fees and meet the minimal entry requirements, then you are accepted. The fees though are very high for an average middle class Filipino family, who will often have to borrow heavily in the hope that their student will eventually repay them with enough extra for their older years. As the drop out rate is high you can imagine the consequences. If you are poor then you need a sponsor, often a family member who is themselves working abroad.

It's no wonder you don't see too many Filipino nurses in the UK in social situations, but only in hospitals. They are too busy working and then sending most of what they earn back home.

Even if every place on offer in the Universities for Nursing degrees was full (and there aren't so many vacancies now) we would still need to recruit overseas. If we doubled the number of our students I think we would still need to do so. How long though it would take us to double the number of training places, let alone for the NHS itself to cope with the extra demand to look after students on placements, are quite other questions.

So overseas recruitment of nurses is going to be necessary for the foreseeable future.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Mar 20 11.37am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle


The idea that it's easier in the Philippines is though very wrong. It's a 5 year course there, and not 3 as it is here, but the standards are not so high, hence the need for a 6 month adaptation if they join the NHS.

I picked the Philippines at random partly because my wife works with several Filipino nurses but without checking I am sure that it's also easier to get into nursing in pakistan and India too.

One of the disadvantages of making the entry into nursing so academic is that you end up with the wrong sort of people in the profession as those with the aptitude for the job don't have the academic qualifications for entry whilst those that do aren't necessarily the most suitable.

On the subject of diversity in nursing though one of the positives is that there are a large number of Muslim nurses at my wife's hospital who are happy to work Christmas Day (at double time) so wifey can always get the day off

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 11 Mar 20 11.45am

A lot of the nursing work could be undertaken by part-time health care workers/ auxiliaries. These people could work flexible hours to suit family/ other commitments.
However, low skilled people will not be allowed over. People with nursing degrees are going to be in a protected category - like secondary teachers, and as the case is in the USA/ Australia etc. The UK is also the destination of choice for Irish nurses once again. Many do their training in Belfast - where they already get the bursary.

 


Red and Blue Army!

W12 11 Mar 20 11.53am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

This is something I have direct, current and personal experience of. If anyone really wants to know how and why please PM me.

That the NMC (Nursing and Midwifery Council) have raised standards by making nursing a degree course is beyond doubt. That they have done so is, partly at least, to ease the pressures on doctors and prepare the NHS for it's future. That the move from bursary funding to student loans has reduced the numbers applying for the courses is true. Hence the £5000 per year grant announced by the Government in December which will probably be confirmed in today's budget. This should help encourage more to enter the profession, whose loans are very unlikely ever to be paid back in full anyway. Raising the status, and salaries, of graduate nurses is going to be the real answer though, in my own opinion.

The idea that it's easier in the Philippines is though very wrong. It's a 5 year course there, and not 3 as it is here, but the standards are not so high, hence the need for a 6 month adaptation if they join the NHS. The key sticking point though is money. Entry is easy. The nursing colleges are commercial enterprises and if you can pay their fees and meet the minimal entry requirements, then you are accepted. The fees though are very high for an average middle class Filipino family, who will often have to borrow heavily in the hope that their student will eventually repay them with enough extra for their older years. As the drop out rate is high you can imagine the consequences. If you are poor then you need a sponsor, often a family member who is themselves working abroad.

It's no wonder you don't see too many Filipino nurses in the UK in social situations, but only in hospitals. They are too busy working and then sending most of what they earn back home.

Even if every place on offer in the Universities for Nursing degrees was full (and there aren't so many vacancies now) we would still need to recruit overseas. If we doubled the number of our students I think we would still need to do so. How long though it would take us to double the number of training places, let alone for the NHS itself to cope with the extra demand to look after students on placements, are quite other questions.

So overseas recruitment of nurses is going to be necessary for the foreseeable future.

So if the arguments for mass immigration are purely either economic or practical (and not moral) then where does this end, obviously immigrants age the same as indigenous people. At what point would we be able to stop immigration following the current ponzi model?

Also if the arguments are mainly economic this means that the average person coming into the country needs to be a net benefit to the economy which means they need to earn in the range of £40k, not be playing benefit system, not having large numbers of kids and not committing any crime. If so, how does this justify immigration from violent tribal societies from the 3rd world that are clearly living completely separately from the indigenous people? (It's natural and I don't blame them for this btw).

Apart from all this it's telling how WE & Co completely ignore the more fundamental societal issues like why diversity is a good idea or is anything more then less white indigenous people.


Edited by W12 (11 Mar 2020 11.54am)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Mar 20 2.52pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I picked the Philippines at random partly because my wife works with several Filipino nurses but without checking I am sure that it's also easier to get into nursing in pakistan and India too.

One of the disadvantages of making the entry into nursing so academic is that you end up with the wrong sort of people in the profession as those with the aptitude for the job don't have the academic qualifications for entry whilst those that do aren't necessarily the most suitable.

On the subject of diversity in nursing though one of the positives is that there are a large number of Muslim nurses at my wife's hospital who are happy to work Christmas Day (at double time) so wifey can always get the day off

As I am sure your wife will confirm HCAs (Health Care Assistants) now take on much of the work that lower level nurses used to do and are often the backbone in any ward. They provide a vital service which is often much under appreciated. However recruiting HCAs is likely to get much more difficult as it seems to me that this job won't qualify in the proposed points based system. Maybe this will have to be one of the first exemptions.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Mar 20 2.59pm

Originally posted by W12

So if the arguments for mass immigration are purely either economic or practical (and not moral) then where does this end, obviously immigrants age the same as indigenous people. At what point would we be able to stop immigration following the current ponzi model?

Also if the arguments are mainly economic this means that the average person coming into the country needs to be a net benefit to the economy which means they need to earn in the range of £40k, not be playing benefit system, not having large numbers of kids and not committing any crime. If so, how does this justify immigration from violent tribal societies from the 3rd world that are clearly living completely separately from the indigenous people? (It's natural and I don't blame them for this btw).

Apart from all this it's telling how WE & Co completely ignore the more fundamental societal issues like why diversity is a good idea or is anything more then less white indigenous people.


Edited by W12 (11 Mar 2020 11.54am)

If the NHS would fail unless you permit the recruitment of staff from overseas then no amount of concern about "societal issues" can justify not allowing it.

You tackle the societal issues separately, with total determination to overcome them but with a matching attitude that brooks no behaviour that deviates from our accepted norms.

Permitting needed immigration and ensuring we retain a homogeneous, well ordered, society are not mutually exclusive. It just requires effort.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 11 Mar 20 3.10pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

If the NHS would fail unless you permit the recruitment of staff from overseas then no amount of concern about "societal issues" can justify not allowing it.

You tackle the societal issues separately, with total determination to overcome them but with a matching attitude that brooks no behaviour that deviates from our accepted norms.

Permitting needed immigration and ensuring we retain a homogeneous, well ordered, society are not mutually exclusive. It just requires effort.

Here we go again with that old baloney.

What happens when the immigrants outnumber the original population? Whose morals and codes do we follow then?
It is just a matter of time and not a very long time either.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic