You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A few thoughts on why we have no money to spend
November 16 2026 5.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

A few thoughts on why we have no money to spend


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Holton thunderbolt Flag 23 Aug 20 1.44pm

I do not believe we will be spending any serious money this year or next either on players or the new stand .Covid is the perfect excuse for owners who despite being exceedingly wealthy both individually and corporately are reportedly known in the States to be one of the most frugal in the NBA and were when they bought 60% of our shareholders shares for approx £60 m with the deal as reported being for them to loan back that money to the club to help finance the build of the standThat could well be why we have no stand and ongoing “issues” of 106 agreements with the council and difficulties in buying car park off Sainsbury’s etc etc
Unlike other premiership smaller clubs whose Chairman and directors are unpaid our chairman appears from our accounts to have a salary of £2.5 million plus 1mill bonus for staying up plus other possible related commercial agreements for head office property and marketing etc.A lot of money over 8 years of premiership life!
Who is going to buy the club with these expenses,a stand to be built and an ageing squad to rebuild when our owners would in press reports value the club north of £200 million.?Despite our catchment area for young players and existing fan base etc there will be plenty of other more cost effective clubs available post COVID for very wealthy owners to purchase.If we remain with our existing shareholders who do not want to invest their own money and indeed take out what they can we will almost certainly be relegated despite the sterling efforts of the last 8 years to cling on.The academy will not produce stars to sell quickly enough to stop this inevitable process.Of course this is only an opinion but if you look at our recent transfer windows despite selling Wan Bissaka it could unfortunately be the truth of the matter.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Aug 20 4.53pm

The gate painting was pretty expensive but can be written off over three years for tax purposes.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Aug 20 5.42pm

Originally posted by Holton thunderbolt


Unlike other premiership smaller clubs whose Chairman and directors are unpaid our chairman appears from our accounts to have a salary of £2.5 million plus 1mill bonus for staying up plus other possible related commercial agreements for head office property and marketing etc.

Who is going to buy the club with these expenses,

The main reason why Palace is unsaleable is that Parish wants to hang on to a minority shareholding and continue to run the club and anyone that is willing to fork out a couple of hundred million will want total control

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 23 Aug 20 6.06pm

I think the biggest problem is that 80% of the clubs income is paid on wages. This is the main reason why we cannot compete financially with other teams.

I agree with the questions raised about Parish’s salary, but do not let this cloud your judgement on other chairman/Owners. West Ham’s owners as one example don’t take a salary but they did loan the club money at questionable rates which would far exceed the salary being taken by SP. Do not get me started on the Glaziers at United.

Anyway. We have just paid 20m for a new academy and we have paid back some of the debts.

The thing with the virus and football is that we are a club that does not really rely on our hospitality income (arsenal as an example do). So our outgoings is pretty much covered by TV revenue. However the big clubs use TV+Hospitality. Now when you have no hospitality coming in for the foreseeable and you have an ozil on 300k a week. It means your transfer kitty is impacted. This means not so many clubs will be in for so many players which means the market is diluted.

Hopefully we can capitalise on this and get some players in that we would usually lose to other clubs.

 

davehuggins Flag 23 Aug 20 6.20pm

I have said for ages now we need investment and this lack of will be our downfall I am sorry to say. Previous bad windows have now left us with little or no money. Great shame for a club with our potential, a lot of promises and no end product!!

 

sotac464 Flag Berkshire 23 Aug 20 6.21pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The main reason why Palace is unsaleable is that Parish wants to hang on to a minority shareholding and continue to run the club and anyone that is willing to fork out a couple of hundred million will want total control

Oh come on that is not the main reason at all, Parish has said if the right owners come along and are willing to invest, he is willing to sell his share.

We are simply not an attractive proposition, ageing squad, run down stadium. New owner's wouldn't take over for the love of Palace, they would buy us as an investment, to then sell on at a profit.

Any new owner coming in would have to shell out investment in younger players, upgrading the stadium. So the £200 million to buy the club, suddenly turns into £400-500 million.

Not such an attractive proposition, considering Newcastle already have the stadium in place, and Ashley still can't sell, despite being on the market for the past 5 years.

 


My equalibrium unbalanced me. Paul Draper Brighton 19/2/2018

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 23 Aug 20 6.34pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

The gate painting was pretty expensive but can be written off over three years for tax purposes.

The gate painting would be written off in one year. It’s not a capital asset.

I always struggled with girls, it’s a mystery why.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Aug 20 6.48pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

The gate painting would be written off in one year. It’s not a capital asset.

I always struggled with girls, it’s a mystery why.

If you practiced ‘‘wax, on, wax off’’ and ‘’paint the fence’’ you would’ve caught the prize catch and fought off the competition.

 


COYP

palace99 Flag New Mills 23 Aug 20 7.47pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

I think the biggest problem is that 80% of the clubs income is paid on wages. This is the main reason why we cannot compete financially with other teams.

I agree with the questions raised about Parish’s salary, but do not let this cloud your judgement on other chairman/Owners. West Ham’s owners as one example don’t take a salary but they did loan the club money at questionable rates which would far exceed the salary being taken by SP. Do not get me started on the Glaziers at United.

Anyway. We have just paid 20m for a new academy and we have paid back some of the debts.

The thing with the virus and football is that we are a club that does not really rely on our hospitality income (arsenal as an example do). So our outgoings is pretty much covered by TV revenue. However the big clubs use TV+Hospitality. Now when you have no hospitality coming in for the foreseeable and you have an ozil on 300k a week. It means your transfer kitty is impacted. This means not so many clubs will be in for so many players which means the market is diluted.

Hopefully we can capitalise on this and get some players in that we would usually lose to other clubs.

i agree SP has let wages, including his own, get too high. Most 1st teamers are now on £60k plus per week and we know top 4 are on over £100k. If all 20 came down by an average of £10k less per week that's £200k a week saving and £10m per year.

These wages would still be very competitive at £10k less a week e.g. Jimmy Mac on £50k per week rather than £60k etc

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 24 Aug 20 8.37am

Is it in the accounts what percentage SP actually owns now?

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Aug 20 8.54am

I think the issue is that our strategy has been to sign experienced PL players and these carry higher wages. Other clubs of our size have with varying degrees of success signed foreign on lower league players who they can tie down on smaller contracts. 8 years in the PL has shown that however much we might complain our strategy has worked so far, with that experience coming in handy at key moments.

If we were to sell Sakho, Bentenke and Wilf then that would make a huge dent in our wage bill, providing we don't sign new players on similarly high wages.

The one thing that Roy repeatedly stated was that the club are looking to invest in youth, and that in theory should help to bring down the wage bill while also having the potential to create more saleable assets (I don't like talking about players in this way, but as this is a "business" thread).

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 24 Aug 20 8.58am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

If you practiced ‘‘wax, on, wax off’’ and ‘’paint the fence’’ you would’ve caught the prize catch and fought off the competition.

You missed sand the floor!

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 24 Aug 20 11.31am

I thought that all the money SP earns from the club goes back into the club / academy?

We have previously paid too much for players and agreed wages that are too high. It has worked, as we are still in the Premier League, but to be sustainable we need a new AWB to be sold every other year.

Covid could work in our favour, on the one hand we have a reduced income but hopefully new contracts will be lower in the future. West Ham bought Bowen from Hull for £22 million and wages of £80k a week. If he were on sale now I suspect the wages would be a lot less.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 24 Aug 20 11.45am

Originally posted by topcat

I thought that all the money SP earns from the club goes back into the club / academy?

We have previously paid too much for players and agreed wages that are too high. It has worked, as we are still in the Premier League, but to be sustainable we need a new AWB to be sold every other year.

Covid could work in our favour, on the one hand we have a reduced income but hopefully new contracts will be lower in the future. West Ham bought Bowen from Hull for £22 million and wages of £80k a week. If he were on sale now I suspect the wages would be a lot less.

The Fraser deal is certainly looking like that. Sounds like we're very competitive at about half of what he was looking for, and less than Bournemouth offered him.

Ferguson, Eze and this rumoured young CB from abroad will be lower on wages too. Sell Sakho and you're not far off breaking even with an additional three players (3 1/2 counting Sakho's injuries...) and far greater sell on potential.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 24 Aug 20 12.36pm

When we discuss this in our overseas group chat, it is generally fairly soon to " SP is our best ever , the only measure is number of consecutive seasons in PL "

The flip side is we over paid for non performers and also overpaid generally on wages.

You only have to look at other PL clubs to see this is a fact.

We lucked out on AWB financially and to a degree Bolasie.

Apart from these two no system of developing players as for example Southampton seem to do and generate a revenue stream.

General consensus is without new income stream, which would seem to only be possible by a sale we will inevitably be relegated in the next couple of seasons and the old squad / high wage picture will be the main reason.

Ayew became a much better player under Roy and Ray and we lucked out a bit there too.

We will likely find it hard to unload our high wage earners.

Hard to see anyone matching wages of Sakho and Benteke, Meyer would want a good part of any transfer fee as he is unlikely to be offered same wages elsewhere.

With Wilf who knows, maybe after last night PSG may want a game changer player.

Edited by HKOwen (24 Aug 2020 12.39pm)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Aray Flag South London 24 Aug 20 12.40pm

Covid 19 is obviously a terrible thing but it strangley may work in our favour. As others have pointed out, we are not going to take as big a hit given our relative lack of match gate/hospitality earnings.

No one with any sense would have deliberately had so many players contracts ending in 12 months time but we really couldn't be "buying" at a better time. Buying promising youth is expensive normally and it seems that is why we've been shunted into the old pro option.

A budget of £30m+ could get us 2/3 decent players this windows. Am I being unrealistic? Perhaps but of our typical competition in the south: seems like West Ham need to sell before buying. Obviously, Watford and Bournmouth are sellling and I'd say we're a better option than Fulham. Transfer deadline day is October? Two long months ahead...

 

Holton thunderbolt Flag 24 Aug 20 12.45pm

SP has 15% ish -Americans 60% of which 15% each for Harris and Blitzer and 30% through one of their companies.The other 25% owned by original funding shareholders Martin Long Steve Browett and Jeremy Hoskins.They would between them and SP I believe have to put the original £60 mill they got personally back in to the club to build the stand which is why it will prob not be built until some fairy godfather buys them out ..Unlikely especially if SP wants to remain with shares and/or chairman on the wages he is on.The Americans won’t invest in players unless it comes from “league place money” or sales,even then that has not happened over recent windows.It does seem crazy as we are hurtling to the Championship when the value of the club will drop like a stone,but it appears a power standoff between SP and the Americans.Perhaps he is hoping for reinvestment in the January window after an abysmal start and when we are looking down the barrel of relegation and they finally wake up to to the reality of the championship and reduced chances of selling their shares.At least the traffic will be lighter with small crowds,and there maybe some goal excitement!

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 24 Aug 20 12.54pm

Simple answer......we have spent it all.

1. High wages is a big problem.

2. The money spent on the academy. Whether that was worthwhile remains to be seen. Will it be a white elephant or actually produce 1st team players ? My opinion is that talented youngsters look at money and status. At the end of the day we are still Crystal Palace, even if we have a state of the art academy, if a Chelsea or Arsenal come in for them they are gone.

3. Are the Americans taking out money ?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 24 Aug 20 1.20pm

Originally posted by Aray

Covid 19 is obviously a terrible thing but it strangley may work in our favour. As others have pointed out, we are not going to take as big a hit given our relative lack of match gate/hospitality earnings.

No one with any sense would have deliberately had so many players contracts ending in 12 months time but we really couldn't be "buying" at a better time. Buying promising youth is expensive normally and it seems that is why we've been shunted into the old pro option.

A budget of £30m+ could get us 2/3 decent players this windows. Am I being unrealistic? Perhaps but of our typical competition in the south: seems like West Ham need to sell before buying. Obviously, Watford and Bournmouth are sellling and I'd say we're a better option than Fulham. Transfer deadline day is October? Two long months ahead...

Whilst this is true we are almost completely reliant on TV money what happens if that goes down?

I know it will impact the other clubs as well but that is why the rebuilding of the stadium is so important you should not just rely on one income stream.

 


One more point

Aray Flag South London 24 Aug 20 2.03pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Whilst this is true we are almost completely reliant on TV money what happens if that goes down?

I know it will impact the other clubs as well but that is why the rebuilding of the stadium is so important you should not just rely on one income stream.

We'll be in the same boat as other teams in that event, surely? I agree we should still try to build other income streams but as soon as it is created, it is spent. It is a minor levelling of the playing field in our favour. Temporarily no doubt but real nonetheless.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A few thoughts on why we have no money to spend