You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Blame FIFA, not VAR
November 16 2026 5.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Blame FIFA, not VAR


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 28 Sep 20 2.19am

The rule has not changed, the FIFA directive to change the interpretation has caused the problem.

VAR is good for deciding offsides and ball over line from technical view.

For incidents involving fouls it's absurd letting officials review in super slo mo where everything seems to look worse.

There was a stat on I think MOTD2 that the season after the interpretation changed in Europe, a year before England, the number of handball penalties in La Liga increased from 19 to 50 in one season, that's what we're heading for

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Sep 20 7.36am

Originally posted by HKOwen

The rule has not changed, the FIFA directive to change the interpretation has caused the problem.

VAR is good for deciding offsides and ball over line from technical view.

For incidents involving fouls it's absurd letting officials review in super slo mo where everything seems to look worse.

There was a stat on I think MOTD2 that the season after the interpretation changed in Europe, a year before England, the number of handball penalties in La Liga increased from 19 to 50 in one season, that's what we're heading for

I agree

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 28 Sep 20 7.47am

VAR is gonna be good for corrupt VAR officials to help out the bigger clubs, thats what TV companies want and they pay the bills so thats what they get

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 28 Sep 20 8.13am

Originally posted by HKOwen

The rule has not changed, the FIFA directive to change the interpretation has caused the problem.

VAR is good for deciding offsides and ball over line from technical view.

For incidents involving fouls it's absurd letting officials review in super slo mo where everything seems to look worse.

There was a stat on I think MOTD2 that the season after the interpretation changed in Europe, a year before England, the number of handball penalties in La Liga increased from 19 to 50 in one season, that's what we're heading for

It is if you support the notion of a players arm, toenail etc being offside....again, it's the interpretation of the rule that is at fault.

The introduction of VAR in the Premier League clearly didn't legislate for that fact that the poor standard of officiating on the pitch would extend to muppets like Anthony Taylor watching on a screen and still getting it wrong.

We are reaching a point now where just about every game has a VAR related incident involving handball and offside decisions. It's killing the game.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

eritheagle Flag Erith 28 Sep 20 8.16am

Originally posted by HKOwen

The rule has not changed, the FIFA directive to change the interpretation has caused the problem.

VAR is good for deciding offsides and ball over line from technical view.

For incidents involving fouls it's absurd letting officials review in super slo mo where everything seems to look worse.

There was a stat on I think MOTD2 that the season after the interpretation changed in Europe, a year before England, the number of handball penalties in La Liga increased from 19 to 50 in one season, that's what we're heading for

I thought the stat was, 19 pens in Prem from handballs last season compared to 50 in La Liga and 60 in Serie A. Just repeated this stat on Talksport.

But I do agree with you, the new interpretation that they've told the Prem refs to follow is gonna ruin the game we enjoy.
Imagine 26,000 spending their cash to travel to Selhurst to watch a well earned 1-0 win when in injury time up on the big screen is shown a penalty given for handball like the one given against Eric Dier! If that happened I know I'd be questioning if i'd really want to go much longer!

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 28 Sep 20 8.54am

A different but contentious slant.
This change will surely mean that there are less subjective decisions. Crowds cant influence the ref if he has a rule to stick to. In effect this will make the game fairer which is what has been an issue for ages. We have had one for one against.
Manure one for one against. All teams will probably get a similar amount for and against. 3 games in is not long enough to judge if this is good or bad.
It may turn out to be the way to make the on pitch play fairer. Some players are cute enough to do a handball and make it look accidental. Ward could well have been deliberately trying to stop the ball as maupay may have. Clearly they wont admit it but players will try anything for an advantage.
It's in their nature as competitive sportsmen. 100k a week in the prem helps I'm sure!

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 28 Sep 20 9.23am

Surely now, any attacking player has no longer the need to shoot at goal, just a simple head/chip/ blast or whatever of the ball so it touched by an opposition players arm .. in the penalty area, then happy days, slo mo VAR penalty given.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 29 Sep 20 11.51am

Originally posted by HKOwen

The rule has not changed, the FIFA directive to change the interpretation has caused the problem.

VAR is good for deciding offsides and ball over line from technical view.

For incidents involving fouls it's absurd letting officials review in super slo mo where everything seems to look worse.

VAR is not fit for purpose to adjudicate marginal Offsides. There is a well publicised margin of error of up to 14cm on VAR offsides because of freeze frame technology. It absolutely cannot adjudicate on such minor infringements as armpits and toenails or 3cm calls, as we have seen previously, especially when adding in the line drawing which is not an exact science and subject to further human error.

Again in its current form it is simply not suitable and has caused outrage and dismay at numerous times since its introduction. They are currently looking at a number of options / proposals to try and improve the use of VAR for offside decisions.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Sep 20 1.00pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

I thought the stat was, 19 pens in Prem from handballs last season compared to 50 in La Liga and 60 in Serie A. Just repeated this stat on Talksport.

But I do agree with you, the new interpretation that they've told the Prem refs to follow is gonna ruin the game we enjoy.
Imagine 26,000 spending their cash to travel to Selhurst to watch a well earned 1-0 win when in injury time up on the big screen is shown a penalty given for handball like the one given against Eric Dier! If that happened I know I'd be questioning if i'd really want to go much longer!

Yes I won’t want to bother with this s***.

 


COYP

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 29 Sep 20 9.14pm

The issue is clearly not with VAR but with the bellends running it.
VAR records what happens. That is all it does.

The people running football are and always have been dimwits.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 30 Sep 20 8.46am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The issue is clearly not with VAR but with the bellends running it.
VAR records what happens. That is all it does.

The people running football are and always have been dimwits.

100% agree. The biggest d1cks are the Premier League. Since they also took over the reffing, that too has got worse, miles worse. And it was f#cking awful before. It is also only the Premier League using VAR. They want it more like WWF or NFL or something. They are getting their wishes.

 


Red and Blue Army!

The Dolphin Flag 30 Sep 20 10.14am

I have to say that unless they change this farce then I am not sure I will go back.
It is not a knee jerk reaction but given that we are not there currently and I dislike what I am seeing on TV I am just not sure I want to pay a fortune just to be disappointed further.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 30 Sep 20 11.53am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I have to say that unless they change this farce then I am not sure I will go back.
It is not a knee jerk reaction but given that we are not there currently and I dislike what I am seeing on TV I am just not sure I want to pay a fortune just to be disappointed further.

Totally agree with you! Out of all the goals we scored at home last season I think I only celebrated the penalty from Luka, PVA’s free kick and Ayew’s v West Ham with any confidence that they wouldn’t be chalked off.
I remember one time when our player had the ball blasted at him and it may have touched his arm whilst we were attacking. I was willing us to not To bother scoring and to try and win a corner instead as I knew VAR would disallow any goal!

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 30 Sep 20 12.08pm

Nothing wrong with VAR apart from when it has to follow stupid laws to give so many decisions that appear dodgy to everyone. The laws of the game are dodgy, the guy in charge of the VAR for each game is left to the wolves when he gets the blame for putting into action what FIFA tell him lol

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 30 Sep 20 12.31pm

Originally posted by steven_t92

Nothing wrong with VAR apart from when it has to follow stupid laws to give so many decisions that appear dodgy to everyone. The laws of the game are dodgy, the guy in charge of the VAR for each game is left to the wolves when he gets the blame for putting into action what FIFA tell him lol

That’s why I don’t think refs are giving some decisions until they are recommended to go look at the monitors. It then deflects the attention from them as they probably don’t agree with the rule changes anyway.

 

roman eagle Flag South London 30 Sep 20 5.02pm

On a point of information, it is the International Football Association Board (IFAB) that is the law-making body, not FIFA. IFAB (1886) predates FIFA (1904), although FIFA has representation on IFAB.

IFAB has 8 members, four from FIFA and one each from the Football Association of England, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales. For any motion to be passed there has to be a three-quarters majority ie 6 out of 8, so effectively the UK football associations have a veto on any motion, as does FIFA.

Regarding the current controversy, the problem arises from the desire to have a definition of 'deliberate' so there is consistency across the world. Previously referees were the judge of whether handball was deliberate or not.

But unfortunately this raises other issues, primarily what is an 'un-natural' position for a hand/arm. Hence we get situations like the Ward handball, and the week before the Lindelof handball. Under the previous guidance neither of these would have been given. So effectively there is a much lower bar for a handball offence now, and the FA did warn that there would be more penalties as a result this season.

Nothing is going to change until IFAB meets next spring but in the meantime Roy is correct in saying that managers, coaches, players and the like should make their voices heard in opposition to the way the guidance on the law has changed.

 


Audentis fortuna iuvat (Virgil, 19BC)

uncleneal Flag Croydon 01 Oct 20 7.51am

Originally posted by roman eagle

On a point of information, it is the International Football Association Board (IFAB) that is the law-making body, not FIFA. IFAB (1886) predates FIFA (1904), although FIFA has representation on IFAB.

IFAB has 8 members, four from FIFA and one each from the Football Association of England, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales. For any motion to be passed there has to be a three-quarters majority ie 6 out of 8, so effectively the UK football associations have a veto on any motion, as does FIFA.

Regarding the current controversy, the problem arises from the desire to have a definition of 'deliberate' so there is consistency across the world. Previously referees were the judge of whether handball was deliberate or not.

But unfortunately this raises other issues, primarily what is an 'un-natural' position for a hand/arm. Hence we get situations like the Ward handball, and the week before the Lindelof handball. Under the previous guidance neither of these would have been given. So effectively there is a much lower bar for a handball offence now, and the FA did warn that there would be more penalties as a result this season.

Nothing is going to change until IFAB meets next spring but in the meantime Roy is correct in saying that managers, coaches, players and the like should make their voices heard in opposition to the way the guidance on the law has changed.


Interesting - wonder who represented the U.K. nations. Very odd that they have meddled as the result was obvious. VAR is simply the closed circuit TV - people disputing the closeness of the calls in understandable but what would they do? Surely it is easier to stick with fact, off or not?

The handball is not about being seen but the interpretation that it is handball. The Man U decision was harsh, the Joel Ward one is simply wrong and the Spurs one is downright pathetic.

The Brighton one is correct and that is a clear benefit of having VAR.

Would be good if the refs told us how they came to the decision I.e. does Friend think that Ward’s hand is in an unnatural position? Maybe that would cause more debate but the authorities could than see how the refs are thinking.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 Oct 20 8.24am

Originally posted by roman eagle

On a point of information, it is the International Football Association Board (IFAB) that is the law-making body, not FIFA. IFAB (1886) predates FIFA (1904), although FIFA has representation on IFAB.

IFAB has 8 members, four from FIFA and one each from the Football Association of England, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales. For any motion to be passed there has to be a three-quarters majority ie 6 out of 8, so effectively the UK football associations have a veto on any motion, as does FIFA.

Regarding the current controversy, the problem arises from the desire to have a definition of 'deliberate' so there is consistency across the world. Previously referees were the judge of whether handball was deliberate or not.

But unfortunately this raises other issues, primarily what is an 'un-natural' position for a hand/arm. Hence we get situations like the Ward handball, and the week before the Lindelof handball. Under the previous guidance neither of these would have been given. So effectively there is a much lower bar for a handball offence now, and the FA did warn that there would be more penalties as a result this season.

Nothing is going to change until IFAB meets next spring but in the meantime Roy is correct in saying that managers, coaches, players and the like should make their voices heard in opposition to the way the guidance on the law has changed.

A ridiculous committee, Northern Ireland a giant in world football has a big say in technology it can't afford to implement whilst those pesky minnows Germany and Brazil don't.

This is a hangover from when we invented the game and needs to be reformed. The obvious solution is to have a committee made up of the 6 federations.

Scotland Wales and Northern Ireland having a vote on this committee is why they are against a GB team for women or under 23's. They believe that a GB team at any level will eventually mean they lose their vote, FIFA should put them out of their misery and reform the committee and throw all of the home nations off it.

I suspect if this happened their objections to a GB team will disappear.

 


One more point

roman eagle Flag South London 01 Oct 20 9.40am

You can read up on the membership of IFAB here [Link]
The main committee is advised by two panels - the Football Advisory Panel and the Technical Advisory Panel. These comprise various members including former professionals - Luis Figo and Boban for example, representatives of the federations, coaches and former top referees including Collina and Elleray.

Despite all of this accumulated wisdom they’ve managed to make a mess of the handball law. Again I go back to Roy - if the player does it deliberately it’s a penalty, if it hits his hand it’s not. The most ridiculous penalty given this season was the Dier penalty - he actually had his back to the ball so had no idea where the ball was - surely this can’t be what IFAB intended. This makes a mockery of the law and is not a good advert for the game because fairness is a basic principle of football and that is blatantly unfair.

 


Audentis fortuna iuvat (Virgil, 19BC)

roman eagle Flag South London 01 Oct 20 10.06am

Just read this on the Beeb [Link]
so the Premier League want to lobby IFAB - well they don’t have to go very far as we’ve got our own man on the board of directors, His name is Mark Bullingham and he’s the CEO of the FA [Link]
Let’s see if Mark can fix it.

 


Audentis fortuna iuvat (Virgil, 19BC)

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Blame FIFA, not VAR