You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy & Gareth cut from the same cloth
November 16 2026 5.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy & Gareth cut from the same cloth


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Gribbo Flag Bromley 14 Oct 20 9.46pm

Talented players rolling it backwards and sideways. Sitting back and hoping to nick a goal.
No Plan B when they go a goal down.
No creativity on the pitch, Rice and Phillips in midfield, with Grealish sitting on the bench.
The odd good result sneaked now and again.
Lose at home to the dross.

 

Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 14 Oct 20 9.59pm

The ref didn't do England much help tonight.

That penalty decision was bogus, the tackle on Coady 2nd half was as much of a pen if not more.

Still though, can't work out why GS won't play Grealish.

 

eagleheath Flag Burgess Hill 14 Oct 20 9.59pm

And the worry is when he gets sussed out by England next year, Parish will see him as the ideal replacement for when Roy goes

 

jeeagles Flag 14 Oct 20 10.22pm

Originally posted by Wilesy01

The ref didn't do England much help tonight.

That penalty decision was bogus, the tackle on Coady 2nd half was as much of a pen if not more.

Still though, can't work out why GS won't play Grealish.

Couldn't really work out what the ref thought the foul was. At least when someone dives you can see how the ref was tricked.

Southgate seems to have tactical flaws, but to me, the structural changes in the national team structure at all age groups make him a more progressive manager than England have had in a very long time. Its seems like he's finally got the FA to take on some of Sir Clive Woodward's approach to running a national team.

On the national rugby team. There was a point in the 6N where England had just lost to Wales. Eddie Jones seemed to be laughing in the presser afterwards. No one has realised he used it as a dress rehearsal for the tactics they would employ against the All Backs that ended up blitzing them in the world Cup.

There might be more at play here. I think (hope) he might know he's starting and is just testing out his back up plans.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 14 Oct 20 10.53pm

Aha! The old double-bluff - I think I get it. Let's home the A-game works then, cos the back-up plan I sat through tonight was total pants.

 

batcountry Flag Melbourne 15 Oct 20 7.15am

Too many sub international players.
Maguire - clumsy and one dimensional.
Rice - way out of his depth.
Rashford - non existent.
Pickford - everyone knows he’s not the best GK.
Walker - liability.


 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 15 Oct 20 7.48am

Originally posted by eagleheath

And the worry is when he gets sussed out by England next year, Parish will see him as the ideal replacement for when Roy goes

^^^well-played. Nearly a coffee-over-the-keyboard moment

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 15 Oct 20 8.25am

Originally posted by eagleheath

And the worry is when he gets sussed out by England next year, Parish will see him as the ideal replacement for when Roy goes

That thought has crossed my mind. Not ITK or not professing that this is true but I had heard from an acquaintance of ex- Palace manager Alan Smith that GS was not that enamoured with being England manager and would like to return to club football!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 15 Oct 20 8.45am

Originally posted by Spiderman

That thought has crossed my mind. Not ITK or not professing that this is true but I had heard from an acquaintance of ex- Palace manager Alan Smith that GS was not that enamoured with being England manager and would like to return to club football!

He isn’t good enough for top flight club management, but perfect for National Manager as he says the right words.
Lost any credibility he had by continually picking that donkey McGuire, who has no ability or confidence and has personal issues.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Oct 20 9.09am

Whilst we are on England, and sorry if this offends anyone, but am I the only person in the world who has never witnessed Jadon Sancho actually do anything of note, ever, in a game? Isn't he supposed to be the next or even current big thing?

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Gribbo Flag Bromley 15 Oct 20 9.37am

Nope. I am with you, massively overrated. I watched a bit of German football on TV whilst in lockdown - sideways and backwards in their own half, no penetration in the opposing box, everything at snail's pace. Bayern do well obviously and Jadon seems to as well in this environment. Outside of it sadly Jadon is invisible. Over-valued and interesting the Man U scouts, which says it all.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Oct 20 9.45am

Originally posted by Gribbo

Nope. I am with you, massively overrated. I watched a bit of German football on TV whilst in lockdown - sideways and backwards in their own half, no penetration in the opposing box, everything at snail's pace. Bayern do well obviously and Jadon seems to as well in this environment. Outside of it sadly Jadon is invisible. Over-valued and interesting the Man U scouts, which says it all.

Yes forgot to mention that, I have watched him a few times for Dortmund and never actually been that impressed. They're a very good team and play very quick football, he manages to keep up with the action but seems to benefit far more from his team mates than they do from him.

That said, I have not watched Dortmund with any consistency or to any great extent.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

RyWa Flag Beckenham 15 Oct 20 10.27am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Yes forgot to mention that, I have watched him a few times for Dortmund and never actually been that impressed. They're a very good team and play very quick football, he manages to keep up with the action but seems to benefit far more from his team mates than they do from him.

That said, I have not watched Dortmund with any consistency or to any great extent.


Im shocked what im reading. In the Bundesliga, Sancho is rated as one of the best players in the league.
30 goals and 34 assists in 78 league games from a winger, thats a ridiculous return.
I watch alot of Bundesliga and hes extremely direct and would be a huge coup for a premier league team if signed.


Edited by RyWa (15 Oct 2020 10.28am)

 

buzby1 Flag Devon 15 Oct 20 10.30am

Roy... sorry, Gareth, was on the radio this morning saying how well the team played. What I saw was a shambolic performance orchestrated by a manager who is tactically inept, plays people out of position, ignores creative talent like Grealish, Alexander-Arnold and Foden and puts his trust in second-rate players who are out form for their clubs. Kane looked like a forward version of Maguire. Pickford is not only playing poorly but he's got a real attitude problem. The FA will continue to back Southgate and a terrific generation of very talented young English footballers will once again get no rewards. Southgate is a good politician but a lousy football manager.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 15 Oct 20 10.34am

Originally posted by RyWa


Im shocked what im reading. In the Bundesliga, Sancho is rated as one of the best players in the league.
30 goals and 34 assists in 78 league games from a winger, thats a ridiculous return.
I watch alot of Bundesliga and hes extremely direct and would be a huge coup for a premier league team if signed.


Edited by RyWa (15 Oct 2020 10.28am)

Not at all shocked - any decent English youngster gets the same treatment eventually.. we love to slate a prospect.


The even more ridiculous thing about Sancho’s numbers are that he’s done that as a teenager - the only other players to turn out 15goals/15assists in a season over the last 10 years are Messi, Ronaldo, Neymar, Suarez and Hazard.

 

Aray Flag South London 15 Oct 20 10.35am

Right now he's lost the plot, clearly. but i remember a few of years back going to a game at Wembley (Nigeria I think) and I was surprised at how progressive England were. I thought - we might actually be ok, and we were.

Question is whether he can get back to that. Jury is out. But certainly I'd rather he didn't come to Palace if its this version of his managment on offer. Dyche seems to be the obvious choice for a team like ours. He'll get a bit more dosh to spend which will make him happy.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Oct 20 10.36am

Originally posted by RyWa


Im shocked what im reading. In the Bundesliga, Sancho is rated as one of the best players in the league.
30 goals and 34 assists in 78 league games from a winger, thats a ridiculous return.
I watch alot of Bundesliga and hes extremely direct and would be a huge coup for a premier league team if signed.


Edited by RyWa (15 Oct 2020 10.28am)

I'm not sure why you are so shocked?

I am not questioning his footballing ability, his prowess in the Bundesliga nor his stats which are obviously very good.

I stated in my original post 'I must be the only person who has never...' as I am merely saying I have never personally witnessed anything that would back up his reputation in Germany or his stats albeit admittedly not having watched him a great deal only seeing him for England and maybe 5/6 Dortmund games (very rough guess). Just a thought nothing more!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 15 Oct 20 11.35am

Never been a big fan of this current England Setup.

The last World Cup whipped everyone into a fury, but we still were'nt that good, and fluked it to the Semi's.

The single main redeeming feature to this whole setup is that Gareth always has 1 eye on youth. - well, so far in that he used To manage the u21s (has he actually brought anyone in that he did not manage in the u21s yet?)

I get what he is trying to do - It's fine to only playing players "in form", but you need to balance that with some kind of consistency of selection in an effort to get these players playing as a team.

This is the job of the international Manager.

plus, of course, we have no defensive midfielders or Centre backs to speak of but do have some promising youngsters coming through. Rice and Phillips need to come up to speed so Dier never has to pull on an england shirt again, and same goes for Gomez/Coady and Maguire.

On the Flip side, these are(used to be) 'Friendly' games, so GS has a right to experiment in them. Come tournament time then we see the colour of his b*llox.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Gribbo Flag Bromley 15 Oct 20 12.08pm

Is it me or is anyone else frustrated with Harry Kane just shooting every time he gets the ball within 40 yards of goal. I know he scores a few, but he must be a nightmare to play with. Salah does the same. For them it seems scoring goals individually is more important than getting the right outcome for the team. I know goals for the team makes all the difference, but they could help more widely if they made better decisions.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Oct 20 12.11pm

Why not start with the team that finished against Wales, frankly tearing them apart? Instead, revert to the team that fluked a win against Iceland and barely deserved anything against Wales and Denmark. That's just silly.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy & Gareth cut from the same cloth