You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Fitness the Real Problem?
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Fitness the Real Problem?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 01 Mar 21 10.57am

I'm in total bewilderment about our atrocious performances this season. Quite how we've got so many points will forever be a mystery. I am, nevertheless, relieved that it appears we will be in the top division 'Come the Revolution' this summer.

We can bang on forever about contracts, attitude, formation, Roy in or out, investment etc but for me, there is one fundamental problem: fitness.

Scott Guyett has reigned supreme and unchallenged for far too long. From inside the club, it's known as 'The Scott Show', suggesting he can do no wrong and is untouchable. And yet, his (conditioning) record leading to muscular injuries is appalling and our average player distances are always within the bottom three in the league. Natural athletes like Wilf, PVA and Schlupp have all lost their pace and the rest just meander along. Everyone is clearly too comfortable and not conditioned or motivated to reach their full physical potential.

I pray that when a new management team arrive, we see a change of guard in our fitness and conditioning team. Please.

 


Spirit of 1974

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 01 Mar 21 11.39am

Agree 100% general fitness does appear to be a problem that we have had for a long time and is not only in relation to our older players.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 01 Mar 21 11.45am

I don't know if it's Scott's fault, or if it's facilities or whatever. However, I would question our entire coaching/training and scouting system. We seem to lag behind half of the championship sides, and whilst I don't know, we seem one of the poorest in the division.
Injuries an obvious example, general fitness seems bad but also technique seems lacking. First touch, passing, dribbling, shooting all seem poor.
As for scouting, the latest version of FM seems more advanced than us.

 


Red and Blue Army!

kev64 Flag Cambs 01 Mar 21 4.14pm

Why bewildered?. They are playing how they are told to by Roy et al, the training is borderline 70s style, fitness levels and the ability to sprint or play high pressing football is non existent.

As we all know the game plan is 11 behind the ball for 89 minutes and keep fingers crossed that a ball gets crossed to Tekkers for which he never makes a run for anyway. The whole set up makes Trevor Francis look like a football genius, our team is dead man walking, 11 players and manager out of contract, who coincidentally thinks 0-0 to Fulham is all we could of dreamed of.

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 01 Mar 21 4.54pm

Originally posted by kev64

Why bewildered?. They are playing how they are told to by Roy et al, the training is borderline 70s style, fitness levels and the ability to sprint or play high pressing football is non existent.

As we all know the game plan is 11 behind the ball for 89 minutes and keep fingers crossed that a ball gets crossed to Tekkers for which he never makes a run for anyway. The whole set up makes Trevor Francis look like a football genius, our team is dead man walking, 11 players and manager out of contract, who coincidentally thinks 0-0 to Fulham is all we could of dreamed of.


Pretty sure I explained my bewilderment.

 


Spirit of 1974

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Mar 21 5.08pm

Agree totally, this team have not looked for a good while fit enough to compete with the modern pressing game.
I'm pretty certain that a good while ago I saw an interview with Sir Steve the gist of which was whatever can be said about his team, fitness issues were not one of them, they could go toe to toe with any team.
Watching some of over current lot saunter about like it's a school playground kickabout is a joke.

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Mar 21 5.47pm

An interesting perspective that I hadn't thought of.
Having an older squad doesn't help,but perhaps it's a broader issue.
If there is a change of manager in the summer there may also be a change of backroom staff.
Not sure it would address our lack of pace without the addition of new players though.

Originally posted by bifffabazz

I'm in total bewilderment about our atrocious performances this season. Quite how we've got so many points will forever be a mystery. I am, nevertheless, relieved that it appears we will be in the top division 'Come the Revolution' this summer.

We can bang on forever about contracts, attitude, formation, Roy in or out, investment etc but for me, there is one fundamental problem: fitness.

Scott Guyett has reigned supreme and unchallenged for far too long. From inside the club, it's known as 'The Scott Show', suggesting he can do no wrong and is untouchable. And yet, his (conditioning) record leading to muscular injuries is appalling and our average player distances are always within the bottom three in the league. Natural athletes like Wilf, PVA and Schlupp have all lost their pace and the rest just meander along. Everyone is clearly too comfortable and not conditioned or motivated to reach their full physical potential.

I pray that when a new management team arrive, we see a change of guard in our fitness and conditioning team. Please.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 01 Mar 21 6.12pm

You train your fitness for what you require no more no less.

If a manager has a set style then that is what it would be for.

Players losing pace that happens again with style of play also age plus wear (humans are not suppose to do these activities its not natural it takes its toll)

Regarding injuries these happen no matter your level of fitness and a big point that has been missed is schedule professional athletes should not be competing in so many games in short periods their is lots of evidence to back this up plus as stated before humans are not designed for these activities its not healthy.

The clear example when it comes to fitness was Pep when he went to City he has a style and it took him over a year to get players upto the fitness levels required also he could see some people just cant do what you are asking so they needed replacing.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Mar 21 6.23pm

A combination of fitness and age are taking their toll on our team. But we seem to buy players that have injury issues. When is the WBA player ever going to play??

Don’t get me started on Connor Wickham, it’s beyond a joke now...

 

jeeagles Flag 01 Mar 21 7.19pm

27 to 29 should be when you hit peak fitness.

You shouldn't start losing pace until you start losing muscle and mobility.

In modern sport 30 shouldn't be that old.

We get an alarming amount of hamstring injuries.

Our midfield isn't that mobile, but Luka, McArthur, and previously Meyer all covered a lot of ground in seasons gone by, but that seems to be diminished drastically in the last couple of seasons.

Guys the size of Benteke, Wickham, Sorloth etc are carrying around 20kg more that a smaller nimble midfielder. You shouldn't expect them to put in the same amount of ground over 90mins as the test of the team.

Everyone knows who I'm going to point the finger at. It's all very concerning.

Some managers seem to get more injuries that others, Pardew sides had lots of injuries at Palace and Newcastle.

The Dad's Army argument can apply to players aged 33 plus, but for the majority of our side, it shouldn't be an issue.

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 01 Mar 21 9.26pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

You train your fitness for what you require no more no less.

If a manager has a set style then that is what it would be for.

Players losing pace that happens again with style of play also age plus wear (humans are not suppose to do these activities its not natural it takes its toll)

Regarding injuries these happen no matter your level of fitness and a big point that has been missed is schedule professional athletes should not be competing in so many games in short periods their is lots of evidence to back this up plus as stated before humans are not designed for these activities its not healthy.

The clear example when it comes to fitness was Pep when he went to City he has a style and it took him over a year to get players upto the fitness levels required also he could see some people just cant do what you are asking so they needed replacing.


Absolutely tosh. Poor fitness and conditioning are entirely the cause of muscular injuries.

 


Spirit of 1974

Xong Kudu Flag 01 Mar 21 9.38pm

I’ve been thinking about McArthur recently. I know he’s a tad unfashionable, aging and also another defensive midfielder but his positional awareness and link up play in the middle has always been good. It’s not a coincidence that our frailty in the middle has coincided with his absence. I also think Milo plays better with him as a wing man in the middle if that makes sense. If we’re going to push on towards 50 points this season we need him back. I’m not convinced with Riederwald in the middle although I don’t doubt is commitment and overall improvement..

 

Xong Kudu Flag 01 Mar 21 10.04pm

Ps. I am always staggered with our lack of movement and guile in the box. Freedman needs to get a young Fowler or G Murray who has that ability to be there at the right time and let the wingers and midfield build around that.

 

Xong Kudu Flag 01 Mar 21 10.24pm

Last one. We all celebrated when Benteke scored a few days back but it was like watching one of those trees from Lord of the Rings finally being in a lucky position when a leg or branch swings out and....thank god it goes in. With his heavy legs and lack of movement we can only hope he does that 1 in 7 games. It’s just not good enough. Defenders say he is the easiest player in Premier League to pick because his movement is so predictable and leg movements so slow.

 

CT Charlie Flag 02 Mar 21 2.41am

Our fitness is poor, but I just don't think we have much speed in our legs nor stamina in our aging bodies. I do not think the injuries are a reflection of fitness so much as age. For Wilf, the main source of his troubles is constantly being hacked. Even if the actual foul isn't the direct cause of an injury, he's constantly forced to compensate and recover on the run – a sure way to turn tweaks and nicks into more troublesome injuries.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 02 Mar 21 3.53am

Originally posted by bifffabazz


Absolutely tosh. Poor fitness and conditioning are entirely the cause of muscular injuries.


Partially true

I stated some other reasons which you clearly discarded which Im not surprised you are not educated on the subject so when you get qualifications in this subject like myself feel free to come out with some fact based information


Originally posted by CT Charlie

Our fitness is poor, but I just don't think we have much speed in our legs nor stamina in our aging bodies. I do not think the injuries are a reflection of fitness so much as age. For Wilf, the main source of his troubles is constantly being hacked. Even if the actual foul isn't the direct cause of an injury, he's constantly forced to compensate and recover on the run – a sure way to turn tweaks and nicks into more troublesome injuries.


Our fitness is not poor if it was the players would be on their last legs every game and picking up injuries every game.

the fitness levels are set for the style of play.

A lot of the players we have was never quickest so its not to do with age.

More excuses for Wilf nothing to do with being fouled he looked quick in lower league he has stepped up a class and now he has been shown to not be as that quick he is more about dribbled not speed also adding bulk slows you down.

Injuries will be because he is playing all the games the schedule for last few seasons has been terrible the players do not get enough recovery time plus people forget players that have been putting their body through this since they was teenagers it takes its toll this was the reason they was classed as having short careers

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 02 Mar 21 6.27am

What an ignorant narcissist you are Mr G Mort.
Nothing like derailing a reasonable debate is there? Muppet.

 


Spirit of 1974

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 Mar 21 8.12am

Originally posted by Xong Kudu

Ps. I am always staggered with our lack of movement and guile in the box. Freedman needs to get a young Fowler or G Murray who has that ability to be there at the right time and let the wingers and midfield build around that.

I think potentially Mateta is this player but needs to get game time, unfortunately Roy has basically said Benteke is better at defensive duties so there by lies the problem

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 02 Mar 21 9.29am


[Link]

Maybe their diet is the problem. As they used to say - a good meat pudd’n would do them good.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 02 Mar 21 10.53am

I’ve been saying all season it’s like they’re all playing in concrete boots, there’s no energy in the team Ayew is the only one who tries to drive forward and put a bit of zip into our game. And obviously Wilf when he’s around

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Fitness the Real Problem?