You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Views on PV
November 16 2026 3.16am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Views on PV


Page 1 of 17 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Living In Hope Flag Petersfield 22 Jan 23 12.30pm

I am sitting on the fence as I write this. On the one hand PV had an incredibly tough job last year with such a massive change needed to players and age profile, and he did better than we could have hoped for. This season I am not at all convinced though, and the promise of last season is dwindling. We aren’t playing well, will be lucky to stay out of the relegation battle, and I can’t understand some of his decisions (eg playing Schlupp rather than Hughes as midfield starter), whilst the substitutions are usually baffling. However, I also think he hasn’t been given the right support in transfer dealings since last season, where we have let useful players go without replacing them (eg Kouyate who would have been really valuable at times this season). So the jury’s very much still out for me. What do others think ?

 

waddy Flag Highton,Melbourne 22 Jan 23 12.37pm

I am Pro PV
He is trying hard to get the team around play it from back , have confidence on the ball , creative more attacking entertaining football

You can see he has a squad of young learning vs old tiresome & slow
and a three lazy sods

So he’s done well last season ,tricky this but the top 8 are fully investing in players not us so we need to be fair to him

If he is not supported with new players I guess he himself will be snapped up
and we will get a new a coach to blame I'm sure
So let’s give him the time the players then judge

He is the best v CCP is h we’ve had in a long time let’s keep him like Arsenal stood by Arteta with their frap season last year - look now who is screaming hot Arteta out now ????

 


Forever Palace Proud

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jan 23 12.39pm

Very good manager. Do I agree with every decision he makes? No. But on balance, the scales are tilted massively in his favour. He's calm, professional, ambitious, has a plan, has the respect of the players, has given us added credibility as a club, and overall has moved us forward on the pitch (with very little support from the board over the last twelve months). If we want to do better, we need to support him, not replace him. Further, he doesn't make knee-jerk decisions, backs himself, and while everyone makes mistakes, he gets far more right than he gets wrong.

Obviously, I could get into the details of why I think some of his decisions make sense but I'll save that for another day. Anyone who thinks we should replace him, I don't understand at all.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Jan 23 1.03pm

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

Very good manager. Do I agree with every decision he makes? No. But on balance, the scales are tilted massively in his favour. He's calm, professional, ambitious, has a plan, has the respect of the players, has given us added credibility as a club, and overall has moved us forward on the pitch (with very little support from the board over the last twelve months). If we want to do better, we need to support him, not replace him. Further, he doesn't make knee-jerk decisions, backs himself, and while everyone makes mistakes, he gets far more right than he gets wrong.

Obviously, I could get into the details of why I think some of his decisions make sense but I'll save that for another day. Anyone who thinks we should replace him, I don't understand at all.

Some of the players signed whilst Vieira has been at the helm :
Andersen, Guehi, Gallagher, Hughes,Olise,Eduoard,Johnstone,Richards,Doucoure.
Over £100 mill of signings.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Jan 23 1.06pm

I'm all for PV, talk of getting rid of him is daft. We can't go out and buy an entire new line up, so he has to manage what he's got. So far he's doing alright. I'm interested to see how he progresses the youth players and accommodates them into the squad, which I believe is one of Parish's long term aims.

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 22 Jan 23 1.19pm

PV did a very decent job last season when Mr Textor's money provided him with the tools.
Post that things have replied to type - we no longer have Gallagher, Kouyate was foolishly not re-signed, Macarthur has been unavailable & Benteke left without any replacement.The only tangible replacement on the midfielders above has been Decoure & we still haven't had any of the much needed upgrades on for example Ward (cruelly exposed last night), Luka and Ayew to make but 3.
PV has done and can carry on doing a good job for Palace, but and it is large one, Mr Parish must put aside his apparent lack of agreement with Mr Textor and over the next 9 days, provide the right back, central midfielder and hopefully another forward to get us comfortably to the end of the season when another restructure looks likely with so many out of contract players.

 

EddieMac Flag 22 Jan 23 1.37pm

Overall I am happy with PV especially last season when we looked to be in serious trouble leading up to the start of the season.

This season has been strange and some of his decisions leave me baffled,but the things he can’t control are our individual mistakes which lead to goals and our woeful finishing of goal chances.

My main gripe as always is his constant use of Schlupp. I get the feeling that Schlupp is a project of his and he is determined to turn him into a certain type of player when in my view Schlupp doesn’t even resemble a football player most of the time.

If we can get ourselves a decent pair of ball playing full backs, a centre mid and a striker it will make all the difference.

Edited by EddieMac (22 Jan 2023 1.38pm)

 

davehuggins Flag 22 Jan 23 1.51pm

100% Happy from me, we are just struggling a bit right now. All clubs have spells like this and questions are asked but IMO he has done a very good job to date.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 22 Jan 23 2.03pm

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

Very good manager. Do I agree with every decision he makes? No. But on balance, the scales are tilted massively in his favour. He's calm, professional, ambitious, has a plan, has the respect of the players, has given us added credibility as a club, and overall has moved us forward on the pitch (with very little support from the board over the last twelve months). If we want to do better, we need to support him, not replace him. Further, he doesn't make knee-jerk decisions, backs himself, and while everyone makes mistakes, he gets far more right than he gets wrong.

Obviously, I could get into the details of why I think some of his decisions make sense but I'll save that for another day. Anyone who thinks we should replace him, I don't understand at all.

Ridiculous statement, he may become one, but he certainly isn't yet, failed at Nice, over 100m spent, no sign of any improvement, in fact i think most players have deteriorated under him, poor formation selection for most of the season, lot of players playing out of position, until the last two games, no passion, the jury is very much out for me

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Jan 23 2.10pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Ridiculous statement, he may become one, but he certainly isn't yet, failed at Nice, over 100m spent, no sign of any improvement, in fact i think most players have deteriorated under him, poor formation selection for most of the season, lot of players playing out of position, until the last two games, no passion, the jury is very much out for me

What exactly do you expect? PV has actually done better league positionally than Roy, who originally inherited a decent squad. When that side was run down and out of contract PV had to pick up the pieces and start over.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 22 Jan 23 2.10pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Ridiculous statement, he may become one, but he certainly isn't yet, failed at Nice, over 100m spent, no sign of any improvement, in fact i think most players have deteriorated under him, poor formation selection for most of the season, lot of players playing out of position, until the last two games, no passion, the jury is very much out for me

Do you though? I'm starting to wonder.

I think Vieira has done enough for us to give him some patience. He has overseen the overhaul of the squad and transitioned the team to playing in a new way without us ever seriously looking in threat of being drawn into a relegation fight. Guehi and Mitchell both received England call-ups under his watch and Olise has been eased into the PL and has been improving. I'm not about to build a statue, but I'm happy with him at the helm.

Edited by taylors lovechild (22 Jan 2023 2.11pm)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jan 23 2.16pm

Still learning his trade - can imagine him at a big side sooner or later. Football has definitely improved, we sometimes play well. Vieira has also shown willingness to just dig in a couple of times - so is not completely set in his ways like a previous manager was.
I don't like the complaints over substitutions - sometimes fatigue is just a factor. With Hughes kind of high intensity play, we can't just play him and never anyone else. We've had three matches close together - we had to rotate with the unfortunately sh1tty squad we have.
If people think Vieira can't hack it - then I would ask, who used Gallagher so well last season? There were and there are other managers who don't get a tap out of players. There are managers who wouldn't even play Gallagher.
I used to think Potter a superior manager if truth be told. Now I'm glad we have PV. I reckon he's starting to get the Palace way.
The caveat, however, is that it's obviously a results game. Palace have been known to sack if necessary, so anything could happen. Which is I guess the beauty of football that is being somewhat removed by the silly mega bucks.

 


Red and Blue Army!

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 22 Jan 23 3.09pm

Pats improved our playing style no doubt, however we play a lot of long balls. Even without Anderson yesterday we were playing from back to front a hell of a of a lot and invariably losing the ball. We Continually kept pumping balls up to the forwards and getting beat. I could not understand the number of balls including long kicks from Guaita to the side Dan Burn was playing. Barely any of our forwards generally even bother jumping. Our play is so basic.

Our possession stats are not what they were either. We run the fewest distance in the prem, and score the fewest goals from open play. A lot needs to be done with this team. Can't all be down to Gallager surely


 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 22 Jan 23 3.12pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Pats improved our playing style no doubt, however we play a lot of long balls. Even without Anderson yesterday we were playing from back to front a hell of a of a lot and invariably losing the ball. We Continually kept pumping balls up to the forwards and getting beat. I could not understand the number of balls including long kicks from Guaita to the side Dan Burn was playing. Barely any of our forwards generally even bother jumping. Our play is so basic.

Our possession stats are not what they were either. We run the fewest distance in the prem, and score the fewest goals from open play. A lot needs to be done with this team. Can't all be down to Gallager surely

The way he wants to play Viera needs 2 x new fullbacks, a Gallagher clone and a goalscorer then we can judge him imo.


 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 22 Jan 23 3.23pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

What exactly do you expect? PV has actually done better league positionally than Roy, who originally inherited a decent squad. When that side was run down and out of contract PV had to pick up the pieces and start over.

Roy was a very good manager, 15 clubs, 3 international sides, only sacked twice, yes, he had over 100m to pick up the pieces, most were finished the previous season, and the one player he should have kept, Kouyate, he didnt.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 22 Jan 23 3.32pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Do you though? I'm starting to wonder.

I think Vieira has done enough for us to give him some patience. He has overseen the overhaul of the squad and transitioned the team to playing in a new way without us ever seriously looking in threat of being drawn into a relegation fight. Guehi and Mitchell both received England call-ups under his watch and Olise has been eased into the PL and has been improving. I'm not about to build a statue, but I'm happy with him at the helm.

Edited by taylors lovechild (22 Jan 2023 2.11pm)

He isn't a very good manager, we dont know yet, he is new and needs to learn, the way of playing is his choice, is the style the best for the players we have? thats what a very good manager does, time will tell, could be good, could be incapable of putting what he wants to do before the best interest of the club

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

TheBigToePunt Flag 22 Jan 23 3.37pm

He did a very good job last year, incorporating lots of new players and a very different way of playing whilst maintaining a healthy midtable position (and a cup run, although they happen more by mistake these days).

This year we have maintained a reasonable midtable position but not been anything like as good to watch. You would hope the team would be more cohesive in a managers second year, but the opposite is true, at least as an attacking force.

For me, the issue is the quality and type of attacking player at the managers disposal. For a decade we've played defensive football and relied on moments of individual endeavour to get goals. Each of Zaha, Bolasie, Townsend, Ayew, Edouard etc wants (or wanted) the ball to feet so they can improvise. None of them make good runs off the ball to make sharp forward passing possible, or have any great gift for combination play.

That didn't matter so much until we started trying to have more of the ball. Our periods of possession and pressure come around more often now, but only serve to illustrate how infrequently our forwards are capable of coordinated movement or combinations. One of the forwards coming towards our midfield asking for the ball to feet is common, but how often do you see a well timed run behind the opponents defence? One of the forwards trying to find a way past two or three opponents (often without success) happens almost every time we attack, but you can wait weeks to see a simple one-two passing combination. In fact, one and two touch pass and move football in the opposition half appears to be an alien concept.

Pundits say that individualistic players are hard to play against because they are unpredictable, but actually they are entirely predictable - every time they get they will try and beat you by themselves, and if they can't, they will hold the ball for far too long before releasing it so the momentum of the attack disappears.

That's why we've scored so infrequently, but the manager only has the players he has.

I'd like to see a post-Zaha Palace involve at least one forward who runs off the ball at pace, and a midfielder who times runs into space. We can then develop a team around football intelligence and movement as well as individual endeavour, which will get the best from Eze and Olise. Both players are capable of beating their man occasionally, but we aren't getting any benefit from their passing range and awareness at the moment.

All the time that Vieira has to select from Ayew, Edouard and Mateta, I find it hard to criticise him for our stodgy forward play.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (22 Jan 2023 3.44pm)

Edited by TheBigToePunt (22 Jan 2023 3.46pm)

 

CT Charlie Flag 22 Jan 23 3.48pm

I'm pro-PV. I think he has earned the respect of a team that isn't necessarily easy to work with. Our inconsistency and lack of focus is to be expected from a team so young.

In terms of talent, we have one excellent attacker, one excellent midfielder, and two excellent defenders (three if Mitchell is healthy and rested), however "excellent" (except for the complicated Wilf) means "would start at most PL teams outside the top 8" – not necessarily excel.

 

Runningman Flag Keston 22 Jan 23 3.55pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

He did a very good job last year, incorporating lots of new players and a very different way of playing whilst maintaining a healthy midtable position (and a cup run, although they happen more by mistake these days).

This year we have maintained a reasonable midtable position but not been anything like as good to watch. You would hope the team would be more cohesive in a managers second year, but the opposite is true, at least as an attacking force.

For me, the issue is the quality and type of attacking player at the managers disposal. For a decade we've played defensive football and relied on moments of individual endeavour to get goals. Each of Zaha, Bolasie, Townsend, Ayew, Edouard etc wants (or wanted) the ball to feet so they can improvise. None of them make good runs off the ball to make sharp forward passing possible, or have any great gift for combination play.

That didn't matter so much until we started trying to have more of the ball. Our periods of possession and pressure come around more often now, but only serve to illustrate how infrequently our forwards are capable of coordinated movement or combinations. One of the forwards coming towards our midfield asking for the ball to feet is common, but how often do you see a well timed run behind the opponents defence? One of the forwards trying to find a way past two or three opponents (often without success) happens almost every time we attack, but you can wait weeks to see a simple one-two passing combination. In fact, one and two touch pass and move football in the opposition half appears to be an alien concept.

Pundits say that individualistic players are hard to play against because they are unpredictable, but actually they are entirely predictable - every time they get they will try and beat you by themselves, and if they can't, they will hold the ball for far too long before releasing it so the momentum of the attack disappears.

That's why we've scored so infrequently, but the manager only has the players he has.

I'd like to see a post-Zaha Palace involve at least one forward who runs off the ball at pace, and a midfielder who times runs into space. We can then develop a team around football intelligence and movement as well as individual endeavour, which will get the best from Eze and Olise. Both players are capable of beating their man occasionally, but we aren't getting any benefit from their passing range and awareness at the moment.

All the time that Vieira has to select from Ayew, Edouard and Mateta, I find it hard to criticise him for our stodgy forward play.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (22 Jan 2023 3.44pm)

Edited by TheBigToePunt (22 Jan 2023 3.46pm)


Zaha isn’t half the player he was last year. Don’t want to write him off but I think we looked a lot more mobile after he was subbed off yesterday.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 22 Jan 23 4.03pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Roy was a very good manager, 15 clubs, 3 international sides, only sacked twice, yes, he had over 100m to pick up the pieces, most were finished the previous season, and the one player he should have kept, Kouyate, he didnt.

Since when ? Stuck Roberto Carlos in midfield, Harry kane on corners haha that tells you everything you need to know about him, terrible at Liverpool, you wouldn't have his career if you was bad but I definitely wouldn't describe him as good and playing for a draw at home to struggling teams in the league. No thanks

Viera is doing a great job, managers always need 3 years to build their own squad. Unless things are going drastically wrong then you keep them. If things go drastically right they usually get a bigger club. It would make no sense at all to get rid of viera and no chance the club would anyway.

 

Page 1 of 17 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Views on PV