You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should he stay or should he go.
November 16 2026 3.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should he stay or should he go.


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Therealeaglestilidie Flag 14 May 23 9.06am

There were a lot of unhappy fans when Roy returned but given the upturn in form over the past two months.

Would you now take Roy as manager come August?

Edited by Therealeaglestilidie (14 May 2023 9.07am)

 


I'm so Palace I don't even know it

davehuggins Flag 14 May 23 9.20am

RH is a very good manager as we all know, when he was with us before he didn't have the talent we have now to work with. Last stint he IMO did a brilliant job keeping us up and mid-table with far less quality. So, answer to your question, if he feels he wants and the players are onside then YES!!

 

YT Flag Oxford 14 May 23 9.25am

Let's not CLASH over this.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

waddy Flag Highton,Melbourne 14 May 23 9.31am

The great debate of RH came in we turned a corner
What if PV stayed on would we have turned the corner ?
( as we know we played top teams on a run got a couple of narrow loses
& tight draws (( Man City 81st minute / Man Utd 91st Draw )) under PV

So if we keep RH on what is our expectation next year 12/13/14th spot ?

What if we have a poor run in first 3 months playing the top 8 teams from this year
Do we sack him like PV ?

 


Forever Palace Proud

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 14 May 23 9.56am

It is not just about Roy and I appreciate he is the focal point but the back room staff come heavily into this …. Ray, Paddy etc so the question also is what do they want to do?
Ray is on the same short term contract as Roy with Paddy longer.
If the team can be kept together I would say Yes.

 


Bring back Brolin

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 14 May 23 10.26am

Originally posted by YT

Let's not CLASH over this.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

PatrickA Flag London 14 May 23 10.27am

I started a similar thread a short time ago, 'If it ain't broke don't fix it.'
Unless there's an outstanding candidate available in the summer as part of some strategic master plan (which I doubt) there's no real point in making a change, particularly taking into account that the average tenure of a Premier League manager is less than two years in any event.
Roy has made it clear that he's not retiring in the summer and has been at pains to suggest how happy he and Ray have been upon their return.
It would surely be nonsensical to make a change merely based upon his age.

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 14 May 23 11.42am

Its a big question would he have same effect next season , will we have the same squad apart from couple of upgrades , if he takes a job upstairs over seeing the new manager , but who will we have , it is a hard one , Long live King ROY and Prince RAY

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 14 May 23 12.05pm

I will be very surprised if Roy wants the job full-time. I expect him to go off on his hols (as he has said he will once the season is over) in the knowledge that he has finished his Palace career on a high and corrected a good number of people's misconceptions about his managerial limitations.

 

beak Flag croydon 14 May 23 12.13pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

It is not just about Roy and I appreciate he is the focal point but the back room staff come heavily into this …. Ray, Paddy etc so the question also is what do they want to do?
Ray is on the same short term contract as Roy with Paddy longer.
If the team can be kept together I would say Yes.

If Hodgson stays so does Ray,why would the heir apparent Paddy jump ship, it would make no sense. A huge yes to keep Croydon Roy.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 14 May 23 12.27pm

Originally posted by Therealeaglestilidie

There were a lot of unhappy fans when Roy returned but given the upturn in form over the past two months.

Would you now take Roy as manager come August?

Edited by Therealeaglestilidie (14 May 2023 9.07am)

I was very disappointed latterly with the Veira football but we'd played some of the best teams in this year's PL. It was a bit harsh to sack him when we were coming to a run of theoretically winnable games. However, I'm not sure Veira would have motivated the team like Roy, Ray and Paddy have done. On the basis of our recent results I'd be happy with the status quo but we should be adding to our current squad not potentially weakening it if all this talk of transfers is to be believed.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 May 23 12.48pm

Roy is refusing to discuss his plans which suggest to me that he wants to stay. As others have pointed out unless there is an outstanding candidate better the devil you know.

Edited by Badger11 (14 May 2023 12.49pm)

 


One more point

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 14 May 23 12.49pm

Originally posted by waddy

The great debate of RH came in we turned a corner
What if PV stayed on would we have turned the corner ?
( as we know we played top teams on a run got a couple of narrow loses
& tight draws (( Man City 81st minute / Man Utd 91st Draw )) under PV

So if we keep RH on what is our expectation next year 12/13/14th spot ?

What if we have a poor run in first 3 months playing the top 8 teams from this year
Do we sack him like PV ?

Are you serious, PV couldn't turn on a tap, never mind the corner.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 May 23 12.52pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Are you serious, PV couldn't turn on a tap, never mind the corner.

LOL.

If PV is a good manager he will prove it elsewhere in which case we will become his Motherwell to Alex Ferguson.

 


One more point

YT Flag Oxford 14 May 23 1.53pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Roy is refusing to discuss his plans which suggest to me that he wants to stay. As others have pointed out unless there is an outstanding candidate better the devil you know.

Edited by Badger11 (14 May 2023 12.49pm)

It's SONIA conscience if you get it wrong though.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 14 May 23 2.14pm

Love Roy, but he had nothing to lose coming back, the upturn in form was always going to happen with the fixtures we had whoever was in charge. So I wouldn’t want him to stay because when the going gets tough next season it will soon slip back into the negative dour football of the last couple of years of his reign. I’d like him to go out on a high against Forest and for us to have a fresh start next season

 

Jacey Flag 14 May 23 2.19pm

Originally posted by monkey

Love Roy, but he had nothing to lose coming back, the upturn in form was always going to happen with the fixtures we had whoever was in charge. So I wouldn’t want him to stay because when the going gets tough next season it will soon slip back into the negative dour football of the last couple of years of his reign. I’d like him to go out on a high against Forest and for us to have a fresh start next season

Disagree.
PV,would probably taken us down as was proving to be devoid of any new ideas or a change of direction.
Without Connor,we seemed toothless and a win was a step too far under his tenure.

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 14 May 23 2.44pm

I am not against him staying in view of the effect he has had in motivating players to such an extent that he has shown we have a squad more than capable of maintaining our Premiership status. My only doubt occurred yesterday when he made his substitutions. He brought on Jairo and Maca rather than any of the other young midfielders and made the point in his interviews that there is plenty of talent in the older players which I am sure with his knowledge is totally correct. However if the Club is looking to move forward with younger players there is a doubt in my mind that Roy would give them the opportunity to get game time. If the Club really do want to move forward with youth I am not sure Roy is the one to do it. Either way I will not be annoyed if Roy stays COYP

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 14 May 23 3.02pm

Ultimately, the job of a manager in any business is to get the most out of his staff. So rather than comparing PVs tough run of fixtures with our more recent fixtures under Roy, I'd be inclined to compare like-for-like; the performances of the team under Roy versus the performances (not just the results) of the same team in the same fixtures earlier in the season. In those games, PV's side mainly eked out some results. Roy's team in contrast has been rampant; utterly dominant. In short, no comparison. Roy has unlocked the squad at his disposal in a way that PV simply never did.

While I don't think it's a good idea to let the tail wag the dog, you only need to listen to Eze, Ward, Ayew, or any of a number of others to make it clear there may be a lot of work to be done over the summer, but we don't need to spend time looking for a new manager.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 14 May 23 3.11pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Disagree.
PV,would probably taken us down as was proving to be devoid of any new ideas or a change of direction.
Without Connor,we seemed toothless and a win was a step too far under his tenure.

Roy has definitely benefited from the easier run of fixtures and I believe PV would’ve got us enough points as well, as in when we comfortably beat Bournemouth on New Year’s Eve. How would Roy have done in that same tough run we had after that? We’ll never know and we all see it different, but some seem to have forgotten the massive turn around under PV and how good we looked at times last season.

That’s why I want Roy to go at the end of the season, because I would hate those with short memories that turned on PV to turn on Roy again next season when the going gets tough, as it most certainly will

Edited by monkey (14 May 2023 3.13pm)

Edited by monkey (14 May 2023 3.14pm)

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should he stay or should he go.