You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Racist Hate Crime
November 21 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Racist Hate Crime


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 22 Jul 23 1.38pm

A hand gesture we all do, has been labelled a Racist Hate Crime. Its the 'OK' sign. Rooney's DC United have fallen foul of it.

[Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

YT Flag Oxford 22 Jul 23 1.46pm

I've long suspected that the world has gone mad, now here's the ultimate proof.


 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jul 23 1.55pm

I hope they take a case - f*** all of this.

 


Red and Blue Army!

TheBigToePunt Flag 22 Jul 23 2.35pm

On one hand, who cares? It's in America, not here. Whether the OK hand sign genuinely has some racist connotation in the US, or the whole thing is woke politics in extreme I couldn't say and don't care, as neither the case or the context are British.

On the other hand, the fact the story is reported by the BBC provides (yet more) reason for concern about their agenda. What is the relevance to the British public of one person getting sacked on the other side of the world? What is the purpose of reporting this, rather than (for example) an isolated theft, murder or civil dispute case from another country which, within itself, would have greater impacts for those involved? Hundreds of thousands of the latter go unreported (understandably so), but not this case. Why? What editorial policy results in this?

I don't mind a slight obsession with race, gender etc on thier part, if they apply high intellectual standards and basic objectivity, but they never do. The report in question is typical. It explains the potential implications of the symbol, and that even the regulatory body recognises the need to take care when attributing meaning to what has long been a perfectly innocent gesture, but (as usual with the BBC) doesn't offer any serious critique of the decision in this case or of the culture. If you're not going to critique it, why report it?

My own concern is that the BBC go out of their way not to examine the trend of identity politics, to the point of refusing to acknowledge the existence of the many detailed and reasonable criticisms many other mainstream media platforms seem able to host. Once you've denied that conversation any oxygen, all these reports become layer after layer of creating a BBC worldview.

It's hard not to feel they search the haystack for needles relating to race, gender etc. The report isn't exactly lauding the process that led to someone getting sacked for something 'some people consider racist' but it certainly doesn't examine the decision either.

 

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 22 Jul 23 2.38pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

A hand gesture we all do, has been labelled a Racist Hate Crime. Its the 'OK' sign. Rooney's DC United have fallen foul of it.

[Link]

Could be a lot of people out of work in the shadow puppet industry…no more bunnies with pointed ears!

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

YT Flag Oxford 22 Jul 23 2.50pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

On one hand, who cares? It's in America, not here. Whether the OK hand sign genuinely has some racist connotation in the US, or the whole thing is woke politics in extreme I couldn't say and don't care, as neither the case or the context are British.

On the other hand, the fact the story is reported by the BBC provides (yet more) reason for concern about their agenda. What is the relevance to the British public of one person getting sacked on the other side of the world? What is the purpose of reporting this, rather than (for example) an isolated theft, murder or civil dispute case from another country which, within itself, would have greater impacts for those involved? Hundreds of thousands of the latter go unreported (understandably so), but not this case. Why? What editorial policy results in this?

I don't mind a slight obsession with race, gender etc on thier part, if they apply high intellectual standards and basic objectivity, but they never do. The report in question is typical. It explains the potential implications of the symbol, and that even the regulatory body recognises the need to take care when attributing meaning to what has long been a perfectly innocent gesture, but (as usual with the BBC) doesn't offer any serious critique of the decision in this case or of the culture. If you're not going to critique it, why report it?

My own concern is that the BBC go out of their way not to examine the trend of identity politics, to the point of refusing to acknowledge the existence of the many detailed and reasonable criticisms many other mainstream media platforms seem able to host. Once you've denied that conversation any oxygen, all these reports become layer after layer of creating a BBC worldview.

It's hard not to feel they search the haystack for needles relating to race, gender etc. The report isn't exactly lauding the process that led to someone getting sacked for something 'some people consider racist' but it certainly doesn't examine the decision either.

Congratulations on an excellent, post. How would you feel about sending it as feedback to the BBC (with a few tweaks "you" (the BBC) for "they" etc) to see what reaction it gets?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Teddy Eagle Flag 22 Jul 23 2.59pm

That's Eddie Murphy in trouble again.


[Link]

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jul 23 3.22pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

That's Eddie Murphy in trouble again.


[Link]

Constantly in blackface or stereotypical Jewish impersonations. Probably done a 'Red Indian' or Chinaman that I can't remember.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Jul 23 3.37pm

That means that all divers are racists.

While we allow lunatics to control the narrative, this kind of insanity will continue.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Jul 23 3.46pm

So all deaf people are now racist. Having a deaf family member this is a common hand sign to give an approval or agreement. f*** em all I guess, their fault for being born deaf

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 22 Jul 23 3.47pm

Originally posted by YT

Congratulations on an excellent, post. How would you feel about sending it as feedback to the BBC (with a few tweaks "you" (the BBC) for "they" etc) to see what reaction it gets?

Waste of time in my experience, unfortunately.

Around the time of the euros, BBC support (or regular, prominent and ultra non-critical coverage) regarding BLM reached the point where, for the first and only time, I submitted a complaint as follows:


Bias in coverage of BLM and footballer kneeling. 

Please can you at least attempt to exercise balance and fairness in your coverage of opposition to BLM and to footballers taking the knee?

Contrary to what appears your default position, my objections to both do not stem from racism, or from a lack of education or compassion. I oppose identity politics because I consider it a divisive, harmful and deeply flawed school of thought. For similar reasons I oppose the (evidently political) position of an organisation like BLM, whose own website called for the police to be defunded, and who advocate positive discrimination. As a human being living through a time of unprecedented crisis, I was furious about the unlawful, life-threatening gatherings during the height of the first lockdown - most of us were enduring the pain of being cut off from loved ones but complying nonetheless, and your critique of the BLM protests was grossly insufficient. In addition, I am concerned that commercial organisations can overpromote their support of BLM, successfully diverting attention away from their complicity in so many other significant issues. Mostly though, and from the outset, I was infuriated by the support offered to BLM despite their failure to show evidence of structural racism in our society. You have led from the front with fact-checks around covid, the vaccine, and your obsession with Trump, yet you apply no such factual, objective scrutiny to BLM. You suspend any comment facility on the subject, denying license fee payers the chance of respectful debate.

I don't need you to agree with my position on this issue, but you do have a responsibility to at least acknowledge the existence of reasoned opposition to BLM and to kneeling. Not doing so is not only unfair on me and others who you are misrepresenting, it is a serious failure on your part to educate and inform. It denies those who support BLM access to a view they ought to consider, misleading them into feeling they are in the presence of racism or ignorance.

I wish I'd kept the response. It was a combination of autotext ('We thank you for taking the time to contact us' the avoidance of proper engagement, dismissive power tripping ('We are not biased, you are wrong' - and that's almost a literal quote) all wrapped up in noticeably low standards (poor grammar, illogical sentences, no discernable structure of thought).

To be honest, the response was so infuriating and pointless that I deleted it, as I didn't want to get wound up every time I saw it lingering in my inbox. It was evident that they do as they please no matter what.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 Jul 23 4.02pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

A hand gesture we all do, has been labelled a Racist Hate Crime. Its the 'OK' sign. Rooney's DC United have fallen foul of it.

[Link]

Any scuba divers are in the s*** then! Ridiculous Sorry just seen Hrolf beat me to it

Edited by Spiderman (22 Jul 2023 4.02pm)

Edited by Spiderman (22 Jul 2023 4.03pm)

Edited by Spiderman (22 Jul 2023 6.15pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 Jul 23 4.05pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Waste of time in my experience, unfortunately.

Around the time of the euros, BBC support (or regular, prominent and ultra non-critical coverage) regarding BLM reached the point where, for the first and only time, I submitted a complaint as follows:


Bias in coverage of BLM and footballer kneeling. 

Please can you at least attempt to exercise balance and fairness in your coverage of opposition to BLM and to footballers taking the knee?

Contrary to what appears your default position, my objections to both do not stem from racism, or from a lack of education or compassion. I oppose identity politics because I consider it a divisive, harmful and deeply flawed school of thought. For similar reasons I oppose the (evidently political) position of an organisation like BLM, whose own website called for the police to be defunded, and who advocate positive discrimination. As a human being living through a time of unprecedented crisis, I was furious about the unlawful, life-threatening gatherings during the height of the first lockdown - most of us were enduring the pain of being cut off from loved ones but complying nonetheless, and your critique of the BLM protests was grossly insufficient. In addition, I am concerned that commercial organisations can overpromote their support of BLM, successfully diverting attention away from their complicity in so many other significant issues. Mostly though, and from the outset, I was infuriated by the support offered to BLM despite their failure to show evidence of structural racism in our society. You have led from the front with fact-checks around covid, the vaccine, and your obsession with Trump, yet you apply no such factual, objective scrutiny to BLM. You suspend any comment facility on the subject, denying license fee payers the chance of respectful debate.

I don't need you to agree with my position on this issue, but you do have a responsibility to at least acknowledge the existence of reasoned opposition to BLM and to kneeling. Not doing so is not only unfair on me and others who you are misrepresenting, it is a serious failure on your part to educate and inform. It denies those who support BLM access to a view they ought to consider, misleading them into feeling they are in the presence of racism or ignorance.

I wish I'd kept the response. It was a combination of autotext ('We thank you for taking the time to contact us' the avoidance of proper engagement, dismissive power tripping ('We are not biased, you are wrong' - and that's almost a literal quote) all wrapped up in noticeably low standards (poor grammar, illogical sentences, no discernable structure of thought).

To be honest, the response was so infuriating and pointless that I deleted it, as I didn't want to get wound up every time I saw it lingering in my inbox. It was evident that they do as they please no matter what.

I complained to the BBC about a misleading graph after the Boris election which claimed the majority of voters were in favour of Remain. Simply untrue and the way they gerrymandered the graph Stalin would have approved.

My complaint was rejected with the same BS as you.

About 1 month later the BBC was hauled over the coals for that graph and they had to admit it was wrong. I and others who complained though never received a retraction, apology or a simple acknowledgment that our complaint was upheld.

 


One more point

TheBigToePunt Flag 22 Jul 23 4.30pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I complained to the BBC about a misleading graph after the Boris election which claimed the majority of voters were in favour of Remain. Simply untrue and the way they gerrymandered the graph Stalin would have approved.

My complaint was rejected with the same BS as you.

About 1 month later the BBC was hauled over the coals for that graph and they had to admit it was wrong. I and others who complained though never received a retraction, apology or a simple acknowledgment that our complaint was upheld.

That's what happens when the complaints dept isn't functioning independently of the organisation.

The state of the BBC is a tragedy for everyone.

I can accept (or at least understand) that private, commercial media outlets inevitably end up as echo chambers, or low standard bearers as they exist to target a certain profile of customer as much, or more, as to actually deliver information. It's very far from perfect (sometimes it's awful) but it's perhaps inevitable given the commercial model they rely on and which, in turn, ensures vital independence from the state.

Thing is, the BBC aren't subject to those commercial pressures. They are one of the few media outlets to be publicly funded but not state controlled. They don't have to rely on appealing to one part of the political, social or economic spectrum to stay in business. In a world full of dumb, manipulative or ignorant echo chamber media, the BBC could be a lighthouse of higher standards and objectivity, simply because they are one of the few media organisations that can afford to be. They could challenge and difuse echo chamber thinking without fear of losing custom, but they don't. They just create their own.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 22 Jul 23 7.51pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I complained to the BBC about a misleading graph after the Boris election which claimed the majority of voters were in favour of Remain. Simply untrue and the way they gerrymandered the graph Stalin would have approved.

My complaint was rejected with the same BS as you.

About 1 month later the BBC was hauled over the coals for that graph and they had to admit it was wrong. I and others who complained though never received a retraction, apology or a simple acknowledgment that our complaint was upheld.

why bother giving the BBc the effort of your time or respect ?

the only person i would like to throw their way is Oppenheimer

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Jul 23 8.00pm

It's blue anon being blue anon.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Jul 23 8.14pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

It's blue anon being blue anon.

The world was so much simpler when we just had Blue Nun.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Jul 23 8.21pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The world was so much simpler when we just had Blue Nun.

Yep.

I notice absolutely nothing has been done to find or check on whoever was sending those ridiculous messages to the Qanon crowd.

Personally it suggests to me that it was an operation from within the security services.

I hope that some work is done on this at some point and whatever the truth is that it's revealed.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 22 Jul 23 8.34pm

regarding the OP,

the extreme Left gives birth to the extreme Right.

we are living in very scary times, comrades.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 22 Jul 23 10.20pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

A hand gesture we all do, has been labelled a Racist Hate Crime. Its the 'OK' sign. Rooney's DC United have fallen foul of it.

[Link]

I don't know any more than anyone else does but could it be that it was the context of the event, rather than the actual gesture, which resulted in the sacking?

He obviously wasn't diving, and probably not using sign language to a deaf person. If he was deliberately being offensive then perhaps whatever gesture was used would have caused the same outcome.

Why have the BBC reported this? Probably because of the Wayne Rooney connection.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Racist Hate Crime