You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Should a general election be called.
November 22 2026 1.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should a general election be called.


Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6
leifandersonshair Flag Newport 07 Jul 16 9.27pm

Originally posted by chris123

The difference is that following Brexit, you can get rid of politicians that don't deliver via your vote.

Apart from the Lords of course. Who can block/delay/derail to their hearts content any legislation they don't fancy. When are the House of Lords elections again?

 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 07 Jul 16 9.28pm

Thought we had fixed 5 year term governments now? Is it so - unless the government of the day decide to go earlier?
If we had an election now - or later this year - the outcome would almost certainly be damaging to both 'major' parties as I would expect the labour party vote to split with a good percentage going to UKIP along with some of the Tory right vote so that they (UKIP) could become the second largest party and could possibly even end up going into coalition. Can't imagine many in the government would take that risk - so think an early election most unlikely - as long as the present government continue to have a working majority.

 

JohnyBoy Flag 07 Jul 16 9.33pm

Originally posted by chris123

On a previous post pre- the vote, I said on here my preferred route would be whatever is best for us, including WTO options.

The EU is not the only market, and if you exclude Northern Europe, the Southern areas are all pretty moribund trade wise.

So which model is best for us? Surely we all want 'what is best for us'. I would imagine that there would be some disagreement over which brexit one is really the best though...and i personally doubt that we would get a better deal or more control i.e. vetoes etc than the one we've just decided to leave.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 07 Jul 16 9.46pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

So which model is best for us? Surely we all want 'what is best for us'. I would imagine that there would be some disagreement over which brexit one is really the best though...and i personally doubt that we would get a better deal or more control i.e. vetoes etc than the one we've just decided to leave.

On my previous post, that I mentioned earlier, the subject was trade - hence mention of the WTO. So for example we may negotiate trade deals that are better than the ones we currently have, and I'm thinking of China in particular.

 

JohnyBoy Flag 07 Jul 16 9.56pm

Originally posted by chris123

On my previous post, that I mentioned earlier, the subject was trade - hence mention of the WTO. So for example we may negotiate trade deals that are better than the ones we currently have, and I'm thinking of China in particular.

We already are in wto agreement with China but when Switzerland negotiated their 'free' trade agreement with China, they said ok China we have a population of 10million and we want free trade with you and your population of 1billion +. Ok said China we will do a deal with you, we will give you free trade ....ahem but only in 15 years time but you give us full and free access to yours now....or we will never trade with you, which means your market will bd flooded by cheap Chinese goods.......er ok said Switzerland, thats a deal. They couldnt have said that to the eu because its a bigger economic market....but this is a redundant argument now anyway....leave is leave but lets not be naive that all of these great deals will suddenly come our way now that we are smaller but 'in control'

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 07 Jul 16 10.00pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

We already are in wto agreement with China but when Switzerland negotiated their 'free' trade agreement with China, they said ok China we have a population of 10million and we want free trade with you and your population of 1billion +. Ok said China we will do a deal with you, we will give you free trade ....ahem but only in 15 years time but you give us full and free access to yours now....or we will never trade with you, which means your market will bd flooded by cheap Chinese goods.......er ok said Switzerland, thats a deal. They couldnt have said that to the eu because its a bigger economic market....but this is a redundant argument now anyway....leave is leave but lets not be naive that all of these great deals will suddenly come our way now that we are smaller but 'in control'

For absolute clarity, I have never said that deals will be great - just the best possible.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 14 Jul 16 8.40pm

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

Apart from the Lords of course. Who can block/delay/derail to their hearts content any legislation they don't fancy. When are the House of Lords elections again?

The slight difference here is that this is the will of the people (the majority) and in this regard they would be foolish to prevaricate. It will be interesting to see what the agreement process will be for the negotiations i.e. will it have to be agreed by Parliament...I would have thought so and therefore crucial that there is a strong Chief Whip for the Tories.

 


Bring back Brolin

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 14 Jul 16 9.37pm

Originally posted by HeathMan

I am confused, and will appreciate comment.

In 2015 Dave was elected on a manifesto that included the referendum. He has a Mandate to take the country out of the European Union; has he decided that after arranging for the arguments to be presented he can opt out of leading the country as it has decided. An election will just delay matters and could potentially give us a diet of Euro-fudge - rather than the preferred Devon Fudge.


I think it'll be true in any scenario...that ain't fudge.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Should a general election be called.