You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Graham Poll (TalkSport)
November 16 2026 10.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Graham Poll (TalkSport)


Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4
chateauferret Flag 04 Mar 17 11.39pm

Originally posted by Phil H

Yes.Did you see Anthony Taylor's ridiculous award of a penalty today to Burnley v Swansea when a Burnley player (Vokes) handled? Video technology would never allow that penalty to be awarded. The whole thing's a joke. Even Wimbledon tennis is ahead of the Premier League.

I've just seen that. Beggars belief. Ref sees ball hit someone's arm in the penalty area so assumes it belongs to a defender. Preposterous.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 05 Mar 17 8.04am

Give teams one appeal per match that is maintained/rolled over if upheld or a player gets booked if it's not upheld (and teams lose any right to subsequent appeeals). Either side has the right to appeal in any situation but an incorrect appeal=booking. Would take a lot of sting out of the fans too, who frequently shout for stuff just to pressure refs.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 05 Mar 17 8.20am

Just don't be too hasty. I'm sure that the referees defender in chief, Willo, will give us a perfectly plausible reason why this was not the fault of the referee but was, in fact, down to too many players being in the box and out of position, thereby confirming that they also make errors.

The reality, of course, is that some simply aren't good enough.

Look at the lack of a Red for Ibrahamivic and Mings in the Man Utd v Bournemoufh game. Bloody awful.

Madleys reward for his terrible failed penalty award decision against us was to referee a high profile Arsenal v Liverpool game.

If you reward abject failure rather than punish it then there's nothing for the refs to fear and you get substandard results - which is what we are seeing.

All of these decisions should receive the equivalent of retrospective 'straight reds' for the ref. An instant 3 match ban. A couple of those in a season should see relegation back down the refs pyramid. They should get yellow equivalents as well - so a totting up process.


Edited by Helmet46 (05 Mar 2017 8.33am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 17 8.55am

Originally posted by Helmet46

Just don't be too hasty. I'm sure that the referees defender in chief, Willo, will give us a perfectly plausible reason why this was not the fault of the referee but was, in fact, down to too many players being in the box and out of position, thereby confirming that they also make errors.

The reality, of course, is that some simply aren't good enough.

Look at the lack of a Red for Ibrahamivic and Mings in the Man Utd v Bournemoufh game. Bloody awful.

Madleys reward for his terrible failed penalty award decision against us was to referee a high profile Arsenal v Liverpool game.

If you reward abject failure rather than punish it then there's nothing for the refs to fear and you get substandard results - which is what we are seeing.

All of these decisions should receive the equivalent of retrospective 'straight reds' for the ref. An instant 3 match ban. A couple of those in a season should see relegation back down the refs pyramid. They should get yellow equivalents as well - so a totting up process.


Edited by Helmet46 (05 Mar 2017 8.33am)

You say "Out of position" - at the end of the day the referee cannot be everywhere for heaven's sake ! As for "Confirming errors", I have always asserted that referees err from time to time - goodness me, they cannot be expected to be right 100% of the time !!!!
The way that some people comment on here, one would think that my mantra is that referees are never wrong !!!!

As for the 'Handball' incident, I haven't had a chance to view it so cannot comment but might do if I do see it.

 

You What Flag se25 05 Mar 17 9.00am

Originally posted by Helmet46

Just don't be too hasty. I'm sure that the referees defender in chief, Willo, will give us a perfectly plausible reason why this was not the fault of the referee but was, in fact, down to too many players being in the box and out of position, thereby confirming that they also make errors.

The reality, of course, is that some simply aren't good enough.

Look at the lack of a Red for Ibrahamivic and Mings in the Man Utd v Bournemoufh game. Bloody awful.

Madleys reward for his terrible failed penalty award decision against us was to referee a high profile Arsenal v Liverpool game.

If you reward abject failure rather than punish it then there's nothing for the refs to fear and you get substandard results - which is what we are seeing.

All of these decisions should receive the equivalent of retrospective 'straight reds' for the ref. An instant 3 match ban. A couple of those in a season should see relegation back down the refs pyramid. They should get yellow equivalents as well - so a totting up process.

Edited by Helmet46 (05 Mar 2017 8.33am)

The amount of mistakes they make really makes you question things!!!!

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 05 Mar 17 9.07am

Originally posted by Willo

You say "Out of position" - at the end of the day the referee cannot be everywhere for heaven's sake ! As for "Confirming errors", I have always asserted that referees err from time to time - goodness me, they cannot be expected to be right 100% of the time !!!!
The way that some people comment on here, one would think that my mantra is that referees are never wrong !!!!

As for the 'Handball' incident, I haven't had a chance to view it so cannot comment but might do if I do see it.


You might want to read my first paragraph again.

What's worrying is that in every one of the incidents cited the ref was NOT out of position.


Edited by Helmet46 (05 Mar 2017 9.37am)

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 05 Mar 17 9.25am

Originally posted by You What

The amount of mistakes they make really makes you question things!!!!

if only they were all "mistakes"!

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 05 Mar 17 9.32am

How did Cán stay on the pitch? Madeley knew it was him that made the tackle and bottled it again. Guy is a joke.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 05 Mar 17 9.43am

Originally posted by Dangermouse

How did Cán stay on the pitch? Madeley knew it was him that made the tackle and bottled it again. Guy is a joke.

Yep. So this weekend alone it's:-
No yellow for Rondon for the blatant dive against us.
Penalty for handball when it was clear and obvious that the forward handled it.
No red for Ibrahimivic for a stamp and elbow and Mings for a stamp.
No punishment for Cán.

This on top of the recent booking for McArthur for a dive when it was a nailed on penalty.

It's getting worse and worse.

Edited by Helmet46 (05 Mar 2017 9.44am)

 

peterg Flag Anerley 05 Mar 17 10.09am

Rondon's dive was as good as the one by Snodgrass. Snodgrass said afterwards he dived because he thought he was going to be tackled, which could have been true. Maybe Rondon knew about that excuse and thought he would give it a go. Why he wasn't booked is a mystery, especially in light of the decisions against Jimmy Mac and against Wilf (by Willo's hero Cluttenfunk).

Edited by peterg (05 Mar 2017 10.09am)

 


The right place at the right time

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 05 Mar 17 10.21am

Originally posted by peterg

Rondon's dive was as good as the one by Snodgrass. Snodgrass said afterwards he dived because he thought he was going to be tackled, which could have been true. Maybe Rondon knew about that excuse and thought he would give it a go. Why he wasn't booked is a mystery, especially in light of the decisions against Jimmy Mac and against Wilf (by Willo's hero Cluttenfunk).

Edited by peterg (05 Mar 2017 10.09am)

The Ref knew Rondon dived, the reaction of the Palace players would have further reinforced that. He also knows that simulation is unsporting behaviour and, therefore, a yellow card offence under the laws of the game. So, if he knew it was a dive and did not award a card that was a deliberate decision on his part and not an error.
Why, then, did he deliberately not award a card, thereby contravening a law of the game?

Edited by Helmet46 (05 Mar 2017 10.33am)

Edited by Helmet46 (05 Mar 2017 10.44am)

 

bicycle repair man 05 Mar 17 10.32am

Yes the Rondon dive was certainly in the Snodgrass league.
How on earth was he not booked ?
You could guarantee if it were Wilf he would get a yellow immediately. But then Wilf wouldn't have done that because he doesn't cheat.

 

chateauferret Flag 05 Mar 17 10.33am

Originally posted by Helmet46

The Ref knew Rondon dived, the reaction of the Palace players would have further reinforced that. He also knows that simulation is unsporting behaviour and, therefore, a yellow card offence under the laws of the game. So, if he knew it was a dive and did not award a card that was deliberate on his part and not an error.
Why, then, did he deliberately not award a card?

You suggesting that refs are influenced by players' reactions? Surely not. Not unless they're Rooney, anyway.


Edited by chateauferret (05 Mar 2017 10.34am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 05 Mar 17 10.43am

Originally posted by chateauferret

You suggesting that refs are influenced by players' reactions? Surely not. Not unless they're Rooney, anyway.


Edited by chateauferret (05 Mar 2017 10.34am)

Not overly but that's additional evidence which, when placed alongside his not awarding the penalty claimed for suggests he knew full well it was a dive - cos there's no bloody way he can claim he thought he slipped, if you view the incident. That would totally kill any remaining credibility he has left.

Edited by Helmet46 (05 Mar 2017 10.43am)

 

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 05 Mar 17 11.03am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

Yes the Rondon dive was certainly in the Snodgrass league.
How on earth was he not booked ?
You could guarantee if it were Wilf he would get a yellow immediately.
But then Wilf wouldn't have done that because he doesn't cheat.

This is absolutely true.

Wilf is on fire at the mo so more likely to get into tangles with the defence. lets hope he gets more going his way regarding the refs the way that manure get the decisions.
COYP

 

Shebeagle Flag Shebbear 05 Mar 17 2.56pm

Reviews must come soon but personally, I would prefer these to be the responsibility of the captain rather than the manager, as in cricket. He would benefit from the input of those closest to the incident and be in a position to make the best informed decision.
As for retrospective action against divers, this only solves half of the problem. Had Snodgrass received a retrospective ban and then been unavailable to play against three of our relegation rivals it only compounds the wrong done to us. I can't imagine retrospective points deductions to right the wrong would be popular but some form of restorative justice for the sinned against might be a nice idea.

 

Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Graham Poll (TalkSport)