You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Chlorine washed chicken
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Chlorine washed chicken


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
davenotamonkey Flag 27 Jul 17 4.18pm

Originally posted by npn

I'm genuinely confused.

I am on no particular side of the fence with regard to washing chicken in chlorine (I don't know enough about the process), but I find it amusing that so many people are going off the deep end in horror that we may allow the process thereby allowing chlorine into the food chain, despite the fact that there is chlorine in our drinking water (which I assume you all partake in), and you'll happily steralise your baby bottles with it, allow your kids to swim in it etc.

In fact, I have to put a home brew on tonight, and I'll probably be steralising my equipment with chlorine-based steraliser.

Is it just because it's america? Just because the EU don't allow it so it's a Brexit weapon? Or just because you are doing what so many people on all sides do in these internet days: reading a headline and charging off as if you are suddenly a world expert

Here, let me help you out - I'll present it from the perspective of the anti-Brexit brigade:

Brexit bad.
Everything related to Brexit bad.
If something related to Brexit could be good, find something that could be bad.
Become expert on the bad.
Emphasise bad.
Brexit always bad.
EU better.
Brexit bad.

A UK-US FTA will have all the Remainiacs throw a 5hitfit, because it demonstrates perfectly that we can thrive and grow perfectly well without their beloved EU. They will therefore attempt to devalue any positive news arising from Brexit, and proclaim doom and gloom for each and every trade deal we negotiate. It will never be good enough, it will never be enough.

Let's assume that EU member states must all meet or exceed the relevant minimum EU standard for food safety. It is reasonable to correlate food safety standards with Salmonella infection rates.

Here's some Salmonella stats, incidence per 100,000, taken from peer-reviewed journals, as contemporaneously as possible. It is also safe to assume the worst infection rates within a member state nevertheless conform to wonderful EU standards:

Malta*: 2141 per 100,000 (yum! Winner, winner, Chicken dinner: Caesar salads all round on europalace's beloved yacht)
US: 344 per 100,000
UK: 119 per 100,000
Average**: 693 per 100,000

* There are two worse infection rates in the dataset, but Bulgaria was not a member when the data were collated, nor is/was Turkey, yet.

** based only on EU member states from that data.

Sources:
[Link]
[Link]

So, it looks like you would, on average, be approximately 2.01 times as likely to contract salmonella in an EU-regulated state than you would in the US.

If you were dining with europalace, you'd probably want to bring a bucket of bleach with you (because that's what the Grauniad would have you believe happens), as you would be 6.2 times more likely to contract samlonella than in the US. I'm assuming Malta's chickens meet the minimum EU standards.

Last week, we were all experts on radioisotopes. This week it's chicken. As Liam Fox is currently in Australia, I'll assume next week we'll be terrified that dropping EU regulations forbidding use of boomerangs as defensive weapons will cause street-wars in apocalyptic post-Brexit Britain.

Expect FUD threads like this for whatever bogeyman the Remainiacs deem to be their cause-celebre as a counter to positive news on our path to Brexit.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Jul 17 6.25pm

Originally posted by npn

I'm genuinely confused.

I am on no particular side of the fence with regard to washing chicken in chlorine (I don't know enough about the process), but I find it amusing that so many people are going off the deep end in horror that we may allow the process thereby allowing chlorine into the food chain, despite the fact that there is chlorine in our drinking water (which I assume you all partake in), and you'll happily steralise your baby bottles with it, allow your kids to swim in it etc.

In fact, I have to put a home brew on tonight, and I'll probably be steralising my equipment with chlorine-based steraliser.

Is it just because it's america? Just because the EU don't allow it so it's a Brexit weapon? Or just because you are doing what so many people on all sides do in these internet days: reading a headline and charging off as if you are suddenly a world expert

I know right. That said I believe that Chlorine washing of food is not an EU thing alone. The British were very keen on it (Probably because it protected the UK chicken farmers).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Great Northern Loony Flag Saint Paul 29 Jul 17 9.58am

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

I saw an interview with a woman who was told by her doctor that she had Diabetes and she must change her diet and eat more fresh produce. She went out to buy fresh fruit and veg but there was not one shop that sold anything fresh.

Undeterred, she had a garden, and started to grow her own. She received a bit if attention and to cut a long story short, the local authority forced her to stop.

Your right it was in the inner city.

I remember that story; it was in Tulsa, OK (see below). The issue was NOT that she was growing her own food, but rather that she was growing it out on her front lawn. Many towns and cities in the US have local yard maintenance ordinances that often at least inadvertently prevent 'farming on your front lawn'.

[Link]

At any rate, it's a lawn-grooming issue, and not food. And those are always city ordinances, not state laws. I can't imagine a state in the Union that would even consider banning vegetable gardening.

 

sitdownstandup Flag 31 Jul 17 2.06pm

[Link]

Report about chlorine washed chickens.

 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Chlorine washed chicken