You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The James McCarthy thread
November 16 2026 5.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The James McCarthy thread


Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4
ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 27 Feb 20 10.24am

Originally posted by mattteo

I'm not against McCarthy himself and I think that if he plays like this, then he really proves himself. I'm just saying I wouldn't keep all 3 of Kouyate, McCarthy and Luka in a 25 men squad.

Hard to chose though. Kouyate has probably been the best. McCarthy has been good for his price. Luka has been captain (penalties don't count). But he is 28 already and maybe if a 20 million offer would come, it would be good to let him go, cause it will not happen after 30.

When did Luka last have a good game, I cant remember one this season.

 

EddieMac Flag 08 Mar 20 10.51am

In my opinion he is the our 1st choice CM now. It will be interesting to see who Roy starts in the next game. James MCCarthur had an off day yesterday so wouldn’t be surprised to see Luka step back in.

 

esox lucius Flag Deal 08 Mar 20 11.28am

Originally posted by EddieMac

In my opinion he is the our 1st choice CM now. It will be interesting to see who Roy starts in the next game. James MCCarthur had an off day yesterday so wouldn’t be surprised to see Luka step back in.

McCarthur had probably his best game for us yesterday, it was his type of game against a physical side like Watford where we had to match them kick for kick. Jimmy Mac didn't have a particularly good game yesterday and at the point when he was subbed we were starting to look a bit heavy legged, when Luka came on I do think we improved and yes I do think Luka will start at Bournemouth although I'm still not sure he should.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Mar 20 11.31am

Originally posted by EddieMac

In my opinion he is the our 1st choice CM now. It will be interesting to see who Roy starts in the next game. James MCCarthur had an off day yesterday so wouldn’t be surprised to see Luka step back in.

James McCarthy played a valuable part in our victory.
Apropos McArthur,to my aged eyes he looked somewhat weary towards the end of the Brighton game and he wasn't at his best yesterday.

About 5-10 mins before he was replaced I mentioned to the learned gentleman next to me that I felt Milivojevic should be introduced from the bench and of course Hodgson duly obliged.

 

EddieMac Flag 08 Mar 20 11.42am

Originally posted by Willo

James McCarthy played a valuable part in our victory.
Apropos McArthur,to my aged eyes he looked somewhat weary towards the end of the Brighton game and he wasn't at his best yesterday.

About 5-10 mins before he was replaced I mentioned to the learned gentleman next to me that I felt Milivojevic should be introduced from the bench and of course Hodgson duly obliged.

Agreed, and I don’t think any of us will hold a bad game against James McCarthur. He has been brilliant all season.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 08 Mar 20 11.45am

I don't think it was a coincidence that McCarthy's inclusion yesterday resulted in Watford's failure to bully Palace out of the game in midfield.

Yes, we saw the same rotational fouling that Watford are known for but McCarthy and Kouyate stood up to them.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Mar 20 11.59am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I don't think it was a coincidence that McCarthy's inclusion yesterday resulted in Watford's failure to bully Palace out of the game in midfield.

Yes, we saw the same rotational fouling that Watford are known for but McCarthy and Kouyate stood up to them.

Indeed.
I have to mention Kouyate who was impressive against aggressive opponents.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 08 Mar 20 8.50pm

Originally posted by Willo

Indeed.
I have to mention Kouyate who was impressive against aggressive opponents.

Quite possibly our most improved player from last season

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 08 Mar 20 9.52pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Agreed, and I don’t think any of us will hold a bad game against James McCarthur. He has been brilliant all season.

For many seasons

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 08 Mar 20 9.52pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Quite possibly our most improved player from last season

Ayew?

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 08 Mar 20 10.04pm

With McCarthy showing his worth with every game and Kouyate on form, what happens next week? Will Roy stick with Jimmy Mac (MaCarthur) or bring in Luka, or will he bench one of the first two mentioned who have played important roles in our last three wins with their midfield play, so as to keep Jimmy Mac in the team?
An interesting conundrum.

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 08 Mar 20 10.23pm

Originally posted by doombear

With McCarthy showing his worth with every game and Kouyate on form, what happens next week? Will Roy stick with Jimmy Mac (MaCarthur) or bring in Luka, or will he bench one of the first two mentioned who have played important roles in our last three wins with their midfield play, so as to keep Jimmy Mac in the team?
An interesting conundrum.

I think he will rest Jimmy MAC and start with Luka. COYP

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 08 Mar 20 10.47pm

The benefit being that one player change can alter the system we play.
Either defensive with luka or slightly braver with mac.
Depending on how the game is going.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 09 Mar 20 8.27pm

Personally would go with the two JMs and Luka.
Kouyate a great player to bring on.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 09 Mar 20 11.41pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

For many seasons

Agree... He really has been an amazing signing. Just so consistent year after year...

A very good mate of mine is an Everton nut... When we signed McCarthy he said if we can keep him fit then we have an amazing player on our hands...

He said that Everton fans had a saying that ‘70% of the earth is covered by water.... The rest of it is covered by James McCarthy’..

I now know what he means!

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

dreamwaverider Flag London 10 Mar 20 6.36am

Originally posted by EddieMac

In my opinion he is the our 1st choice CM now. It will be interesting to see who Roy starts in the next game. James MCCarthur had an off day yesterday so wouldn’t be surprised to see Luka step back in.

Very rare for RH to change a winning team

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Mar 20 1.41pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Ayew?

Kouyate is because in my book he was so awful mostly with losing possession and in turn momentum to how he is today so his improvement started from being a liability to being an asset today ...while Ayew started very decently but with only one goal to show for it to becoming totally out of this world ..in Palace fc terms of being able to score lol

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 10 Mar 20 6.39pm

He's a worker more than a player but he's a high class worker, he's technically very good although there aren't too many slide rule passes, maybe that's down to losing his touch a bit after his injuries and it'll come back I don't know, I didn't see him all that much for Everton, but I reckon he'd be a perfect partner for a playmaker, like Graham Roberts and Glenn Hoddle - Jan Wouters, Claude Makelele all great players who did the dirty work for the artists, I remember David Wright running around with his arse on fire to put the ball on the spot for Owen Garvan's sweet left foot, it may not be Roy'style, we seem to be tracking Tufan from Turkey, but we could afford a luxury playmaker with McCarthy next to him to set him up, the same way Henderson and Milner do the donkey work for the star players in the Liverpool side.

 

Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The James McCarthy thread