You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Players to offload (if we can) in the summer.
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Players to offload (if we can) in the summer.


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Eaglecoops Flag CR3 10 Mar 20 5.03pm

It’s all about having a balanced squad. At present it is too old. If you look at our centre half’s as an example. We could shed two of them and bring in 1 decent youngster. I would keep Tomkins, Cahill and Kelly and would sell Sakho and Dann. That should be more than sufficient to half the wage bill for that position and have enough cash to bring in a quality youngster as well as help with balancing the books for the more needed positions.

We need a young addition at right back. PVA and Reidewald/Schlupp have the left covered. I would sell one of Milivojevic, Kouyate, McArthur and McCarthy and based on the ability to raise money that would probably be Milivojevic. He should be replaced by a young attacking midfielder as we have enough defensive players. If Roy genuinely doesn’t like Meyer then I would look for a like for like type of swap, but I get the feeling he might be staying. Up front, if Zaha goes we need two wingers and if he stays, one. If Benteke stays we need a quality young forward and if he goes two. Again I think Benteke will stay. Not sure about Wilf. Townsend and Ayew are good enough for a few seasons.

So, in summary, this summer I believe we can expect to see perhaps 4 outgoing players and hopefully 5 or 6 incoming younger players. We should also make sure our loan spots are fully used up.

All in my opinion of course, but that is what chat boards are for!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Mar 20 5.29pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

Luka needs to pull his head out of his arse or I would let him go. McArthy for me is a future Captain along with Cahill.

Benteke I have been Benheskey's greatest detractor for all but his last two games. Something has changed in the way Roy plays him, and he is without douby improved now the weight is off him to score. There is a very promising partnership developing with him and Ayew. Much like Bright and wright ( not as dynamic but you get the point ?) for that reason alone he has to stay IMO.

Meyer needs to be the attacking midfielder in a 451 or 442 Roy plays neither so we will never see the best of him which is a shame as he is technically one of our best players. It's a shame but square peg in a round hole so he's got to go I think.

Sakho has struggled with Injury this season, and reminds me a bit of when we Had Anthony Gardener From Spurs, on his day looks like a world beater but always has that one moment in a game where you think how the fcuk is he a professional footballer. His age is an issue as well plus wages, if it's a toss up between him and Tomkins I would keep Tomkins, with Dann doing OK and Kelly able to Cover at Center Back I think Sakho is an expense we can't carry.

Hennessy needs game time elsewhere, Guita has shown just how poor Hennesey actually is. I was never a fan of Hennesey two slow, and for a gurt big lump sh1t at commanding his area. We need better cover for G man.

Wilf - Wouldn't be to certain he will leave to be honest. His performances and goal return do not warrant the fee Parish is after, can you honestly see anyone offering the 70 million we're after ? I would say Adama Traore from Wolves, and Allan Saint-Maximin have probably gone ahead of Wilf in the Bigger clubs "would like to have" lists, and have arguably had better seasons. However the Chelsea deal with Bats coming our way is apparently a done deal so who the feck Knows.

Sorloth - Don't care how many goals he's scored in Turkey, it's a tin pot league and he was absolutely out of his depth in the prem. Championship player at best. Vent.

Wickham - Made of glass and not tearing up tree's with Wednesday get rid.

Agree about Benteke 100%, Meyer is in the same league as Sorloth I'm afraid but I'd keep Wickham easily good enough if he can remain fit, didn't know about the Chelsea deal because I thought Zaha would never be leaving considering how dull he's become ..maybe knowing about the move and being cross about Parish still has made him this way if that's the case and he's off to Chelsea, Sakho can go along with the saluting one in my book.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Mar 20 7.25pm

I doubt there will be a big clearout in the summer, as some continuity is needed. I expect 4-5 will go, if we can offload them and bring in younger players. My choice to go would be Sakho ( wages and fitness ) Meyer ( wages and just not stronger enough ) Dann ( out of contract ) Ward ( age ) and Wickham ( fitness issues ) or Zaha ( the usual saga and he may just go this summer )

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Mar 20 2.45am

Rubbish.

Hennessy a quality prem keeper and a great option at #2.

hahahahahahahah

I don't see what's funny? How many other teams can boast an international #1 as their back up option? No one's saying he's better than VG...but laughing like that at the suggestion he's a decent back up only backs yourself look silly.

Meyer gives something different and changed the game regularly when he enters the fray.

He is a good player in my opinion, however he doesn't fit into Hodgesdon's style of playing, I think he was added to the squad to play the deep role that Cabaye Played so well, so if you compare him to Cabaye you see his short comings in that position.

Fair enough. Personally I still think he's contributed when he's come on...but that's open for debate.


Sakho our most talented defender when fit. Needs a chance to get back to that.

Cahill is head and shoulders above any other defender at the club. Sakho when fit is good cover for Tomkins nothing else.

That's your opinion. Cahill is solid as and a better leader. I think Sakho is a better football player. All opinions. Regardless, doesn't mean we should get rid of Sakho just because Cahill might be better?

Luka. Doesn't even deserve a reply.

Have you watched his performances this season ? He has been savagely average at best all season and got torn a new one by Moy at home to the weed. Pace is letting him down, and to a certain degree McArthur is mopping up his errors.

Yes I have. Did you watch his performances over the last two? Again, being slightly below par for half a season doesn't mean you get rid of someone who's undoubtedly one of our best players. Suggesting we move Luka on is laughable.

Benteke - starting to show some great form.

Agreed, the withdrawn number 9 role suits him better.


We need to be adding to the squad...not depleating it.

Only if it betters what we have. Agree.

Only people i'd consider moving on are Dann and Townsend. Love them both, but they need to be playing.

Dann and Townsend are you actually mental sorry mate but that's crazy talk.

How's that crazy? Makes much more sense to keep Mama than Dann. And yeah, maybe you're right on Andros. Worth keeping around.


Edited by sprites (11 Mar 2020 2.48am)

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Mar 20 2.46am


Edited by sprites (11 Mar 2020 2.52am)

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 11 Mar 20 3.16am

Realistically we need to trim our defensive options. We have Tonks, Cahill, Dann, Kelly and Sakho as well as Jairo and Kouyate for cover.

Ultimately not all of those players are going to be happy on the bench. For me Cahill is our best CB and Tomkins and him are probably the best pairing.

Sakho is up there without a doubt but on over 100k per week, we can’t have a player that is fit for 10-20 games a season. He is the one that needs to move on for the benefit of the squad.

Kelly covers a couple of positions and is on cheap wages and is a great option in the squad. And Dann is an excellent option at cover, one who will get enough games if he is our first choice cover.

I like Sakho but for how much we pay, it’s just not worth having him in the squad.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Mar 20 3.28am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Realistically we need to trim our defensive options. We have Tonks, Cahill, Dann, Kelly and Sakho as well as Jairo and Kouyate for cover.

Ultimately not all of those players are going to be happy on the bench. For me Cahill is our best CB and Tomkins and him are probably the best pairing.

Sakho is up there without a doubt but on over 100k per week, we can’t have a player that is fit for 10-20 games a season. He is the one that needs to move on for the benefit of the squad.

Kelly covers a couple of positions and is on cheap wages and is a great option in the squad. And Dann is an excellent option at cover, one who will get enough games if he is our first choice cover.

I like Sakho but for how much we pay, it’s just not worth having him in the squad.

That's fair enough. I'm mostly looking at the ability of the players without taking $$$ into it too much.

You might be right. I just think he's a cracking player defensively and offensively when he's on song.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 11 Mar 20 5.20am

Originally posted by sprites

That's fair enough. I'm mostly looking at the ability of the players without taking $$$ into it too much.

You might be right. I just think he's a cracking player defensively and offensively when he's on song.

I rate him too, honestly. But for a player with a track record of terrible injuries and a player that has a mistake in him at any point in the first 15 minutes of a match it’s just too much. I think now is the ideal time to get rid because he still has something to give another team and we could sell him rather than letting him go for nothing.

Realistically looking at our expenditure, we have to look at every player from the perspective of their worth to the club both on the pitch and financially. I also really like Meyer and think he hasn’t had a fair crack because of this system, but if we could shift him in the summer it wouldn’t be the worst idea either. 230-250k a week is an enormous sum and that money needs to be being used sensibly.

In an ideal world they play well every week next season and are worth that money, but if that isn’t the case then we need to make a move.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 11 Mar 20 9.05am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

I rate him too, honestly. But for a player with a track record of terrible injuries and a player that has a mistake in him at any point in the first 15 minutes of a match it’s just too much. I think now is the ideal time to get rid because he still has something to give another team and we could sell him rather than letting him go for nothing.

Realistically looking at our expenditure, we have to look at every player from the perspective of their worth to the club both on the pitch and financially. I also really like Meyer and think he hasn’t had a fair crack because of this system, but if we could shift him in the summer it wouldn’t be the worst idea either. 230-250k a week is an enormous sum and that money needs to be being used sensibly.

In an ideal world they play well every week next season and are worth that money, but if that isn’t the case then we need to make a move.

Who is on £230k- £250k per week? No-one at our club. Are you talking about more than one player here?

 

Den1923 Flag 11 Mar 20 10.25am

Originally posted by Johng

Nobody has said they hate anybody. These are the weekly wages for the following. Are they really providing value for money. These salaries are a massive drain on the club's finances.

Max Meyer £125,000
Christian Benteke £120,000
Mamadou Sakho £100,000

Edited by Johng (09 Mar 2020 10.54am)

Your quite correct when the input is greater than the output then that is the correct time to act!, however under Parish that does not apply!

 

PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 11 Mar 20 11.26am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Busy next season - Players' contracts' by bexleydave

There are 12 players' contracts ending in June 2021. How busy will Palace be, selling any before then to get a transfer fee, negotiating new contracts to keep them here? (some done during the coming summer) or just letting any go then. Then there is the knock on problem of replacing any that leave for any reason.

Only Scott Dann & Stephen Henderson's end in the coming June.

[Link]

 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

nead1 Flag 11 Mar 20 12.29pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Busy next season - Players' contracts' by bexleydave

About half of the players quoted seem unlikely to be issues - Townsend (already indicated he wants to stay), Cahill - unlikely to want to move again and playing very well, McArthur, Schlupp - discussions already underway, Kelly, Ward and Hennessy.

The more problematic ones are likely to be Meyer, Sakho, Benteke - all high earners - and possibly Van Aanholt if he wants to return to the Netherlands and possibly Guaita - may well be others interested although he seems very settled.

I would be surprised if there was not some movement around Sakho and Meyer this summer (both areas of the team that has a good level of cover) with a desire to replace them with cheaper/better options and get back as much as possible re what was paid - Sakho.

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 12 Mar 20 2.34pm

Originally posted by sprites

Rubbish.

Hennessy a quality prem keeper and a great option at #2.

hahahahahahahah

I don't see what's funny? How many other teams can boast an international #1 as their back up option? No one's saying he's better than VG...but laughing like that at the suggestion he's a decent back up only backs yourself look silly.

Meyer gives something different and changed the game regularly when he enters the fray.

He is a good player in my opinion, however he doesn't fit into Hodgesdon's style of playing, I think he was added to the squad to play the deep role that Cabaye Played so well, so if you compare him to Cabaye you see his short comings in that position.

Fair enough. Personally I still think he's contributed when he's come on...but that's open for debate.


Sakho our most talented defender when fit. Needs a chance to get back to that.

Cahill is head and shoulders above any other defender at the club. Sakho when fit is good cover for Tomkins nothing else.

That's your opinion. Cahill is solid as and a better leader. I think Sakho is a better football player. All opinions. Regardless, doesn't mean we should get rid of Sakho just because Cahill might be better?

Luka. Doesn't even deserve a reply.

Have you watched his performances this season ? He has been savagely average at best all season and got torn a new one by Moy at home to the weed. Pace is letting him down, and to a certain degree McArthur is mopping up his errors.

Yes I have. Did you watch his performances over the last two? Again, being slightly below par for half a season doesn't mean you get rid of someone who's undoubtedly one of our best players. Suggesting we move Luka on is laughable.

Benteke - starting to show some great form.

Agreed, the withdrawn number 9 role suits him better.


We need to be adding to the squad...not depleating it.

Only if it betters what we have. Agree.

Only people i'd consider moving on are Dann and Townsend. Love them both, but they need to be playing.

Dann and Townsend are you actually mental sorry mate but that's crazy talk.

How's that crazy? Makes much more sense to keep Mama than Dann. And yeah, maybe you're right on Andros. Worth keeping around.


Edited by sprites (11 Mar 2020 2.48am)

Hennessy is the welsh Goal keeper. Yes that makes him an international but so would playing for Gibraltar. He is Crap. There's a reason we bought a new keeper in, in front of him. he's Rubbish!!

I'm a season ticket holder mate have been for years. Luka is not the player he was, and has been poor all season, not half a season, but all season and like I said got shown up against Brighton at Home as Moy ran rings around him. I honestly hope he returns to his best, but I just don't see it.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 12 Mar 20 3.27pm

Zaha
Sakho
Hennessy
Henderson

The others below I would also consider for other reasons like never going to be used or starting to get towards not being good enough at this level but realistically it's not going to happen

Ward
Kelly
Dann
Schlupp
Meyer
Riedewald


 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 12 Mar 20 4.04pm

A number of posters have suggested we let Dann go as he is out of contract. I think he is playing well at the moment and would keep him providing he wages are not an issue.

To be honest I would not be unhappy if everyone stayed. I doubt that we will receive any blockbuster offers so it is more does Roy want them and do they want to stay.

Trust in Roy let's hope he gets the funds he needs.

COYP

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 12 Mar 20 7.10pm

Originally posted by Badger11

A number of posters have suggested we let Dann go as he is out of contract. I think he is playing well at the moment and would keep him providing he wages are not an issue.

To be honest I would not be unhappy if everyone stayed. I doubt that we will receive any blockbuster offers so it is more does Roy want them and do they want to stay.

Trust in Roy let's hope he gets the funds he needs.

COYP


Well Dann is on fairly good wage and not young plus he is a poor version of Tomkins we really need some youth back their with some pace.

I expect the club has already offered him another 1 year deal.

Don't expect really many changes Roy likes set names so those I expect will be kept maybe Zaha only one to go.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Midlands Eagle Flag 12 Mar 20 7.23pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Dann is on fairly good wage and not young plus he is a poor version of Tomkins we really need some youth back their with some pace.

The older ones amongst us will remember that in 1966 we won the world cup with one of the slowest central defenders ever to pull on an England shirt

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 12 Mar 20 11.06pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The older ones amongst us will remember that in 1966 we won the world cup with one of the slowest central defenders ever to pull on an England shirt


1966 is not 2020 different game now.

Plus our defenders are not internationals or in any cup competitions.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

sprites Flag Auckland 12 Mar 20 11.54pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

Hennessy is the welsh Goal keeper. Yes that makes him an international but so would playing for Gibraltar. He is Crap. There's a reason we bought a new keeper in, in front of him. he's Rubbish!!

I'm a season ticket holder mate have been for years. Luka is not the player he was, and has been poor all season, not half a season, but all season and like I said got shown up against Brighton at Home as Moy ran rings around him. I honestly hope he returns to his best, but I just don't see it.

Disagree about Hennessy. But that's fine.

And agree that Luka has been below par this season...but you don't just get rid of a player for that.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 14 Mar 20 11.03am

Originally posted by grumpymort


1966 is not 2020 different game now.

Plus our defenders are not internationals or in any cup competitions.

yes your right 1966 isnt 2020 but you still had quick strikers in 1966 and tougher most of the players today wouldnt survive back then,as most act like little girls when touched by someones little finger

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Players to offload (if we can) in the summer.