You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Baroness Shirley Williams
November 21 2026 9.56pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Baroness Shirley Williams


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
cryrst Flag The garden of England 15 Apr 21 1.15pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

So Cameron and the Tory grandees gave in and decided to risk the referendum in order to save the Tory Party.

It was a massive miscalculation which will set the country back decades. It was an abdication of their duty as citizens. One in which they put Party above Country and one for which they won't be forgiven by me or many others who walk on the middle path.

That the EU also miscalculated was no reason for us to also be stupid. We needed to show patience, understanding but most of all tenacity to keep on making the arguments. When you are right eventually the mists clear and you get the job done.

So you don't think the thought was for the people and the good of the UK. if apathy had a part to play that got brexit across the line then don't preach about how stupid it was to anyone who voted. Tell the ones who didn't. We are 4 months in and already some can see the future! Amazing how they can't see the future if we stayed in the eu.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 15 Apr 21 3.24pm

Originally posted by cryrst

So you don't think the thought was for the people and the good of the UK. if apathy had a part to play that got brexit across the line then don't preach about how stupid it was to anyone who voted. Tell the ones who didn't. We are 4 months in and already some can see the future! Amazing how they can't see the future if we stayed in the eu.

4 months in already? Thats music to my ears, 8 weeks to go and counting.........

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 15 Apr 21 6.21pm

Originally posted by cryrst

So you don't think the thought was for the people and the good of the UK. if apathy had a part to play that got brexit across the line then don't preach about how stupid it was to anyone who voted. Tell the ones who didn't. We are 4 months in and already some can see the future! Amazing how they can't see the future if we stayed in the eu.

No I most certainly don't. No-one at the top of the Tory Party wanted, or expected, that the vote would go that way. Their motivation was solely to get rid of the UKIP problem as they feared that there would be sufficient drift to let Labour back in and for their future to be questionable.

That a bunch of hardworking arch anti-Europeans existed is obvious. They have been there for decades. That apathy existed was equally obvious but also both understandable and predictable. It's always easier to promote change and jam tomorrow than it is to promote the status quo.

Now we see the result when the promises and expectations have to be turned into realities.

If any now see a future that is better than the past then I don't encounter them. Come and talk to some of our local fishermen and you will realise just how let down they feel. If the vote was held again now I would wager my house against a penny the result would be the other way. That sweet jam has been shown to actually be a very bitter marmalade. We have all been fooled by sweet promises in the past. Some of us though are wise enough to recognise them as being empty before the event.

Decisions of this kind ought not be allowed to be impacted by the jam tomorrow syndrome. They are just too important to become political footballs. They always need to be taken in Parliament, by those we have elected to study and consider all the issues.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

The Dolphin Flag 15 Apr 21 6.28pm

I clicked on this thread to read about Shirley Williams but appear to have found Brexit and the EU!

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 15 Apr 21 7.02pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

4 months in already? Thats music to my ears, 8 weeks to go and counting.........

10 weeks.....

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 15 Apr 21 7.06pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

No I most certainly don't. No-one at the top of the Tory Party wanted, or expected, that the vote would go that way. Their motivation was solely to get rid of the UKIP problem as they feared that there would be sufficient drift to let Labour back in and for their future to be questionable.

That a bunch of hardworking arch anti-Europeans existed is obvious. They have been there for decades. That apathy existed was equally obvious but also both understandable and predictable. It's always easier to promote change and jam tomorrow than it is to promote the status quo.

Now we see the result when the promises and expectations have to be turned into realities.

If any now see a future that is better than the past then I don't encounter them. Come and talk to some of our local fishermen and you will realise just how let down they feel. If the vote was held again now I would wager my house against a penny the result would be the other way. That sweet jam has been shown to actually be a very bitter marmalade. We have all been fooled by sweet promises in the past. Some of us though are wise enough to recognise them as being empty before the event.

Decisions of this kind ought not be allowed to be impacted by the jam tomorrow syndrome. They are just too important to become political footballs. They always need to be taken in Parliament, by those we have elected to study and consider all the issues.

Do you remember when we went in the common market.
I don't as i was a nipper. Was it all plain sailing after 14 weeks?

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 15 Apr 21 8.26pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Do you remember when we went in the common market.
I don't as i was a nipper. Was it all plain sailing after 14 weeks?

I was 29 and so far as I recall it was pretty plain sailing and regarded by most as a golden opportunity. Only those who regarded it as "us giving up our Sovereignty" seemed unhappy, and they went on being unhappy until Brexit. It was always a fake argument with only emotional consequences but there are still those who put such things above the welfare and prosperity of their fellow citizens.

I know which side of this argument Shirley Williams stood on and with her passing we have lost another voice of reason.

Now we are likely to witness the break-up of the UK, which would probably have been avoided without Brexit. Is that really a price worth paying? Political systems evolve to suit altered environments and all I ever saw from the Brexiteers was fear of progress, rather than an embrace of it. Baroness Williams must have viewed the last few years with great sadness.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 15 Apr 21 9.41pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I clicked on this thread to read about Shirley Williams but appear to have found Brexit and the EU!


Unfortunately whichever thread you click on here either ends up as Brexit or some race issue.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 15 Apr 21 9.53pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I was 29 and so far as I recall it was pretty plain sailing and regarded by most as a golden opportunity. Only those who regarded it as "us giving up our Sovereignty" seemed unhappy, and they went on being unhappy until Brexit. It was always a fake argument with only emotional consequences but there are still those who put such things above the welfare and prosperity of their fellow citizens.

I know which side of this argument Shirley Williams stood on and with her passing we have lost another voice of reason.

Now we are likely to witness the break-up of the UK, which would probably have been avoided without Brexit. Is that really a price worth paying? Political systems evolve to suit altered environments and all I ever saw from the Brexiteers was fear of progress, rather than an embrace of it. Baroness Williams must have viewed the last few years with great sadness.

The Scottish independence referendum was in 2014, so don't think you can blame the break-up of the UK on Brexit. That they had a referendum is proof of unrest in the union.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 16 Apr 21 8.11pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

The system was pretty shonky in the 70’s when it was a miserable experience for all involved. Streaming meant a lot of kids were more or less abandoned. CSEs were a waste of time.

I attended a "secondary modern" school before comprehensives were introduced. I "failed" the 11+ as my parents wanted as they couldn't afford the uniform and the expectations of the grammar school. When I was a child kids like me didn't go to grammar school. They were for "posh" kids and not for those of us who lived in council houses. It continued when I reached 16 and my headmaster wanted me to go on to further education and then to University. My mother wanted me to earn, so I went to work.

I ended up doing OK but I often wonder whether I would have done even better had those chances been on offer.

So this question has to be considered in the round and whether, on balance, the greatest number achieve the greater good via a comprehensive or selective system. My own experiences inform my opinion.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 16 Apr 21 8.14pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3621296]

The Scottish independence referendum was in 2014, so don't think you can blame the break-up of the UK on Brexit. That they had a referendum is proof of unrest in the union.

Unrest which was rejected. In the EU referendum the Scots voted overwhelmingly to remain and it's this which appears to have swung the balance.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 16 Apr 21 8.27pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I attended a "secondary modern" school before comprehensives were introduced. I "failed" the 11+ as my parents wanted as they couldn't afford the uniform and the expectations of the grammar school. When I was a child kids like me didn't go to grammar school. They were for "posh" kids and not for those of us who lived in council houses. It continued when I reached 16 and my headmaster wanted me to go on to further education and then to University. My mother wanted me to earn, so I went to work.

I ended up doing OK but I often wonder whether I would have done even better had those chances been on offer.

So this question has to be considered in the round and whether, on balance, the greatest number achieve the greater good via a comprehensive or selective system. My own experiences inform my opinion.

My experience was pretty similar.
As I said streaming in Comprehensive schools meant some people were more or less abandoned. As long as they didn’t smash the place up they were more or less left alone.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Apr 21 8.56pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I attended a "secondary modern" school before comprehensives were introduced. I "failed" the 11+ as my parents wanted as they couldn't afford the uniform and the expectations of the grammar school. When I was a child kids like me didn't go to grammar school. They were for "posh" kids and not for those of us who lived in council houses. It continued when I reached 16 and my headmaster wanted me to go on to further education and then to University. My mother wanted me to earn, so I went to work.

I ended up doing OK but I often wonder whether I would have done even better had those chances been on offer.

So this question has to be considered in the round and whether, on balance, the greatest number achieve the greater good via a comprehensive or selective system. My own experiences inform my opinion.

I went to Wisbech Grammar for free. I'm from a single parent household and council flat. My scholarship was a Tory initiative. I thought there was a series about kids doing this today? Can't remember what it was called 'The Test' perhaps? I didn't used to fit in, but it was an excellent school. Gave me my first taste of Rugby, Cricket and Latin.
As a mature student, I went to university and have as many qualifications as is possible (I mean why leave?) all from an EU scholarship.
I owe my education to the Tories and to the EU. You'd think I'd be more grateful really.

Edited by ASCPFC (16 Apr 2021 8.57pm)

 


Red and Blue Army!

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 16 Apr 21 10.12pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Unrest which was rejected. In the EU referendum the Scots voted overwhelmingly to remain and it's this which appears to have swung the balance.

EU referendum Scotland result wasn't as overwhelming as you seem to think. About half a million (500k) votes separated the outcome out of the circa 4 million voters. 67% of voters turned out.

Scottish independence referendum was even closer, with the difference less than 400k, but almost 85% turnout.

It appears that Scottish people were less concerned about EU membership than UK membership.

So to try and pin the break-up of the UK on Brexit is somewhat remiss. An awful lot of the Scots are, and always were, anti English. They loathe Westminster and see English politicians as upper class toffs. Many have, quite rightly, stronger connections to Ireland than to England. It's an ancestry and a religious split, as it is in NI. So if you want to pin the break-up on anything, look no further than the church.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

dannyboy1978 Flag 17 Apr 21 6.48am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3621401]

EU referendum Scotland result wasn't as overwhelming as you seem to think. About half a million (500k) votes separated the outcome out of the circa 4 million voters. 67% of voters turned out.

Scottish independence referendum was even closer, with the difference less than 400k, but almost 85% turnout.

It appears that Scottish people were less concerned about EU membership than UK membership.

So to try and pin the break-up of the UK on Brexit is somewhat remiss. An awful lot of the Scots are, and always were, anti English. They loathe Westminster and see English politicians as upper class toffs. Many have, quite rightly, stronger connections to Ireland than to England. It's an ancestry and a religious split, as it is in NI. So if you want to pin the break-up on anything, look no further than the church.

Are you suggesting that because they have stronger cultural ties with another country they should leave the union?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 17 Apr 21 7.55am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

My experience was pretty similar.
As I said streaming in Comprehensive schools meant some people were more or less abandoned. As long as they didn’t smash the place up they were more or less left alone.

Yup in my school that lot were the gardening and pottery club, I kid you not.

Oddly enough the rest of us swots envied them at the time as they were always outside and having a good time. Still in the long run....

 


One more point

Teddy Eagle Flag 17 Apr 21 9.01am

Originally posted by Badger11

Yup in my school that lot were the gardening and pottery club, I kid you not.

Oddly enough the rest of us swots envied them at the time as they were always outside and having a good time. Still in the long run....

...they became landscape architects and ceramics experts? Probably not.
At my school there seemed to be quite a lot of colouring in.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 17 Apr 21 10.19pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

Are you suggesting that because they have stronger cultural ties with another country they should leave the union?

I'm not suggesting anything. How did you come to that conclusion? Did you understand that my point was about blaming Brexit for the break-up of the UK, (which isn't currently on the cards)?

I think the pipes are calling you

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Baroness Shirley Williams