This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Do you have a link to those reports you can share please? Yes I'd be interested to see the details too.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Yes I'd be interested to see the details too. I got it from bbc football sports page, late last week, wish id copied & pasted it at the time, sorry peeps
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It's laughable when people talk about racism in football. You get jobs on merit, and if you are a winner, you will definitely get a chance. Did anyone notice how keen Twitter were to tell that most of the racist tweets during the Euros came from England? Just for debate did Rooney get the job at Derby based on merit? What coaching experience did he have? At my local low level non league footie club a few years ago Shaun Goater turned up to help with the coaching. I asked him why? He stated he had all the coaching badges but wasn't even getting interviews. When feedback was requested he was told he didn't have enough coaching hours. He said "at least they won't be able to use that as an excuse going forward". So there may be an issue at the bottom level giving managers that first opportunity. If you don't get that initial opportunity how will you ever get experience?
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
Just for debate did Rooney get the job at Derby based on merit? What coaching experience did he have? At my local low level non league footie club a few years ago Shaun Goater turned up to help with the coaching. I asked him why? He stated he had all the coaching badges but wasn't even getting interviews. When feedback was requested he was told he didn't have enough coaching hours. He said "at least they won't be able to use that as an excuse going forward". So there may be an issue at the bottom level giving managers that first opportunity. If you don't get that initial opportunity how will you ever get experience? Players who were successful at Big Clubs get opportunities over others, e.g., Dalglish’s first job at Liverpool or John Barnes at Celtic.
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
Just for debate did Rooney get the job at Derby based on merit? What coaching experience did he have? At my local low level non league footie club a few years ago Shaun Goater turned up to help with the coaching. I asked him why? He stated he had all the coaching badges but wasn't even getting interviews. When feedback was requested he was told he didn't have enough coaching hours. He said "at least they won't be able to use that as an excuse going forward". So there may be an issue at the bottom level giving managers that first opportunity. If you don't get that initial opportunity how will you ever get experience? Rooney was a player at Derby , then a player/coach, joint interim manager and then manager. I accept all this happened fairly quickly about a year. Howver Derby had achance to assess him in all those roles before appointing him. Steve Coppell was initially a very strange appointment but like a few other sucessful managers he retired early due to injury eg Clough and Howe. He was also a student of the game and even at that stage he impressed with his knowledge and nous. Would it happen now not so sure. Shaun Goater is currently employed as a youth coach by Macclesfield where he was brought in by Sol Campbell
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
Just for debate did Rooney get the job at Derby based on merit? What coaching experience did he have? At my local low level non league footie club a few years ago Shaun Goater turned up to help with the coaching. I asked him why? He stated he had all the coaching badges but wasn't even getting interviews. When feedback was requested he was told he didn't have enough coaching hours. He said "at least they won't be able to use that as an excuse going forward". So there may be an issue at the bottom level giving managers that first opportunity. If you don't get that initial opportunity how will you ever get experience? Goater is in the (sizable) majority in that he finished playing, did his badges, quite possibly had something to offer but couldn't get a job in football. Its massively oversubscribed. When I did the coaching badges there were guys like Andy Sinton (England, QPR and Spurs winger for younger readers, very good player indeed) and Jason Dodd who played hundreds and hundreds of top flight games for Southampton, both of whom could only find coaching 'opportunities' in non league football (I put the word in inverted commas as I am familiar with the standard). Quite why these guys and so many others didn't get the vital first chance to manage or coach when other guys with a similar background did is anyone's guess, and as you say, nobody has experience until they get a job, but you only have to look at the number of candidates to vacancies (especially given that the Premier league and championship recruit managers from abroad so much) to see that there will be far more unsuccessful and frustrated aspiring coaches than ones who get their chance. Every year hundreds of guys retire from playing, and just have to join the back of a queue that gets added to by new members much faster than it moves. Like any profession, you can get qualified and have something to offer but that doesn't create a job for you. One thing for sure, if you can get you first chance then you are far more likely to get other chances afterwards, especially at the level you have experience of. Allardyce, Pulis, Bruce, Hughes et al are obvious examples, as are Chris Houghton, Chris Powell, Leroy Rosenior etc. Campbell got back into football with Southend quite quickly after leaving Macclesfield. Even our own Vieira is on his third job already. It's getting the first job that opens it all up.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
I got it from bbc football sports page, late last week, wish id copied & pasted it at the time, sorry peeps Not to worry. I did see this today and it's not dissimilar from your info [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nubes
It is a difficult and tricky debate to be had around Sulzeer Campbell. I gather he isn’t particularly well liked within the football fraternity and this also seems to be mirrored by a section of fans who follow football. He will cite that it is harder for him to be shortlisted for potential posts if he has been applying over a period of time without much joy. Ignorance or / and prejudice is part of the subconscious of many and Sulzeer being an outspoken, not charismatic and what seems to be deemed possessing an awkward personality adds to his limited chances of progressing as he so desires. Personally, I feel he needs to offer his services doing some sort of consultancy to clubs especially defensively and develop a reputation and list of contacts through positive relations with clubs then after a period of time apply for managerial positions after demonstrating and evidencing that what he says holds weight whilst making a difference That seems a good option. PV played with him - wonder if he’d be interested.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
That seems a good option. PV played with him - wonder if he’d be interested.
Does that make me a racist? Not at all. I'm delighted we've got Patrick Vieira as our new manager. Vieira has earned the opportunity to be given a chance by reason of the apprenticeship at Citeh, NYC and Nice. Campbell is nowhere near earning the chance.
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Palace in the Blood
Rooney was a player at Derby , then a player/coach, joint interim manager and then manager. I accept all this happened fairly quickly about a year. Howver Derby had achance to assess him in all those roles before appointing him. Steve Coppell was initially a very strange appointment but like a few other sucessful managers he retired early due to injury eg Clough and Howe. He was also a student of the game and even at that stage he impressed with his knowledge and nous. Would it happen now not so sure. Shaun Goater is currently employed as a youth coach by Macclesfield where he was brought in by Sol Campbell Rooney came straight in to Derby in a player/coach role. Southgate would be a better example of a player who played for a club and then moved into a managerial role (at Middlesboro). Boro had to get special dispensation from the Prem league as Southgate didn't have the required coaching badges. I think Newcastle did the same wehn Shearer took over for a period prior to their relegation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
If Campbell had been any good he'd have a job. Even if he'd been average he'd probably be working. As he's been total pants, he hasn't got a job as a manager. I'm not convinced there's any reasons other than the obvious. That may be what’s called An Inconvenient Truth.
|
|
|
Originally posted by IMMER PALACE
Having caught up on this fast moving thread, I still reckon the only sure fire way for Sol to succeed is to back his talent and buy a club. At the moment there is a danger he appears a bit of a spoiled child, demanding a role and is totally dumbfounded that anybody would ever say no to Sol Campbell. He is young enough, rich enough and.... if he is good enough he will make it. It would be fascinating to watch him do it.
If those red Mancs can do it, why not Sol? Take over a lower league club, appoint himself as manager and let the cameras roll. It could be a great watch.
|
|
|
Originally posted by tonymikejoe
If those red Mancs can do it, why not Sol? Take over a lower league club, appoint himself as manager and let the cameras roll. It could be a great watch. Seems like a good idea. I'd watch that.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.