You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle fan- I come in peace.
November 16 2026 12.00pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Newcastle fan- I come in peace.


Page 1 of 15 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Gallowgate Ender Flag 15 Aug 16 11.01am

Not here to gloat or laugh or say we told you so.
But been reading palace fans on twitter and watching their games mainly via MOTD, nut really history is repeating.
The long winless runs, the baffling subs, the dreadful football, alienation of players (usually due to inability to man manage), the absolute spin "we play good attacking football" yet his teams are toothless.
At palace as at Newcastle, and his other clubs starts off well, gets his feet under the table then it all goes wrong.
It's down to his brilliance when the team win, but its bad luck, conspiracies, bad refs, the transfer window etc etc when it goes badly.

This man will ruin everything that's enjoyable about supporting your club. He'll divide the squad, divide the support and make it a pain in the arse to attend games because it's so dull.

I can see it has already started by skimming through this board. Don't fall into the trap of battered wife syndrome "well who else is better". Get out while you can

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Aug 16 11.02am

How has it been since you got rid of Pardew?

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Gallowgate Ender Flag 15 Aug 16 11.05am

Well after Pardew chose to leave for more money and total control over transfers, the board appointed john carver on an interim basis, and he was as bad as pardew, then after that they appointed McClaren who was probably even worse.
Benitez came in and couldn't save the sinking ship in time.

 

Gallowgate Ender Flag 15 Aug 16 11.08am

I'd also add that it's my opinion that Pardew is a lucky manager, stumbles on a formation or a line up (usually forced on him by injuries or suspension) then might win, say 6 out of 10, and the pardew for england noises start. But he can't sustain that level and goes on long winless runs which he can't turn around. That suggests he doesn't really know how to affect a result. But he'll always blame luck or bad luck when it's not going his way

 

Percy of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 15 Aug 16 11.08am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

How has it been since you got rid of Pardew?

However, there's an element of familiarity in all of the above!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt!

steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 15 Aug 16 11.09am

Originally posted by Gallowgate Ender

Well after Pardew chose to leave for more money and total control over transfers, the board appointed john carver on an interim basis, and he was as bad as pardew, then after that they appointed McClaren who was probably even worse.
Benitez came in and couldn't save the sinking ship in time.

To the great joy of your fans

Edited by steph_eagle (15 Aug 2016 11.09am)

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 15 Aug 16 11.09am

Carver In!

 

Jacey Flag 15 Aug 16 11.10am

Originally posted by Gallowgate Ender

Well after Pardew chose to leave for more money and total control over transfers, the board appointed john carver on an interim basis, and he was as bad as pardew, then after that they appointed McClaren who was probably even worse.
Benitez came in and couldn't save the sinking ship in time.

Think the Benitez appointment was brilliant but seems not even he could prevent you from losing your first two Championship games.Are you to having a 'transitional' season??

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 15 Aug 16 11.11am

You're right, our team is toothless - but that's because we haven't spent on any attacking reinforcements, and I don't think even Newcastle fans think Pardew is so stupid that he's not desperate to get upgrades into this squad ASAP. The lack of infrastructure at this club with regards to transfers, and the penny-pinching of our negotiators are delaying the transfers which could have settled my fears at least.

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 15 Aug 16 11.15am

I think a huge amount of our fanbase has a real desire for Pardew to do well, which he definitely didn't have at Newcastle.

We'll also back him, Newcastle didn't.

I'll wait til 5 games after the window to judge him. It's been a rotten year but he's still a solid mid table Premier League manager and I don't think we'd get anybody better.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 15 Aug 16 11.15am

I really don't get why their fans feel the need to come on here all the time. I love the fact they all start with 'am not here to gloat' when they are.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Aug 16 11.17am

You had and have some really good players at Toon. Your defence is bloody awful though. You may find grinding out results is key in the Championship. We should know - hold on a minute - si should you. Best of luck for the season. Are you happy or unhappy with your owner at present?

 


Red and Blue Army!

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Aug 16 11.21am

Originally posted by Gallowgate Ender

Well after Pardew chose to leave for more money and total control over transfers, the board appointed john carver on an interim basis, and he was as bad as pardew, then after that they appointed McClaren who was probably even worse.
Benitez came in and couldn't save the sinking ship in time.

So it was definitely Pardew that was the problem then. Benitez and McClaren are both more accomplished and experienced managers than Pardew.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Aug 16 11.22am

Originally posted by steph_eagle

I really don't get why their fans feel the need to come on here all the time. I love the fact they all start with 'am not here to gloat' when they are.

I don't read it that way. I think the Toon fans are looking for reinforcement that they were right all along. If it wasn't Pardew then they would have to look elsewhere to understand what their problem was. Pardew is a simple solution to a complex question. And he is easy to knock with his dubious morality, his gambling history (allegedly) and his ridiculous levels of self-belief.

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 15 Aug 16 11.24am

Originally posted by Bangell

You're right, our team is toothless - but that's because we haven't spent on any attacking reinforcements, and I don't think even Newcastle fans think Pardew is so stupid that he's not desperate to get upgrades into this squad ASAP. The lack of infrastructure at this club with regards to transfers, and the penny-pinching of our negotiators are delaying the transfers which could have settled my fears at least.

The WBA debacle was nothing to do with transfers. Pardew was unable to prepare a team to combat a very predictable
bottom rung EPL team. WBA beat us all over the park. We were useless despite months to prepare. Pardew is a legend in his own mind. The lesson from our toon visitor and Newcastle is that there are (believe it or not) worse options that Pardew. But if we can get someone close to Rafa then we should divorce and remarry asap.

 


[Link]

Gallowgate Ender Flag 15 Aug 16 11.24am

When we signed Cisse in jan2012 he scored 12 goals in 13 appearances.
Pardew played him as a right midfielder for the first few months of the following season. Absolutely baffling.

Now Pardiola has total control at palace and he says you need more goals he allows players like Gayle to leave, but his incoming purchases have been the likes of Whickham and Adebayor.

He will kill your club

 

Gallowgate Ender Flag 15 Aug 16 11.29am

Parchmore Eagle, I dunno how to quote but you are right.
Worse options than Pardew for sure, but don't let fear of the unknown keep you in a miserable situation.

Pardew done the worst thing a manager can do, and removed HOPE from the supporters. The way you start the season and think "you never know...."

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 15 Aug 16 11.30am

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

The WBA debacle was nothing to do with transfers. Pardew was unable to prepare a team to combat a very predictable
bottom rung EPL team. WBA beat us all over the park. We were useless despite months to prepare. Pardew is a legend in his own mind. The lesson from our toon visitor and Newcastle is that there are (believe it or not) worse options that Pardew. But if we can get someone close to Rafa then we should divorce and remarry asap.

Our only attacking options were wide players, it's not hard to predict and it's not hard to defend against us. We had absolutely no creativity through the middle, having to squeeze Championship-quality Lee into the no. 10 position.

If we wanted a new manager we should have got one at the end of last season. Things will only be made worse by destabilising the club now.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Aug 16 11.30am

Originally posted by Gallowgate Ender

I'd also add that it's my opinion that Pardew is a lucky manager, stumbles on a formation or a line up (usually forced on him by injuries or suspension) then might win, say 6 out of 10, and the pardew for england noises start. But he can't sustain that level and goes on long winless runs which he can't turn around. That suggests he doesn't really know how to affect a result. But he'll always blame luck or bad luck when it's not going his way

He did however seem to do rather well at Newcastle or at least fairly consistently over that period of time, also winning the Manager of the season, and achieving some respectable placing's. Granted I accept it wasn't like the glory days, and Houghton's record was better, but that did include playing in the championship with a premiership team.

Probably the most successful manager you've had in a decade (allowing for the fact that Houghton's championship advantage.

And it does seem to have been even worse since he left. Is it possible that actually he was playing a rather good hand, with some very poor cards?

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Aug 16 11.35am

Originally posted by Gallowgate Ender

Parchmore Eagle, I dunno how to quote but you are right.
Worse options than Pardew for sure, but don't let fear of the unknown keep you in a miserable situation.

Pardew done the worst thing a manager can do, and removed HOPE from the supporters. The way you start the season and think "you never know...."

Not really, I think getting a team relegated. You did seem to be doing rather ok until he left. Arguably pushed out by the 'great loyal Newcastle fans', than anything else.

We then went from absolutely s**t to go onto record our most successful 12 months of football for 20 years, going from bottom, to get our higest ever premiership finish, and second best finish of all time.

How does it happen, if Pardew is so bad, that he seems to keep poor clubs punching well above their weight (see Southampton as well)

I don't think he's great by the way. But I think he's about the best that clubs of our level can realistically hope to attract.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 1 of 15 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle fan- I come in peace.