You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Real Reason We Lost.
November 16 2026 11.44am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Real Reason We Lost.


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
citizensmudge Flag midlands 16 Oct 16 12.43am

Bored reading some of the anti-AP comments and I haven't actually read anyone volley home the reason we lost against the Spam so here it is.James McArthur got caught ball watching for a split second,end of conversation.He has been the difference so far this season in mine and a lot of other peoples opinions but today his rare and very small mistake cost us a point. No one is perfect and the margins are that small, Benteke gets the fastest ever WC Qualifier goal in history and a hatrick but a few days later misses a penalty.If anyone had a right to apportion blame and start throwing toys around it would be the manager for several players under performing today.

 

MandurahEagle Flag Mandurah 16 Oct 16 1.05am

You can't pin the blame for this loss on one player's lack of concentration. It seems that when Benteke has a bad game, then the rest of the team do too. The forward passing was atrocious that is why, it seems, when attacking, the ball was invariably passed back. The crosses were abysmal. When the ball did get to the Spammers end it was wasted.Punch needs to concentrate his training next week on passing the ball to a Palace player!

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 16 Oct 16 1.13am

Originally posted by MandurahEagle

You can't pin the blame for this loss on one player's lack of concentration. It seems that when Benteke has a bad game, then the rest of the team do too. The forward passing was atrocious that is why, it seems, when attacking, the ball was invariably passed back. The crosses were abysmal. When the ball did get to the Spammers end it was wasted.Punch needs to concentrate his training next week on passing the ball to a Palace player!

In bold best summing up of today

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 16 Oct 16 2.34am

I don't want to hang Pardew just because we lose to a good team like West Ham who play better than on the day. It's not about losing the match. It's about West Ham being able to play like a team straight after the first whistle, while our lot - most of them - looked like they hadn't touched a football for weeks. I feel the same as I did watching us play West Brom in our first match after the season break. Pardew, for what ever reason, did not have the team ready. Just moments before their first goal it was just a question of time before they'd score. we were utterly crap. Hoofing it about, not being able to work the ball far, nt winning duels, mistakes galore, a Zaha miss in space with time, Ward's header back to Mandanda, etc. we played nowhere near how we were playing our last handful of games. And how many times it takes us a whole 45 minutes of a match to finally get things right? Not good enough! We are simply not good enough even at our best to keep giving opponents 45 minutes. We can't expect to keep coming back from goals down. Their manager out-witted AP - do I think we should sack AP? No. Not in our interest. But let's call a spade a spade? - end of rant. Do

 


[Link]

twist Flag Miami, Florida 16 Oct 16 2.49am

Reason we lost is because Spam bought more intensity to the middle and wings, and we didnt have time or space to get our passing game going.

But back to benteke, he scored 3 for Belguim, sure it was against Gibraltar, but they were all with his feet. Just saying we are not utilizing his full abilities when we just aiming for his head.

 

Bangerparr Flag Perth 16 Oct 16 3.13am

I thought we seemed to be crowded out most of the time and consequently went for the long diagonal ball much more than we have been doing. West ham then had three big centre backs doing their best to keep Benteke off the ball. Every time the ball was put in the box it seemed very crowded also. I just wish Wickham had been able to get a little closer and above the ball for his last minute header.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 16 Oct 16 6.58am

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

I don't want to hang Pardew just because we lose to a good team like West Ham who play better than on the day. It's not about losing the match. It's about West Ham being able to play like a team straight after the first whistle, while our lot - most of them - looked like they hadn't touched a football for weeks. I feel the same as I did watching us play West Brom in our first match after the season break. Pardew, for what ever reason, did not have the team ready. Just moments before their first goal it was just a question of time before they'd score. we were utterly crap. Hoofing it about, not being able to work the ball far, nt winning duels, mistakes galore, a Zaha miss in space with time, Ward's header back to Mandanda, etc. we played nowhere near how we were playing our last handful of games. And how many times it takes us a whole 45 minutes of a match to finally get things right? Not good enough! We are simply not good enough even at our best to keep giving opponents 45 minutes. We can't expect to keep coming back from goals down. Their manager out-witted AP - do I think we should sack AP? No. Not in our interest. But let's call a spade a spade? - end of rant. Do

Could not agree more! The first half was unbelievable, even a lot worse than the WBA game when we kicked off the season. Everyone was to blame and we made the opposition look like the German national side. How is it possible over & over to start our games so sloppy?

 

Mikep1981 Flag Sutton 16 Oct 16 7.19am

Ward should of been closer to cresswell for the cross and shouldn't turn his back! Which happens a lot.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 16 Oct 16 8.52am

Surely the reason we lost was because Benteke took the worst penalty in league history.
If he has cored we would have gone in 1-1 and I think we would have won.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 16 Oct 16 9.07am

We could blame the weather our passing game broke down in the heavy rain but to me the issue was in part we didn't have a leader out there. When things started to go wrong no one stepped up to bring the team together and lead the team. Damo was unusually quiet.

 

cpj Flag Kent 16 Oct 16 9.19am

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

I don't want to hang Pardew just because we lose to a good team like West Ham who play better than on the day. It's not about losing the match. It's about West Ham being able to play like a team straight after the first whistle, while our lot - most of them - looked like they hadn't touched a football for weeks. I feel the same as I did watching us play West Brom in our first match after the season break. Pardew, for what ever reason, did not have the team ready. Just moments before their first goal it was just a question of time before they'd score. we were utterly crap. Hoofing it about, not being able to work the ball far, nt winning duels, mistakes galore, a Zaha miss in space with time, Ward's header back to Mandanda, etc. we played nowhere near how we were playing our last handful of games. And how many times it takes us a whole 45 minutes of a match to finally get things right? Not good enough! We are simply not good enough even at our best to keep giving opponents 45 minutes. We can't expect to keep coming back from goals down. Their manager out-witted AP - do I think we should sack AP? No. Not in our interest. But let's call a spade a spade? - end of rant. Do

This is the point - in nearly every game he has to make half-time substitutions because his formation/team was wrong in the first half. We've conceded first in 6 of our 8 games - this cannot keep happening.

 

superbeagle Flag Vauxhall 16 Oct 16 9.21am

We definitely miss Dann's presence (as captain and one of the best centre backs in the league) both at the back and getting up the field and scoring. Will be good to have him back next week.

 

Hoof Hearted 16 Oct 16 9.23am

I think the reason we lost was all about preparation and application of a game plan as well as sloppy finishing and a general air of malaise about our team.

WHU came out all guns blazing and were on top of us for the first 25 minutes pressing us hard and getting down their left flank with Cresswell finding space to cross into our box and Payet with room to feed him.

We were lucky not to be more than 1-0 down before we stemmed the tide and began to contain their threat.

Why are we so woeful at pressing teams and yet allow them to pin us back? Watch Leicester and in particular Vardy - he runs his nuts off to shut down a building attack from the front. Compare and contrast with any of our attacking players who amble around when we haven't got the ball.

The penalty we missed was typical of the day we were having, careless and clumsy. Beforehand I was convinced he would use power rather than a chip.

2nd half we had more possession but we were wasteful of opportunities - the free kick Townsend passed to Ward that he wasn't expecting on his left foot was typical of the bad decisions made.

WHU going down to 10 made little difference either and time ran out on us.

For me the only bonus was that Cabaye looked as though he was on the mend and eager to contribute.

If we play like that again next week Leicester will beat us easily.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 16 Oct 16 9.40am

Originally posted by MandurahEagle

You can't pin the blame for this loss on one player's lack of concentration. It seems that when Benteke has a bad game, then the rest of the team do too. The forward passing was atrocious that is why, it seems, when attacking, the ball was invariably passed back. The crosses were abysmal. When the ball did get to the Spammers end it was wasted. Punch needs to concentrate his training next week on passing the ball to a Palace player!

This perfectly summarises our first half especially. Puncheon was terrible.

We may also need to sort out a kit that can be seen against those awful glaring neon hoardings! Maybe start using our away kit at home?


Edited by Henry of Peckham (16 Oct 2016 9.43am)

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 16 Oct 16 10.06am

Originally posted by Bangerparr

I thought we seemed to be crowded out most of the time and consequently went for the long diagonal ball much more than we have been doing. West ham then had three big centre backs doing their best to keep Benteke off the ball. Every time the ball was put in the box it seemed very crowded also. I just wish Wickham had been able to get a little closer and above the ball for his last minute header.

Good points. If Benteke was being taken off the ball by 3 centre backs then what were the other supposedly attacking minded players doing ? Unfortunately that was one of the pieces in the jigsaw that didn't materialise pre season but we seemed to be looking. Hopefully we won't stand still in Jan but continue targeting quality in this area as it needs improvement particularly in games like yesterday where our first shot on target was on 60 mins at home. Other issues were their 3-5-2 formation stifling us so easily and the lack of clean sheets at the back due to a number of silly errors over a number of games such as yesterday, WBA and the Spuds.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 16 Oct 16 10.12am

real reason we lost.

west ham did a job on us and because they played 3 at the back with wing backs we had very little space in the final 3rd to operate in.

we go again next week against a poor leicester side

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


auk Flag 16 Oct 16 10.26am

Interesting point by Henry of Peckham. We seem. To play better in our away strip.

That red and blue is a bit murky under our floodlights.

The match was like our home defeat to S'land last season.

 

bodge Flag 16 Oct 16 10.53am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

real reason we lost.

west ham did a job on us and because they played 3 at the back with wing backs we had very little space in the final 3rd to operate in.

we go again next week against a poor leicester side

I hope that's a joke.

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 16 Oct 16 10.53am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

real reason we lost.

west ham did a job on us and because they played 3 at the back with wing backs we had very little space in the final 3rd to operate in.

we go again next week against a poor leicester side

Agree with the above. We could all see that they were going to score but never changed things until half time. After 10 minutes something needed to be done. They took the game to us and it paid off for them.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 16 Oct 16 11.05am

The West Ham formation caused us all manner of grief and we couldn't fully adjust till half time. The new gameplan worked well in the second half and we dominated by playing the ball on the floor. In the 53rd minute Benteke received the ball to his feet for the first time all game and held it up and played it wide superbly. We seem to be able to be forced away from our gameplan early in nearly every game so far and AP has mentioned it on occasions that we didn't start as he expected. As someone said we need a Gerrard type in midfield and more pace at the back in the fb areas IMO. Cabaye also has to start. I really don't care what the nay sayers are bleating about, he is one of our best players and knows how to control a game. The transition in style will take a little longer and with that we will still sometimes be caught between two stools, but it will come good I'm sure of it.

Edited by Dangermouse (16 Oct 2016 11.05am)

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Real Reason We Lost.