This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Steve Mandanda
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
MARKY coulsdon 02 Nov 16 12.43pm |
|
|
I am amazed Mandanda hasn't come in for more criticism. His shot stopping has been poor (apart from 1 great save). The modern identikit of a premier league goalie is being 6ft 5 and coming out and dominating your area from set pieces, we are now conceding goals from corner etc. because he doesn't come off his line. Analysts from other clubs are looking at him and dropping corners, free kicks on our 6yd line and putting our centre half’s under huge pressure. I think we should put Hennessy in for the Burnley game, I think he was better than Palace fans gave him credit for and had a really good Euro's. While I am ranting he is another Pardew buy that isn't shaping up Saoure - jury still out whether he is a good premiership full back Kebaye - has not lived up to price tag/wages, not guaranteed starter Tompkins - looks average Townsend - been disappointing Sakho - championship player Chongy - too inconsistent Wickham - injury prone, has looked uninterested this season Benteke - no brainer
Don't think we will win another home match before Pardew's 2 year anniversary, that could be 2 home wins in a year, as much as I want Pardew to be a success too many cracks are appearing, you judge a manager on buys, tactics and improving players he is looking average on all counts
|
mickeyCPFC Crawley 02 Nov 16 12.48pm |
|
|
Mandanda is the best keeper we have, and has made some terrific saves so far, its not him that needs work on, its our defence. A keeper can only be as good as his back 4. In my opinion he has been brilliant and would have him over Wayne any day. Our defence will improve I'm sure......3 Points at Burnley, positivity!!!
|
IMpalace London 02 Nov 16 12.49pm |
|
|
Bravo - error prone Kolarov - suspect defensively Stones - complacent, makes errors Kompany - always injured Otamendi - goes flying out of defence, often leaves holes Fernandinho - crap going forward De Bruyne - can go missing in big games Ageuero - injured a lot Sterling - bad hair
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 16 1.06pm |
|
Originally posted by MARKY
I am amazed Mandanda hasn't come in for more criticism. His shot stopping has been poor (apart from 1 great save). The modern identikit of a premier league goalie is being 6ft 5 and coming out and dominating your area from set pieces, we are now conceding goals from corner etc. because he doesn't come off his line. Analysts from other clubs are looking at him and dropping corners, free kicks on our 6yd line and putting our centre half’s under huge pressure. I think we should put Hennessy in for the Burnley game, I think he was better than Palace fans gave him credit for and had a really good Euro's. While I am ranting he is another Pardew buy that isn't shaping up Saoure - jury still out whether he is a good premiership full back Kebaye - has not lived up to price tag/wages, not guaranteed starter Tompkins - looks average Townsend - been disappointing Sakho - championship player Chongy - too inconsistent Wickham - injury prone, has looked uninterested this season Benteke - no brainer
Don't think we will win another home match before Pardew's 2 year anniversary, that could be 2 home wins in a year, as much as I want Pardew to be a success too many cracks are appearing, you judge a manager on buys, tactics and improving players he is looking average on all counts
Marky
I actually agree with a lot of your comments. I accept that you and I in broad agreement is a very worrying development as far as you are concerned !
|
dg1937 02 Nov 16 1.08pm |
|
|
Guardiola out!!
|
victor43 St. Albans 02 Nov 16 1.14pm |
|
Originally posted by MARKY
I am amazed Mandanda hasn't come in for more criticism. His shot stopping has been poor (apart from 1 great save). The modern identikit of a premier league goalie is being 6ft 5 and coming out and dominating your area from set pieces, we are now conceding goals from corner etc. because he doesn't come off his line. Analysts from other clubs are looking at him and dropping corners, free kicks on our 6yd line and putting our centre half’s under huge pressure. I think we should put Hennessy in for the Burnley game, I think he was better than Palace fans gave him credit for and had a really good Euro's. While I am ranting he is another Pardew buy that isn't shaping up Saoure - jury still out whether he is a good premiership full back Kebaye - has not lived up to price tag/wages, not guaranteed starter Tompkins - looks average Townsend - been disappointing Sakho - championship player Chongy - too inconsistent Wickham - injury prone, has looked uninterested this season Benteke - no brainer
Don't think we will win another home match before Pardew's 2 year anniversary, that could be 2 home wins in a year, as much as I want Pardew to be a success too many cracks are appearing, you judge a manager on buys, tactics and improving players he is looking average on all counts
Come on, if you're going to criticise our players, at least try and spell them right!
And it would be 3 home wins in a year actually, excluding cup games.
Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]
Twitter:
|
TheArmaniCode 02 Nov 16 1.20pm |
|
Originally posted by mickeyCPFC
Mandanda is the best keeper we have, and has made some terrific saves so far, its not him that needs work on, its our defence. A keeper can only be as good as his back 4. In my opinion he has been brilliant and would have him over Wayne any day. Our defence will improve I'm sure......3 Points at Burnley, positivity!!!
couldn't have put it better myself, it's so easy to point fingers at him because he's a "big name". Mandanda can only do so much, it's our defence that needs to figure out how to mark players properly
|
MARKY coulsdon 02 Nov 16 1.21pm |
|
Originally posted by IMpalace
Bravo - error prone Kolarov - suspect defensively Stones - complacent, makes errors Kompany - always injured Otamendi - goes flying out of defence, often leaves holes Fernandinho - crap going forward De Bruyne - can go missing in big games Ageuero - injured a lot Sterling - bad hair
Not sure where your going with this but I watched the champions league last night and De Bruyne was MOTM against Barcelona, and Guardiola has made Sterling look a decent player! I agree with the hair though. Also my point was specifically Pardew buys don't think Guardiola has bought all those listed
|
Beastie 02 Nov 16 1.24pm |
|
Originally posted by TheArmaniCode
couldn't have put it better myself, it's so easy to point fingers at him because he's a "big name". Mandanda can only do so much, it's our defence that needs to figure out how to mark players properly
I’ve got no problem with Mandanda but I suspect if we’d signed him from Torquay, he would be getting absolutely slated by now.
|
paperhat croydon 02 Nov 16 1.27pm |
|
Originally posted by MARKY
Also my point was specifically Pardew buys don't think Guardiola has bought all those listed
So, it's Pardew you have the issue with then?
Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan
|
TheArmaniCode 02 Nov 16 1.30pm |
|
Originally posted by Beastie
I’ve got no problem with Mandanda but I suspect if we’d signed him from Torquay, he would be getting absolutely slated by now.
well maybe, but I still do think we're being a bit harsh, I seriously doubt any of our other keepers could do much better
|
I'mPalace Till I Die 02 Nov 16 1.30pm |
|
|
In my opinion, Steve Mandanda is the best keeper Palace have had since Nigel Martyn. He's got a shed load of French International caps and has saved us/made very few errors. I still think people are being overly critical of him collecting crosses. Regardless of whether a keeper comes for the ball or not, no player should be totally unmarked or given a free header in the box. Therefore the biggest problem is the way our defence has been. I'm sure with Dann fully fit this weekend and not playing against the likes of Firminho and Coutinho we will be back on it
|
palace99 New Mills 02 Nov 16 2.39pm |
|
|
i agree with some of your observation regarding Steveee.
A few decent stops but doesn't dominate his area. Also thought both goals from corners on Sat could have been saved - both were right at him, low and high, albeit very hard. Jury still out in my view.
Have to say though it helps if you can spell players names as I thought you were referring to Kebe for a second - an absolutely terrible and costly mistake but not Pardew's.
|
Painter Croydon 02 Nov 16 3.35pm |
|
|
[quote=I'mPalace Till I Die;3073930]
In my opinion, Steve Mandanda is the best keeper Palace have had since Nigel Martyn. He's got a shed load of French International caps and has saved us/made very few errors. I still think people are being overly critical of him collecting crosses. Regardless of whether a keeper comes for the ball or not, no player should be totally unmarked or given a free header in the box. Therefore the biggest problem is the way our defence has been. I'm sure with Dann fully fit this weekend and not playing against the likes of Firminho and Coutinho we will be back on it
Your opinion is misguided, his inability to come for crosses is unsettling the defence, it's pretty obvious.
A keeper that cannot catch a ball is the same player that cannot trap a ball.
People are blinded by the fact he is the French reserve keeper, let's face it, he doesn't compare to Lloris.
|
NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Nov 16 3.36pm |
|
|
He has similar qualities / traits to Speroni.
Although his distribution is better.
Old, Ungifted and White
|
KAOS In a tree 02 Nov 16 4.59pm |
|
Originally posted by victor43
Come on, if you're going to criticise our players, at least try and spell them right!
And it would be 3 home wins in a year actually, excluding cup games.
Bit of a worry when the only 2 things you can pull him up on on his post are those eh! Haha
|
Brentmiester_General Front line in the battle against t... 02 Nov 16 5.09pm |
|
Originally posted by Beastie
I’ve got no problem with Mandanda but I suspect if we’d signed him from Torquay, he would be getting absolutely slated by now.
It's the fact we haven't which means he needs time to adapt to the game here. His pedigree is there for all to see. Remember Bartethz when he first joined Man U.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...
|
cpj Kent 02 Nov 16 5.12pm |
|
|
Shhh, don't let BrentmeisterGeneral know of your dark thoughts! You are not allowed to criticise Mandanda because we bought him for a French club so he must be good.
How people can say he's made a load of great saves is beyond me - yes, one excellent one on Saturday, but other than that he's been beaten by some pretty ordinary efforts (Bournemouth, Sunderland, Boro come to mind) and has a worrying tendency not to even try saving some shots (W Ham and Everton, although apparently the latter was all the fault of the wall unlike when WH was being beaten by free kicks last season).
Re the corners on Saturday, for the second one he started out about 4 yards from goal, but moved back to his line once he saw the trajectory of the ball. Unlike our corners, which are floated in and give the keeper an age to follow the ball and grab it, the Liverpool corners were whipped in with pace and swing, so I'm not blaming Mandanda as much now for those.
Still not impressed with him though. As was said above, very much in the Speroni mode of making a few flash saves. And don't get me started on his dodgy distribution.
|
sickboy Deal or Croydon 02 Nov 16 5.14pm |
|
|
[quote=I'mPalace Till I Die;3073930]
In my opinion, Steve Mandanda is the best keeper Palace have had since Nigel Martyn. He's got a shed load of French International caps and has saved us/made very few errors. I still think people are being overly critical of him collecting crosses. Regardless of whether a keeper comes for the ball or not, no player should be totally unmarked or given a free header in the box. Therefore the biggest problem is the way our defence has been. I'm sure with Dann fully fit this weekend and not playing against the likes of Firminho and Coutinho we will be back on it
Wow. You sir are one hell of a judge of a player to come to that conclusion in just 10 games.
|
Elpis In a pub 02 Nov 16 5.15pm |
|
|
Well I'm glad I'm not the only one who has questioned the keeper not coming for crosses in and around the goals . I was talking to my bro in the pub the other night about how useless in general goalkeepers are these days . England used to have the best goalkeepers in the world .They dominated the box ,all of them from best at the top clubs to those in the lower leagues goalkeeping was an art that included catching crosses in the box .
We remembered going to England games where we saw the foreign keeper PUNCH the ball away . We immediately knew they had a dodgy keeper and screamed at our wingers to get the ball in the box .
Oh well ,we have to work with what we have got ,maybe the answer is not to give away corners
|