You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Parish question?
November 16 2026 11.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Steve Parish question?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 16 Dec 16 8.57am

Now I do have so much respect for Steve Parish and the board, But I am questioning his wisdom in keeping Alan Pardew in a job. Lots have been said on here about Alan Pardew being out of his depth and unable to change things around, With Parish and I love the guy, Is he out of his depth, If you look at the facts, He was comfortable with Ian Holloway guiding us through the first year of the Premier league, Iw was following such bad performances that Holloway was so embarrassed that he resigned and admitted that he was not the man for the job, With Tony Pulis he was never Steve'a first choice in fact at the time it was widely reported that he was the only one who accepted the job. So we did well by default under Pulis. another appointment was Neil Warnock & I don't think i need to say anything about that situation and again Steve let that run on far too long, and with the threat of relegation before he acted.


My question is I know Steve Parish has the company at heart and we all have the utmost respect for him, But is he out of his depth in the premier His appointment of managers in the Premier is pretty abysmal with Holloway, who IMO was lucky to get us promoted, He was put in charge with us pretty much expecting to be at least in the playoffs and nearly missed out, I think we needed to beat Peterborough on the last day, and Warnock and Pardew, Surely we have to question his wisdom on Management appointments.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 16 Dec 16 9.07am

Burley - I don't remember seeing too many negative posts, it was a sign of a bright new future. Didn't work out. Their first appointment

Freedman - the peoples choice, f***ed us over, not SP fault

Holloway, again lauded as a great manager to get us out of the championship, which he did. he also knew when to walk. Overall a success

Pulis, delayed getting him, he wanted lots of cash, kept us up when we looked doomed - Money grabbing t*** but a success

Warnock - Hobson's choice at the time. Could perhaps have looked elsewhere but we didn't have a lot of time.

Pardew, kept us up & finished 10th. Last season an FA Cup Final. We are struggling now, whether he stays or goes overall a success

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 16 Dec 16 9.17am

Cant disagree with the Burley & Freedman comments, But I was referring to the this premier stay. Holloway in a way was a success but the point I made is Parish let it run far too long. Pulis was not first choice at all, He tried many candidates, And Pulis was the only one who accepted the job on the second approach. Warnock no excuses a poor appointment in taking any mitigating circumstances into account. Pardew a success if he actually goes now and does not take us down Otherwise its a major disaster

This thread is just asking for peoples opinions on Parish no wrongs or rights here

----------------------------------------------

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Burley - I don't remember seeing too many negative posts, it was a sign of a bright new future. Didn't work out. Their first appointment

Freedman - the peoples choice, f***ed us over, not SP fault

Holloway, again lauded as a great manager to get us out of the championship, which he did. he also knew when to walk. Overall a success

Pulis, delayed getting him, he wanted lots of cash, kept us up when we looked doomed - Money grabbing t*** but a success

Warnock - Hobson's choice at the time. Could perhaps have looked elsewhere but we didn't have a lot of time.

Pardew, kept us up & finished 10th. Last season an FA Cup Final. We are struggling now, whether he stays or goes overall a success

 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 16 Dec 16 9.33am

I've been consistently in the "Pardew Out" camp since April / May.

However it's not AP's fault he is still in charge & I believe Pards genuinely has the club at heart & is trying his best.
(however I, personally, don't think he's good enough).

The blame for our current plight lies solely with the men in charge.
(Parish, aided by the Americans).

They, crassly, gave Pards a 4 year deal when we were already on the
worst form run in the UK.

They now, from my angle, are stuck by the financial penalties imposed by the new deal & burdened by the fact that to admit error of judgement now is a major blow to credibility.

The wallet & personal arrogance is now preventing correct decisions being taken - IMHO.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 16 Dec 16 9.42am

Originally posted by Dancer Cat

I've been consistently in the "Pardew Out" camp since April / May.

However it's not AP's fault he is still in charge & I believe Pards genuinely has the club at heart & is trying his best.
(however I, personally, don't think he's good enough).

The blame for our current plight lies solely with the men in charge.
(Parish, aided by the Americans).

They, crassly, gave Pards a 4 year deal when we were already on the
worst form run in the UK.

They now, from my angle, are stuck by the financial penalties imposed by the new deal & burdened by the fact that to admit error of judgement now is a major blow to credibility.

The wallet & personal arrogance is now preventing correct decisions being taken - IMHO.

Did they? I keep seeing this being said, though usually 5 yrs and when I have googled it I have been unable to find anything that confirms it ever happened

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 16 Dec 16 9.54am

Parish tried to appoint Malky Mackay and he did appoint that other corrupt bloke as Sporting Director.

Got lucky with Pulis. Holloway walked but was not going to be sacked going by Browett's comments so we were heading straight back to The Championship with their acceptance. Hence, the signing of Dwight Gayle imo pre-empting that scenario. Thanks Ian for going. Respect.

Warnock - Should have been a consultant on 'Walking With Dinosaurs' not our manager. Never had a successful Prem season ever but was appointed anyway.

Alan came in and saved the day.

Whatever luck ( a lot) Parish has had he has earned it but I don't think he has the magic to upgrade and refurbish the club and get the staff and academy needed long-term to survive in The Prem.

His legacy unless he up's his game will not be 'naming-a-stand-after-him' worthy.

And selling 40% of the club to the Yanks? Thanks, Steve.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Bangell Flag Oxford 16 Dec 16 10.07am

Holloway seemed a decent appointment at the time, and did get us promoted (just). I think his 'resignation' was just Parish letting him go gracefully. Warnock I also think was a sensible appointment - we were in absolute turmoil and he seemed like the kind of battling manager to keep us going for a while - he was never intended to be more than a stop-gap, and we did get enough points under him to stay afloat. Can't be denied that Pardew was a good appointment at the time, and has overall been good for our club, even if he has lost the plot now.

I do question Parish's judgment with every game that goes by with Pardew in charge at this point, but a sacking soon and a good manager to take us forward and I don't see how we'll be able to complain about the direction Parish is taking us.

 

aashman12 Flag 16 Dec 16 10.40am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Burley - I don't remember seeing too many negative posts, it was a sign of a bright new future. Didn't work out. Their first appointment

Freedman - the peoples choice, f***ed us over, not SP fault

Holloway, again lauded as a great manager to get us out of the championship, which he did. he also knew when to walk. Overall a success

Pulis, delayed getting him, he wanted lots of cash, kept us up when we looked doomed - Money grabbing t*** but a success

Warnock - Hobson's choice at the time. Could perhaps have looked elsewhere but we didn't have a lot of time.

Pardew, kept us up & finished 10th. Last season an FA Cup Final. We are struggling now, whether he stays or goes overall a success


Holloway did almost as much to not get us promoted as he did to get us. That run in was absolute disastrous up to jedi getting the winner vs Peterborough


 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 16 Dec 16 10.51am

Originally posted by aashman12


Holloway did almost as much to not get us promoted as he did to get us. That run in was absolute disastrous up to jedi getting the winner vs Peterborough

He got us promoted, when we had to win we did. Our form was poor at times but we were never going to continue the 6 game winning streak that suddenly made Dougie the best manager Palace ever had.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Dec 16 10.59am

Originally posted by Medway Eagle

With Tony Pulis he was never Steve'a first choice in fact at the time it was widely reported that he was the only one who accepted the job. So we did well by default under Pulis.

My memory tells me that it was Pulis that didn't really want the job and Steve Parish spent ages courting him and trying to persuade him to take it

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 16 Dec 16 11.00am

People are really questioning SP. Just because he hasnt done what they want yet. f***ing unbelievable. Last time i checked we were still in the prem for our longest run ever and had made the cup final for only the second time in our history. And we arent even in the bottom 3. No wonder we get called Nigels.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Dec 16 11.03am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

He got us promoted, when we had to win we did. Our form was poor at times but we were never going to continue the 6 game winning streak that suddenly made Dougie the best manager Palace ever had.

That's rewriting history to suit the current mood. It was Dougie's team, the majority of whom was still forming the backbone of our first team in the Premiership and we were flying into one of the automatic promotion spots when he left and there is no reason at all why that run of form wouldn't have continued.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 16 Dec 16 11.14am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

That's rewriting history to suit the current mood. It was Dougie's team, the majority of whom was still forming the backbone of our first team in the Premiership and we were flying into one of the automatic promotion spots when he left and there is no reason at all why that run of form wouldn't have continued.

It's not rewriting history, it is what happened. You are implying that we would have carried on as we had if Dougie had stayed. You are ignoring our poor start and the goals we were shipping

We carried on the good form for the rest of the year and it was only around March time we started a wobble. Are you saying that wouldn't have happened at some stage in the season with any other manager including Freedman? I have seen nothing in his subsequent career to suggest that wouldn't have been the case. You are also forgetting the alleged conversation in the car park.

Dougie certainly has an eye fro a player, manager though? the jury is still out

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Dec 16 11.41am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch


I have seen nothing in his subsequent career to suggest that wouldn't have been the case. You are also forgetting the alleged conversation in the car park.

Dougie certainly has an eye fro a player, manager though? the jury is still out

I've never really believed in that alleged conversation in the car park. How did the discussion get into the public domain as neither Parish nor Freedman would have spread the stories around.


 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 16 Dec 16 11.47am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I've never really believed in that alleged conversation in the car park. How did the discussion get into the public domain as neither Parish nor Freedman would have spread the stories around.


Hence the alleged. The rest of my post still stands though

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Den1923 Flag 16 Dec 16 1.06pm

SP since 2010 generally has been and still is doing a great job for this club. The good news is that since that date the club has reached new horizons and is now at the critical mass point where the club is now outgrowing its structure and therefore SP needs to step back from football matters and appoint a first class director of football who has all the right contacts that are necessary to attract quality players to the club. The director of football 9who would have already been a successful coach himself) could plan any future succession planning and oversee the manager/head coach helping with advice on tactics and team selection. This could also help in the AP situation because he could either accept the change of structure and his new reporting line or resign in which case that may reduce any compensation that may be due to him!

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 16 Dec 16 1.37pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I've never really believed in that alleged conversation in the car park. How did the discussion get into the public domain as neither Parish nor Freedman would have spread the stories around.


Think people forget that Parish used to attend most games and still speaks to the people he used to sit with/ know personally. He's quite candid with info. Would have been even more open back then without the media circus that is the PL buzzing around the clubs every movement.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 16 Dec 16 1.42pm

Originally posted by Den1923

SP since 2010 generally has been and still is doing a great job for this club. The good news is that since that date the club has reached new horizons and is now at the critical mass point where the club is now outgrowing its structure and therefore SP needs to step back from football matters and appoint a first class director of football who has all the right contacts that are necessary to attract quality players to the club. The director of football 9who would have already been a successful coach himself) could plan any future succession planning and oversee the manager/head coach helping with advice on tactics and team selection. This could also help in the AP situation because he could either accept the change of structure and his new reporting line or resign in which case that may reduce any compensation that may be due to him!

No Director of Football rubbish.We have been there done that.
Parish is fine,he will decide on AP.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Dec 16 1.44pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Think people forget that Parish used to attend most games and still speaks to the people he used to sit with/ know personally. He's quite candid with info. Would have been even more open back then without the media circus that is the PL buzzing around the clubs every movement.

Perhaps, but he's a shrewd businessman and therefore knows that one doesn't run down the senior management in public

 

Den1923 Flag 16 Dec 16 2.03pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

No Director of Football rubbish.We have been there done that.
Parish is fine,he will decide on AP.

That is why we are in the difficulties that we in, the key is finding the right person and the chairman is not the right person! it work very well at many clubs not least of all at Southampton!

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Parish question?