You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Is The Department for Education 'Fit for Purpose'?
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is The Department for Education 'Fit for Purpose'?


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Sportyteacher Flag London 13 Apr 17 3.11pm

Just presenting the reported facts:

How real term spending cuts is projected to affect your local primary / secondary school:

[Link]

Meanwhile, ignoring the above, The Government continues to break the bank upon the creation of additional free schools sometimes to as much as five times the going rate on sites:

[Link]

National Audit Office report recently stated that only £6.7bn was needed just to bring all existing school buildings up to a 'satisfactory' standard yet it had chosen to prioritise spending billions on state-of-the-art free schools:

[Link]

No conclusive evidence to date that free schools (and academy) models outperform local maintained, as reinforced by recent reports published by cross party Education Select Committee, however core educational funding has undoubtedly been allotted to the former.

Any thoughts to share, especially from any of you working in the profession?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Apr 17 3.46pm

I don't think its been fit for purpose for at least 20 years or so.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Apr 17 6.34pm

The edumacation system is f***ed, staff morale at an all time low. That's why I got out. I can't be complicit in what the government have done to the curriculum and the stress levels put on kids and teachers regarding sats.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 13 Apr 17 7.04pm

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Just presenting the reported facts:

How real term spending cuts is projected to affect your local primary / secondary school:

[Link]

Meanwhile, ignoring the above, The Government continues to break the bank upon the creation of additional free schools sometimes to as much as five times the going rate on sites:

[Link]

National Audit Office report recently stated that only £6.7bn was needed just to bring all existing school buildings up to a 'satisfactory' standard yet it had chosen to prioritise spending billions on state-of-the-art free schools:

[Link]

No conclusive evidence to date that free schools (and academy) models outperform local maintained, as reinforced by recent reports published by cross party Education Select Committee, however core educational funding has undoubtedly been allotted to the former.

Any thoughts to share, especially from any of you working in the profession?

It must be tough having a guaranteed wage and pension provision, in these days of austerity.

You feel so bad for teachers. Having choices in these days of 'gap employment' makes you the most poorly treated people in society.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Lakeview Flag Lincoln 13 Apr 17 7.06pm

This year, my classroom had multiple ceiling leaks which meant buckets and bowls had to be left out during the working day & over weekends. There was black-spot mould throughout cupboards & parts of the ceiling. After more than 4 months of reminders, they finally fixed the dripping ceiling etc.
These mobile classrooms were brought in over 20 years ago as a "temporary measure." My spouse became sick of me smelling of mould after a day's work! This is before the new financial pressures hit.
The futile aspects of recent times mean I'm looking to take early retirement; the crazily detailed planning, record-keeping/data handling, the written conversation between teacher and pupil that is modern marking and deteriorating behaviour which is almost unpunished by some heads means I'm keen to escape. I'd advise anyone to avoid the profession for now. The present advertising campaign to enlist teachers shows there is a shortfall of applicants and is laughable-not reflecting life as a teacher at all. 72 hour weeks are a minimum to survival; 80 hours and I just about stay on top of things, but so much of that is of no benefit to pupils that I've had enough.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 13 Apr 17 10.57pm

Originally posted by Lakeview

This year, my classroom had multiple ceiling leaks which meant buckets and bowls had to be left out during the working day & over weekends. There was black-spot mould throughout cupboards & parts of the ceiling. After more than 4 months of reminders, they finally fixed the dripping ceiling etc.
These mobile classrooms were brought in over 20 years ago as a "temporary measure." My spouse became sick of me smelling of mould after a day's work! This is before the new financial pressures hit.
The futile aspects of recent times mean I'm looking to take early retirement; the crazily detailed planning, record-keeping/data handling, the written conversation between teacher and pupil that is modern marking and deteriorating behaviour which is almost unpunished by some heads means I'm keen to escape. I'd advise anyone to avoid the profession for now. The present advertising campaign to enlist teachers shows there is a shortfall of applicants and is laughable-not reflecting life as a teacher at all. 72 hour weeks are a minimum to survival; 80 hours and I just about stay on top of things, but so much of that is of no benefit to pupils that I've had enough.

Perfect argument for LESS government not more, part of the reason for these problems are the amount of red tape & bureaucracy you need file to get anything done, IE Maintenance, repairs etc.

 


Pro USA & Israel

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Apr 17 11.06pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Perfect argument for LESS government not more, part of the reason for these problems are the amount of red tape & bureaucracy you need file to get anything done, IE Maintenance, repairs etc.

Hardly any red tape. Premises manager should be more than capable to manage.All down to juggling a shrinking budget. Building vs Kids needs.

In the past, authorities had their own buildings dept who would have provided necessary tradesmen / equipment. Now it's down to schools to sort out themselves. Also used to be an emergency pot of cash kept aside to assist schools if major work was needed.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 13 Apr 17 11.09pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Hardly any red tape. Premises manager should be more than capable to manage.All down to juggling a shrinking budget. Building vs Kids needs.

In the past, authorities had their own buildings dept who would have provided necessary tradesmen / equipment. Now it's down to schools to sort out themselves. Also used to be an emergency pot of cash kept aside to assist schools if major work was needed.

Then surely you have a list of approved tradesman you can call on at short notice.

 


Pro USA & Israel

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Apr 17 11.30pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Then surely you have a list of approved tradesman you can call on at short notice.

Me? I don't. The premises manager would have his list.

What I was getting at is its not red tape and bureaucracy that's the reason for schools not getting repairs done. It's money.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 14 Apr 17 12.35am

Originally posted by matt_himself

It must be tough having a guaranteed wage and pension provision, in these days of austerity.

You feel so bad for teachers. Having choices in these days of 'gap employment' makes you the most poorly treated people in society.

Any teacher out there will tell you that you go into the profession to support the best short and long term needs of children and young people FIRST AND FOREMOST. Guaranteed wage and pension provision is also a thing of the past. You're regrettably out of touch with the everyday workings of the profession.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Apr 17 12.48am

There are some on here who think that primary school is finger painting and colouring in. (if only, art is being pushed out of the primary curriculum)

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 14 Apr 17 12.50am

Originally posted by nickgusset

There are some on here who think that primary school is finger painting and colouring in. (if only, art is being pushed out of the primary curriculum)

Nearly 1 AM in the UK & the only people up posting? You guessed it Teachers !!!

 


Pro USA & Israel

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Apr 17 1.06am

Originally posted by Jimenez

Nearly 1 AM in the UK & the only people up posting? You guessed it Teachers !!!

Sorry that I'm staying up late the night before a bank holiday sir!

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 14 Apr 17 2.26am

Originally posted by nickgusset

Sorry that I'm staying up late the night before a bank holiday sir![/quote


Holiday whats that ? Like I said Teacher.

 


Pro USA & Israel

Hoof Hearted 14 Apr 17 10.37am

Compared to the government interference in financial services being a teacher is a piece of p1ss compared to being an IFA these days.

The compliance regime for an IFA is particularly onerous.

Boohoo teachers are employed in a warm comfortable classroom and paid a good wage with additional benefits like a final salary pension scheme and how many weeks holidays a year do they get?

An IFA is typically self employed and only earns money by continually foraging for clients (and paying for advertising to generate leads with their own money so are out of pocket before they begin) and charging a fee which some clients refuse to pay despite agreeing to it and acting upon the advice. Any pension provision is paid for by himself and holidays as well, because if your not working your not earning. The Regulators insist upon compliance with their terms and conditions which also costs a fortune and is paid for upfront before you are able to earn and any subsequent legislation costs money to comply with as it affects stationery and record keeping. Travel to and from clients houses/offices has to be paid for and accommodation when necessary for Industry training events etc.

I suppose someone will bring up marking homework and extra duties expected of teachers, but even so I doubt they will work only half the hours of an IFA over a year and quite frankly are well remunerated for the easy job they are asked to do.

I'm sure there are more examples of jobs that make a teacher's life look like a cushy number.... let's hear about them too please.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Apr 17 10.52am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Compared to the government interference in financial services being a teacher is a piece of p1ss compared to being an IFA these days.

The compliance regime for an IFA is particularly onerous.

Boohoo teachers are employed in a warm comfortable classroom and paid a good wage with additional benefits like a final salary pension scheme and how many weeks holidays a year do they get?

An IFA is typically self employed and only earns money by continually foraging for clients (and paying for advertising to generate leads with their own money so are out of pocket before they begin) and charging a fee which some clients refuse to pay despite agreeing to it and acting upon the advice. Any pension provision is paid for by himself and holidays as well, because if your not working your not earning. The Regulators insist upon compliance with their terms and conditions which also costs a fortune and is paid for upfront before you are able to earn and any subsequent legislation costs money to comply with as it affects stationery and record keeping. Travel to and from clients houses/offices has to be paid for and accommodation when necessary for Industry training events etc.

I suppose someone will bring up marking homework and extra duties expected of teachers, but even so I doubt they will work only half the hours of an IFA over a year and quite frankly are well remunerated for the easy job they are asked to do.

I'm sure there are more examples of jobs that make a teacher's life look like a cushy number.... let's hear about them too please.

This is about the dept of Education being s***, not s*** job top trumps.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 14 Apr 17 12.25pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Compared to the government interference in financial services being a teacher is a piece of p1ss compared to being an IFA these days.

The compliance regime for an IFA is particularly onerous.

Boohoo teachers are employed in a warm comfortable classroom and paid a good wage with additional benefits like a final salary pension scheme and how many weeks holidays a year do they get?

An IFA is typically self employed and only earns money by continually foraging for clients (and paying for advertising to generate leads with their own money so are out of pocket before they begin) and charging a fee which some clients refuse to pay despite agreeing to it and acting upon the advice. Any pension provision is paid for by himself and holidays as well, because if your not working your not earning. The Regulators insist upon compliance with their terms and conditions which also costs a fortune and is paid for upfront before you are able to earn and any subsequent legislation costs money to comply with as it affects stationery and record keeping. Travel to and from clients houses/offices has to be paid for and accommodation when necessary for Industry training events etc.

I suppose someone will bring up marking homework and extra duties expected of teachers, but even so I doubt they will work only half the hours of an IFA over a year and quite frankly are well remunerated for the easy job they are asked to do.

I'm sure there are more examples of jobs that make a teacher's life look like a cushy number.... let's hear about them too please.

Stop it, Hoof. Guffaw. That is comedy gold

Alan Partridge eat your heart out.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 14 Apr 17 10.05pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Compared to the government interference in financial services being a teacher is a piece of p1ss compared to being an IFA these days.

The compliance regime for an IFA is particularly onerous.

Boohoo teachers are employed in a warm comfortable classroom and paid a good wage with additional benefits like a final salary pension scheme and how many weeks holidays a year do they get?

An IFA is typically self employed and only earns money by continually foraging for clients (and paying for advertising to generate leads with their own money so are out of pocket before they begin) and charging a fee which some clients refuse to pay despite agreeing to it and acting upon the advice. Any pension provision is paid for by himself and holidays as well, because if your not working your not earning. The Regulators insist upon compliance with their terms and conditions which also costs a fortune and is paid for upfront before you are able to earn and any subsequent legislation costs money to comply with as it affects stationery and record keeping. Travel to and from clients houses/offices has to be paid for and accommodation when necessary for Industry training events etc.

I suppose someone will bring up marking homework and extra duties expected of teachers, but even so I doubt they will work only half the hours of an IFA over a year and quite frankly are well remunerated for the easy job they are asked to do.

I'm sure there are more examples of jobs that make a teacher's life look like a cushy number.... let's hear about them too please.

Can't speak for the life of an IFA, but you really don't have a Danny about the life of a teacher.

Have you ever been through an OFSTED for example? Lots of wonderful compliance type stuff to float your boat there.

I have and I'm now very much subject to financial sector regulatory procedures. You might be shocked to learn that compliance is a huge thing in many, many sectors of UK employment.

You are doing little more than playing to your particular gallery. If you're not, then kindly remove your head from your anus before dazzling us with your supposed insights into the teaching profession.

As for the OP, one wonders what the actual purpose of the Education department is. It's arguably the dept. that's most vulnerable to government whims and dogma regardless of the political stripe that government has. Chaos, short termism and focus on narrow measureables prevail at the expense of any sort of strategic vision for where the country is going.

Edited by Mr_Gristle (14 Apr 2017 10.10pm)

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Hoof Hearted 15 Apr 17 11.43am

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Can't speak for the life of an IFA, but you really don't have a Danny about the life of a teacher.

Have you ever been through an OFSTED for example? Lots of wonderful compliance type stuff to float your boat there.

I have and I'm now very much subject to financial sector regulatory procedures. You might be shocked to learn that compliance is a huge thing in many, many sectors of UK employment.

You are doing little more than playing to your particular gallery. If you're not, then kindly remove your head from your anus before dazzling us with your supposed insights into the teaching profession.

As for the OP, one wonders what the actual purpose of the Education department is. It's arguably the dept. that's most vulnerable to government whims and dogma regardless of the political stripe that government has. Chaos, short termism and focus on narrow measureables prevail at the expense of any sort of strategic vision for where the country is going.

Edited by Mr_Gristle (14 Apr 2017 10.10pm)

How many teachers go to work with no pay and have to invest upwards of £10K of their own money to sort out registration, rent an office or have to pay business rates if they work from home then?

NONE... they get paid even if little johnny doesn't pass his exams.

Try being a self employed IFA Mr G.... a teacher's life is a doddle mate.

 

Hoof Hearted 15 Apr 17 11.47am

Originally posted by Kermit8

Stop it, Hoof. Guffaw. That is comedy gold

Alan Partridge eat your heart out.

That's the 2nd thing you've laughed about that I'm aware of today.

Sadly both things are not funny and highlight your ignorance on most matters.

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Is The Department for Education 'Fit for Purpose'?