You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Scott Dann
November 16 2026 9.40am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Scott Dann


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Mstrobez Flag 06 Jul 17 1.08pm

Was discussing this earlier with someone. I've been quite amazed by how many Palace fans seem to think his days with us may be numbered and that Tomkins should be ahead of him in the pecking order.

If we go through last season, Dann and Tomkins were paired together during an absolutely awful time and it was pretty much the first time since he's been with the club that Dann really started putting a foot wrong. I think people forget that during that time Tomkins was poor as well and many wanted him out, as I understand it Dann played a few games injured as well. He then was out with injury, Tomkins stepped in and as the Sam effect started working we inevitably became a more solid unit and Tomkins was very impressive in his contribution. Dann regained fitness and Sam is renowned for not messing with a working system.

It's easy to forget that barring Wilf, Dann has pretty much been our best player since he came in. Bags a few but in my opinion has been a class act defensively as well. I find it mental that all of a sudden he now isn't fancied by quite a few. For me the new CB (Sakho or otherwise) and Dann should be the main pairing with Tomkins and a new younger CB as back up. Surely I'm not the only one who thinks he's a better player than Tomkins?

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 06 Jul 17 1.24pm

Tomkins is now better than Dann.

 


@sxp55555

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 06 Jul 17 1.28pm

Tomkins has proven to be better than Dann. I can see him leaving in January

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Mstrobez Flag 06 Jul 17 1.33pm

Originally posted by dannyh

Tomkins has proven to be better than Dann. I can see him leaving in January

He played in a big Sam system and did well but "proven" to be better than Dann? Fickleness at its finest in my opinion. Dann has been unbelievable for us and Tomkins was as poor if not poorer during the time Dann took his first and only dip in form for the club. Never got his place back after injury but as said that was simply because Sam didn't wanna mess with a working system. Dann is still a better player in nearly every regard for me.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Jul 17 1.34pm

Dann two season ago a better player than Tomkins is now. Dann last season a worse player. Just had an off season has our Scott but if he comes back firing on all cylinders should be one of the first names on the team sheet imo. If not he is deadwood.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Jul 17 1.38pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Dann two season ago a better player than Tomkins is now. Dann last season a worse player. Just had an off season has our Scott but if he comes back firing on all cylinders should be one of the first names on the team sheet imo. If not he is deadwood.

Last year's poorer than normal performance was put down to the burden of captaincy at the time

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 06 Jul 17 1.40pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Last year's poorer than normal performance was put down to the burden of captaincy at the time

Agreed, he needs to be judged with a leader next to him rather than being asked to lead.

Tomkins performed best out of a bad bunch. And was lucky enough Dann was injured when Sakho arrived. Sakho would make anyone else next to him shine.

Jury is out on whose best.

Fact is neither can lead the line!

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 06 Jul 17 1.42pm

Dann, if stays should lose captaincy but I would be against selling him and getting Sakho and someone like joe Gomez of Liverpool (local lad- born in catford) as 3rd choice and Kelly as 4th choice.

Edited by Dan89 (06 Jul 2017 1.46pm)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Jul 17 1.43pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Last year's poorer than normal performance was put down to the burden of captaincy at the time

I don't go with that theory as he is/was a very assertive vocal player anyway and being captain should be an honour. Maybe the fire in his belly has gone. We shall see.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 06 Jul 17 1.50pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Was discussing this earlier with someone. I've been quite amazed by how many Palace fans seem to think his days with us may be numbered and that Tomkins should be ahead of him in the pecking order.

If we go through last season, Dann and Tomkins were paired together during an absolutely awful time and it was pretty much the first time since he's been with the club that Dann really started putting a foot wrong. I think people forget that during that time Tomkins was poor as well and many wanted him out, as I understand it Dann played a few games injured as well. He then was out with injury, Tomkins stepped in and as the Sam effect started working we inevitably became a more solid unit and Tomkins was very impressive in his contribution. Dann regained fitness and Sam is renowned for not messing with a working system.

It's easy to forget that barring Wilf, Dann has pretty much been our best player since he came in. Bags a few but in my opinion has been a class act defensively as well. I find it mental that all of a sudden he now isn't fancied by quite a few. For me the new CB (Sakho or otherwise) and Dann should be the main pairing with Tomkins and a new younger CB as back up. Surely I'm not the only one who thinks he's a better player than Tomkins?

Not quite true .
Sam signed the 4 new players,and for the Boro game he dropped Dann and Jimmy Mac.
Sakho took Danns spot.
In effect Luka replaced Jimmy.
Sakho was partnered with Tompkins.
If Sakho or AN Other do not sign I am sure Scott will get back in the 11.
Jimmy Mac will be on the bench.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Jul 17 1.52pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

I don't go with that theory as he is/was a very assertive vocal player anyway and being captain should be an honour. Maybe the fire in his belly has gone. We shall see.

I didn't go along with it either for the same reason as you but the burden of captaincy did seem to be the generally held view on this forum for his lack of form

 

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 06 Jul 17 1.54pm

We need depth and 3 good CBs. Why sell Dann?

 


La la la your mum

npn Flag Crowborough 06 Jul 17 2.00pm

I thought he was comparatively poor last season, but that doesn't mean he's finished. He was our backbone prior to that, and I'me sure he can be again. Playing with proven players like Sakho and/or Tomkins should help with that.

He'll be back!

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 06 Jul 17 2.05pm

Fact is Sakho made Kelly look half decent and I'm still convinced that was down to Sakho. Tompkins went from looking average to quality next to Sakho and Dann never got a chance to spend any decent time playing next to Sakho. The common denominator is that our struggling CBs looked class next to Sakho, so when it comes to first choice pairing, I'm not too fussed who gets the nod as long as one of them is a top quality CB we buy, Sakho or someone else.

Also I'm sure at times we will play 3 at the back so they will all get their chance. As well as that, the injury record of our squad suggests that cover is going to be needed. I doubt we will see 1 player sitting on the bench all season, and I think the gulf in class between the two of them is very narrow, we will see both.

 

Mstrobez Flag 06 Jul 17 2.26pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Not quite true .
Sam signed the 4 new players,and for the Boro game he dropped Dann and Jimmy Mac.
Sakho took Danns spot.
In effect Luka replaced Jimmy.
Sakho was partnered with Tompkins.
If Sakho or AN Other do not sign I am sure Scott will get back in the 11.
Jimmy Mac will be on the bench.

Dann had only played in the prior game due to having no other options and was essentially playing through a knock if I remember correctly.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 06 Jul 17 2.28pm

no one can deny that Dann had a big wobble last season but he shouldn't be written off. If we get one very good CB in, a Sakho or similar, that takes pressure off of Dann and Tomkins, means they perform better, concentrate on their game rather than bossing the back line, and we have a solid CB trio to call upon i.e. our new guy and one of Dann/Tomkins

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 06 Jul 17 2.30pm

I think Dann at his best is better than Tomkins at his best. If he gets over his injury properly and has a full pre-season under a proper coach, hopefully we'll have an amazing defender back.

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 06 Jul 17 2.38pm

There's always a goal threat when Dann's on the pitch. Tomkin's missed some sitters.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 06 Jul 17 2.48pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

There's always a goal threat when Dann's on the pitch. Tomkin's missed some sitters.

There was always a goal threat, when Leon Cort was on the pitch. Scott dann 30, if we do bring in Sakho, we need a younger cb aswell.

Edited by Dan89 (06 Jul 2017 2.48pm)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 06 Jul 17 2.48pm

Originally posted by dannyh

Tomkins has proven to be better than Dann. I can see him leaving in January

Why?

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Scott Dann