This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Time to say goodbye to Speroni (LOCKED)
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
deetee 28 Dec 17 11.44pm |
|
|
He has served us well but like Hennessey is not a premiership keeper. In fact I prefer Hennessey, Jules was slow to both Sanchez shots and is not dominating enough in the air. I say play Wayne until we buy someone better.
|
Tyrelli London 28 Dec 17 11.50pm |
|
|
The guy is the best GK we have ever had since he joined .. He’s my first choice and is way better than a lot of Prem keepers out there, I stand by him .. he is a rock
Edited by Tyrelli (28 Dec 2017 11.52pm)
Edited by Tyrelli (28 Dec 2017 11.52pm)
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 28 Dec 17 11.58pm |
|
|
We've said goodbye to two younger keepers who've proven not good enough to replace him and Hennessey is heading towards the same group despite a significant age and height advantage.
|
dynamicdick Dormansland 29 Dec 17 12.00am |
|
Originally posted by deetee
He has served us well but like Hennessey is not a premiership keeper. In fact I prefer Hennessey, Jules was slow to both Sanchez shots and is not dominating enough in the air. I say play Wayne until we buy someone better.
Why not direct your criticism at that useless lump of c--p masquerading as our centre forward instead of someone who gives 100% and to be honest didn't get a great deal of help from his defence tonight.
Bring back Brolin
|
EagleEssex Essex 29 Dec 17 12.02am |
|
|
Way too harsh. Speroni wasnt at fault tonight and he made a very good save.
I was thinking to myself, if Hennessey had been in goal he would have been slated on here for Arsenal's second and third goal.
I think some on here have an ultra idealistic view of what keepers should be doing for us, they cant perform miracles every save. Goals can and do get scored, theres a reason strikers cost more than any other player.
We've got two solid PL standard keepers and Waynes waiting in the wings, theres not much difference between the two. If we can get a world class keeper in the Jan transfer window, great, if not we will do ok with the two we have.
|
MKCPFC Spain/MK 29 Dec 17 12.16am |
|
Originally posted by deetee
He has served us well but like Hennessey is not a premiership keeper. In fact I prefer Hennessey, Jules was slow to both Sanchez shots and is not dominating enough in the air. I say play Wayne until we buy someone better.
100 per cent correct.
|
Headbert Mitcham 29 Dec 17 12.35am |
|
Originally posted by deetee
He has served us well but like Hennessey is not a premiership keeper. In fact I prefer Hennessey, Jules was slow to both Sanchez shots and is not dominating enough in the air. I say play Wayne until we buy someone better.
I think you are wrong. Speroni is a very good PL keeper. He saved at least 3 today. His rating would be a 7 today. I don't think most PL players would have got a touch to some of the shots today, including Hennessey, who is not better than Speroni, according to the stats and Roy. I would go as far as to stick with Speroni even if we buy a new keeper in January, and Hennessey would lose his place on the bench! It's hard to make people 'get it' sometimes, even when you show them the numbers...
|
merganser 29 Dec 17 12.38am |
|
|
I think he’s been doing OK since his first-team recall. He was no worse than the Arsenal fellow tonight. There are only five or six Premier keepers playing better than Jules.
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 29 Dec 17 1.36am |
|
|
at least 2 of the arsenal goals were extremely difficult to stop and maybe unstoppable.
3 goals conceded and yet still i believe speroni is our best option. Put hennessey into the goal tonight and our goal difference would be down another five or six goals....and Wales are out of the world cup.
Benteke was the waste of space. Speroni is the man until we sign somebody proven good.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
CockneyRebel West Harrison,NY. 29 Dec 17 2.06am |
|
|
Give me a friggin break... The longer we keep Jules the better..cannot be put at fault for tonight. end..
Here since 81...(LAST CENTURY !!).. x-Dunraven School, early 1960.... Palace 'nut' since 58....
|
kenbarr Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 29 Dec 17 4.00am |
|
|
Jules is not to blame for the timid display in the first half. Sanchez is quality and he can score on any PL keeper, including the "sainted" De Gea. I missed the 2nd half but from all I've read and heard Palace put in a much better performance than the first. Unless a better keeper can be brought in, for the moment Jules should be the first choice. What is needed is more performances like the one at Leicester.
Divorced...And LOVING it! VJRAM Rev. CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach Trevor Francis, International PRAT
|
mogrem 29 Dec 17 4.09am |
|
Originally posted by deetee
He has served us well but like Hennessey is not a premiership keeper. In fact I prefer Hennessey, Jules was slow to both Sanchez shots and is not dominating enough in the air. I say play Wayne until we buy someone better.
I have no idea why you blame Speroni for this, Arsenal played really well, best I have seen them this season and we still had as much chances as they had. Zaha's header (of his shoulder) should have been a clear goal. No matter what goalie we had tonight they would have scored 3.
|
Aray South London 29 Dec 17 7.04am |
|
Originally posted by deetee
He has served us well but like Hennessey is not a premiership keeper. In fact I prefer Hennessey, Jules was slow to both Sanchez shots and is not dominating enough in the air. I say play Wayne until we buy someone better.
Sorry mate but not seen you post before - do you go to the games? I admit there was once situation last night when I thought- "keepers" and Jules never came for it but Hennessy was awful in this respect- always rooted to his line when I watched. And a poor shot stopper- I thought Jules kept us in the game. I would be shocked if he doesn't start vs City.
|
BarEagle Monmouth 29 Dec 17 7.33am |
|
Originally posted by Aray
Sorry mate but not seen you post before - do you go to the games? I admit there was once situation last night when I thought- "keepers" and Jules never came for it but Hennessy was awful in this respect- always rooted to his line when I watched. And a poor shot stopper- I thought Jules kept us in the game. I would be shocked if he doesn't start vs City.
I thought Jules played well and kept us in the game.
First goal was Kelly's fault; he is becoming a real weak link unfortunately. One of the other goals came from between Tomkins legs and Jules still got his fingers to it. I thought he played well and kept us in the game.
|
Goal Machine The Cronx 29 Dec 17 7.37am |
|
|
I think the OP is right sadly.
Club legend, love the man. Would probably one day name my son after him but not quite up to it anymore. Don’t think he was at fault for any of the goals but could have done better. At the moment I prefer him to Hennessey.
It’s vital we sign a keeper in Jan.
|
BelfastEagle 29 Dec 17 8.18am |
|
|
Speroni is only playing because we failed to sign anybody else....simple as that.
|
The Dolphin 29 Dec 17 8.46am |
|
|
He is a good keeper but he hesitated big time for their third goal in my opinion. Can you blame him - tough one that - would a bigger more confident man have moved forward quicker - probably. Will we sign a better replacement - remains to be seen. Is he beter than WH - head and shoulders!!
|
Aj's_Magic_Hat Las Palmas 29 Dec 17 9.08am |
|
|
Honestly?? We all know why he is playing, buut last night first goal was a crap clearance by Schlupp and poor marking by Kelly, the second was a shocking clearance by Benteke. Jules kept us in the game last night. We need a new keeper everyone at the club knows that but come you cant knock Jule's performance last night
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Dec 17 9.29am |
|
|
[quote=Aj's_Magic_Hat;3287450]
Honestly?? We all know why he is playing, buut last night first goal was a crap clearance by Schlupp and poor marking by Kelly, the second was a shocking clearance by Benteke. Jules kept us in the game last night. We need a new keeper everyone at the club knows that but come you cant knock Jule's performance last night
This is very much my thinking. I really cannot opportune blame on Speroni for last night's goals. Bad clearances,bad marking and bad defending resulted in the goals. All round disappointing performance.
Edited by Willo (29 Dec 2017 9.30am)
|
Mapletree Croydon 29 Dec 17 10.06am |
|
Originally posted by Willo
This is very much my thinking. I really cannot opportune blame on Speroni for last night's goals. Bad clearances,bad marking and bad defending resulted in the goals. All round disappointing performance.
Edited by Willo (29 Dec 2017 9.30am)
Apportion?
|