You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew v Hodgson
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pardew v Hodgson


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 04 Apr 19 10.34am

Why is Hodgson better than Pardew, both never won anything worth winning, both been sacked regularly, Pardew gung ho, Hodgson ultra defensive,
Pardew Pl 87-w35-d13-l39 40.2%.
Hodgson Pl 76-w27-d17-l32 35.5%.
Hodgson with better players, who is better?

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

KAOS Flag In a tree 04 Apr 19 11.24am

Some very interesting stats TBF!

Bet Roy's a better dancer tho ...

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 04 Apr 19 12.11pm

Pardew's first year in charge was excellent, but eventually showed that he had no idea how to organise a team. We were an absolute shambles towards the end, especially defensively.

Hodgson has the opposite problem - overly rigid, inflexible, and cautious. Still, given a choice between the two, Hodgson will get you just enough to stay up whereas with Pardew it's a complete gamble.

 

JohnB Flag 04 Apr 19 12.22pm

Erm we do remember 2016 where we were officially the worst team of all 92 clubs in terms of points per game. right?

Hodgson teams might be a bit dull to watch but we are consistent and given the miracle he pulled off last season after FDB, he deserves more respect.

He's not exactly been backed in the market since he came here compared to most of our other managers. He's had a couple of decent loan players and a few signings.

Allardyce, Pards even Pulis were backed far heavier than he has been.

The one I would have loved to have seen stay as I think he would have really stabilised us was Allardyce. I think he knew he wouldn't be backed and walked out on a high.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 04 Apr 19 12.46pm

The manager is always secondary to the players in terms of performance.
The fact is that we have not spent enough money in the last two windows and we have gone backward. Our squad is flimsy as shown when we lose Sakho.

It always puzzles me why fans always blame the manager when the truth is so easy to see.

Hodgson does tend to play the negative game against the top teams but that is realism I suppose. He knows that our best chance to get something from those games is to play it tight and hope for a lucky break. When that fails, it looks awful like against Spurs and Chelsea but when it works like against City, it looks like a masterstroke.

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 04 Apr 19 12.54pm

I can’t really see us being involved for too long in a relegation scrap with Roy, I could with Pardew

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Apr 19 1.06pm

Originally posted by JohnB

Erm we do remember 2016 where we were officially the worst team of all 92 clubs in terms of points per game. right?

Hodgson teams might be a bit dull to watch but we are consistent and given the miracle he pulled off last season after FDB, he deserves more respect.

He's not exactly been backed in the market since he came here compared to most of our other managers. He's had a couple of decent loan players and a few signings.

Allardyce, Pards even Pulis were backed far heavier than he has been.

The one I would have loved to have seen stay as I think he would have really stabilised us was Allardyce. I think he knew he wouldn't be backed and walked out on a high.

Hodgson’s football is very dull but the lack of backing is true. In fact it’s even worse to the point of no strikers etc and signing players for business decisions or hopes who he probably doesn’t want or was asked about. This is a concern if we ended his contract without a quality planned replacement.

Last season he was blessed with RLC and it hid some of Roy’s limitations even though the results were very good before RLC became a regular. A bit of new manager effect and getting 100% out of 11 players every single minute of every game as well.

 


COYP

jeeagles Flag 04 Apr 19 1.16pm

Pardew had a harder job than Roy in his first season in that he took over later and had worse player.

In his second season we were safe by Christmas then he focused on the cup.

In his 3rd season, he ran out of ideas, as all these average managers do. BFS got a huge transfer kitty to replace him.

In his last few games we were going gung-ho partly because we had no defense. The players were still showing effort and commitment and at least there were goals and excitement.

Fans at Newcastle hated him because he was part of the "Cockney mafia". I spoken to some staff at Newcastle and they all really liked him and said he was an excellent people manager, shame about the tactics.

Roy isn't even going for it. Fans and Players alike look fed up.

 

RickEveleigh Flag Little Kimble, nr Aylesbury 04 Apr 19 1.16pm

Spending more money isn't always the answer: look at Fulham.

Yes we haven't kicked on but both times we tried it (Pardew 2nd season, then FDB) it didn't go well.

Be careful what you wish for cf. Charlton.

Since we came up all these teams have gone down:
Burnley
Cardiff
Fulham
Hull (twice)
Middlesbrough
Newcastle
Norwich (twice)
QPR
Stoke
Sunderland (double relegation)
Swansea
Villa
WBA

Southampton came 8th in 13/14, 7th in 14/15, 6th in 15/16, 8th in 16/17 and then nearly went down twice. Wet Spam keep struggling. Everton can't kick on. Chelsea came 10th in 15/16!

While of course I want us to improve I'd rather we're like we are than being in the Championship or worse: Leeds & Forest have both been in League 1 and neither have come up in the last 6 seasons.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 04 Apr 19 1.42pm

Originally posted by RickEveleigh

Spending more money isn't always the answer: look at Fulham.

Yes we haven't kicked on but both times we tried it (Pardew 2nd season, then FDB) it didn't go well.

Be careful what you wish for cf. Charlton.

Since we came up all these teams have gone down:
Burnley
Cardiff
Fulham
Hull (twice)
Middlesbrough
Newcastle
Norwich (twice)
QPR
Stoke
Sunderland (double relegation)
Swansea
Villa
WBA

Southampton came 8th in 13/14, 7th in 14/15, 6th in 15/16, 8th in 16/17 and then nearly went down twice. Wet Spam keep struggling. Everton can't kick on. Chelsea came 10th in 15/16!

While of course I want us to improve I'd rather we're like we are than being in the Championship or worse: Leeds & Forest have both been in League 1 and neither have come up in the last 6 seasons.

What you say has a lot of truth, but, I do feel that we can't go on as we are as we will be joining those relegated teams that you have listed. We have a place in the Premier League and, within reason, should do all we can to preserve that place.

The club has to try to find some way to progress - that may entail a new manager, new coaching staff, different tactics or some clever spending in the transfer market, but I fear that if we carry on going back to square one each year, and not building on the previous season, our luck will eventually run out.

Of course there are risks involved with change as we
found out with De Boer, but there are also risks involved with just playing safe as you end up standing still and being overtaken by other teams.

 

Tipp_Eagle Flag Tipperary 04 Apr 19 8.33pm

Any stats on big sam or tony pulis ?

 


oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 04 Apr 19 9.37pm

Pulis Pl28-w12-d5-l11 42.86%
Sam Pl24-w9-d3-l12 37.5%

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 04 Apr 19 10.00pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Why is Hodgson better than Pardew, both never won anything worth winning, both been sacked regularly, Pardew gung ho, Hodgson ultra defensive,
Pardew Pl 87-w35-d13-l39 40.2%.
Hodgson Pl 76-w27-d17-l32 35.5%.
Hodgson with better players, who is better?

Try doing that with league results.

Pardew: p73 88pts ppg = 1.20. W34.2% L47.9%
Roy: p66 80pts ppg = 1.21. W31.8% L42.4%

Roy’s lost players, has had pretty much no money to spend, and inherited a team bereft of form, confidence, and had a huge injury crisis to deal with. He’s had no striker fit for the purpose either.

Pardew got to spend a fair amount of money, and had inherited a functional team with a lot of fight: which by the time he left was ruined and unfit.

Sam: p21 26pts ppg = 1.24.
Pulis: p26 38pts ppg = 1.46.

Sam got a bunch of money to spend, and results only truly improved when Sahko was in the team.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Apr 19 11.18am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The manager is always secondary to the players in terms of performance.
The fact is that we have not spent enough money in the last two windows and we have gone backward. Our squad is flimsy as shown when we lose Sakho.

It always puzzles me why fans always blame the manager when the truth is so easy to see.

Hodgson does tend to play the negative game against the top teams but that is realism I suppose. He knows that our best chance to get something from those games is to play it tight and hope for a lucky break. When that fails, it looks awful like against Spurs and Chelsea but when it works like against City, it looks like a masterstroke.

It is very irritating.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Apr 19 11.25am

Originally posted by NickinOX

Try doing that with league results.

Pardew: p73 88pts ppg = 1.20. W34.2% L47.9%
Roy: p66 80pts ppg = 1.21. W31.8% L42.4%

Roy’s lost players, has had pretty much no money to spend, and inherited a team bereft of form, confidence, and had a huge injury crisis to deal with. He’s had no striker fit for the purpose either.

Pardew got to spend a fair amount of money, and had inherited a functional team with a lot of fight: which by the time he left was ruined and unfit.

Sam: p21 26pts ppg = 1.24.
Pulis: p26 38pts ppg = 1.46.

Sam got a bunch of money to spend, and results only truly improved when Sahko was in the team.


Pardew achieved much excitement, this must not be overlooked ..for both sets of fans in almost every game lol

Edited by Tickled pink (05 Apr 2019 11.27am)

 

xomnea Flag 05 Apr 19 12.25pm

Players win you games, managers lose them. During the dreadful Pardew run I could not believe the amount of individual errors/missed chances that were costing us.
Rarely do I walk away from a win and go, ‘Roy Hodgson was excellent today.’

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 05 Apr 19 9.44pm

Pardew did brilliantly for a while and commanded a level of respect. The signing of Cabaye at a decent price was also big step for the club but he seems all over the place in terms of his personality and ability to maintain trust and respect. Roy is different class by comparison.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 06 Apr 19 1.00am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Why is Hodgson better than Pardew, both never won anything worth winning, both been sacked regularly, Pardew gung ho, Hodgson ultra defensive,
Pardew Pl 87-w35-d13-l39 40.2%.
Hodgson Pl 76-w27-d17-l32 35.5%.
Hodgson with better players, who is better?

the stats don't show the bigger picture or can be tilted either way, what i mean by that is, whilst Roy is lower, i feel safer in Roy's hands (ohh lovely) and Pardew has amazing spells followed by crap spells. I dunno, it's an interesting debate, i think it boils down to - would we accept a swap of Roy for Pards, i can imagine a lot of us would say no!

I think if Pardew was able to keep Cabaye as the bench mark and we didn't need to break the bank for benteke then later Sako, i feel he jsut jumped the shark a bit and it damaged us, parish was to blame too.

A decent scouting network should have been #1 priority in 2014, that's our first mistake really.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Maine Eagle Flag USA 06 Apr 19 3.28am

Chalk and cheese.

Totally different people, and football managers.

Pardew is too far down one road, while Roy is too far down the other.

You need some of Pardew like having some guts, having a go at teams, and taking the shackles off.....

But you want a bit of Roy in there, solid shape when out of possession and well drilled.

You need to strike a balance. If we could strike that balance we could be much higher up the league table, and approaching an FA cup semi final.

You know what both are s*** at though? Coming up with a plan b when plan a isn’t working out, during a game.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 06 Apr 19 2.50pm

Pardew ripped the heart out of our team. He had no idea about sensible subs. And he lost every single game for about two years.
Huge difference between him and Roy. I've only just about recovered from Pardew.

One of those is an exaggeration...

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew v Hodgson