You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What if Allardyce hadn't left?
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What if Allardyce hadn't left?


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
efernandez060604 Flag London 08 Jun 19 2.21pm

What do you think would happen with us if Allardyce didn't snake out on us?

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 08 Jun 19 2.26pm

Originally posted by efernandez060604

What do you think would happen with us if Allardyce didn't snake out on us?

We would still be playing with a 10 man defence and boring the pants off our fans.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 08 Jun 19 3.32pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

We would still be playing with a 10 man defence and boring the pants off our fans.

As opposed to...

 

JohnB Flag 08 Jun 19 3.49pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

We would still be playing with a 10 man defence and boring the pants off our fans.

I thought we played some of our best football under Allardyce. We played Arsenal off the park in a 3-0 win, beat Liverpool 2-1 at Anfield, beat Chelsea 2-1.

He spent a fair bit of money but I think the majority of his signings have been a success and still doing it for us today.

He was the best manager for getting the best out of Benteke. I'd have him back in a heartbeat if he was committed to staying at the club for a more longterm project.

I also think his repuatation of defensive hoofball is unfair when you think back to teams like his Bolton team of JayJay, Campo, Djorkaeff etc. where they played some great football at times.

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 08 Jun 19 4.25pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

As opposed to...

Having one of our most comfortable seasons in the Premiership with a healthy points total.

 

davehuggins Flag 08 Jun 19 4.31pm

For me SA was a good acquisition at the time, he kept us up and bought some very decent players. I am an RH fan and like the way we play now, feel confident with him in charge but Sam I would have back if he would commit.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 08 Jun 19 4.33pm

For whatever reason he didn't want to stay with us. Like Pulis, Pardew and Hodgson he got us out of a hole. Aside from Bolton every club he's managed the fans seem to get fed up with him sooner or later. I think that speaks volumes. He's gone and personally I'm not bothered.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 08 Jun 19 5.11pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

Having one of our most comfortable seasons in the Premiership with a healthy points total.

Not sure about the most comfortable bit, but ok. You keep deluding yourself.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 08 Jun 19 6.47pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

Having one of our most comfortable seasons in the Premiership with a healthy points total.

Eventually!!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 08 Jun 19 6.51pm

Originally posted by JohnB

I thought we played some of our best football under Allardyce. We played Arsenal off the park in a 3-0 win, beat Liverpool 2-1 at Anfield, beat Chelsea 2-1.

He spent a fair bit of money but I think the majority of his signings have been a success and still doing it for us today.

He was the best manager for getting the best out of Benteke. I'd have him back in a heartbeat if he was committed to staying at the club for a more longterm project.

I also think his repuatation of defensive hoofball is unfair when you think back to teams like his Bolton team of JayJay, Campo, Djorkaeff etc. where they played some great football at times.

Good post, agree 100%. He has been getting grief for comments made on Talksport about England, when he said you shouldn't play out from the back all the time. Totally agree with him doesn't make him a dinosaur. Would have a committed SA back (I am not having a go at Roy here)

 

Palace 1979 Flag Surrey 08 Jun 19 7.12pm

I would like him and his scouting team to become part of our scouting network as he certainly bought in some good players. I didn't think the football was anywhere near as bad as under Pulis and tactically he is very astute. However, I am happy with how we play now compared to these two.

 


Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.

rikz Flag Croydon 08 Jun 19 8.13pm

Tbf to pulis, he inherited a terrible squad and was pretty much a miracle keeping us up our first season in the prem.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 09 Jun 19 8.52am

Originally posted by JohnB

I thought we played some of our best football under Allardyce. We played Arsenal off the park in a 3-0 win, beat Liverpool 2-1 at Anfield, beat Chelsea 2-1.

He spent a fair bit of money but I think the majority of his signings have been a success and still doing it for us today.

He was the best manager for getting the best out of Benteke. I'd have him back in a heartbeat if he was committed to staying at the club for a more longterm project.

I also think his repuatation of defensive hoofball is unfair when you think back to teams like his Bolton team of JayJay, Campo, Djorkaeff etc. where they played some great football at times.

Ha didn't spend a red cent. Those players were bought by the club.

Agree your point re benteke.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 09 Jun 19 11.01am

we saw with both Pulis and Sam that their perceived image is way off the reality, both have used direct football when it was the most workable option but their decisions re tactics and personnel with us showed their astuteness and sophistication as coaches - Everton fans were grossly unfair to Sam, was at Goodison when his Everton played us off the park last season (we had RLC and Wilf missing tbf), Freedman was off the mark when he described West Ham's football as 'long ball' when Sam was in charge there - Sam got the funds to keep us up, the fact that he knew there wouldn't be much more money coming was no doubt a big part of his decision to leave regardless of his relationship with Parrish, if he were still here I think we'd be in roughly the same place, maybe a place or two higher but it's irrelevant to speculate because we would have quite a different squad, I don't think Jimmy Mac would still be here for example.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 09 Jun 19 2.18pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

we saw with both Pulis and Sam that their perceived image is way off the reality, both have used direct football when it was the most workable option but their decisions re tactics and personnel with us showed their astuteness and sophistication as coaches - Everton fans were grossly unfair to Sam, was at Goodison when his Everton played us off the park last season (we had RLC and Wilf missing tbf), Freedman was off the mark when he described West Ham's football as 'long ball' when Sam was in charge there - Sam got the funds to keep us up, the fact that he knew there wouldn't be much more money coming was no doubt a big part of his decision to leave regardless of his relationship with Parrish, if he were still here I think we'd be in roughly the same place, maybe a place or two higher but it's irrelevant to speculate because we would have quite a different squad, I don't think Jimmy Mac would still be here for example.

Great post. The job Pulis did for us is underrated in the football world. He performed a miracle. It was a shame he got all c***y afterwards, but fair play to Parish for sorting it out and getting the money back. Big Sam did play backs to the wall, long ball football at times, but he also played some of the best football I've seen from us. He made tactical subs, maximised what was available and set the team up to suit the opposition. All things Hodgson could take note of.

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 09 Jun 19 4.11pm

When Roy decides to retire I'd be entirely happy if Sam wanted to come back. Unlike Pulis, who although he did a remarkable job he did leave under an unforgivable cloud...


Edited by Sansbup (09 Jun 2019 4.15pm)

 

Painter Flag Croydon 09 Jun 19 4.35pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

When Roy decides to retire I'd be entirely happy if Sam wanted to come back. Unlike Pulis, who although he did a remarkable job he did leave under an unforgivable cloud...


Edited by Sansbup (09 Jun 2019 4.15pm)

Allardyce, Bruce and Dowie are all exactly the same as Pulis. Two bob chancers who took the piss out of us as a club and thought the grass was greener elsewhere and lied to get out of their contracts. I don't care how good a manager any of them are, even if we were in dire straits nearing relegation, Palace would lose any credibility it has, if any of them were considered by the club.
It may be an old fashioned view, but morally devoid individuals don't warrant a second chance.

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 09 Jun 19 5.02pm

J

Originally posted by Painter

Allardyce, Bruce and Dowie are all exactly the same as Pulis. Two bob chancers who took the piss out of us as a club and thought the grass was greener elsewhere and lied to get out of their contracts. I don't care how good a manager any of them are, even if we were in dire straits nearing relegation, Palace would lose any credibility it has, if any of them were considered by the club.
It may be an old fashioned view, but morally devoid individuals don't warrant a second chance.

Agreed

 

gloryhunter Flag EDINBURGH 09 Jun 19 5.10pm

Originally posted by Painter

Allardyce, Bruce and Dowie are all exactly the same as Pulis. Two bob chancers who took the piss out of us as a club and thought the grass was greener elsewhere and lied to get out of their contracts. I don't care how good a manager any of them are, even if we were in dire straits nearing relegation, Palace would lose any credibility it has, if any of them were considered by the club.
It may be an old fashioned view, but morally devoid individuals don't warrant a second chance.

My initial kneejerk reaction to your post was to jump all over it. I took a deep breath, gave it some thought and read it again and have to say I agree with your take on this topic.

Edited by gloryhunter (09 Jun 2019 5.10pm)

 


gloryhunter (eagle in exile)

efernandez060604 Flag London 09 Jun 19 8.07pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

When Roy decides to retire I'd be entirely happy if Sam wanted to come back. Unlike Pulis, who although he did a remarkable job he did leave under an unforgivable cloud...


Edited by Sansbup (09 Jun 2019 4.15pm)

Yh f***ing mug trying to stiff us.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What if Allardyce hadn't left?