This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
I'm not sure I'm right to start this thread and I'm even less sure about how to explain what's behind it. Firstly, let me say that HOL is my only online interaction. I have no interest or involvement in Facebook, Twitter or any other social media so I have no personal experience. But, from what I see and hear these sites are a breeding ground for venomous hatred and malicious gossip carried out by folk who seem to have nothing better to do than sling vile abuse at other people they don't know whilst remaining anonymous. What troubles me though, is how much of this abuse aimed at black folk is deemed to be racist when colour may not really be the issue. I was struck, in particular by the incident in the Man Utd/Leicester game at the weekend when Fred made a sloppy back pass and let Iheanacho in to score for Leicester. Perhaps unsurprisingly, he received a fair amount of stick for that. He claims it was racist. Was it racist though? I shouted 'you idiot!' at him through my TV. Not because of the colour of his skin, but because he made a silly mistake. It happens. What if Maguire had done that I wondered? Would I have yelled at him? You bet I would. There's been a fair amount of abuse thrown at our own people on here, even the manager sparks furious debate. I don't like to see it, but there isn't much said if criticism is made of a Welsh goalkeeper for instance. What if he was black? Would that criticism be automatically considered racist? At this point I should say I do not consider myself racist. I have worked with people from a wide range of ethnic backgrounds in various countries and always had good relationships with them. In fact, I went out with a black girl from Croydon in the late sixties for a while, but that's another story. I wholeheartedly support Wilf in standing up against racism. The kneeling thing has lost it's impact now, standing says a lot more. Racism is wrong which ever way you look at it, but that's not the only reason behind online criticism. Some of the online comments we all read about almost every day are just plain awful, but when it's a person from an ethnic background on the receiving end it's not necessarily racist. Or is it? It never had any in the first place. This is a long winded way of asking if Black people play the race card for their own benefit. Of course they do.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
There's truth to what you say in that things can be deemed racist that clearly aren't. Of course, the other side of that coin is that numerous players have been targeted on social media with racial slurs of late, so it's a mixed picture, which the latter clearly being racist. I would like to think such individuals are a distinct minority though. And we have automatically accepted that a racial slur is worse than another slur. It is part of the indoctrination. It is blamed on 'history'. Very selective history. People get offended by all sorts. On what basis can one say that one form of insult is more hurtful than another? Do we now decide these things based on who complains the most? Or who causes the most disorder? We all face prejudice of one sort or another, and I'm sure everyone has been purposefully antagonized by some moron to get a reaction at some point. Apparently, if you are a certain colour, it means that the whole White nation has to take notice and accept collective responsibility every time it happens. It's a joke.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
And we have automatically accepted that a racial slur is worse than another slur. It is part of the indoctrination. It is blamed on 'history'. Very selective history. People get offended by all sorts. On what basis can one say that one form of insult is more hurtful than another? Do we now decide these things based on who complains the most? Or who causes the most disorder? We all face prejudice of one sort or another, and I'm sure everyone has been purposefully antagonized by some moron to get a reaction at some point. Apparently, if you are a certain colour, it means that the whole White nation has to take notice and accept collective responsibility every time it happens. It's a joke. But it’s not just words that are the problem is it? It’s attitudes and prejudices that mean that others are not afforded the same as others. You’re right that there shouldn’t be some sort of hierarchy of abuse - no abuse is nice - but you’re wrong to discount having to look to history. Black people have been subservient to white people throughout history and that attitude still commonly exists that white people are superior to black people. Even if you don’t personally hold that attitude it is obvious that it is still prevalent. Same as women being subservient to men. There are still a lot of blokes that think that they should hold the power over a woman.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
And we have automatically accepted that a racial slur is worse than another slur. It is part of the indoctrination. It is blamed on 'history'. Very selective history. People get offended by all sorts. On what basis can one say that one form of insult is more hurtful than another? Do we now decide these things based on who complains the most? Or who causes the most disorder? We all face prejudice of one sort or another, and I'm sure everyone has been purposefully antagonized by some moron to get a reaction at some point. Apparently, if you are a certain colour, it means that the whole White nation has to take notice and accept collective responsibility every time it happens. It's a joke. Yes, racism is a one way street. Is it fvck.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
But it’s not just words that are the problem is it? It’s attitudes and prejudices that mean that others are not afforded the same as others. You’re right that there shouldn’t be some sort of hierarchy of abuse - no abuse is nice - but you’re wrong to discount having to look to history. Black people have been subservient to white people throughout history and that attitude still commonly exists that white people are superior to black people. Even if you don’t personally hold that attitude it is obvious that it is still prevalent. Same as women being subservient to men. There are still a lot of blokes that think that they should hold the power over a woman. How do you know? How much history do you know about? You are choosing the bits you like. A small bit of History involving the African slave trade. How much longer can we use that as an excuse?
|
|
|
Originally posted by madcap_v2
A simple answer to this would be, if you called me a c***, you may be right, may be wrong (probably right), but that's subject to your opinion. If you called me a black c***, you've attached race to it and it can be interpretted as racism. If the abuse Fred received was directed at his race and not him being a dogs*** footballer, then there is valid claim to racism. Yes, that’s true but still doesn’t explain why the racial element automatically makes it a far more serious situation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by madcap_v2
A simple answer to this would be, if you called me a c***, you may be right, may be wrong (probably right), but that's subject to your opinion. If you called me a black c***, you've attached race to it and it can be interpretted as racism. If the abuse Fred received was directed at his race and not him being a dogs*** footballer, then there is valid claim to racism. The whole point of antagonism is to antagonise. If you know that a racial slur is effective, then any dopey teenager online is going to use it to get a response. It's not rocket science. By using the term racism constantly, all people have done is cheapened and diluted the meaning. The holocaust. That was racism in the broad sense, since Jews are not a race, but they were an identifiable group. Calling people names? Give me a break.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The whole point of antagonism is to antagonise. If you know that a racial slur is effective, then any dopey teenager online is going to use it to get a response. It's not rocket science. By using the term racism constantly, all people have done is cheapened and diluted the meaning. The holocaust. That was racism in the broad sense, since Jews are not a race, but they were an identifiable group. Calling people names? Give me a break. I was answering in the context of the original post, dear.
La la la your mum |
|
|
Originally posted by madcap_v2
I was answering in the context of the original post, dear. Yeah, but the subject needs expanding....darling.
|
|
|
Originally posted by madcap_v2
I was answering in the context of the original post, dear. But did it involve a colour. I suspect one may have maybe but that doesn't give Fred the right to associate genuine posts suggesting he performed badly as racist. Its the old all Muslims are terrorist analogy. Edited by cryrst (24 Mar 2021 1.23pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The whole point of antagonism is to antagonise. If you know that a racial slur is effective, then any dopey teenager online is going to use it to get a response. It's not rocket science. By using the term racism constantly, all people have done is cheapened and diluted the meaning. The holocaust. That was racism in the broad sense, since Jews are not a race, but they were an identifiable group. Calling people names? Give me a break. This is a genuine question have you ever called anyone the N word after all that is only a word?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.