You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Can Palace become an established top 10 side?
November 16 2026 4.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Can Palace become an established top 10 side?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Zaha127 Flag 20 Jul 21 8.24am

No doubt there is quality. Guehi looks to be a decent signing. Olise when he is fit could have a similar impact like Eze.

Having players like Eze, Olise, Benteke means goals and assists can come from other areas rather than just relying on Zaha. However, I still think Palace do need at least three more signings.

Definitely a striker to make compete with Benteke (someone like Adam Armstrong could be a good signing and is a realistic option.) Another creative player/winger is required Matheus Pereira would be perfect knows the Premiership can score and assist.

An attacking midfielder maybe e.g. Someone like Loftus Cheek. Left back should be okay Mitchell and Hannam could both do well at that role.

Do you think top 10 is a possibility currently? How many more signings and who do you think would be ideal to make this possible?

 

davehuggins Flag 20 Jul 21 8.46am

Anything is possible, but all these changes may well take time to gel. The next question is can PV be the man to lead us there? Let us all hope and pray our future is bright.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Jul 21 8.52am

Originally posted by Zaha127

No doubt there is quality. Guehi looks to be a decent signing. Olise when he is fit could have a similar impact like Eze.

Having players like Eze, Olise, Benteke means goals and assists can come from other areas rather than just relying on Zaha. However, I still think Palace do need at least three more signings.

Definitely a striker to make compete with Benteke (someone like Adam Armstrong could be a good signing and is a realistic option.) Another creative player/winger is required Matheus Pereira would be perfect knows the Premiership can score and assist.

An attacking midfielder maybe e.g. Someone like Loftus Cheek. Left back should be okay Mitchell and Hannam could both do well at that role.

Do you think top 10 is a possibility currently? How many more signings and who do you think would be ideal to make this possible?

Southampton would like him to replace Ings if,as expected,Ings departs.
Armstrong has scored 44 goals in the last 2 seasons.

Edited by Willo (20 Jul 2021 8.53am)

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 20 Jul 21 8.59am

It,s always possible we could develop a team that gains a top ten position,. Not so likely one that adapts and stays there year in year out.
The biggest problem with either scenario in MHO is if it involves us in European competition , because it would seem the club has some way to go before it could afford a squad big enough and good enough to cope with both Premier league and Europe.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 Jul 21 9.07am

Originally posted by Putitout

It,s always possible we could develop a team that gains a top ten position,. Not so likely one that adapts and stays there year in year out.

I think it depends on whether or not we can develop some gems from the academy as we can't afford to keep buying quality players unless we sell on some of the ones we already have.

The new stand would help

 

taylors lovechild Flag 20 Jul 21 9.18am

When you look at how much Everton had to spend to finish tenth last season, and they had Ancelotti at the helm, it shows the size of the task. For me it is not about position in the league (providing that position is outside the bottom three) it is about being competitive and providing some entertainment. If we take the German approach and look to attract the best young talent with a clear path to the first team then I think we have a bright future.

The idea of Wilf, Eze and Olise all in the same starting line-up will surely have created arousal even amongst the most prudish of supporters.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 20 Jul 21 9.24am

we seem to have ripped the heart out of our squad.

History has shown that it is extremely difficult to create a working squad from a large number of newbies. No matter how expensive and talented all these newbies are.


top ten ? yeah sure, but not in this league.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

rikz Flag Croydon 20 Jul 21 9.37am

Originally posted by davehuggins

Anything is possible, but all these changes may well take time to gel. The next question is can PV be the man to lead us there? Let us all hope and pray our future is bright.

Unlikely, one good season and he will just go to a bigger club.

 

si_1967 Flag Surrey 20 Jul 21 9.48am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

we seem to have ripped the heart out of our squad.

History has shown that it is extremely difficult to create a working squad from a large number of newbies. No matter how expensive and talented all these newbies are.


top ten ? yeah sure, but not in this league.


I'm not sure I entirely agree that we've ripped the heart out looking at the people who've left so far:


PVA, Townsend, Cahill are the main one I guess, but all over thirty now!

Hennessy, Sahko, Wickham, Dann, McCarthy: not particularly bothered for various reasons.

Now, admittedly we do still need cover, otherwise we'll be short if injuries/suspensions bite

 


... what

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Jul 21 9.59am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

we seem to have ripped the heart out of our squad.

History has shown that it is extremely difficult to create a working squad from a large number of newbies. No matter how expensive and talented all these newbies are.


top ten ? yeah sure, but not in this league.


Pardon?
- Hennessey 3rd choice keeper
- Henderson 4th choice keeper
- Sakho serial treatment room attendee last 2 years
- Wickham serial treatment room attendee - period.
- McCarthy part time squad player
- Dann slow and past it
As for the others:
- PvA wanted out and I suspect wouldn't have accepted the reduced terms arising from the rebased wage structure in any case
- Townsend would have been nice had he stayed but his price for staying was more than the club were prepared to pay
- Cahill possibly like Townsend but not fully known yet
- Clyne = emergency cover brought in because of the Ferguson situation and may yet sign a deal

I don't see the above as the heart of our squad last year. Rather it was:
- Guaita
- Ward
- Tomkins
- Milivojevic
- McArthur
- Kouyate
- Riedewald
- Schlupp
- Ayew
- Zaha
- Benteke
plus the youngsters:
- Mitchell
- Eze.
AS I've suggested on another thread I suspect we will start the season with the first XI comprising most of the above with the only new members being Guehi (and even he might only start on the bench against Chelsea) and possibly a new wide player.


Edited by doombear (20 Jul 2021 1.01pm)

 

jeeagles Flag 20 Jul 21 10.01am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

When you look at how much Everton had to spend to finish tenth last season, and they had Ancelotti at the helm, it shows the size of the task. For me it is not about position in the league (providing that position is outside the bottom three) it is about being competitive and providing some entertainment. If we take the German approach and look to attract the best young talent with a clear path to the first team then I think we have a bright future.

The idea of Wilf, Eze and Olise all in the same starting line-up will surely have created arousal even amongst the most prudish of supporters.

Everton are very bad at spending money.

It wouldn't be impossible, but maybe we should aim for just a top half finish or a cup run first.

Next season giving some of the youngsters chance decent exposure to premiership football would be enough and start building a platform on that once they have experience at this level.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Jul 21 10.02am

Originally posted by rikz

Unlikely, one good season and he will just go to a bigger club.


I'm not so sure. I think he will be enthused by the project of bringing youth through and may well stay for at least 3 years if we manage to stay in the PL this season.

 

m/k mick Flag milton keynes 20 Jul 21 10.26am

We seem to be making the right moves to be a successful maybe top ten, especially with the academy, however the key to me is the Stadium, build the new stand, increased revenue, and the future looks much brighter, stay as we are we will struggle long term

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 20 Jul 21 10.28am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

When you look at how much Everton had to spend to finish tenth last season, and they had Ancelotti at the helm, it shows the size of the task. For me it is not about position in the league (providing that position is outside the bottom three) it is about being competitive and providing some entertainment. If we take the German approach and look to attract the best young talent with a clear path to the first team then I think we have a bright future.

The idea of Wilf, Eze and Olise all in the same starting line-up will surely have created arousal even amongst the most prudish of supporters.

It seems that is exactly what we are doing.

Everton is a poor comparison. They have been spending unwisely for a long long time with little success; and Ancelotti - as good as her is - was, surprisingly, a poor fit.

West Ham and Leicester are non-top 6 sides who fared better. And neither of them are following the German model as we seem to be.

The club need to grit their teeth and persevere in the face of huge public backlash. Gelling youth and seeing the fruits of the academy play out in the first XI takes time. With the current culture of instant gratification, impatience will spill over very quickly.

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 20 Jul 21 10.35am

Originally posted by silvertop

It seems that is exactly what we are doing.

Everton is a poor comparison. They have been spending unwisely for a long long time with little success; and Ancelotti - as good as her is - was, surprisingly, a poor fit.

West Ham and Leicester are non-top 6 sides who fared better. And neither of them are following the German model as we seem to be.

The club need to grit their teeth and persevere in the face of huge public backlash. Gelling youth and seeing the fruits of the academy play out in the first XI takes time. With the current culture of instant gratification, impatience will spill over very quickly.

Think we generally agree but not sure WH or Leicester stack up either as a comparison.

West Ham have one season really - there is generally a bottom half club that come good for a season. They could easily be down to 13th 14th next time. Nothing intrinsically strong in their set up.

Leicester are a top 5 club nowadays - only public perception puts them behind Spurs and Arsenal. They have bought and sold brilliantly for a number of years now.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 20 Jul 21 10.36am

it's possible but we need a heck of a lot to go right, some of that will be outside of our control.

This will be a transitional season. I'd expect us to finish this season in the 13-16 bracket, however with a massive step-change in how we approach football i.e. the pursuit of betterment rather than mere survival.

I would also expect that if Vieira really nails our new football philosophy, we can attract more talent to the project, going into the 22-23 season, without having to pay mercenaries to do us a favour.

I'm also really excited to see how we approach cup competitions. Like, to actually aim to progress through them and get to a final.

Edited by Frickin Saweet (20 Jul 2021 10.38am)

 

beak Flag croydon 20 Jul 21 10.39am

Originally posted by Zaha127

No doubt there is quality. Guehi looks to be a decent signing. Olise when he is fit could have a similar impact like Eze.

Having players like Eze, Olise, Benteke means goals and assists can come from other areas rather than just relying on Zaha. However, I still think Palace do need at least three more signings.

Definitely a striker to make compete with Benteke (someone like Adam Armstrong could be a good signing and is a realistic option.) Another creative player/winger is required Matheus Pereira would be perfect knows the Premiership can score and assist.

An attacking midfielder maybe e.g. Someone like Loftus Cheek. Left back should be okay Mitchell and Hannam could both do well at that role.

Do you think top 10 is a possibility currently? How many more signings and who do you think would be ideal to make this possible?

We need a minmum of three more defenders.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 20 Jul 21 10.41am

What does success look like ?
We are in a period of transition & I would guess if you asked the board, PV & the supporters that question it would probably raise some interesting answers -

Year 1 - Suggestions -
Finish somewhere between 10 - 16 in the league ?
Lower the average age of the team / squad by .... years ?
Reduce the team / squad salary by .... % age
A cup run ?
Confirm the pathway from Academy to first team (by actually making it happen for .... players)
Encourage new investment ?
Play more attacking football?
New stand development ?

Year 2 -
( Obviously year 2 targets really depend on how successful we were in Year 1)

Any thoughts ?

 

YT Flag Oxford 20 Jul 21 10.43am

Yes we can, however all the clubs we are aiming to scramble above will think that they can too, and will be throwing similar cash at "exciting new signings". What they DON'T have in reserve, though, is Jacob Montes. Actually, I'm not sure that WE have him in reserve either!

Oops - Jacob, not Jason. Now corrected.

Edited by YT (20 Jul 2021 10.45am)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 Jul 21 11.11am

Originally posted by YT

What they DON'T have in reserve, though, is Jacob Montes. Actually,

If we're relying on him I think that we're fooked

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Can Palace become an established top 10 side?