You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we boring and does it matter?
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we boring and does it matter?


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
taylors lovechild Flag 29 Nov 23 7.03am

[Link]

This article in the inews posits the question as to what is the point of what Palace are doing in the PL. No goals, no entertainment but just enough points to bob along in mid-table. A risk averse approach with limited "fun" as the article suggests. This seems to be the existential question that has fuelled these boards in recent years (especially since the final couple of years of Roy's reign).

Brighton were in a very similar position until Bloom decided he wanted to go down a different route. He's made his money in gambling and his gambles are paying off and everyone has forgotten what they were like under Hughton.

Right now I personally think we have a pool (albeit small) of talent that means we should be being braver, taking more risks and trying to actually entertain the fans, rather than just grinding out results. What is the point of Roy's approach? It may work to get a midtable finish, but does anyone really enjoy the football and his stubborn refusal to experiment?

I don't blame Roy, he's delivering what many of his feared he would. He will likely keep Palace up. But I no longer think that's enough.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 29 Nov 23 7.51am

If we want entertainment then we need to be in the VAR free Championship .

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Nov 23 8.01am

Rubbish article, Palace bashing.

How do we change, borrow money we don't have then go broke, tried that twice NOT FUN.

Until we have owners prepared to spend Parish is making the best of a bad job. Brighton got a mention, well lucky for them they have an owners whose prepared to spend.

Perhaps the journo would like to point us to a rich owner ?


 


One more point

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Nov 23 8.02am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

[Link]

This article in the inews posits the question as to what is the point of what Palace are doing in the PL. No goals, no entertainment but just enough points to bob along in mid-table. A risk averse approach with limited "fun" as the article suggests. This seems to be the existential question that has fuelled these boards in recent years (especially since the final couple of years of Roy's reign).

Brighton were in a very similar position until Bloom decided he wanted to go down a different route. He's made his money in gambling and his gambles are paying off and everyone has forgotten what they were like under Hughton.

Right now I personally think we have a pool (albeit small) of talent that means we should be being braver, taking more risks and trying to actually entertain the fans, rather than just grinding out results. What is the point of Roy's approach? It may work to get a midtable finish, but does anyone really enjoy the football and his stubborn refusal to experiment?

I don't blame Roy, he's delivering what many of his feared he would. He will likely keep Palace up. But I no longer think that's enough.

We are grinding on akin to a giant armadillo across hazardous terrain.

In terms of Chris Hughton, Brighton finished 15th and 17th in his last 2 seasons.He likes his teams to be compact and admitted himself he is not the most expansive coach.

 

johnny the eagle Flag wivenhoe 29 Nov 23 8.44am

I read that link, couldn't have put it better myself.

 


South London born and bred
red and blue till im dead.

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 29 Nov 23 8.57am

That article aside, to answer your question, yes, we are boring, and does it matter? Yes if it is not producing results.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 29 Nov 23 9.04am

Pathetic assessment of the club, we are a small club punching above our weight without the resources to pay big money, no sugar daddy, no small oil producing nation, the squad has doubled in value over the past two deasons, and who is to say Franca and Hendersen in a years time are players will cant afford to buy, the two collapsed deals was a blow, i really dont know what people expect, if you did a list of how big you think each club is, IMHO we would be about 30th.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 29 Nov 23 9.07am

I'd argue yes, it does matter... now.

I hear/read a lot of 'boring', 'if you don't move forwards you go backwards' etc. however never fully bought into it. I was quite happy plodding along, for a period, if it meant survival. If I'm honest, beyond a miracle or something quite genius being implemented at the club, I couldn't see how we'd manage it.

We're in the position now however of our PL survival hinging upon a few players who may not show the loyalty/willingness to stay as Wilf and may become further demoralised if we do not 'make moves'. We have a good spine to the first XI however are lacking in about 4 positions (RB/LB/LW/ST). That's all provided nobody gets injured which they do, have and will.

Roy's return said nothing about the man to me, he'll do his job to the best of his ability and we should be grateful. What it did say for me however, especially when he was extended, is that the board had run out of money, ideas or both.

The absolute ideal for me as a Palace fan, at a minimum, is that we buy for the first XI alongside identifying a manager who knows the score and will take us forward. Once that is done, we can flirt with the likes of the Francas and Ahamadas of this world.

Right now, we feel like a club with a split personality. We tried something but bottled it in a panic and have resorted back to our old selves, purely just trying to eek out another PL season. We have to give something a try sooner or later. As long as it's not too ridiculous, there's a good chance it will yield results for us.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 29 Nov 23 9.14am

This season was always going to be difficult, and it has been made worse.
We have suffered badly from injuries to our best players on top of losing our best player.

However 'boring' we might be, it is way better than playing QPR in front of 12k.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 29 Nov 23 9.17am

I can tolerate the boring football when we win.

Not so much when we lose.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Nov 23 9.19am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

This season was always going to be difficult, and it has been made worse.
We have suffered badly from injuries to our best players on top of losing our best player.

However 'boring' we might be, it is way better than playing QPR in front of 12k.

Or Charlton, I hear they have a lot of fun in L1.

 


One more point

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 29 Nov 23 9.25am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I can tolerate the boring football when we win.

Not so much when we lose.

haha, same. When we lose its terrible.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 29 Nov 23 9.35am

The OPs article does start an interesting discussion though.

Statistically we are pretty boring, similar league positions, similar points total, similar early cup exits (except for 1).

It would be very easy to say what's the point. But that's such a macro view. Granted we are not fighting for titles, but week to week things are still interesting. Can we put a couple of results together, can we get our best team out. And generally the games are reasonably good to watch. We are also witnessing a relatively rare occurrence, having a few England players.


On a side note, my best mate is a ManC fan, had a season ticket for about 20 years, but stopped going about 4 years ago. Why? Its boring when you win every week, and expect to be winning every game 4-0.

Its all relative.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 29 Nov 23 10.29am

I think for me the issue this season has been that I can't see what it is we trying to do in terms of our forward play. We're not playing a fast high-pressing game like Wolves, we're not playing an old-fashioned get it to the wings and throw crosses in like Everton, and we're not playing intricate fancy sh*t like the big guns. It almost feels like we're just waiting for someone to create something out of nothing. In Roy's previous reign it was about sitting deep and hitting teams on the break, but that isn't really in evidence this season. It seems basically that we get it to Ayew, he draws a foul, we throw the ball in the box. As useless as Eduoard has been in most games he's been feeding off of scraps.

This season the 15 points has masked how rubbish we've been in many games. If Roy isn't going to play the players we've signed then the club need to decide do they want to keep Roy or do they want his input on who they sign. I can't see how things change otherwise.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 29 Nov 23 11.15am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I think for me the issue this season has been that I can't see what it is we trying to do in terms of our forward play. We're not playing a fast high-pressing game like Wolves, we're not playing an old-fashioned get it to the wings and throw crosses in like Everton, and we're not playing intricate fancy sh*t like the big guns. It almost feels like we're just waiting for someone to create something out of nothing. In Roy's previous reign it was about sitting deep and hitting teams on the break, but that isn't really in evidence this season. It seems basically that we get it to Ayew, he draws a foul, we throw the ball in the box. As useless as Eduoard has been in most games he's been feeding off of scraps.

This season the 15 points has masked how rubbish we've been in many games. If Roy isn't going to play the players we've signed then the club need to decide do they want to keep Roy or do they want his input on who they sign. I can't see how things change otherwise.

We can't play on the break if there's no pace in the team. Only Olise,and to a lesser extent Edouard, possess genuine pace but that's it.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

taylors lovechild Flag 29 Nov 23 11.37am

Originally posted by NEILLO

We can't play on the break if there's no pace in the team. Only Olise,and to a lesser extent Edouard, possess genuine pace but that's it.

I agree, but then what exactly is the plan? I think too much burden is placed on Olise and Eze to just come up with something like Zaha used to do under Roy. We defend as a unit but we don't seem to attack like one. I've said it before, but Andros has previously said how Roy doesn't work on the attacking side of the game in training and I do think that shows.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 29 Nov 23 12.05pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I think for me the issue this season has been that I can't see what it is we trying to do in terms of our forward play. We're not playing a fast high-pressing game like Wolves, we're not playing an old-fashioned get it to the wings and throw crosses in like Everton, and we're not playing intricate fancy sh*t like the big guns. It almost feels like we're just waiting for someone to create something out of nothing. In Roy's previous reign it was about sitting deep and hitting teams on the break, but that isn't really in evidence this season. It seems basically that we get it to Ayew, he draws a foul, we throw the ball in the box. As useless as Eduoard has been in most games he's been feeding off of scraps.

This season the 15 points has masked how rubbish we've been in many games. If Roy isn't going to play the players we've signed then the club need to decide do they want to keep Roy or do they want his input on who they sign. I can't see how things change otherwise.

Agreed with most other than Ayew drawing a foul part. When he does that it normally ends up back with our keeper. Now that is boring. After all these seasons in the prem and before we leave it, it would have been great to have got some silverware and/or European games to remember? I wonder if being an up and down club like West Brom would be better for us fans. I’m sure Leicester fans are enjoying this season as are some of the other near the top championship clubs?

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 29 Nov 23 1.15pm

"what is the point of what Palace are doing in the PL. No goals, no entertainment but just enough points to bob along in mid-table"
Give over. We're a smallish club - whos tried to push on in a financially responsible manner.

FdB was brought in to change the playing style (evolution not revolution, remember)
that ultimately failed, so we fell back on RH, who did great with what we had initially, but for whatever reason - probably that financially responsible mindset - kicked in and we didn't ever upgrade the squad got more and more out of date and we revert to safety first 'boring' football
Vieira was then brought in for another go at a young exiting manager.
That ultimately failed, so we fell back on RH, who did great with what we had initially. Then Injuries happen and we revert to safety first 'boring' football.

Are we boring? when necessity calls for it.


Edited by CrazyBadger (29 Nov 2023 1.15pm)

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 29 Nov 23 1.15pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I think for me the issue this season has been that I can't see what it is we trying to do in terms of our forward play. We're not playing a fast high-pressing game like Wolves, we're not playing an old-fashioned get it to the wings and throw crosses in like Everton, and we're not playing intricate fancy sh*t like the big guns. It almost feels like we're just waiting for someone to create something out of nothing. In Roy's previous reign it was about sitting deep and hitting teams on the break, but that isn't really in evidence this season. It seems basically that we get it to Ayew, he draws a foul, we throw the ball in the box. As useless as Eduoard has been in most games he's been feeding off of scraps.

This season the 15 points has masked how rubbish we've been in many games. If Roy isn't going to play the players we've signed then the club need to decide do they want to keep Roy or do they want his input on who they sign. I can't see how things change otherwise.

That someone was Wilfried Zaha and is now a shared responsibility between Eberechi Eze and Michael Olise. One is now injured again and the other did produce something upon return, but we can't even keep it out of our own net these days.

Very limited supply of goals coupled with an inability to keep them out is a recipe for disaster. If Roy cannot deliver the latter, his limitations with the former are irrelevant where that was the primary gripe previously.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

taylors lovechild Flag 29 Nov 23 1.34pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

"what is the point of what Palace are doing in the PL. No goals, no entertainment but just enough points to bob along in mid-table"
Give over. We're a smallish club - whos tried to push on in a financially responsible manner.

FdB was brought in to change the playing style (evolution not revolution, remember)
that ultimately failed, so we fell back on RH, who did great with what we had initially, but for whatever reason - probably that financially responsible mindset - kicked in and we didn't ever upgrade the squad got more and more out of date and we revert to safety first 'boring' football
Vieira was then brought in for another go at a young exiting manager.
That ultimately failed, so we fell back on RH, who did great with what we had initially. Then Injuries happen and we revert to safety first 'boring' football.

Are we boring? when necessity calls for it.


Edited by CrazyBadger (29 Nov 2023 1.15pm)

I think perhaps the problem is that Vieira's first season gave us a glimpse of how well a small club like us can perform. More confident and braver in possession, playing with a more positive mindset, etc. In his second season he seemed to lose his courage of convictions and he and the team went into its shell. Thn Roy came in only needing a handful of points to secure safety, promptly got them against lesser opposition and we could relax and let our forward players have some fun.

Personally I don't think Roy changes his approach with the injuries, I just think when the creative players are out it shows his lack of tactics for the forward areas. Also, when you aren't scoring maybe you need to take a risk and play the £20m forward the club signed, or the athletic £10m signing from the Bundesliga. It might not work, but you can't argue there are no options, he's just not using them. Alternatively you change the shape, like going 3-5-2. I don't think we need to be boring, I just think we have a manager who doesn't care about performances, just results, which is fair enough if you just want to watch the Vidiprinter.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we boring and does it matter?