You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Is it racist to....
November 19 2026 5.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is it racist to....


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 27 Nov 02 5.20pm

Dislike the Welsh? Following that silly thread about supposed ‘racism’ at Palace (yeah, right, like I’m gonna take that serious!), I was interested in a lot of the comments made on the subject of ‘racism’. I declined to get involved in the thread coz I think the whole Dave Lee thing is a boring wind up and I don’t wanna lend credence to it.

My point is; why does colour of skin seem to be the only valid criteria in the ‘racism’ row?

Someone mentioned a certain French arsehole in the thread and seemed to advocate that ‘racism’ against the French was OK and in my opinion, it certainly is, I wholeheartedly agree, but nobody pulled him up or got offended in the least… why? Why is that? Is it the same reason the English happily rip into the Welsh or the Scots, and visa-versa, but would be offended with the same treatment of Africans or ****stanis? Put it like this; I heard tons of pretty offensive anti-Welsh songs being sung at the Norwich game that were aimed at a certain toothless Welsh b****** who was at the time playing an integral part in the beating of a poor Palace side and people all around me were laughing away happily at what was being sung, me included, but why is that? How can this kind of ‘racism’ be so easily excused? Why were the offending choir not shown the door in the midst of football’s gallant crusade on ‘racism’? How can this ‘racism’ aimed at a people that were displaced from their homelands by us English be OK? These people who’s mother-tongue was banned for hundreds of years? These people who have fought against us and with us? No? Not too sure? Ok, I’ll tell ya why! It’s because the targets of the abuse are white and that makes it alright! That makes us all feel comfortable. Just fine and dandy! But how can it be ‘racism’ when they’re white I hear you cry? Easily, I reply a little too smugly; I’m from Saxon stock, as are the majority of white English folk, the blood that flows through most of our veins is Germanic, the Welsh and Scots on the other hand, are Celts! A different race entirely! Different culture, different language, different people! So what I heard at Norwich was ‘racism’, pure and simple! ‘Racism’ overlooked by my fellow fans, the Police and anyone else who happened to be in earshot of the excellent ‘Welsh shag each other’ song. And yet, much that I enjoyed the song, I can’t help but wonder why ‘racism’ against people of the same hew is deemed to be ok and yet racism against people of a different shade causes such involuntary frothing at the mouth reactions from a lot of you? Now let me just point out that we’re talking ‘racism’ here, not racial hatred. So, is ‘racism’ the dangerous and evil hot potato they say it is or not? Make yer bleedin’ minds up will ya, coz I’m… confused!

Just a thought.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Smokey Flag Hiding under Syd Little's floorboa... 27 Nov 02 5.57pm

No.

 


"Technically, I've been bummed". - Matt_Himself , Barcelona, Jan 2005

Jake d'Eagle Flag in the section labelled 'shirts', ... 27 Nov 02 6.02pm

My point is; why does colour of skin seem to be the only valid criteria in the ‘racism’ row?


It's a complex question. But a simple answer.

It isn't.

It is racist to discriminate on the basis of colour, racial origin, etc.

But it is based on the premise that these differences make people better/worse than one another.

And they don't. There are so many more valid reasons to hate people other than the arbitary fact of where they or their ancestors came from.

 


Put a Glide in your Stride, and Dip in your Hip,
Come on over to the Mothership, baby

[Link] Transformation is Happening


Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 27 Nov 02 6.49pm

Quote Jake d'Eagle at 27 Nov 2002 6:02pm
There are so many more valid reasons to hate people other than the arbitary fact of where they or their ancestors came from.

Like what? Hatred is hatred whatever colour you paint it! Like I said, we're taking about the word 'racism' here, we're not talking about racial hatred.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

titsfannyandpalace Flag Dont ask me 27 Nov 02 8.53pm

Scotland hate the English and the English hate the Scottish.

till I die!

 


An' I wanna move the town to the clash city rockers

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 28 Nov 02 8.20am

Good post Pete, I agree. It just goes to show that our society hasn't yet come to terms with racism, as it can't even define it!

I think it's fair to say that if the Welsh (for example) were predominantly brown or black, then anti-Welsh chants would be considered unacceptable.

Which is blatantly stupid, double standards.

It's not a new argument, but it's an interesting one, and I've yet to see ANYONE come up with a decent answer. Yet.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 28 Nov 02 9.44am

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 28 Nov 2002 8:20am

Good post Pete, I agree. It just goes to show that our society hasn't yet come to terms with racism, as it can't even define it!

I think it's fair to say that if the Welsh (for example) were predominantly brown or black, then anti-Welsh chants would be considered unacceptable.

Which is blatantly stupid, double standards.

It's not a new argument, but it's an interesting one, and I've yet to see ANYONE come up with a decent answer. Yet.

Excellent response slugs, in fact your response IS the answer, well it's the answer I was fishing for because it hits the nail square on the head.
My argument is that we're using the wrong word to describe racial hatred and racial discrimination. The word racism has been redefined in modern terms to describe the above things and I think it generalises the issues, blurs the edges and places basically good people in the firing line.

Example: A neighbourly old lady living in the East End of London, no matter how much she tries, just does not like the Bangladeshi people that have taken over her community. She's lived in the same street for seventy eight years, the very same house she was born in, she's lived through the blitz and the Black shirts, and little by little she's seen her community broken down as her neighbours and friends have moved away or died. Her street is very different now. She's met one or two Bangladeshi people that have seemed quite nice, mostly the younger ones, but on the whole, she doesn't much like their ways, she can't understand what they're saying half the time and the women, with their faces hidden behind those spooky black masks won't talk to her at all. It's not a political stance, she aint about to vote for the BNP, she votes labour, always has, always will, it's just the way she feels, she can't help it, she's not proud of it, it's not very Christian, but what can she do?

So in today’s terms, she's a racist and that places her in the same league as full-on nazi's and society condemns this hard-working clean-living lady as something that must be eradicated. If her truth is ever found out, she'll be the victim of bricks through windows verbal abuse and all manner of blind unfounded hatred.

My point is; the word 'racism' is a sweeping generalisation which is every bit as dangerous as the subject matter it purposes to represent

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

matt_the_eagle Flag Tulse Thrill 28 Nov 02 9.50am

I'm not racist and I'm not sexist, I just hate black woman.

 


I think Keith Murray said it best when he rapped
"If you aint fly you cant play with my yo-yo".

I'm sure you'll agree.

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 28 Nov 02 11.59am

At the time of the Matthew Simmons / Cantona incident, MS was branded a racist for his alleged anti french comments to Cantona. If MS IS a racist then there are a high percentage of racists in society as a whole and there were a large number of racists in the main stand that night.

This also raises another question. Was the comment to Mr Cantona 'you french ****' a racist sentiment or simply a statement of fact?

 

matt_the_eagle Flag Tulse Thrill 28 Nov 02 12.02pm

Is French a race? if not, they're not racist, they're just honest.

 


I think Keith Murray said it best when he rapped
"If you aint fly you cant play with my yo-yo".

I'm sure you'll agree.

Selhurst Stallion Flag Guildford 28 Nov 02 12.24pm

It's an excellent post Pete and one that certainly got me thinking....

In today's society (lad culture)I think it has just become more acceptable to ridicule someone because of their nationality as part of 'jovial banter' amongst all types of people including football supporters. You can get away with saying almost anything at a football match that you wouldn't even dream of saying in everyday life and it's looked upon as a laugh and a joke because it's all part of the banter that goes on between two sets of football supporters. Being German is frowned upon by the English because of the war and vice-versa and 95% of the time it's just laughed off. You see and hear jokes made about Germans / Scottish / French on TV and it's considered perfectly acceptable. The odd person will take acception to it. We stereotype Brighton fans as being homosexual because we all know Brighton has the largest gay population. Football is a masculine game and being gay is looked upon as being feminine which means it's the obvious wind up to all masculine Brighton fans and once again is just laughed off.

But when it comes down to the colour of skin it becomes nastier and more personal and that you're being singled out amongst everyone else around you. If it's at a football match and you're insulting a black person either on the opposing team or in the away fans section it just doesn't make sense because your own fans and team also have black players.

It's hard to sum up in words what you feel about racism but I've tried as clearly as I can.

Edited by Selhurst Stallion (28 Nov 2002 12:27pm)

 


"Friend first, Boss second..Probably chilled out entertainer third" - David Brent 2002.

Selhurst Stallion Flag Guildford 28 Nov 02 12.32pm

At the end of the day the Cantona / Simmons incident had nothing to do with Cantona's nationality but the fact that he played for Man Utd and was notrious for being an arrogant, petulant and dirty player who everyone loved to hate. The same for Keane now. If the word "french" or "france" came out of Simmons' gob it was purely because the heat of the moment situation and not because he hates the French.

 


"Friend first, Boss second..Probably chilled out entertainer third" - David Brent 2002.

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 28 Nov 02 12.35pm

If insulting someones skin colour is racist then where does hair colour fit in? Are the anti-ginger lobby racists too?

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 28 Nov 02 12.49pm

Quote matt_the_eagle at 28 Nov 2002 12:02pm

Is French a race? if not, they're not racist, they're just honest.

France is very similar to Britain in the formation of it's populace, it has a similar history to Britain. I believe the Brettons are Celtic, but I think in the main the French are of Saxon origin, they made up part of the Gaul of Roman times that also included Belgium and parts of Germany and Holland, and then Armorica in the post-Roman era I believe, although the Normans - like the people of Norfolk - are generally speaking, of Nordic decent - which again is ultimately Germanic, so, it would be silly to term an anti-French attitude of a briton 'racist', but it also raises another point; is disliking a person because of his race, as bad as disliking a person because of his country of origin? If not, why not?
Let me just reiterate, I'm using the word 'dislike' here; not 'hate'.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 28 Nov 02 12.52pm

Quote Selhurst Stallion at 28 Nov 2002 12:32pm

At the end of the day the Cantona / Simmons incident had nothing to do with Cantona's nationality but the fact that he played for Man Utd and was notrious for being an arrogant, petulant and dirty player who everyone loved to hate. The same for Keane now. If the word "french" or "france" came out of Simmons' gob it was purely because the heat of the moment situation and not because he hates the French.

Exactly, good point!

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 28 Nov 02 1.26pm

Quote Petealiator at 28 Nov 2002 12:52pm

Quote Selhurst Stallion at 28 Nov 2002 12:32pm

At the end of the day the Cantona / Simmons incident had nothing to do with Cantona's nationality but the fact that he played for Man Utd and was notrious for being an arrogant, petulant and dirty player who everyone loved to hate. The same for Keane now. If the word "french" or "france" came out of Simmons' gob it was purely because the heat of the moment situation and not because he hates the French.

Exactly, good point!


Ahh, that clears it up then. And if it had been Paul Ince sent off (another player we love to hate) and Simmons had called him a 'black ****' in the heat of the moment (not because he hates black people) he wouldn't deserve to be called a racist then either?

I think the answer is that racism is only racism if someone interprets it that way. It is common for English people to dislike the French or the Welsh so to insult their race is deemed acceptable. So something that is racist to one person may not be racist to someone else.

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 28 Nov 02 2.02pm

Quote Meerkat 2 at 28 Nov 2002 1:26pm

Ahh, that clears it up then. And if it had been Paul Ince sent off (another player we love to hate) and Simmons had called him a 'black ****' in the heat of the moment (not because he hates black people) he wouldn't deserve to be called a racist then either?
I think the answer is that racism is only racism if someone interprets it that way. It is common for English people to dislike the French or the Welsh so to insult their race is deemed acceptable. So something that is racist to one person may not be racist to someone else.

EXACTLY! When Cantona jumped studs-first into that stand like a raging mindless animal, his whole career hung in the balance and in my opinion the FA disgraced themselves totally over the whole sorry episode, they should have had the guts to ban the b****** for life, if you did it in a Sunday League match, you'd get banned for life no worries. The racism card was shamelessly used to save his sorry French arse and with the help of top-paid lawyers, he got off lightly and Simmons was branded a racist thug and banned for life! Everyone took a step back and went 'Ah, so that's why he lost it big-time...racism!' IT'S BULLs***! No one even stopped to consider that it couldn't be 'racism', the police, the courts, the media all declined to point out that Cantona is the same f***ing race as Simmons!

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Selhurst Stallion Flag Guildford 28 Nov 02 2.22pm

Quote Meerkat 2 at 28 Nov 2002 1:26pm

Ahh, that clears it up then. And if it had been Paul Ince sent off (another player we love to hate) and Simmons had called him a 'black ****' in the heat of the moment (not because he hates black people) he wouldn't deserve to be called a racist then either?

Yeah Simmons may well have said something like that had Ince been sent off but no I still wouldn't call him a racist. I would never say anything like that to Ince - not even in the heat of the moment - but they're certain individuals with the mentality of a moron who would say because they probably see it as 'being a lad', 'being cool' at a football match and wouldn't even give it a second thought after they said it....To me a racist is someone who would go to a football match, make monkey noises and throw a bananas on the pitch or someone who would stand on a street corner tormenting a person from a different culture even to the point of beating them up not a moron who can't think before he speaks.

At the end of the day we've all laughed at or told a racist joke (as have black people), that doesn't make us racists though does it?


Edited by Selhurst Stallion (28 Nov 2002 2:50pm)

 


"Friend first, Boss second..Probably chilled out entertainer third" - David Brent 2002.

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 28 Nov 02 2.51pm

Quote Selhurst Stallion at 28 Nov 2002 2:22pm

To me a racist is someone who would go to a football match, make monkey noises and throw a bananas on the pitch or someone who would stand on a street corner tormenting a person from a different culture even to the point of beating them up not a moron who can't think before he speaks.


That's the whole point of my argument! The actions you describe are 'racial abuse', but by categorising it 'racism', in today's general conception of what 'racism' is, you place my harmless little old lady from Stepney in the same category as the bloke throwing the bananas onto the football pitch!
My point is that in today’s terms, you are a considered racist if you merely dislike a group of people due to personal experience or otherwise and that's my beef! To force people to accept that their point of view is evil and wrong, is nothing less than mind-control! It's a person's right to like or dislike whatever they feel in life, and furthermore I believe EVERYONE on this planet is 'racist' to one extent or another, it's a natural human instinct to dislike or distrust one group or another, but racial hatred and racial abuse are a whole different ball game!


Edited by Petealiator (28 Nov 2002 2:53pm)

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Selhurst Stallion Flag Guildford 28 Nov 02 3.06pm

Quote Petealiator at 28 Nov 2002 2:51pm

That's the whole point of my argument! The actions you describe are 'racial abuse', but by categorising it 'racism', in today's general conception of what 'racism' is, you place my harmless little old lady from Stepney in the same category as the bloke throwing the bananas onto the football pitch!
My point is that in today’s terms, you are a considered racist if you merely dislike a group of people due to personal experience or otherwise and that's my beef! To force people to accept that their point of view is evil and wrong, is nothing less than mind-control! It's a person's right to like or dislike whatever they feel in life, and furthermore I believe EVERYONE on this planet is 'racist' to one extent or another, it's a natural human instinct to dislike or distrust one group or another, but racial hatred and racial abuse are a whole different ball game!


Edited by Petealiator (28 Nov 2002 2:53pm)

That's exactly how I wanted to say it but couldn't. Yes Black, White, Asians, Indians we're all racists.

 


"Friend first, Boss second..Probably chilled out entertainer third" - David Brent 2002.

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Is it racist to....