This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Why are 'refugees' just called 'migrants' now?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Kermit8 Hevon 24 Aug 15 4.56pm |
|
|
It's obvious the Syrians that are fleeing are refugees not migrants yet they don't seem to be allowed that title by the media and we are following their lead by lumping them in with others who are heading to Europe but who are not being persecuted.
Someone somewhere is manipulating emotive language to suit certain agendas. Something is going on.
Remember reading an article last year about a Yale or maybe Harvard grad - can't remember his name annoyingly - in the US who heads up a team who work on a mission to confuse the media and world opinion to such an extent that no one is quite clear about what is really going on anymore.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
leggedstruggle Croydon 24 Aug 15 5.01pm |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 4.56pm
It's obvious the Syrians that are fleeing are refugees not migrants yet they don't seem to be allowed that title by the media and we are following their lead by lumping them in with others who are heading to Europe but who are not being persecuted.
Someone somewhere is manipulating emotive language to suit certain agendas. Something is going on.
Remember reading an article last year about a Yale or maybe Harvard grad - can't remember his name annoyingly - in the US who heads up a team who work on a mission to confuse the media and world opinion to such an extent that no one is quite clear about what is really going on anymore.
Is Legaleagle a Yale or Harvard graduate?
mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler
|
Catfish Burgess Hill 24 Aug 15 5.26pm |
|
|
Simple answer. You are not a refugee until you have been assessed and it is agreed that you meet the definition of refugee. Until then you are an asylum seeker. You are only a refugee if you have a well founded fear of persecution in your home country. You are obliged to claim asylum in the first safe country you get to. If you are getting out of a war zone your situation may be complex. It may be that you certainly have grounds to be afraid but are not being persecuted. It may also be that you can simply move to a different part of the country where there is less danger. Then there are other complications if the basis of your fear is that you have committed criminal acts or war crimes. What may be a war crime to one person may be an act of resistance to another. The vast majority of applicants do not qualify as refugees but are often allowed to stay because it is dangerous to return them to their home country. It is reasonable to call them migrants.
Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial
|
Jamesrichards8 24 Aug 15 5.33pm |
|
|
Well, these people, as true 'refugees' wouldn't be allowed to pick and choose which country they seek asylum in. They are in France, and other non-violent countries, yet seek asylum elsewhere. Refugees seek refuge in the first peaceful country they enter. I've got to get off this site. The liberal bulls*** is doing my head in. Cue some sarcastic reply applauding my decision to leave. Gee this site has really gotten boring.
When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...
|
Kermit8 Hevon 24 Aug 15 5.38pm |
|
Quote Jamesrichards8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.33pm
Well, these people, as true 'refugees' wouldn't be allowed to pick and choose which country they seek asylum in. They are in France, and other non-violent countries, yet seek asylum elsewhere. Refugees seek refuge in the first peaceful country they enter. I've got to get off this site. The liberal bulls*** is doing my head in. Cue some sarcastic reply applauding my decision to leave. Gee this site has really gotten boring.
But Jewish refugees from Nazi Germany in the 1930's went all over and didn't just end up next door in Poland or France and they weren't called migrants. if you are genuinely fleeing a war or murderous persecution wherever you end up surely you are still a refugee and not a migrant.
It is the manipulation of language that is interesting and our subservience to it.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Stuk Top half 24 Aug 15 5.52pm |
|
|
They aren't.
Optimistic as ever
|
elgrande bedford 24 Aug 15 5.52pm |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.38pm
Quote Jamesrichards8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.33pm
Well, these people, as true 'refugees' wouldn't be allowed to pick and choose which country they seek asylum in. They are in France, and other non-violent countries, yet seek asylum elsewhere. Refugees seek refuge in the first peaceful country they enter. I've got to get off this site. The liberal bulls*** is doing my head in. Cue some sarcastic reply applauding my decision to leave. Gee this site has really gotten boring.
But Jewish refugees from Nazi Germany in the 1930's went all over and didn't just end up next door in Poland or France and they weren't called migrants. if you are genuinely fleeing a war or murderous persecution wherever you end up surely you are still a refugee and not a migrant.
It is the manipulation of language that is interesting and our subservience to it.
Think there is a slight difference there Kerms,seeing as Nazi Germany extended most of Europe. Poland /France/Holland/Austria/Italy all under Nazi rule. The Jews were being Hunted all over Europe by the nazi, the Migrants/Refugees are not.
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.
|
Hrolf The Ganger 24 Aug 15 5.53pm |
|
|
Surely you are both if you are fleeing danger. Migration is a more general term to cover anyone moving from one place to another.
|
Stirlingsays 24 Aug 15 5.58pm |
|
|
By virtue of our location in Europe we should get very few actual refugees.
Unless they have family here then they should be taking the first safe country.....though there are some reasonable exceptions to this.
Bleeding hearts would like this country to pay for the provision and housing of foreigners when we haven't sorted out the problems of our own population.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
radsyrendot From Coventry now in Leicester 24 Aug 15 5.59pm |
|
|
In post office today 2 lads came in from Kosovo with 2 envelopes of £20 notes doing a money transfer back to there homeland 1 stayed 1 went out postmistress asked questions ie where he lived work his mate couldn't answer her she told him to tell friend to come back in he never other lad told her where he lived and his job as a cleaner £4300 he sent back .....w***ers
|
Catfish Burgess Hill 24 Aug 15 6.00pm |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.38pm
Quote Jamesrichards8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.33pm
Well, these people, as true 'refugees' wouldn't be allowed to pick and choose which country they seek asylum in. They are in France, and other non-violent countries, yet seek asylum elsewhere. Refugees seek refuge in the first peaceful country they enter. I've got to get off this site. The liberal bulls*** is doing my head in. Cue some sarcastic reply applauding my decision to leave. Gee this site has really gotten boring.[/quote
But Jewish refugees from Nazi Germany in the 1930's went all over and didn't just end up next door in Poland or France and they weren't called migrants. if you are genuinely fleeing a war or murderous persecution wherever you end up surely you are still a refugee and not a migrant.
It is the manipulation of language that is interesting and our subservience to it.
It is entirely possible that the media are manipulating language but the expressions used officially are based on statute and conventions. Some expressions are used wrongly by the media such as deportation - which has a very precise meaning in law. The expressions such as illegal immigrant have bad connotations because of the way they were used as euphemisms in the 60s. Illegal immigrant is actually a reasonable description of someone who has entered the UK without permission. What is a poorer use of language is to label someone a refugee without knowing anything about their motives.
Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial
|
Stirlingsays 24 Aug 15 6.12pm |
|
Quote radsyrendot at 24 Aug 2015 5.59pm
In post office today 2 lads came in from Kosovo with 2 envelopes of £20 notes doing a money transfer back to there homeland 1 stayed 1 went out postmistress asked questions ie where he lived work his mate couldn't answer her she told him to tell friend to come back in he never other lad told her where he lived and his job as a cleaner £4300 he sent back .....w***ers
Yep a foreign worker is a poor economic substitute for a British one.
The pro-immigration surveys that your typical pro economic immigrant lefty quotes at you don't of course take account of the significant amount of money that is sent out of this country.
A working class British worker is far less likely to do that.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Ray in Houston Houston 24 Aug 15 6.14pm |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.38pm
But Jewish refugees from Nazi Germany in the 1930's went all over and didn't just end up next door in Poland or France and they weren't called migrants.
I'm not sure that taking refuge in Poland or France would have been a good strategy for them.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.
|
Kermit8 Hevon 24 Aug 15 6.17pm |
|
|
From the UN website:
Who is a refugee?
"A refugee is someone who has been forced to flee his or her country because of persecution, war, or violence. A refugee has a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership in a particular social group. Most likely, they cannot return home or are afraid to do so. War and ethnic, tribal and religious violence are leading causes of refugees fleeing their countries."
So Syrians are definitely not migrants yet I don't see them being called refugees by the media either. I suppose if they were called refugees than it has an emotional impact which for one reason or another is not desired by those that pull the heart strings.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Kermit8 Hevon 24 Aug 15 6.19pm |
|
Quote Ray in Houston at 24 Aug 2015 6.14pm
Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.38pm
But Jewish refugees from Nazi Germany in the 1930's went all over and didn't just end up next door in Poland or France and they weren't called migrants.
I'm not sure that taking refuge in Poland or France would have been a good strategy for them.
Quite a few though thought it would be. That didn't work out well for them at all.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Kermit8 Hevon 24 Aug 15 6.26pm |
|
Quote elgrande at 24 Aug 2015 5.52pm
Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.38pm
Quote Jamesrichards8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.33pm
Well, these people, as true 'refugees' wouldn't be allowed to pick and choose which country they seek asylum in. They are in France, and other non-violent countries, yet seek asylum elsewhere. Refugees seek refuge in the first peaceful country they enter. I've got to get off this site. The liberal bulls*** is doing my head in. Cue some sarcastic reply applauding my decision to leave. Gee this site has really gotten boring.
But Jewish refugees from Nazi Germany in the 1930's went all over and didn't just end up next door in Poland or France and they weren't called migrants. if you are genuinely fleeing a war or murderous persecution wherever you end up surely you are still a refugee and not a migrant.
It is the manipulation of language that is interesting and our subservience to it.
Think there is a slight difference there Kerms,seeing as Nazi Germany extended most of Europe. Poland /France/Holland/Austria/Italy all under Nazi rule. The Jews were being Hunted all over Europe by the nazi, the Migrants/Refugees are not.
I meant just in the 1930's and before Poland was invaded. Many Jewish 'refugees' got out and the diaspora went worldwide. My point being of course that just because some chose to go further afield than the nearest safe haven did not stop them being refugees. Any Syrians fleeing IS and murderous persecution by their own government who end up here or in Germany or elsewhere are not 'migrants' however much the media or others with an agenda try to make it so.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Kermit8 Hevon 24 Aug 15 6.32pm |
|
Quote Catfish at 24 Aug 2015 6.00pm
Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.38pm
Quote Jamesrichards8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.33pm
Well, these people, as true 'refugees' wouldn't be allowed to pick and choose which country they seek asylum in. They are in France, and other non-violent countries, yet seek asylum elsewhere. Refugees seek refuge in the first peaceful country they enter. I've got to get off this site. The liberal bulls*** is doing my head in. Cue some sarcastic reply applauding my decision to leave. Gee this site has really gotten boring.[/quote
But Jewish refugees from Nazi Germany in the 1930's went all over and didn't just end up next door in Poland or France and they weren't called migrants. if you are genuinely fleeing a war or murderous persecution wherever you end up surely you are still a refugee and not a migrant.
It is the manipulation of language that is interesting and our subservience to it.
It is entirely possible that the media are manipulating language but the expressions used officially are based on statute and conventions. Some expressions are used wrongly by the media such as deportation - which has a very precise meaning in law. The expressions such as illegal immigrant have bad connotations because of the way they were used as euphemisms in the 60s. Illegal immigrant is actually a reasonable description of someone who has entered the UK without permission. What is a poorer use of language is to label someone a refugee without knowing anything about their motives.
I would hope that being a citizen of Aleppo would tell those that can help that that is motive enough. Anyone who is on the receiving end and coming from a severe war-zone is a refugee.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
corkery Cork City 24 Aug 15 6.42pm |
|
|
Of the Migrants that claim asylum in Ireland, 92% are found not to be economic migrants and deported. I'm not sure how the rest of Europe adds up but I'd say figures like that make them say the word 'migrant.'
We'll never die
|
Stirlingsays 24 Aug 15 6.49pm |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 6.26pm
I meant just in the 1930's and before Poland was invaded. Many Jewish 'refugees' got out and the diaspora went worldwide. My point being of course that just because some chose to go further afield than the nearest safe haven did not stop them being refugees. Any Syrians fleeing IS and murderous persecution by their own government who end up here or in Germany or elsewhere are not 'migrants' however much the media or others with an agenda try to make it so.
It does stop them being refugees.
Unless they have a family or previous connection to a particular country they should be taking the first safe haven.
The use of WW2 as an excuse for moving towards richer northern European countries is patently ridiculous.
Italy or Greece are in absolutely no danger of an fundamentalist Islamic takeover.
The conceit that there is a binary choice between refugee and economic immigrant in many of these situations......is nonsense.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
| Hoof Hearted 24 Aug 15 6.50pm |
|
|
I call them Cuckoos.

Waits for indignant backlash.........
|