This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Sg Bilko at 30 Sep 2015 11.05am
The way I see it is, Europe as a whole is a predominantly Christian society and has been for many hundreds of years, and if other ethnic religions want to come and live amongst us they are welcome but they have to learn tolerance towards the Christian ways and adjust to our ways, just like we have to when we go to their Counties. I'm a frequent visitor to Egypt, and no way would I even try to force my Christian beliefs on them, if I did I would very quickly find myself in chains and thrown into their hellhole of a prison, and I've seen that done in Sharm-el-Sheikh to three Russians, and Egyptians don't invite you politely, your aggressively manhandled, and they are a very tolerant society compared to most others. Thing is, I've never actually experienced any attempt by Muslims to convert me or otherwise force their views on me, despite living in an area that has a sizable Muslim population. But there have been three visits in five years from the two 'evangelical' church asking if 'I'd be interested in hearing the good word' and a visit from the 'holy high pants of nonsense' brigade (Mormans). Our 'Christian Traditions' are essentially the product of a King having 'had enough of religious interference' in the domination of state, and deciding to resolve a four hundred year old problem. And yet, still that elimination of the power of religion, resulted in the Church of England and ultimately Anglican faiths coming about, and still ending up trying to decide for everyone how they should live and behave. Of course the irony of people defending a migrant belief system, that has its basis in militancy, and the middle east, as being rightfully the 'dominant faith' of the country and thus dismissing an older, and related faith, with the same god, as having any validity is amusing. The simple fact is that Abrahamic faiths are seeped in the idea of telling people what is right and demanding that they abide by their right to do so, even when it would be no problem to actually allow people to decide for themselves.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 30 Sep 2015 11.09am
Quote Sg Bilko at 30 Sep 2015 11.05am
The way I see it is, Europe as a whole is a predominantly Christian society and has been for many hundreds of years, and if other ethnic religions want to come and live amongst us they are welcome but they have to learn tolerance towards the Christian ways and adjust to our ways, just like we have to when we go to their Counties. I'm a frequent visitor to Egypt, and no way would I even try to force my Christian beliefs on them, if I did I would very quickly find myself in chains and thrown into their hellhole of a prison, and I've seen that done in Sharm-el-Sheikh to three Russians, and Egyptians don't invite you politely, your aggressively manhandled, and they are a very tolerant society compared to most others.
I am an atheist myself, but agree that our society is based on Christian beliefs, so visitors should respect that fact.[/quote] I'm an atheist, I reject the notion that Christian beliefs have any more validity than Muslim ones in determining how people's right to choose and live. Something the churches of England don't agree to with. They've always been defenders of stupid moral laws that simply have caused misery decade on decade and suffering for people who don't even have the same beliefs. Its not difficult either. If you don't want, say, an abortion, don't have one. If you don't want to have sex with someone of the same gender, don't do it. Don't want to get stoned, then don't take a hit from the bong and so on. That is all multi-culturalism actually requires. Not expecting other people to be you, and allowing people to be themselves, even if its stupid or reckless or against your selected probably nonexistent entities so called book and laws.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote sydtheeagle at 30 Sep 2015 2.04pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Sep 2015 1.04pm
I'm an atheist, I reject the notion that Christian beliefs have any more validity than Muslim ones in determining how people's right to choose and live. It's worth remembering that the C of E is presently mid-schism and doesn't even agree within itself how people should live. Well except when it comes to urging MPs and followers to oppose say 'assisted suicide' etc. There in lies the problem not that an organization has to state 'do this', but that it can use a democratic process in order to exert its will by getting its supporters to pressure, lobby and vote to determine how people will be allowed to live. For example, on Assisted Suicide. The outcome, is that many MPs followed their 'religious convictions' and voted against the bill, and in doing so, removed the right to choose from everyone else, and call it democracy (when in fact its not its a passive repression of freedom of the individual). Democracy to be real, must allow wherever possible, people to decide for themselves how to live their life, rather than have a majority in the position to dictate what is permitted (obviously where there in no clear consensus in society, the choice should be with the individual, not the majority).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Sg Bilko at 30 Sep 2015 2.51pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Sep 2015 12.57pm
Quote Sg Bilko at 30 Sep 2015 11.05am
The way I see it is, Europe as a whole is a predominantly Christian society and has been for many hundreds of years, and if other ethnic religions want to come and live amongst us they are welcome but they have to learn tolerance towards the Christian ways and adjust to our ways, just like we have to when we go to their Counties. I'm a frequent visitor to Egypt, and no way would I even try to force my Christian beliefs on them, if I did I would very quickly find myself in chains and thrown into their hellhole of a prison, and I've seen that done in Sharm-el-Sheikh to three Russians, and Egyptians don't invite you politely, your aggressively manhandled, and they are a very tolerant society compared to most others. Thing is, I've never actually experienced any attempt by Muslims to convert me or otherwise force their views on me, despite living in an area that has a sizable Muslim population. But there have been three visits in five years from the two 'evangelical' church asking if 'I'd be interested in hearing the good word' and a visit from the 'holy high pants of nonsense' brigade (Mormans). Our 'Christian Traditions' are essentially the product of a King having 'had enough of religious interference' in the domination of state, and deciding to resolve a four hundred year old problem. And yet, still that elimination of the power of religion, resulted in the Church of England and ultimately Anglican faiths coming about, and still ending up trying to decide for everyone how they should live and behave. Of course the irony of people defending a migrant belief system, that has its basis in militancy, and the middle east, as being rightfully the 'dominant faith' of the country and thus dismissing an older, and related faith, with the same god, as having any validity is amusing. The simple fact is that Abrahamic faiths are seeped in the idea of telling people what is right and demanding that they abide by their right to do so, even when it would be no problem to actually allow people to decide for themselves. They might have different views but they still have Christian values. Not really the point, the point was I don't get Muslims banging on my door at 10am on a Saturday or Sunday trying to get me to join their church. Who the f**k thinks that turning up to strangers houses to talk about god, uninvited, is in anyway acceptable? There are no Christian values, because there is no Christian god to underpin them. They're ideas for the most part, that people like. The difference between me, and them, maybe is that I would vote to support their right to be Christians and practice their faith even though its a nonsense to me, where as they would likely as not vote against allowing others to do things their faith considers wrong (abortion, gay marriage, drug legalization, euthanasia and so on). Its not just a religious thing. The principle of 'right to exert moral power over others' forms a strong current in our nation, probably from its Christian heritage.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote sydtheeagle at 30 Sep 2015 3.29pm
Second, and I am not religious myself, for all the harm you point out, I don't think we can deny that Christian (and other religious) values have also been a force for good. The shared values of religious communities that are vested in schools, hospitals, etc. (often free) have generally played an enormously beneficial role in society. The church has also played a critical counter-role in many countries that have been politically subjugated; it's not without reason that Stalin obsessed over destroying the Catholic Church in much of Eastern Europe. Just saying it's not all black and white. I generally agree, that religion has been probably a force for more good, than evil in the world. But that doesn't justify any kind of system where in a majority group can exert moral choices onto others. No group in society should have that right or capacity to inflict its moral character onto the population except where the population has a clear consensus (such as committing rape or where those choices would inhibit or harm the freedom of others). Wherever possible, each person should have as much freedom to make their own choices in life and about their lives, and how they wish to live them (that doesn't mean the state should necessarily fund them to do so).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote sydtheeagle at 30 Sep 2015 4.07pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Sep 2015 3.47pm
Wherever possible, each person should have as much freedom to make their own choices in life and about their lives, and how they wish to live them (that doesn't mean the state should necessarily fund them to do so). Agreed in principle but individuals, by nature, organise themselves into groups (basic Durkheim, if I remember right) and it's within those groups that values coalesce. You only have to go to Selhurst to see individuals willingly cede their identity and act in a collective rather than personal way. Personally,I think you are absolutely right.But objectively I just don't think things work along "each man for himself" lines not least because all too many individuals want air cover; they lack the courage to grasp the nettle. Edited by sydtheeagle (30 Sep 2015 4.09pm) I think we're conditioned into the idea of promoting shared values, beyond their required need, and that this does stem from Christian influence. The need to 'save souls' and to effectively push Christian values has a central place in Christianity. The concept of the missionary and the conversion of heathens and pagans runs throughout history, and that we as a society have essentially adopted this notion of organizational power to enforce its values onto others, irrespective of whether than want or need them. Central to Christianity is the idea that Christian Values are truth (its true of all Abrahamic faiths) and that these values apply to everyone, everywhere. However you don't really see this in say Buddhism, or Shinto or even most forms of Hinduism (arguably the first two aren't really religions in any sense we understand the term). It stems, arguably, from the foundation of Catholicism, which was a militant Christian faith. I think that we essentially have spent two thousand years or so, conditioning ourselves in the idea that its right to promote values as universally applicable to everyone, rather than being personal or community shared values. When you look at community shared values, they tend to be relevant to specific incidents and needs that occur in a group, and evolve from social participation of a group, rather than being dictated from authority figures.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.