This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by PZ Eagle
According to the Times Mark Clattenberg has stated that Niase dived and it wasn't a penalty. What say you now Willo?? This is the general consensus of opinion regarding the incident.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
This is the general consensus of opinion regarding the incident. Ahhh a sudden change of tune ?? General consensus? Except for Willo?
|
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
Ahhh a sudden change of tune ?? General consensus? Except for Willo? I have never advocated that there isn't general consensus regards the incident so I cannot be accused of changing my tune. As I have said, Taylor gave the decision based on what he saw from his angle and Gallagher reflected my viewpoint.The referee doesn't have access to umpteen 'Slow-Mos'. IF VAR had been in operation the outcome might have been different based on the referee's opinion based on what he had seen on the monitor. Edited by Willo (20 Nov 2017 8.03pm)
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
Ahhh a sudden change of tune ?? General consensus? Except for Willo? He never said the ref f***ed up, only that "refs err from time to time", as in this case. Only thing is that particular ref didn't just "err", he looked like the lost sheep in Isiah 51 : 6. Completely out of his depth. They've just done a whole spiel about VAR on TalkSh!te, in which a whole catalogue of ghastly decisions from last weekend was reeled off, including one that was even worse than the Niasse dive - an elbow in the face from Vincent Komany for Citeh against Leicester which was given a yellow card instead of a red in keeping with one of the Unwritten Laws of Football, the one that says "A player shall not be sent off for an offence committed in the first twenty minutes, no matter how horrible it may be".
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by bifffabazz
Willo is such a tease. And possibly blessed with a massive scoop of feminine side &/or serving as a politician. Anyways, whatever he may or may not be, he never answers a direct question, however cornered he becomes; always skirting and deflecting. If he had big t!ts I might think that my missus was secretly moonlighting under the Willo moniker! Whatever, it shouldn't have been a pen and the to$$er should be on a charge for simulation. Fact, not opinion. I can assure you there is nothing feminine about me and that I have never worn a skirt. You might say there is the 'Politician' in me and my goodness there are a few 'Jerry Paxman's' on here as well subjecting the politician to some interrogation.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I can assure you there is nothing feminine about me and that I have never worn a skirt. You might say there is the 'Politician' in me and my goodness there are a few 'Jerry Paxman's' on here as well subjecting the politician to some interrogation. We all like sheep :-) Not just any politician but a Tory one. Edited by chateauferret (20 Nov 2017 9.06pm)
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I have never advocated that there isn't general consensus regards the incident so I cannot be accused of changing my tune. As I have said, Taylor gave the decision based on what he saw from his angle and Gallagher reflected my viewpoint.The referee doesn't have access to umpteen 'Slow-Mos'. IF VAR had been in operation the outcome might have been different based on the referee's opinion based on what he had seen on the monitor. Edited by Willo (20 Nov 2017 8.03pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
He never said the ref f***ed up, only that "refs err from time to time", as in this case. Only thing is that particular ref didn't just "err", he looked like the lost sheep in Isiah 51 : 6. Completely out of his depth. They've just done a whole spiel about VAR on TalkSh!te, in which a whole catalogue of ghastly decisions from last weekend was reeled off, including one that was even worse than the Niasse dive - an elbow in the face from Vincent Komany for Citeh against Leicester which was given a yellow card instead of a red in keeping with one of the Unwritten Laws of Football, the one that says "A player shall not be sent off for an offence committed in the first twenty minutes, no matter how horrible it may be".
Firstly, yes I have said referees err from time to time but anyone viewing HOL without seeing my comments would think that with the vitriol against me I risibly said that referees get it right 100% of the time. Secondly, I understand the arguments made about referees being reluctant to issue cards when the game is in it's infancy.On the other hand, if one of our players wasn't issued with a 'Red' for an offence deserving of one when the game was in it's infancy there would card no complaints on here ! Sometimes issuing a card is a 50/50 call and if referees get too card happy there are complaints that he was too card happy and ruined the game.!
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Firstly, yes I have said referees err from time to time but anyone viewing HOL without seeing my comments would think that with the vitriol against me I risibly said that referees get it right 100% of the time. Secondly, I understand the arguments made about referees being reluctant to issue cards when the game is in it's infancy.On the other hand, if one of our players wasn't issued with a 'Red' for an offence deserving of one when the game was in it's infancy there would card no complaints on here ! Sometimes issuing a card is a 50/50 call and if referees get too card happy there are complaints that he was too card happy and ruined the game.! You enjoying Seaweed v Stoke, Willo? Another of your pals having a brilliant game. Not.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
We all like sheep :-) Not just any politician but a Tory one. Edited by chateauferret (20 Nov 2017 9.06pm) Well one cannot point to any "U-Turns" as my message is consistent.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Well one cannot point to any "U-Turns" as my message is consistent. And just as wrong as hers was.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
I really don't think that he had "Big club Leeds" in his head. It's a load of piffle to believe referees go on to the pitch with the idea of favouring a 'Big club'.Referees cannot see everything as they make decisions based on their view on the field of play which is of course very different from the umpteen views we see on TV. I'm am sure there were numerous decisions made by Gallagher which were a credit to his profession.I recall him as being a very capable referee who refereed on the PL for 15 years. Edited by Willo (20 Nov 2017 9.29pm)
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I really don't think that he had "Big club Leeds" in his head. Referees cannot see everything as they make decisions based on their view on the field of play which is of course very different from the umpteen views we see on TV. I'm am sure there were numerous decisions made by Gallagher which were a credit to his profession.I recall him as being a very capable referee. Let's just have a quick review of the weekend, shall we? Arsenal 2 Spurs 0 - Dean. Free kick for first goal at least contentious; both goals offside. Burnley 2 Swansea 0 - Atkinson. Nothing to report. Palace 2 Everton 2 - Taylor. Everyone here knows just how f***ing abysmal he was. Citeh 2 Leicester 0 - Scott. Failed to dismiss Kompany for a blatant elbow in the face. Bin dippers 3 Saints 0 - Jones. Nothing to report. West Brom 0 Chelsea 4 - Moss. Nothing to report. Man U 4 Toon 1 - Pawson. Ciaran Clark pulled Lukaku over by the shirt in the box. Nothing given. Bournemouth 4 Huddersfield 0: Probert. Clear foul for the first goal and clearly offside for the second. Also a player off the field who should have been allowed on. Watford 2 West Spam 0 - Marriner. Andy Carroll elbowed Zeegelar in the face. Should've been sent off. Nothing done. Seaweed 2 Stoke 2 - Mason. Failed to dismiss Murray for a clear red-card tackle. Failed to give Seaweed a pen for a clear foul in the box. Ten matches. Seven affected by serious errors by referees. That's just the Premier League. There was another ghastly cockup in the Leeds game in the Championship and what happened to Northern Ireland is also f***ing disgraceful. On what planet is that good enough? Edited by chateauferret (20 Nov 2017 10.22pm)
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Let's just have a quick review of the weekend, shall we? Arsenal 2 Spurs 0 - Dean. Free kick for first goal at least contentious; both goals offside. Burnley 2 Swansea 0 - Atkinson. Nothing to report. Palace 2 Everton 2 - Taylor. Everyone here knows just how f***ing abysmal he was. Citeh 2 Leicester 0 - Scott. Failed to dismiss Kompany for a blatant elbow in the face. Bin dippers 3 Saints 0 - Jones. Nothing to report. West Brom 0 Chelsea 4 - Moss. Nothing to report. Man U 4 Toon 1 - Pawson. Nothing to report. Bournemouth 4 Huddersfield 0: Probert. Clear foul for the first goal and clearly offside for the second. Also a player off the field who should have been allowed on. Watford 2 West Spam 0 - Marriner. Nothing to report. Seaweed 2 Stoke 2 - Mason. Failed to dismiss Murray for a clear red-card tackle. Failed to give Seaweed a pen for a clear foul in the box. Ten matches. Five affected by serious errors by referees. That's just the Premier League. There was another ghastly cockup in the Leeds game in the Championship and what happened to Northern Ireland is also f***ing disgraceful. On what planet is that good enough? I don't agree with all the 'Serious errors' that you have listed. But of course the excellent split-second decisions that I am sure were made throughout the weekend are simply not highlighted by the media as they are often not that obvious and of course the media concentrate on contentious issues. Off to eat now and then to bed.Goodnight.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I don't agree with all the 'Serious errors' that you have listed. But of course the excellent split-second decisions that I am sure were made throughout the weekend are simply not highlighted by the media as they are often not that obvious and of course the media concentrate on contentious issues. Off to eat now and then to bed.Goodnight. What fatuous logic. Absolute bollocks. It only takes one wrong decision to completely ruin a match, to change the outcome, and to leave half the spectators leaving the ground with the words "that ref was a disgrace" on their lips. But you think that's fine as long as they get most of the easy ones right. You can't really be that stupid so you must be doing this deliberately.
============ |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I don't agree with all the 'Serious errors' that you have listed. But of course the excellent split-second decisions that I am sure were made throughout the weekend are simply not highlighted by the media as they are often not that obvious and of course the media concentrate on contentious issues. Off to eat now and then to bed.Goodnight. Actually you're right: in that the list isn't quite complete. I forgot to mention Clark pulling Lukaku down by the shirt in the box, and Carroll's elbow in the face of Zeegelar. I've updated the list. So that's seven out of ten Premiership matches involving serious errors by the referee. Six of them are discussed here and all are listed as incorrect decisions. The ref review considers "every red card (or avoidance of one), every penalty and any other major incident every matchday". There were eight of those decisions over the weekend (not counting the Seaweed match tonight) and the refs got six of them wrong. 75% of major refereeing decisions in Premier League matches wrong. Three out of four. The seventh s*** ref performance of the weekend occurred this evening and wasn't reviewed, but the referee left the Amex to a chorus of loud boos from both sets of fans and was roundly condemned by the BBC commentary, so he presumably also has scant defence. Yet according to you 30% of Premier League matches being officiated correctly and fairly, 25% of major calls being right, is acceptable; because after all "most" of the decisions (the easy ones, at least) are OK. I've never heard such bollocks in all my life.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
What fatuous logic. Absolute bollocks. It only takes one wrong decision to completely ruin a match, to change the outcome, and to leave half the spectators leaving the ground with the words "that ref was a disgrace" on their lips. But you think that's fine as long as they get most of the easy ones right. You can't really be that stupid so you must be doing this deliberately. Hogwash. Grandstanding rhetoric to assert that "One wrong decision" automatically changes the course of a match.Suppose referees will be blamed for mistakes made at the back or forwards missing from close range.Just don't blame the players ! You mention "Easy ones", I never used these words.I mentioned that referees make some brilliant decisions but they are mostly overlooked as they are not headline news. Of course referees can err from time to time but to choose a selective list of so called "Wrong decisions" from one weekend to fit your agenda is not worth debating. Finally off to bed now.Just keep expecting referees to be 100% right ALL of the time when making split-second decisions with the naked eye in a fast moving game.
Edited by Willo (20 Nov 2017 11.01pm)
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Hogwash. Grandstanding rhetoric to assert that "One wrong decision" automatically changes the course of a match.Suppose referees will be blamed for mistakes made at the back or forwards missing from close range.Just don't blame the players ! You mention "Easy ones", I never used these words.I mentioned that referees make some brilliant decisions but they are mostly overlooked as they are not headline news. Of course referees can err from time to time but to choose a selective list of so called "Wrong decisions" from one weekend to fit your agenda is not worth debating. Finally off to bed now.Just expect referees to be 100% right ALL of the time when making split-second decisions with the naked eye in a fast moving game. Where did I make this claim? All I said was that 25%, 30% was not good enough. And if you think it is then you need your f***ing bumps felt. You wouldn't know what grandstanding rhetoric was if it got up and smacked you in the face. I gave you a list of hard facts: specific matches, specific decisions, specific references to expert analysis of them, even links to reports and video clips. That isn't grandstanding rhetoric, it's concrete evidence. True, only from one weekend, a weekend on which about 35% of football fans were ripped off by the officials. If by "brilliant decisions" you mean the big ones that they actually get right, this weekend they managed two out of the eight listed in the reviews I referenced. I suppose two out of eight could be called "some". I'd like them to get more than "some" of them right, and certainly more than a quarter. Nowhere did I mention 100%. My list isn't selective. I looked at every single PL game this weekend just gone, and at reviews of every single "big" decision (as defined above). All of them. Including the ones they got right. I did not "select" anything. The only "big" calls not included are the penalty appeals denied (there was one of those in our match). And those decisions aren't so-called anything. They're objectively, clearly and plainly incorrect. Bad decisions on big calls certainly do affect the outtomes of matches. Are you seriously claiming that: - a team reduced to ten men for nearly the whole game isn't significantly weakened? In fact it was asserted on TalkSh!te this evening, and by people who know far better than you or I, that the notorious ghost goal incident of 1980 affected Palace not only for that match but for the whole of the rest of the season and contributed significantly to our relegation. I don't know if I'd go that far but it certainly had effects that went well beyond that one game. (Happily it could not happen today, but the decisions I listed could be similarly significant). And of course this research only covered big decisions, it makes no mention of the constant failure to protect important players, the poor match management and the failure to apply the Laws consistently which we saw 95 minutes of on Saturday. It is you who are grandstanding, my friend, because it is you that are making statements unsupported with any evidence more solid than "my pal said this so it must be right" or "100 years ago I took a referees' test". It is you twist the words of others to put words like "100 per cent." into their mouths so that you can attack what they didn't say. And it is you who stick your fingers in your ears as soon as anyone produces evidence that demolishes your one and only argument. Typical Tory politician, I suppose.
============ |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.