This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by chris123
The Premier League is a corporation, so if changes are proposed why don't they just have a vote? They will in the next few days it will be 14 against six so they will be voted out. Remember the failed reforms that the big six wanted last year included reducing the voting rules for the PL now we know why. I presume they will be expelled and then the lawyers get involved and who knows where that goes but at a guess: 1. The PL has the right to decide who they're members are so I can't see the big six Being allowed to stay. Win for football. 2. FIFA banning the players from internationals will be problematic as they are punishing employees for an employers decision. I think the players will win that one. Win for the players. 3. Players at the big six e.g. Milner demanding a free transfer or release from contract. Again I think they have a good case as I expect the words Premier League, FIFA, UEFA will be all over their contracts and no mention of the ESL. Win for the players who want out of the big six. 4. Negotiated settlement. At some point I suspect the ESL and UEFA will reach a deal. However as they want more money and guaranteed spots in the competitions a settlement will favour the rebels. Loss for football world. 5. Capitulation. They come crawling back under the current rules.
Edited by Badger11 (20 Apr 2021 11.01am) Edited by Badger11 (20 Apr 2021 11.05am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
The best players in the world are not going to play for teams which restricts their access to the Premier League, La Liga, Bundesliga, Serie A, the Champions League or the World Cup. If they want to go we shouldn’t even be standing in their way - merely standing firm and enforcing the bans. I am catching up with this thread and saw this so forgive me if already answered by another. I am not so sure you are correct. A guaranteed E250M a year for each participating club mean they can pay any wage they like. The remaining EPL clubs will suffer diminishing returns (and I can't see how TV revenue won't fall without the international cache of the popular clubs) and can't compete. It will attract the best players on the planet and we will just be another feeder club. Most owners and all players alike are loyal only to money and players have long considered international duty as little more than a booster to their personal sportswear sponsorship revenue. So even if the best players are hoofed out of their national teams, all that will do is devalue the summer tournaments we so look forward to. I would love the government to intervene to ensure no player is restricted from walking out of his rebel club if he chooses to, imposing substantial windfall tax on the 6 clubs and any broadcaster who seeks to stream their games etc. However, all this will do will be to force the teams to relocate to friendly countries and play there. Whether it remains commercially viable if the ESL is not being legally broadcast in the very continent it seeks to be the elite representative of is, I suspect, the only thing that will stop it. Couple this with full ejection from the domestic leagues and cup games and the main news media refusing to report on any ESL games, and it will disappear from our collective consciousness. Give it a generation, as another has said, and new elites will emerge as all the teams go up a peg. Regrettably, that will not happen. Neither the UK, EFTA, or the EU will do this. And the tp leagues will be motivated by short term self interest and allow the rebel clubs to field teams in the domestic cups etc. ESL will go ahead if they wish it to, the threats will all fizzle out in in-fighting and acrimony, people will pay vast sums in pay-per-view world over, and the game as we know it will only exist in a very diluted form. Essentially, Palace will be relegated to a lesser tier without actually going down.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I am catching up with this thread and saw this so forgive me if already answered by another. I am not so sure you are correct. A guaranteed E250M a year for each participating club mean they can pay any wage they like. The remaining EPL clubs will suffer diminishing returns (and I can't see how TV revenue won't fall without the international cache of the popular clubs) and can't compete. It will attract the best players on the planet and we will just be another feeder club. Most owners and all players alike are loyal only to money and players have long considered international duty as little more than a booster to their personal sportswear sponsorship revenue. So even if the best players are hoofed out of their national teams, all that will do is devalue the summer tournaments we so look forward to. I would love the government to intervene to ensure no player is restricted from walking out of his rebel club if he chooses to, imposing substantial windfall tax on the 6 clubs and any broadcaster who seeks to stream their games etc. However, all this will do will be to force the teams to relocate to friendly countries and play there. Whether it remains commercially viable if the ESL is not being legally broadcast in the very continent it seeks to be the elite representative of is, I suspect, the only thing that will stop it. Couple this with full ejection from the domestic leagues and cup games and the main news media refusing to report on any ESL games, and it will disappear from our collective consciousness. Give it a generation, as another has said, and new elites will emerge as all the teams go up a peg. Regrettably, that will not happen. Neither the UK, EFTA, or the EU will do this. And the tp leagues will be motivated by short term self interest and allow the rebel clubs to field teams in the domestic cups etc. ESL will go ahead if they wish it to, the threats will all fizzle out in in-fighting and acrimony, people will pay vast sums in pay-per-view world over, and the game as we know it will only exist in a very diluted form. Essentially, Palace will be relegated to a lesser tier without actually going down. Excellent post. I have just posted that the end game will be a rival Premier League with invited UK clubs and no relegation it's the only way that the ESL makes sense. I hope I am wrong.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
They will in the next few days it will be 14 against six so they will be voted out. Remember the failed reforms that the big six wanted last year included reducing the voting rules for the PL now we know why. I presume they will be expelled and then the lawyers get involved and who knows where that goes but at a guess: 1. The PL has the right to decide who they're members are so I can't see the big six Being allowed to stay. Win for football. 2. FIFA banning the players from internationals will be problematic as they are punishing employees for an employers decision. I think the players will win that one. Win for the players. 3. Players at the big six e.g. Milner demanding a free transfer or release from contract. Again I think they have a good case as I expect the words Premier League, FIFA, UEFA will be all over their contracts and no mention of the ESL. Win for the players who want out of the big six. 4. Negotiated settlement. At some point I suspect the ESL and UEFA will reach a deal. However as they want more money and guaranteed spots in the competitions a settlement will favour the rebels. Loss for football world. 5. Capitulation. They come crawling back under the current rules.
Edited by Badger11 (20 Apr 2021 11.01am) Edited by Badger11 (20 Apr 2021 11.05am) But if the proposal fails, why should the PL do anything? The six can walk away if they wish, but if the vote is properly constituted, I'd have thought a status quo would be quite legal and proper?
|
|
| michaelpearce |
|
|---|---|
|
well if fans stop supporting these clubs Palace will benefit as we are the nearest to the Manu fan base,
|
|
|
Originally posted by manwitheagletattoo
I have questions 1.. Where are these so called Super clubs going to buy players to keep them in this super league..I cannot think for one minute that these 12 clubs are going to have a transfer market between themselves and weaken their so called prospects of winning the JP Morgan Cup or are they going to rely on youth policy. ? 2/ Are not all Referees registered to UEFA and their respective Football Associations. Seeing as UEFA are against this Super League how are these Super matches going to be refereed or are they going to set up a Super league referee association. 3/ What is going to happen if these clubs players don’t want to play in this Super League how are these clubs going to enforce contracts they just cannot force a player to play nor can let they let a player walk away., Manchester China FC have already roped in their 2 referee's Howard Webb & Mark Clattenberg. Others are applying as we speak.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
I think the ESL is a good idea. It's given everyone a common enemy.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
Ruben den Broeder emails in to suggest what football can learn from F1: “In Formula 1, concerns emerged over both the hegemony of Mercedes for seven straight years and the huge amounts of money spent by the big teams. Instead of the big teams crying for ever more money to continue the hegemony, they illustrated they actually cared about the sport itself and about the smaller teams: a budget cap will be imposed starting next season. This will level the playing field and prevent major financial difficulties down the road for the teams.
It was interesting to read this Guardian article, glad you put it out here. I have seen similarities in this ESL proposal, not with modern day F1, but with the rebellion which took place in what was then known simply as Grand Prix racing in the 70s and 80s. Without going into all the detail a certain Mr Bernard Ecclestone led the setting up of the Formula One Constructors Association in 1981 I think it was. The idea was to change the way prize money was distributed among other things. There were a lot of protestations from the traditionalists who thought the sport would be ruined. The rest is history and F1 became a 'sport' requiring billions to run and it made Ecclestone a very wealthy man. Certainly not everybody's cup of tea and one of the reasons historic car racing is so popular. Goes back to it's roots.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.