You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Akshata Murty tax affairs
November 21 2026 9.56pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Akshata Murty tax affairs


Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 17 Apr 22 12.34am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Is the main objection that she’s rich or that she’s married to a Tory?

It is that she lives in the UK, which is clearly her main residence, but pays no tax here to the benefit of her, her husband and her children. It is that the rules should be tightened but her husband is responsible for the rules and is therefore disincentivised. It is that her husband just put up NIC for all EXCEPT for non-employment related income and so is uniquely almost unaffected by his decision. It is that the Chancellor should pay the same taxes as everyone else.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 17 Apr 22 12.39am

Originally posted by Mapletree

It is that she lives in the UK, which is clearly her main residence, but pays no tax here to the benefit of her, her husband and her children. It is that the rules should be tightened but her husband is responsible for the rules and is therefore disincentivised. It is that her husband just put up NIC for all EXCEPT for non-employment related income and so is uniquely almost unaffected by his decision. It is that the Chancellor should pay the same taxes as everyone else.

Yes, right, but none of those were options. Rich or Married to a Tory?

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 17 Apr 22 12.39am

Originally posted by Mapletree

It is that she lives in the UK, which is clearly her main residence, but pays no tax here to the benefit of her, her husband and her children. It is that the rules should be tightened but her husband is responsible for the rules and is therefore disincentivised. It is that her husband just put up NIC for all EXCEPT for non-employment related income and so is uniquely almost unaffected by his decision. It is that the Chancellor should pay the same taxes as everyone else.

FFS, try and keep up. She paid tax here on her UK income and paid a fee for doing so. That is the prevailing rule. To state she pays no tax here is not correct.

That your post has basic error is no surprise.

Edited by HKOwen (17 Apr 2022 12.40am)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 17 Apr 22 1.10am

Originally posted by BlueJay

Vast numbers of people in fact. I quoted your posts. You can always reference back to that or your actual posts if you have no memory of what you said (which seems to be a recurrent theme).

I'm not opening this thread anymore. This pointless back and forth isn't adding anything, so I'll opt out.

Edited by BlueJay (16 Apr 2022 10.54am)

"Vast numbers"? Really? Or just the SJW idiots.

You did indeed quote my posts, but for some reason felt the need to inform me of what you think they mean, instead of what I typed (which is a recurrent theme!).

And now, unsurprisingly, you flounce off again.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 17 Apr 22 1.19am

Originally posted by HKOwen

It's clearly annoying you that your posts are systematically picked apart by toddlers and idiots

It wouldn't be annoying even if someone did pick my posts apart, but as you're obviously talking about BlueJay, he picks nothing apart, he merely twists the words of others to suit his assault of opposing ideas. Even to the point of telling people how they really think.

But if you are just posting a 'Rah rah rah' rallying cry for BJ, then you are probably one of those seeking to pick my posts apart.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 17 Apr 22 1.29am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

He says if you’re unhappy about something then change it. But he also calls people outraged idiots if they go and protest. Further he conveniently ignores the fact it’s been a two party political system for a century. Making it easy for the government and the establishment by seeing it this way clearly doesn’t help.

That is a false statement. Show where I have said this. Or at least show some integrity and retract it.

What the fact a two party system has to do with repealing laws has got to do with anything, I'm unsure. Poll Tax got repealed within a century. But not by posting on social media, thats what outraged idiots do. If you want change, go and protest.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 17 Apr 22 1.56am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Can you please explain this

She doesn't pay income tax or NIC in the UK. The money she spends is Sunak's so e.g. VAT is coming from his funds not hers. She has committed to voluntarily pay income tax in two years time, let's see whether that does happen.

So much wrong with this.

She doesn't pay income tax as her income is made in another country. She has non dom status. Which is allowed.

Admittedly, she pays no NIC. But I very seriously doubt that she will be using the NHS, or trying to draw a state pension.

VAT is paid by all consumers in this country. It's really quite irrelevant where the money comes from, as long as the VAT is paid. Rishi's not claiming VAT rebates for his wife. More people spending money, more VAT in the HMRC coffers. But for some reason, you think only her husband pays it, even though they are a couple, and have kids, and shop in this country.

There will be a time when she will have to pay all her taxes in this country if she stays here, which I believe is 2028, and she will be required to become a British citizen. So if she opts to give up her Indian domicle earlier and pay UK taxes, she would have to give up her right to vote, and sell her assets and property, in India. Which is something not many people would be willing to do.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 17 Apr 22 2.02am

Originally posted by cryrst

But he's correct that she paid more tax in the UK than any of us though.
It's either about pound notes or %. Can't mix the two.

I think they're just angry because she is wealthy. Whatever she pays wouldn't be enough. It the politics of envy.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

cryrst Flag The garden of England 17 Apr 22 6.08am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3714342]

I think they're just angry because she is wealthy. Whatever she pays wouldn't be enough. It the politics of envy.

I'm thinking the same. My original post had an error and should have said 'many of us", not any of us before that gets spotted by a n other. I'm glad maple is comfortable enough to pay over 30k in tax himself. Whether he could pay more and doesn't because the rules allow him not to is a question in itself. Its surprising the receipts an accountant can use against what you should pay.
Anyhow I'm sure the chancellors wife hasn't broken any laws and once she pays a tax she doesn't have to the door will open more so extra shovels and diggers can be found.
I really want labour to get in power soon. Not because they are good but because they are sooo bad and reality will smack a few people. Share the wealth will take on a new meaning. Tax tax and even more tax.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 17 Apr 22 8.28am

This is a difficult issue. Tax is a legal obligation but also seen as a moral issue.

I have little doubt that she has paid the right amount of tax according to the law but as the law in the UK is such that you don't pay for ax on worldwide income as you do in other countries she has not paid tax at a level she would say in the level she would in some other places.

It's a oddity in the UK system which can be argued to attract money into the UK.

But tax is taxing. I do see an irony in the £millions the UK government pays Infosys that swell the Murray coffers and that the Chancellor indirectly benefits from

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 17 Apr 22 8.39am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3714341]

So much wrong with this.

She doesn't pay income tax as her income is made in another country. She has non dom status. Which is allowed.

Admittedly, she pays no NIC. But I very seriously doubt that she will be using the NHS, or trying to draw a state pension.

VAT is paid by all consumers in this country. It's really quite irrelevant where the money comes from, as long as the VAT is paid. Rishi's not claiming VAT rebates for his wife. More people spending money, more VAT in the HMRC coffers. But for some reason, you think only her husband pays it, even though they are a couple, and have kids, and shop in this country.

There will be a time when she will have to pay all her taxes in this country if she stays here, which I believe is 2028, and she will be required to become a British citizen. So if she opts to give up her Indian domicle earlier and pay UK taxes, she would have to give up her right to vote, and sell her assets and property, in India. Which is something not many people would be willing to do.

Are you saying an NRI can’t hold property or assets in India?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 17 Apr 22 8.40am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Yes, right, but none of those were options. Rich or Married to a Tory?

Clearly neither

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 17 Apr 22 8.47am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

This is a difficult issue. Tax is a legal obligation but also seen as a moral issue.

I have little doubt that she has paid the right amount of tax according to the law but as the law in the UK is such that you don't pay for ax on worldwide income as you do in other countries she has not paid tax at a level she would say in the level she would in some other places.

It's a oddity in the UK system which can be argued to attract money into the UK.

But tax is taxing. I do see an irony in the £millions the UK government pays Infosys that swell the Murray coffers and that the Chancellor indirectly benefits from

That is the crux of the problem when people start demanding that somebody should pay more tax even though they have done nothing wrong.

It's like a cop pulling you over for speeding and when you object and tell him your were under the speed limit he says "yes but morally you were speeding."

I have said for years we need to simplify our tax system close most of the tax loopholes which in turn would allow the basic rate to be lowered.

I quite like the idea of a flat rate system where everybody body the same rate based on their income (Singapore?) and their are no tax loopholes. If you earn £1m but your net income is £100,000 tough you pay tax on £1m. The tax rate would more likely be around 12 or 15%.

 


One more point

Mapletree Flag Croydon 17 Apr 22 9.04am

Originally posted by HKOwen

FFS, try and keep up. She paid tax here on her UK income and paid a fee for doing so. That is the prevailing rule. To state she pays no tax here is not correct.

That your post has basic error is no surprise.

Edited by HKOwen (17 Apr 2022 12.40am)

What, in Hong Kong?

She paid the ‘annual charge’ but not tax on her earnings. Do keep up.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 17 Apr 22 9.15am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3714341]

So much wrong with this.

She doesn't pay income tax as her income is made in another country. She has non dom status. Which is allowed.

Admittedly, she pays no NIC. But I very seriously doubt that she will be using the NHS, or trying to draw a state pension.

VAT is paid by all consumers in this country. It's really quite irrelevant where the money comes from, as long as the VAT is paid. Rishi's not claiming VAT rebates for his wife. More people spending money, more VAT in the HMRC coffers. But for some reason, you think only her husband pays it, even though they are a couple, and have kids, and shop in this country.

There will be a time when she will have to pay all her taxes in this country if she stays here, which I believe is 2028, and she will be required to become a British citizen. So if she opts to give up her Indian domicle earlier and pay UK taxes, she would have to give up her right to vote, and sell her assets and property, in India. Which is something not many people would be willing to do.

She will pay uk tax if she is resident in the UK for at least 15 of the 20 tax years immediately before the relevant tax year. I am not aware she will be required to’become’ a British citizen, she will just be taxed on an arising not a remittance basis.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Apr 22 9.47am

Nothing to do with how rich she is. That is just people with little left to defend it with. He is the chancellor. He has almost as much power as the PM. Certainly financially he does. He decides what tax everyone pays while doing this. But it isn’t only this. There’s the US green cards. Why? And what happens in 2028 when she’ll need to relinquish or sell her assets in India or return to India? Does he leave politics? Infosys hey? Profits for cabinet individuals when the opportunities arise but avoid the tax. Then there’s the conflict of interest and so far no mention of these tightening these loopholes and advantages he is using. Just getting very annoyed at everyone else. The cronyism and taking advantage of us and what opportunities present for themselves and blatantly using them for huge multimillion pond profits isn’t the kind of party I feel comfortable voting for with this current lot in it.

Some of us have gone from thinking it’s someone’s right to make a lot of money to it’s the government’s right to take as much as they can while the opportunity is there. It’s nothing to do with how rich she is. That’s for the left wingers and The Daily Mirror.

 


COYP

Mapletree Flag Croydon 17 Apr 22 10.15am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3714341]

So much wrong with this.

She doesn't pay income tax as her income is made in another country. She has non dom status. Which is allowed.

Admittedly, she pays no NIC. But I very seriously doubt that she will be using the NHS, or trying to draw a state pension.

VAT is paid by all consumers in this country. It's really quite irrelevant where the money comes from, as long as the VAT is paid. Rishi's not claiming VAT rebates for his wife. More people spending money, more VAT in the HMRC coffers. But for some reason, you think only her husband pays it, even though they are a couple, and have kids, and shop in this country.

There will be a time when she will have to pay all her taxes in this country if she stays here, which I believe is 2028, and she will be required to become a British citizen. So if she opts to give up her Indian domicle earlier and pay UK taxes, she would have to give up her right to vote, and sell her assets and property, in India. Which is something not many people would be willing to do.

As a non-resident she has no right to NHS services unless she pays for them.

That must be awkward.

Edited by Mapletree (17 Apr 2022 12.17pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Apr 22 10.36am

The NHS and all other services are not an opt in-opt out option. Everyone having access to services and everything being maintained has a benefit for all. If they weren’t there then crime and breakdowns in society would be worse. I live here but won’t pay because I’m not likely to use them doesn’t wash. And what if she causes a car crash and injuries to others? No education for all means crime and crime on her demographic (level of wealth) as well.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (17 Apr 2022 10.38am)

 


COYP

Teddy Eagle Flag 17 Apr 22 11.09am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Clearly neither

Clearly.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Apr 22 11.19am

We all hated how Blair used his status to make money. Nothing to do with being a Tory, which I and others have voted. That is partly how they get away with it. Well they shouldn’t and I think they’re going to find that out. Unfortunately we may end up with a Kier Labour government so we’ll see. But that threat is wearing thin and governments lose elections rather than opposition’s winning them. One term of Kier might sweep out all the sh1te in the Tory cabinet.

 


COYP

Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Akshata Murty tax affairs