You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bad recruitment
November 16 2026 3.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bad recruitment


Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
DANGERCLOSE Flag London 19 Mar 23 5.49pm

This team is bad, Recruitment has been a massive let down over the last couple of seasons. Our full back's are not up to the task, KG should have been replaced and we needed experienced striker's.
We have ridden our luck over the last couple of years and now the chickens have finally come home to roost.

SP and Co are to blame.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 19 Mar 23 5.50pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

This team is bad, Recruitment has been a massive let down over the last couple of seasons. Our full back's are not up to the task, KG should have been replaced and we needed experienced striker's.
We have ridden our luck over the last couple of years and now the chickens have finally come home to roost.

SP and Co are to blame.

Who is KG?

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 19 Mar 23 5.57pm

Originally posted by Painter

Who is KG?

I think he meant CG unless he really did mean King George?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Dubai Eagle Flag 19 Mar 23 6.04pm

I was thinking of Kagisho Dikgacoi (everyone used to call him KG)


Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

I think he meant CG unless he really did mean King George?

 

Irisheagle87 Flag Co.Derry 19 Mar 23 6.13pm

Mateta. That says all we need to know. Still think we will be ok this year. Could be a long season next campaign.

 


THE 17th OF MAY. MY 17th BIRTHDAY. MICHEAL HUGHES SCORES THE WINNING PENALTY, WHAT WAS HIS NUMBER? 17!!!!!

bryne and holton Flag 19 Mar 23 6.28pm

The current woeful form of Mateta and Edourd is the main problem
for the club.
But the recruitment strategy also needs close analysis.
The club paid a reported £1 million for Plange. He is considered
inferior by the club to the aforementioned two.
He must be pretty awful !

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 19 Mar 23 7.20pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

This team is bad, Recruitment has been a massive let down over the last couple of seasons. Our full back's are not up to the task, KG should have been replaced and we needed experienced striker's.
We have ridden our luck over the last couple of years and now the chickens have finally come home to roost.

SP and Co are to blame.

It hasn't. Its actually been really good. Its the 6 seasons before that has hurt us

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Mar 23 7.44pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

It hasn't. Its actually been really good. Its the 6 seasons before that has hurt us

I don't know if I'd go so far as to say "really good", but it certainly had its moments. But that's only on the basis of doing half the job.

As I see, there are two parts (or halves) to recruitment:

1. Player replacement
2. Player signings

In terms of 2, we've done pretty well. Eze, Olise, Guehi, Andersen, Schlupp, and Hughes, have all looked to some degree or another like decent signings, some very good indeed. Edouard and Mateta have been disasters, but they're very much the minority. More signing have been good than bad. Unfortunately, both of our terrible signings have come in the same position, so that's had a greater impact than it should.

In terms of point 1, though, our recruitment has been awful. We have simply not replaced key players, and as a result, the squad suffers from having a number that are way, way past their sell-by dates. Ward should have been put out to pasture two years ago, Clyne at least a year ago, Luka two years ago, Tomkins two years ago, McArthur probably two years ago, and Conor was never replaced at all. That's left six yawning chasms in what's a small squad to begin with. Most of the above can barely even contribute for ten minutes off the bench, let alone provide competition within the squad. Heaven knows I love Joel Ward, but he was just embarassing today. And to add insult to injury, we've repeatedly recruited sick notes. Nathan Ferguson? Seriously? He was broken before we bought him. How was that ever going to end well? Chris Richards...great player, but perpetually injured everywhere he's been. What was the point? Someone to keep Ferguson company on the physio's table?

The reality is that the success of a handful of our signings has obscured the fact that our overall recruiting strategy has been appalling and now we're paying the price for it with an unbalanced, weak squad that has no depth and provides the manager with no alternatives when the going gets tough. In short, we're a mess.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Swindy Flag Bromley 19 Mar 23 7.52pm

It is kind to call it bad !!!
Ferguson ? Who he ??
Benteke not replaced
Gallagher not replaced
Kouyate not replaced
The new lad from Stuttgart, why not starting ?

Not recruitment, but why all the more promising youngsters allowed to go out on loan for the season with no clause to return early ?
I understand that was one of the tailor's dummy Parish's requirements of PV was to start integrating some youngsters - this was forced on the club this week when Spain's finest ?? went down injured so a 19 year old had to be played in goal because we had loaned a perfectly good ex-England goalkeeper for the rest of the season to Moan Utd !!
You couldn't write it. That dummy Freedman, what does he do ??
This has been my 50th season following our club and in all honesty, despite some horrendous years(1980-81 and the Mullery immediately spring to mind), this will go down as one of the worst, irrespective of whether, by a miracle, we stay up, the playing staff needs massive surgery.
We are also going nowhere fast whilst Parish is still involved withthis club.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 19 Mar 23 7.57pm

Originally posted by bryne and holton

The current woeful form of Mateta and Edourd is the main problem
for the club.
But the recruitment strategy also needs close analysis.
The club paid a reported £1 million for Plange. He is considered
inferior by the club to the aforementioned two.
He must be pretty awful !

To be fair a million these days is a couple of weeks wages for some. I think the majority on he thought the purchases of Anderson, Geuhi, Doucoure, Olise, Eze, Hughes, Eduaord were excellent when we signed them. Personally I had never heard of Mateta or Ahamada before we signed them. I don’t think any of them have been a disaster (Max Meyer style) but clearly some better than others.

We have had a really tough run of games. We have tried to play Royball and we have ground out a few welcome points. But now we play teams we can and should beat. Confidence is low. But we look a far better team on the front foot. We need to stick with a front three Zaha left Olise right and Edouard in the middle. Doucoure Lakonga and Schlup in midfield and our best back four if fit. We need to play on the front foot and attack especially at home.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 19 Mar 23 8.20pm

Originally posted by Painter

Who is KG?

Sorry I ment Connor Gallagher

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 19 Mar 23 8.52pm

I want to write something positive .... but watching the Arsenal debacle today made it clear that it will take a herculean effort to stay up, because we have so many weak spots that the teams below us will exploit. Our team identity needs a reboot.

Two weeks to reignite passion, grit, determination and team spirit.... then we can cover off the weaknesses and perhaps exploit some explosive counterattacking football.

Better get someone in charge real fast!

Edited by radicalsteve (19 Mar 2023 8.53pm)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 19 Mar 23 9.25pm

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

I don't know if I'd go so far as to say "really good", but it certainly had its moments. But that's only on the basis of doing half the job.

As I see, there are two parts (or halves) to recruitment:

1. Player replacement
2. Player signings

In terms of 2, we've done pretty well. Eze, Olise, Guehi, Andersen, Schlupp, and Hughes, have all looked to some degree or another like decent signings, some very good indeed. Edouard and Mateta have been disasters, but they're very much the minority. More signing have been good than bad. Unfortunately, both of our terrible signings have come in the same position, so that's had a greater impact than it should.

In terms of point 1, though, our recruitment has been awful. We have simply not replaced key players, and as a result, the squad suffers from having a number that are way, way past their sell-by dates. Ward should have been put out to pasture two years ago, Clyne at least a year ago, Luka two years ago, Tomkins two years ago, McArthur probably two years ago, and Conor was never replaced at all. That's left six yawning chasms in what's a small squad to begin with. Most of the above can barely even contribute for ten minutes off the bench, let alone provide competition within the squad. Heaven knows I love Joel Ward, but he was just embarassing today. And to add insult to injury, we've repeatedly recruited sick notes. Nathan Ferguson? Seriously? He was broken before we bought him. How was that ever going to end well? Chris Richards...great player, but perpetually injured everywhere he's been. What was the point? Someone to keep Ferguson company on the physio's table?

The reality is that the success of a handful of our signings has obscured the fact that our overall recruiting strategy has been appalling and now we're paying the price for it with an unbalanced, weak squad that has no depth and provides the manager with no alternatives when the going gets tough. In short, we're a mess.

Nicely written.

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 19 Mar 23 10.40pm

We had well defined shortcomings in January, so we spend 10 million quid on someone who cannot step into the starting line up and gets cameo substitutions ... Can someone explain to me this amazingly insightful recruiting strategy? Freedman should have been fired before Patrick

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Nicely written.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 19 Mar 23 11.43pm

Originally posted by radicalsteve

I want to write something positive .... but watching the Arsenal debacle today made it clear that it will take a herculean effort to stay up, because we have so many weak spots that the teams below us will exploit. Our team identity needs a reboot.

Two weeks to reignite passion, grit, determination and team spirit.... then we can cover off the weaknesses and perhaps exploit some explosive counterattacking football.

Better get someone in charge real fast!

Edited by radicalsteve (19 Mar 2023 8.53pm)

I hear we're really going for it ... rumours abound on bringing Roy back to look after us for our last few weeks in the PL. We're also planning for the future by offering Zaha £200k a week!!!! This is the same guy who has done $od all for us since Christmas and appears totally disinterested on his current measly £130k a week. Money speaks but the football certainly doesn’t.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

crvenaeagle Flag 20 Mar 23 6.32am

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

I don't know if I'd go so far as to say "really good", but it certainly had its moments. But that's only on the basis of doing half the job.

As I see, there are two parts (or halves) to recruitment:

1. Player replacement
2. Player signings

In terms of 2, we've done pretty well. Eze, Olise, Guehi, Andersen, Schlupp, and Hughes, have all looked to some degree or another like decent signings, some very good indeed. Edouard and Mateta have been disasters, but they're very much the minority. More signing have been good than bad. Unfortunately, both of our terrible signings have come in the same position, so that's had a greater impact than it should.

In terms of point 1, though, our recruitment has been awful. We have simply not replaced key players, and as a result, the squad suffers from having a number that are way, way past their sell-by dates. Ward should have been put out to pasture two years ago, Clyne at least a year ago, Luka two years ago, Tomkins two years ago, McArthur probably two years ago, and Conor was never replaced at all. That's left six yawning chasms in what's a small squad to begin with. Most of the above can barely even contribute for ten minutes off the bench, let alone provide competition within the squad. Heaven knows I love Joel Ward, but he was just embarassing today. And to add insult to injury, we've repeatedly recruited sick notes. Nathan Ferguson? Seriously? He was broken before we bought him. How was that ever going to end well? Chris Richards...great player, but perpetually injured everywhere he's been. What was the point? Someone to keep Ferguson company on the physio's table?

The reality is that the success of a handful of our signings has obscured the fact that our overall recruiting strategy has been appalling and now we're paying the price for it with an unbalanced, weak squad that has no depth and provides the manager with no alternatives when the going gets tough. In short, we're a mess.

Essentially what I wrote on another thread Syd, really sad to see.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 20 Mar 23 8.28am

The thing that annoys me the most is that teams like Brighton and Brentford seem to be able to identify players from lower leagues that are available for a couple of million or so and who slot seamlessly into the team whereas we buy players like Ahamada for £10m and Richards, then decide they are not ready for the first team.

This also reflects on our overall profitability as we are not generating sufficient revenue from improving players and selling them on (AWB being the notable exception.)

I would say the best signing we could possibly make is to splash the cash on Brighton’s recruitment team and sack Dougie, but alas he appears untouchable.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 20 Mar 23 8.35am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

The thing that annoys me the most is that teams like Brighton and Brentford seem to be able to identify players from lower leagues that are available for a couple of million or so and who slot seamlessly into the team whereas we buy players like Ahamada for £10m and Richards, then decide they are not ready for the first team.

This also reflects on our overall profitability as we are not generating sufficient revenue from improving players and selling them on (AWB being the notable exception.)

I would say the best signing we could possibly make is to splash the cash on Brighton’s recruitment team and sack Dougie, but alas he appears untouchable.

Parish needs his mates around to buff his ego.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 20 Mar 23 9.13am

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

I don't know if I'd go so far as to say "really good", but it certainly had its moments. But that's only on the basis of doing half the job.

As I see, there are two parts (or halves) to recruitment:

1. Player replacement
2. Player signings

In terms of 2, we've done pretty well. Eze, Olise, Guehi, Andersen, Schlupp, and Hughes, have all looked to some degree or another like decent signings, some very good indeed. Edouard and Mateta have been disasters, but they're very much the minority. More signing have been good than bad. Unfortunately, both of our terrible signings have come in the same position, so that's had a greater impact than it should.

In terms of point 1, though, our recruitment has been awful. We have simply not replaced key players, and as a result, the squad suffers from having a number that are way, way past their sell-by dates. Ward should have been put out to pasture two years ago, Clyne at least a year ago, Luka two years ago, Tomkins two years ago, McArthur probably two years ago, and Conor was never replaced at all. That's left six yawning chasms in what's a small squad to begin with. Most of the above can barely even contribute for ten minutes off the bench, let alone provide competition within the squad. Heaven knows I love Joel Ward, but he was just embarassing today. And to add insult to injury, we've repeatedly recruited sick notes. Nathan Ferguson? Seriously? He was broken before we bought him. How was that ever going to end well? Chris Richards...great player, but perpetually injured everywhere he's been. What was the point? Someone to keep Ferguson company on the physio's table?

The reality is that the success of a handful of our signings has obscured the fact that our overall recruiting strategy has been appalling and now we're paying the price for it with an unbalanced, weak squad that has no depth and provides the manager with no alternatives when the going gets tough. In short, we're a mess.

It’s easy to say, they should have got rid of different players, but if they are under contract and nobody wants to buy them, you have a problem. It was widely stated that we would enter a transitional period of moving to younger players with resale value, you can’t do this in a couple of transfer windows it takes time.
Every club has fans that complain about recruitment, nothing is ever good enough, it’s the nature of expectation.
The main problem this season is the players aren’t fit enough or motivated enough, that is squarely the responsibility of the manager and coaching staff. How many games have we faded in the second half and given away goals?

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 20 Mar 23 9.15am

Originally posted by radicalsteve

We had well defined shortcomings in January, so we spend 10 million quid on someone who cannot step into the starting line up and gets cameo substitutions ... Can someone explain to me this amazingly insightful recruiting strategy? Freedman should have been fired before Patrick

There's still quite a few games remaining but the most important thing at the time was the gap between us and trouble which was considerable, it is quite obvious that our club took a gamble with the squad it had and who could predict what was going to happen at the time.

 

Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bad recruitment