You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Zaha
November 16 2026 3.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Zaha


Page 10 of 57 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 31 May 23 5.04pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Mystifying, really, as striking is something the French are usually pretty good at.

:-)

Still one out, all out.

 

Jacey Flag 31 May 23 5.13pm

Originally posted by pax3908

Win ,lose or draw it doesn't matter now,it is more important Wilf makes his mind up what he wants to do,because his indecisiveness now if he stays or goes is cocking up the decision making,of who or what we need to get in for next season!!!

Wilf is behaving like a spoilt brat!!

Edited by Jacey (31 May 2023 6.22pm)

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 31 May 23 5.17pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Wilf is still the difference between us and some teams in the League - and he still could be if he wants to stay.
My take on it is that he wants 4 years and we don't.
However - if he made the difference - total difference - as he would have done on Sunday - then he could add 20 points to the total when we play teams below or around us.
He has a quality - still - that we don't possess without him.
I would give him 4 years at £200k/week personally - £40m over 4 years - it will cost us that to buy even a shadow of Wilf, let alone the wages involved.

£40m over 4 years - good value??

Firstly , let's get the figures correct. Add on employer national insurance of 13.8% and 52 weeks not 50 and it's over £47m.

Then factor in the impact on wages across the squad. Every agent will be knocking on SP's door asking for a payrise. If Wilf is on £200k then surely our core performers should be on at least half. Guehi, Olise and Eze etc will get big pay rises as a consequence.

Why is Wilf on £130k? Because the donkey Benteke was on £120k and Wilf is clearly better. His agent demanded an increase.

Palace's wages have been far too high for our revenues for the last 5 or so years. That's the Benteke/Sakho effect.
The same will happen if Wilf does re-sign on the wages that have been quoted.

 

waddy Flag Highton,Melbourne 31 May 23 5.31pm

The challenge the club has is -

1) offer him top wages way above the others yet he don’t perform as well !
2) he stays but continues to pull up every 4th game with 5 games missed !
3) let him go get two younger players for the price of him who have a point to prove !
4) unleash Scott Banks ( many will moan his too young or not ready - well take the chance ) ! Just like they did with Zaha & AWB / Dean Gordon when they were young
5) throw caution to the wind that he decides to stay not throw a hissy & outplays like Modra has !

 


Forever Palace Proud

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 01 Jun 23 7.53pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Wilf is still the difference between us and some teams in the League - and he still could be if he wants to stay.
My take on it is that he wants 4 years and we don't.
However - if he made the difference - total difference - as he would have done on Sunday - then he could add 20 points to the total when we play teams below or around us.
He has a quality - still - that we don't possess without him.
I would give him 4 years at £200k/week personally - £40m over 4 years - it will cost us that to buy even a shadow of Wilf, let alone the wages involved.


I suggest you take your rose-tinted spectacles off.

1. Wilf has scored just ONE goal since the World Cup and provided just 3 assists all season (which for a wide player is poor (compare with Olise's 11 assists).

2. As has already been mentioned, he failed to score against Forest in the away game.

3, We have performed well during these last 10 games when he has been largely absent.

Given the above, where is your evidence that his presence last Sunday "would have made a total difference"?

Furthermore, your suggestion that his presence would add 20 points to our total is IMHO laughable.

It is vital that the club continues to realign its wage structure to a sustainable level and giving Zaha £200k a week will undermine that.

Having said all that, I would not be averse to Zaha staying BUT IMO, it should be on a LOWER wage (to reflect his reducing contribution) and for no more than 2 years.

Zaha is rightly considered one of the club's greatest ever attacking players (if not the greatest) and we owed our continued existence in the PL for most of the current spell largely to his contributions BUT he is no longer indispensable and it is probably best if he moves on to a team who will be playing European competition next season so he can have a chance to realize his dream.

As for Palace, we need to move on and show (as we have been doing in recent games) that we can function well enough without Zaha.

After all, the club's future lies in the likes of Eze, Olise, Guehi etc. Zaha is increasingly the club's past.

 

becky Flag over the moon 01 Jun 23 8.28pm

Originally posted by doombear


I suggest you take your rose-tinted spectacles off.

1. Wilf has scored just ONE goal since the World Cup and provided just 3 assists all season (which for a wide player is poor (compare with Olise's 11 assists).

2. As has already been mentioned, he failed to score against Forest in the away game.

3, We have performed well during these last 10 games when he has been largely absent.

Given the above, where is your evidence that his presence last Sunday "would have made a total difference"?

Furthermore, your suggestion that his presence would add 20 points to our total is IMHO laughable.

It is vital that the club continues to realign its wage structure to a sustainable level and giving Zaha £200k a week will undermine that.

Having said all that, I would not be averse to Zaha staying BUT IMO, it should be on a LOWER wage (to reflect his reducing contribution) and for no more than 2 years.

Zaha is rightly considered one of the club's greatest ever attacking players (if not the greatest) and we owed our continued existence in the PL for most of the current spell largely to his contributions BUT he is no longer indispensable and it is probably best if he moves on to a team who will be playing European competition next season so he can have a chance to realize his dream.

As for Palace, we need to move on and show (as we have been doing in recent games) that we can function well enough without Zaha.

After all, the club's future lies in the likes of Eze, Olise, Guehi etc. Zaha is increasingly the club's past.

Only problem with that is that, frankly, no-one seems to want him...

Edited by becky (01 Jun 2023 8.28pm)

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Jun 23 8.43pm

Originally posted by becky



Only problem with that is that, frankly, no-one seems to want him...

Edited by becky (01 Jun 2023 8.28pm)

Never mind. The club isn't obliged to renew his contract, it's over. Maybe the BBC are looking for new presenters for MOTD...

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 02 Jun 23 6.17am

I have no idea if all the talk of the £200, 000 a week offer is true, but the talk of it started back when PV was in charge, we were struggling for points & seemed to have lost our identity -
So if the timing of the clickbait splurge is anything to go by maybe SP felt that with all of the problems we were having on the field that to risk loosing Wilf as well (or at least not doing everything he could to keep him) it could have at least had some elements of truth in it, however fanciful it might seem now sitting here after the season has finished with safety achieved-

In any event, whatever the offer I am confident that SP has done everything he can to keep Wilf, as many others have said, whatever happens now is up to Wilf, but personally I think he is going to find that he is not as sought after as he thinks he is going to be (at least not at CL league level with a starting place in the side & silly money wages)

Originally posted by becky

Only problem with that is that, frankly, no-one seems to want him...

Edited by becky (01 Jun 2023 8.28pm)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 02 Jun 23 6.43am

Originally posted by palace99

£40m over 4 years - good value??

Firstly , let's get the figures correct. Add on employer national insurance of 13.8% and 52 weeks not 50 and it's over £47m.

Then factor in the impact on wages across the squad. Every agent will be knocking on SP's door asking for a payrise. If Wilf is on £200k then surely our core performers should be on at least half. Guehi, Olise and Eze etc will get big pay rises as a consequence.

Why is Wilf on £130k? Because the donkey Benteke was on £120k and Wilf is clearly better. His agent demanded an increase.

Palace's wages have been far too high for our revenues for the last 5 or so years. That's the Benteke/Sakho effect.
The same will happen if Wilf does re-sign on the wages that have been quoted.

Right on the money. If he stays now he should be paid in line with our policies.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 02 Jun 23 7.27am

The club should make his mind up for him, Thank you and goodbye.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 02 Jun 23 8.26am

[b]

Originally posted by waddy

The challenge the club has is -

1) offer him top wages way above the others yet he don’t perform as well !
2) he stays but continues to pull up every 4th game with 5 games missed !
3) let him go get two younger players for the price of him who have a point to prove !
4) unleash Scott Banks ( many will moan his too young or not ready - well take the chance ) ! Just like they did with Zaha & AWB / Dean Gordon when they were young
5) throw caution to the wind that he decides to stay not throw a hissy & outplays like Modra has !


Scott Banks is already 21 and has had an ok season in League 2, maybe we can see if he’s ready to be ‘unleashed’ on League 1 before we build the team around him? But thanks, it made me laugh this morning.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Jun 23 9.41am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

The club should make his mind up for him, Thank you and goodbye.


Probably not the way to send one of the club's most iconic players on his way. I would prefer simply to offer him a wage that is in line with our wage structure (less than he's getting now because his impact now is less than it was when he signed the last contract) with a two year term and an option to extend for 1 or 2 years depending on how Zaha plays and how his body stands up to the growing rigours of PL football.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 02 Jun 23 11.48am

Originally posted by doombear


Probably not the way to send one of the club's most iconic players on his way. I would prefer simply to offer him a wage that is in line with our wage structure (less than he's getting now because his impact now is less than it was when he signed the last contract) with a two year term and an option to extend for 1 or 2 years depending on how Zaha plays and how his body stands up to the growing rigours of PL football.

Isn't that the same thing as saying, thank you and goodbye, dont worry to much about offending him, club comes first, and he has his 47m to keep the wolf from the door.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

palace99 Flag New Mills 02 Jun 23 1.35pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Right on the money. If he stays now he should be paid in line with our policies.

Just an observation. I have previously suggested Palace make any offer to Wilf heavily incentive based and have been shot down.

Incentive payments are standard in the game these days.

As an example when Newcastle's Joelinton (bought for £40m) was recently in court his 'basic' wage was reported as £43k a week. I thought this quite low for such a big (on paper) signing, especially as Palace don't have many 1st team players on less than £50k.
However, most wage website report his wage as over £80k a week so c50% appears to be based on incentives - individual (games played, goals, assists etc) and team - wins, points, champ league qualification etc.

Therefore, i will repeat my previous suggestion. If Wilf is to stay it needs to be within our wage structure and any 'extras' should be performance based.

Incidentally, after Wilf OE is reported as our highest earner on over £90k a week. Hopefully this includes a big goal bonus!!

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 02 Jun 23 1.55pm

It feels to me a little like the Roy situation where he's something of a safety net for us and we're afraid to chance what might happen without him.

Given his stature at the club it's understandable that everyone wants him to stay but if you remove the emotional element from it and it was another player who has shown signs of slowing down in terms of pace, explosiveness and a few injuries, nobody would think this supposed four year deal for that kind of money is a good idea.

I do hope he stays, of course, and suspect that there are probably talks happening in the background. If the reality of the situation, though, is that he's weighing up offers and we might miss out on other opportunities while we wait, then I hope we don't give it too long before making the decision ourselves.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Jun 23 2.29pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Isn't that the same thing as saying, thank you and goodbye, dont worry to much about offending him, club comes first, and he has his 47m to keep the wolf from the door.


Basically, yes. Just not as blunt as your suggestion.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 02 Jun 23 8.40pm

Wilf has been great for the club, but his best days are behind him now. Nobody wants him as he unbalances the team, has a reputation for going down too easily and permanent sulking. Talk to fans from other clubs and you find out the love for Wilf goes no further than Selhurst Park.

Seeing out your career in the French or Saudi Leagues, despite the money, will not be something to look back on.

 

PJEagle Flag London 02 Jun 23 9.43pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

Wilf has been great for the club, but his best days are behind him now. Nobody wants him as he unbalances the team, has a reputation for going down too easily and permanent sulking. Talk to fans from other clubs and you find out the love for Wilf goes no further than Selhurst Park.

Seeing out your career in the French or Saudi Leagues, despite the money, will not be something to look back on.

[Link]

Maybe he's off

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 02 Jun 23 11.03pm

For the first time I feel it's time to part company. The team performs well without him being the spearhead . It makes sense financially as well.

I'm also rather fed up him being such a miserable bvgger on the pitch. Must be tough on his salary.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Zaha127 Flag 03 Jun 23 12.31pm

I think like Simon Jordan mentioned on Talksport before yes footballers are overpaid and they get far more then they ever believed. But the economics of giving Zaha a new contract makes sense. Say Zaha was given a 5 year contract (£200,000) that is an extra £70k on his reported current salary. The total extra cost over 5 years is around £18m. It is very hard to find a player like Zaha for £20m plus the new player you will need to pay his salary which would probably be at least £70,000/week so that is a £20m transfer fee plus £18m over 5 years salary for a player on £70k a week total cost = £38m as opposed to giving Wilf a new contract = £18m so it is £20m less. Simon Jordan also mentioned Zaha probably has the same talent as Mahrez. If you put Zaha in a Liverpool or City he would get unreal numbers. Palace are set up differently to the bigger sides and they play a certain way.

[Link]

Plus Zaha is proven in the EPL there is no doubt whether he can perform at the highest level or not. Can easily score 10+ EPL goals a season something which Palace strikers cannot do. His goals will earn Palace more money because the higher you finish in the table the more prize money you get.

Now this is the issue. Palace need to reassure him and improve the squad (RB, midfielder and clinical striker) I think what is stopping him signing the contract is whether Palace have ambition to really go as high as they can e.g. top 8 possibly into Europe with momentum. To have a chance of that they need a striker who scores over 13 EPL goals a season, another midfielder and RB for sure. If Palace can get additional signings and Zaha to stay then they can become an established top 10 EPL side for sure year on year fighting for Europe in some seasons and potentially winning something e.g. an FA CUP, EFL CUP if luck is on their side. If Zaha was playing against Forest I think Palace win that game you can see how much he was missed.

 

Page 10 of 57 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Zaha