You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson
November 16 2026 3.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson


Page 10 of 27 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 16 Dec 23 8.16pm

Tactically superb today. To pull out the last two performances with our injury list is fantastic. The team is remarkably well drilled and all credit has to go to Roy for that.

It was a tough watch today but there was no way we could go toe to toe with City for 90 mins. They’d have torn us apart. Kept it tight and stayed in the game and rolled the dice at the end and come away with a valuable and hard earned point.

Ozoh looked like a seasoned pro, Franca made a big impact and Mateta showed us that he’s actually got decent feet. Delighted to have Henderson and Eze back too. A lot of positives to take from that. Perhaps we’ve got more depth than we thought. Bring in the Weed.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 16 Dec 23 9.08pm

Originally posted by Norbury Old Git

Unfortunately the young attackers will not get any patient tuition unless it’s from Paddy. Roy has twice admitted that he does not coach the forwards and this has been recently been confirmed by Andros Townsend. This is one of the reasons why we don’t score many goals.

All managers delegate. But Roy is a hands on manager, and whoever does the close work with any forward Roy says exactly what he wants to develop, ask Eze. He is very clear on the matter. It’s Roy that give each player match instruction, but only when he knows they can do what he wants. We don’t score many goals because our mid field is not a good enough engine to create that many., and that’s when our best forward players are even on the field.
Only short cameo s today and it’s clear the young players have improved by quite a bit, not enough to use for ninety minutes but vastly improved .
At the time of the Spurs match, Francas problem was he was as green as grass, a headless chicken, he certainly could play but almost certainly trying to hard to justify the hype, , if anyone was bothered to watch his under twenty one outings, he had tricks but not disciplined enough , he couldn’t play in the Premier like that .
It looks like he will do and this season maybe, but it’s still early days, the early days bit applies to all the young players in the squad.Full marks to Roy, getting him right before throwing him a challenge like todays.


Edited by Putitout (16 Dec 2023 9.10pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 19 Dec 23 7.42am

Early picture of Roy's defensive formation - with Joel Ward on the back post.

image.jpeg Attachment: image.jpeg (135.47Kb)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 19 Dec 23 8.22am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Early picture of Roy's defensive formation - with Joel Ward on the back post.

Classic

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Croydon-Trucker Flag 19 Dec 23 10.20am

The bus is well and truly parked .

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Dec 23 10.27am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Early picture of Roy's defensive formation - with Joel Ward on the back post.

Very good!!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Dec 23 10.59am

I find it extraordinary that a manager can avoid the holistic nature of the game and coach a side of 11 players in only one aspect of the totality of the game.
Our lowly position is no surprise, goals win games yet only Burnley and Sheffield United have scored less, unsurprisingly reflected in their league position, just as the teams above us have scored more goals and won more games.
Brighton, our next opponents, have score 33 thus far and have a goal difference of +3, we on the other hand have scored 17 and have a goal difference of -8. The difference in vision of how the game should be played is telling, they are 9 points ahead of us and also playing in Europe this season.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (19 Dec 2023 10.59am)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 Dec 23 11.09am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I find it extraordinary that a manager can avoid the holistic nature of the game and coach a side of 11 players in only one aspect of the totality of the game.
Our lowly position is no surprise, goals win games yet only Burnley and Sheffield United have scored less, unsurprisingly reflected in their league position, just as the teams above us have scored more goals and won more games.
Brighton, our next opponents, have score 33 thus far and have a goal difference of +3, we on the other hand have scored 17 and have a goal difference of -8. The difference in vision of how the game should be played is telling, they are 9 points ahead of us and also playing in Europe this season.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (19 Dec 2023 10.59am)

It’s old school football vs new and I’m afraid a lot of posters on here just don’t get it. They are as old and grumpy as Roy himself.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Dec 23 11.21am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

It’s old school football vs new and I’m afraid a lot of posters on here just don’t get it. They are as old and grumpy as Roy himself.

Yes definitely. I'm afraid one cannot escape the statistics and despite our rather fortunate but very welcome point against City we have in fact accrued just 2 points from our last 6 games. only Forest have done worse with just 1 point, and Luton, Burnley, and Sheff Utd have actually won a game in that period. I find it extraordinary that some folks defend Hodgson's negative approach and describe him as some tactical genius, just for sticking every player behind the ball, ceding possession, and rarely venturing forward. The league table doesn't lie.
Perhaps is because it's because he's from Croydon.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (19 Dec 2023 11.30am)

 

PatrickA Flag London 19 Dec 23 11.23am

There are strong emerging stories that Nuno is about to replace Cooper at Forest.
In recent weeks Cooper has been heavily linked with Palace.
Perhaps it’s putting together 2 and 2 and coming up with 5, but it wouldn’t surprise me if Cooper is our next manager.

 

Jacey Flag 19 Dec 23 11.30am

Originally posted by PatrickA

There are strong emerging stories that Nuno is about to replace Cooper at Forest.
In recent weeks Cooper has been heavily linked with Palace.
Perhaps it’s putting together 2 and 2 and coming up with 5, but it wouldn’t surprise me if Cooper is our next manager.

Surely,we have more ambition than appointing Cooper ??

Edited by Jacey (19 Dec 2023 11.39am)

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 19 Dec 23 11.33am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

It’s old school football vs new and I’m afraid a lot of posters on here just don’t get it. They are as old and grumpy as Roy himself.

Trouble is a lot of posters don’t get that with our finances or lack of them and the squad we’ve got or lack of, especially with injuries, new school football could get us relegated

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 19 Dec 23 11.38am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I find it extraordinary that a manager can avoid the holistic nature of the game and coach a side of 11 players in only one aspect of the totality of the game.
Our lowly position is no surprise, goals win games yet only Burnley and Sheffield United have scored less, unsurprisingly reflected in their league position, just as the teams above us have scored more goals and won more games.
Brighton, our next opponents, have score 33 thus far and have a goal difference of +3, we on the other hand have scored 17 and have a goal difference of -8. The difference in vision of how the game should be played is telling, they are 9 points ahead of us and also playing in Europe this season.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (19 Dec 2023 10.59am)

The empirical evidence is there if you want to find it. Success is more about not conceding than scoring.

The stats you cite reveal Brighton have conceded 30 goals and us only 25.

But for the injuries and teams improbably hitting form just as we play them (e.g. booed off after Bournemouth, but then look what the Cherries did next), we would have conceded a few less less, and possibly scored a few more. That would have us on course for safe mid-table.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 Dec 23 11.58am

Originally posted by monkey

Trouble is a lot of posters don’t get that with our finances or lack of them and the squad we’ve got or lack of, especially with injuries, new school football could get us relegated

That’s where I wholly disagree. We could easily get relegated this season given our dire performances against very mediocre teams. Roy gets paralysed with fear when it comes to picking younger players. He has history of it so it cannot be disputed that he only trusts old pros to implement his defensive strategy. There is more than one way to utilise a squad however and that doesn’t mean relegation is a certainty because of it.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Dec 23 12.27pm

Originally posted by silvertop

The empirical evidence is there if you want to find it. Success is more about not conceding than scoring.

The stats you cite reveal Brighton have conceded 30 goals and us only 25.

But for the injuries and teams improbably hitting form just as we play them (e.g. booed off after Bournemouth, but then look what the Cherries did next), we would have conceded a few less less, and possibly scored a few more. That would have us on course for safe mid-table.

Sure, but as I mentioned, they have a goal difference of +3 while ours is -8. And to reiterate, they are 9 points ahead of us whilst also playing in Europe. What I can conclude from this is that scoring is actually important to one's overall position.
Which returns me to the point I was making: how can a manager who doesn't coach forward play have any say in how to win a game or even which forwards to use? What's his criteria? How can a manager focus on one aspect of the game and ignore the rest? It's ridiculous. How does Hodgson remain in the post?

Edited by southnorwoodhill (19 Dec 2023 12.30pm)

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 19 Dec 23 12.33pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

That’s where I wholly disagree. We could easily get relegated this season given our dire performances against very mediocre teams. Roy gets paralysed with fear when it comes to picking younger players. He has history of it so it cannot be disputed that he only trusts old pros to implement his defensive strategy. There is more than one way to utilise a squad however and that doesn’t mean relegation is a certainty because of it.

For every Brighton, there are any number of clubs that tried to please people with your attitude, and have failed miserably . All three clubs relegated just last year could play, an tried to play with a bit of flare, they are in the Championship because they wouldn’t play to win in any other way. This season Burnley come up full of promise , and they do try, to play with flare .adapt or perish though . Even Forest at the moment, at home they go for it doesn’t happen though does it. .Every season has at least one club goes down like this ,Norwich , come to mind twice since we entered the league, both times trying to impress fans with your ideas of how little clubs should play even though they don’t have the means. The problem being , they tried to be entertaining many times to often, for clubs like those I mention and us that’s not how you stay in this league as long as we have.
We are only in this league because of never getting above our capabilities, this season so far our squad has never been able to do otherwise. Because our injuries have highlighted how close to not adequate it is. And Hodgson has had to deal with this more so than any other manager in the whole period., Go to the Championship and in no time the gates half. Why ? It’s football but not as entertaining.. My feeling is so many modern fans are more for the entertainment ,than the real game. Players know it their all frigging actors now..

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 19 Dec 23 12.36pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Surely,we have more ambition than appointing Cooper ??

Edited by Jacey (19 Dec 2023 11.39am)

One would imagine so , but i think Steve seems to have a hardon for him for some reason , he was interviewed for the job before and rumour has it he turned it down .

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 Dec 23 2.09pm

Originally posted by Putitout

For every Brighton, there are any number of clubs that tried to please people with your attitude, and have failed miserably . All three clubs relegated just last year could play, an tried to play with a bit of flare, they are in the Championship because they wouldn’t play to win in any other way. This season Burnley come up full of promise , and they do try, to play with flare .adapt or perish though . Even Forest at the moment, at home they go for it doesn’t happen though does it. .Every season has at least one club goes down like this ,Norwich , come to mind twice since we entered the league, both times trying to impress fans with your ideas of how little clubs should play even though they don’t have the means. The problem being , they tried to be entertaining many times to often, for clubs like those I mention and us that’s not how you stay in this league as long as we have.
We are only in this league because of never getting above our capabilities, this season so far our squad has never been able to do otherwise. Because our injuries have highlighted how close to not adequate it is. And Hodgson has had to deal with this more so than any other manager in the whole period., Go to the Championship and in no time the gates half. Why ? It’s football but not as entertaining.. My feeling is so many modern fans are more for the entertainment ,than the real game. Players know it their all frigging actors now..

Jeez, what the hell do you mean by my attitude? Firstly you have got completely the wrong end of the stick and secondly you are so into your own mindset that you are as intransigent as Roy when it comes to looking at tools at your disposal.

I’m not asking for a change in the way we play, I’m saying trust the players who are our future to play more than 10 minutes per game. I’m saying stop picking your favourites when they are clearly incapable of playing the modern game and I’m saying take the occasional risk with players who are natural in their positions rather than trying to wedge square pegs into round holes. None of that is asking for a different way to play.

 

Car54 Flag Lower Upington 19 Dec 23 2.15pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Sure, but as I mentioned, they have a goal difference of +3 while ours is -8. And to reiterate, they are 9 points ahead of us whilst also playing in Europe. What I can conclude from this is that scoring is actually important to one's overall position.
Which returns me to the point I was making: how can a manager who doesn't coach forward play have any say in how to win a game or even which forwards to use? What's his criteria? How can a manager focus on one aspect of the game and ignore the rest? It's ridiculous. How does Hodgson remain in the post?

Edited by southnorwoodhill (19 Dec 2023 12.30pm)

You really must be the grumpiest poster, completely ignoring our three american backers who do not want too, or haven't got the relevant financial capabilities, try looking a the overall situation and not just the league table, Jesus Christ

 


There will always be rocks in the road ahead of us. They will be stumbling blocks or stepping stones; it all depends on how you use them.

Friedrich Nietzsche

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Dec 23 2.35pm

I've just gone through the list of games played thus far and tallied up our attempts on target according to the BBC match stats and it appears we are averaging 4 a game. This total is enhanced by good showings against Sheffield United, Wolves, and Luton. Two games we won and one we somehow contrived to lose.
My initial conclusion is that we don't get the ball forward enough when the opportunity arises because the focus is on defence and despite the bemoaning of Edouard and Mateta they don't have much to work with. Ayew's role seems less focussed on forward play than covering for defence.
Again, I have to ask what Hodgson expects from his attack when there is no coaching in that area? For example Pulis had an average side but made sure that we were strong on the set-piece.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (19 Dec 2023 2.38pm)

 

Page 10 of 27 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson