You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread
November 21 2026 12.10pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Holmesdale Fanatics thread


Page 103 of 122 < 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 >
martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 26 Sep 18 9.01pm

How long before the HF demand a free pint and programme in order for us to be blessed with their attendance.

The start of a slippery slope.

I think everyone in block E should pretend to want to be in the choir and renew next season.

 

Palace 1979 Flag Surrey 26 Sep 18 9.02pm

I think this situation was always going to split opinions between fans.

I think that a solution needed to be found as everyone has to agree the HF have been great for the club, especially in those dark bottom half Championship days. The fact that players such as Meyer said they were one of the reasons he joined the club speaks volumes, and I am sure the existing players also had an influence on this outcome.

Going forward I do believe they will make the club even better than it already is, and could well help us attract great sponsors and players as well as more young supporters.

However, i also hope that the fans that will have to be moved and also those that choose to remain and then request a move in later seasons for reasons such as having to stand up all game etc, that they are all compensated by way of free memberships in the stand of their choice for a sufficient length of time. It is what they all deserve as they are just as important as the HF and this has to be recognised.

All parties are vital for the club going forward and I am sure Steve has already considered this when making this decision.

The last point must be that this is the final move and no further changes will be made going forward.

Looking forward to seeing the HF again and here's to getting our famous atmosphere back.

 


Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.

AERO Flag 26 Sep 18 9.06pm

Good post “palace 1979”

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 26 Sep 18 9.07pm

Originally posted by SelhurstEagle

It is a real shame for those who have to move. I can understand how muh history some fans have in those seats and I hope they get a real good deal out of it.

However, it is the best thing the club could have done, and I’m over the moon to hear our atmosphere is going to return. We were slowly turning into Arsenals and it was clearly effecting the players performances, so it’s going to improve results at home for sure.[/quote]

Like losing to Sunderland and Swansea at home with the HF there. When will some of you wake up and realise players win matches not the "Atmosphere".

Our great atmosphere last season I suppose helped us to only win 7 of 19 home games!!

Edited by PZ Eagle (26 Sep 2018 9.12pm)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

AERO Flag 26 Sep 18 9.14pm

Got to improve our chances of winning,or would you rather watch palace in a Library ?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 18 9.16pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Originally posted by SelhurstEagle

It is a real shame for those who have to move. I can understand how muh history some fans have in those seats and I hope they get a real good deal out of it.

However, it is the best thing the club could have done, and I’m over the moon to hear our atmosphere is going to return. We were slowly turning into Arsenals and it was clearly effecting the players performances, so it’s going to improve results at home for sure.[/quote]

Like losing to Sunderland and Swansea at home with the HF there. When will some of you wake up and realise players win matches not the "Atmosphere".

Our great atmosphere last season I suppose helped us to only win 7 of 19 home games!!

Edited by PZ Eagle (26 Sep 2018 9.12pm)

I think I’d take more notice of someone on the pitch than watching in Penzance on a stream and I think Parish does too.

 


COYP

AERO Flag 26 Sep 18 9.16pm

Do you think the H F helped us win any of those 7 games ?

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 26 Sep 18 9.21pm

Originally posted by AERO

Do you think the H F helped us win any of those 7 games ?

Well they didn't help us in the other 12 did they??

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

TulseHillEagle Flag Tulse Hill 26 Sep 18 9.27pm

Fantastic news from the club! Iam pro enhancing the atmosphere and agree with the fans who are of the view that moving a singing section to a more central block will help in achieving this. *This might not even happen in the end,but it's worth trying out.

But iam disheartened with the view of those fans who either don't wish for this to happen or are disengenous about the positives of a good atmosphere to the Match day experience.

#UpThePalace

#UpTheHF


 


Member of the Keith Millen Club. COYP

daven Flag Hailsham 26 Sep 18 9.33pm

The club refer to block E as a singing section, which is fair enough. But the crux of the issue is that nowhere have the club said that it is a standing block because standing is against the rules of the stadium and the law.
This whole affair will have not gone unnoticed in the F.A and I fear that if this results in more standing in the lower holmesdale the club will face punishment.

 

AERO Flag 26 Sep 18 9.33pm

Here here !!!!!!

 

Mstrobez Flag 26 Sep 18 9.34pm

Originally posted by TulseHillEagle

Fantastic news from the club! Iam pro enhancing the atmosphere and agree with the fans who are of the view that moving a singing section to a more central block will help in achieving this. *This might not even happen in the end,but it's worth trying out.

But iam disheartened with the view of those fans who either don't wish for this to happen or are disengenous about the positives of a good atmosphere to the Match day experience.

#UpThePalace

#UpTheHF


That’s such a disingenuous statement to make. I’d say pretty much everyone supported the plans to enhance our atmosphere.

What people have a problem with is going ahead with proposals without consent of the current seat holders.

Although I’m sure you know that already, and that was just a way of attempting to discredit the people who don’t happen to share your personal view.

Edited by Mstrobez (26 Sep 2018 9.35pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 18 9.37pm

Originally posted by daven

The club refer to block E as a singing section, which is fair enough. But the crux of the issue is that nowhere have the club said that it is a standing block because standing is against the rules of the stadium and the law.
This whole affair will have not gone unnoticed in the F.A and I fear that if this results in more standing in the lower holmesdale the club will face punishment.

Just like all those other clubs that haven’t I suppose.

 


COYP

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 26 Sep 18 9.38pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I think I’d take more notice of someone on the pitch than watching in Penzance on a stream and I think Parish does too.

What an arrogant patronising post that is. So just because I live in Penzance negates 70 years of watching Palace does it? I was on the Holmesdale long before it became a stand, I had a season ticket in the Arfur for many years before I moved to Cornwall. When my mum was still alive I would travel up from Cornwall to stay with her and go to Selhurst Park. I've also taken in away games at Plymouth Argyle.

I have produced facts that prove the HF do not do anything for our home record which has been poor for years.

You are quite happy to praise someone who lives in Australia or the USA who agree with you but choose to be sarcastic about someone who lives in Penzance.

I hope you are very comfortable about turning Palace fans against each other on here because you, more than anyone, has kept this thread going as your personal crusade.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Kant Flag exeter 26 Sep 18 9.38pm

People who point to defeats to ‘prove’ that fans/atmosphere make no difference to results really are twerps. However bad the results have been, ‘but for’ the fans/atmosphere those results might have been even worse.

And for the record, although I am potentially going to be turfed out of my seat it is nevertheless the correct decision and has my full backing and support.

The club needs to act in the best interests of all CPFC stakeholders - not just the few in the blocks concerned.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 18 9.41pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

That’s such a disingenuous statement to make. I’d say pretty much everyone supported the plans to enhance our atmosphere.

What people have a problem with is going ahead with proposals without consent of the current seat holders.

Although I’m sure you know that already, and that was just a way of attempting to discredit the people who don’t happen to share your personal view.

Edited by Mstrobez (26 Sep 2018 9.35pm)

They don’t need consent. The club can do what it likes. They’re going to liaise with them after making the decision rather than before. They’ve made the decision and are aware some won’t be happy. Or they could liaise before and not do it because of some against it.

 


COYP

AERO Flag 26 Sep 18 9.44pm

Good post Kant

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 26 Sep 18 9.44pm

Originally posted by Kant

People who point to defeats to ‘prove’ that fans/atmosphere make no difference to results really are twerps. However bad the results have been, ‘but for’ the fans/atmosphere those results might have been even worse.

And for the record, although I am potentially going to be turfed out of my seat it is nevertheless the correct decision and has my full backing and support.

The club needs to act in the best interests of all CPFC stakeholders - not just the few in the blocks concerned.

Well you've got the right user name that's for sure. It's a relief to know that without the HF we'd have lost 0-8 to relegated Sunderland.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 18 9.44pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

What an arrogant patronising post that is. So just because I live in Penzance negates 70 years of watching Palace does it? I was on the Holmesdale long before it became a stand, I had a season ticket in the Arfur for many years before I moved to Cornwall. When my mum was still alive I would travel up from Cornwall to stay with her and go to Selhurst Park. I've also taken in away games at Plymouth Argyle.

I have produced facts that prove the HF do not do anything for our home record which has been poor for years.

You are quite happy to praise someone who lives in Australia or the USA who agree with you but choose to be sarcastic about someone who lives in Penzance.

I hope you are very comfortable about turning Palace fans against each other on here because you, more than anyone, has kept this thread going as your personal crusade.

Not facts, just your stubborn opinion. The club are looking forward, I suggest you do too. It’ll help you get used to what is happening.

And I’ve done nothing to turn fans against each other. The club handled this badly, not me. You’re determined with your vendetta against the HF, not me against block E, which is even more absurd if you don’t attend anymore. The club is moving into the future and not just trying to attract corporates but to maximise its appeal and strength. If you don’t want that over a minority having to move then good luck to you.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (26 Sep 2018 9.56pm)

 


COYP

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 26 Sep 18 9.49pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Really great news, I'm delighted. Well done CPFC. What a difference this will make. As per the club statement, there has been overwhelming support for this, the clubs needs to cater for the majority.

No one is celebrating fans getting kicked out their seat, hopefully they are all well compensated for this - free season ticket next year and first choice seats once the new stand has been built is fair. People are celebrating how exciting it will be once its up and running.

I for one will be back for my first season ticket in a while if I can get in the Holmesdale.

And theres my problem. Someone who hasn't had a season ticket for a while wants to join the singing section in thd holmesdale, while someone who's renewed their ticket fir years will age to move. Never ever thought the club would give in to this. Shame.

 

Page 103 of 122 < 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread