You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Can we adopt our 1861 date of birth?
November 22 2026 2.24pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Can we adopt our 1861 date of birth?


Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Palace_Guard Flag Kyiv 11 Jul 22 4.43am

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

Stevie P is is always desperately looking for new ways to make our club more marketable, which is appreciated as it's building blocks for our future, but this one however is just cringey for me. We can't fabricate a false history simply for the sake of claiming a title as "the oldest". It looks tacky to me, and it will look tacky to others.

He's never said that though, he's always said its up to each palace fan to interpret how they wish to. I dont think he's been pushing an agenda at all.

 


Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia?
Support Crystal Palace?

Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club:
[Link]

Adelaide, South Australia? Join here:
[Link]

Palace_Guard Flag Kyiv 11 Jul 22 5.04am

Originally posted by lefty27

So are you suggesting that the author selected sources to support his narrative? There are two from the 1940s which are pretty irrelevant the handbook can be interpreted in both ways , for and against.
The other sources can be contradicted as have mannings. That’s the thing with history, unless you were there you will never know and there will be historians trying to pursued you there book is the one that reflects the truth.
I couldn’t really care less either way but the legend is cool and I don’t understand some supporters negativity.
People seem to want to use it as some kind of stick to beat parish, it’s weird.

i agree lefty! Its very intriguing and fascinating, but i dont see any negatives from it.

 


Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia?
Support Crystal Palace?

Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club:
[Link]

Adelaide, South Australia? Join here:
[Link]

deleted 25 Flag 11 Jul 22 12.48pm

Recommend a book titled ‘the ball is round’

Which has interesting info about the origins of footie (and rugger)

Does mention a CP

Depends whether you think that a club named originally after a building on the other side of the river can be linked. Certainly worked for Arsenal

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 11 Jul 22 8.06pm

I can't really see why there's so much argument about whether 1861 is right or wrong as pretty much everyone (pro-1861 and against-1861) agrees that there is no definitive claim to the earlier date; it's simply a question of how you interpret various facts. You either think the thread that runs from the earlier club to the 1905 club is strong enough to make the 1861 claim or you don't. But you can't absolutely prove the former beyond any reasonable doubt.

Personally, my view is that we shouldn't adopt 1861 as our date of birth (note; I said "shouldn't", not "can't" but that's simply because I err on the side of respecting a proven tradition rather than engaging in what can surely only be seen as revisionist history. I think you should only make the 1861 claim if the historical evidence for doing so is absolutely incontrovertible in support of the earlier date; nothing I've read persuades me that's the case.

However, as I've noted before the change to 1861 gives the club a nice little marketing/media opportunity and we all know that anything that looks like a new revenue stream is welcome. I suspect that's what's behind the club's enthusiasm for the earlier date as much as any interest in historical accuracy.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Terry Ven Flag 14 Jul 22 6.59pm

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

I can't really see why there's so much argument about whether 1861 is right or wrong as pretty much everyone (pro-1861 and against-1861) agrees that there is no definitive claim to the earlier date; it's simply a question of how you interpret various facts. You either think the thread that runs from the earlier club to the 1905 club is strong enough to make the 1861 claim or you don't. But you can't absolutely prove the former beyond any reasonable doubt.

Personally, my view is that we shouldn't adopt 1861 as our date of birth (note; I said "shouldn't", not "can't" but that's simply because I err on the side of respecting a proven tradition rather than engaging in what can surely only be seen as revisionist history. I think you should only make the 1861 claim if the historical evidence for doing so is absolutely incontrovertible in support of the earlier date; nothing I've read persuades me that's the case.

However, as I've noted before the change to 1861 gives the club a nice little marketing/media opportunity and we all know that anything that looks like a new revenue stream is welcome. I suspect that's what's behind the club's enthusiasm for the earlier date as much as any interest in historical accuracy.

If we shout about 1861 and can't prove it then we will look like a bunch of c*nts...simple

 

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 15 Jul 22 9.30am

They really need to change the signs outside of Thornton Heath Station that says 'Home of CPFC 1905-2005'

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Jul 22 9.40am

Originally posted by Terry Ven

If we shout about 1861 and can't prove it then we will look like a bunch of c*nts...simple

Or if it gets disproved, or is adopted/considered as disproved by the rest of the world, even bigger see you next Tuesdays.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Jul 22 5.55pm

Originally posted by Crazy_Eagle

They really need to change the signs outside of Thornton Heath Station that says 'Home of CPFC 1905-2005'

Would it have been correct anyway? When was Selhurst - early 20s?

 


Red and Blue Army!

Mapletree Flag Croydon 17 Jul 22 6.04pm

Originally posted by Crazy_Eagle

They really need to change the signs outside of Thornton Heath Station that says 'Home of CPFC 1905-2005'

Not a big fan of centenary celebrations then? Or do you really think time stopped in Thornton Heath in 2005? Actually, that is a fair point.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Jul 22 6.21pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Not a big fan of centenary celebrations then? Or do you really think time stopped in Thornton Heath in 2005? Actually, that is a fair point.

Obviously I realised but it wouldn't have been at Thornton Heath, although I never personally visited The Nest. Could have been the nearest station for all I know - but I doubt it. Now I don't know any dates anymore 2012, 1861, 1905, 7/7, Year Zero. The outmoded capitalist concept of time is all relative.

 


Red and Blue Army!

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 19 Jul 22 6.33pm

Originally posted by Terry Ven

If we shout about 1861 and can't prove it then we will look like a bunch of c*nts...simple

prove it to who ? Boris Johnson ? Brighton ? some c..nt friend of Sepp Blatter ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Bearcage Flag Welling 19 Jul 22 6.53pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

prove it to who ? Boris Johnson ? Brighton ? some c..nt friend of Sepp Blatter ?

And prove what? That Crystal Palace FC existed in 1861?
That’s proven. The question is the connection to the Crystal Palace of 1905? there are definite links, the argument seems to be the significance/relevance of these links (compared to the links other clubs claim)?


Edited by Bearcage (19 Jul 2022 6.54pm)

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 19 Jul 22 8.45pm

FFS, if we,re going to support fake news let,s go to 1066 , sounds catchy

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 19 Jul 22 8.46pm

Can we stop opening this can of BS

Edited by HKOwen (19 Jul 2022 8.46pm)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 19 Jul 22 9.11pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

FFS, if we,re going to support fake news let,s go to 1066 , sounds catchy

no need to be flippant mate. There really was a Crystal Palace playing football in 1861. Based at the big old building in Upper Norwood, South London DNA.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

rikz Flag Croydon 20 Jul 22 7.01pm

Why not we nicked, barcas colours, benficas nickname, we even started out in villa's kit, might aswell nick another clubs D.O.B, shame there's no decent stadiums close by we could claim squatters rights in.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 20 Jul 22 7.40pm

Originally posted by rikz

Why not we nicked, barcas colours, benficas nickname, we even started out in villa's kit, might aswell nick another clubs D.O.B, shame there's no decent stadiums close by we could claim squatters rights in.

if spurs got the Olympic stadium we were getting a new one. Probably fake news but somewhere I’m sure I read it.

 

Bearcage Flag Welling 20 Jul 22 8.34pm

Originally posted by cryrst

if spurs got the Olympic stadium we were getting a new one. Probably fake news but somewhere I’m sure I read it.

Yes, as part of spurs taking the Olympic stadium they proposed a new athletic stadium at Crystal Palace, as part of the development CPFC would’ve moved there into a new football stadium too.

Instead they gave the stadium to West Ham and we subsidise them

Edited by Bearcage (20 Jul 2022 8.34pm)

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 08 Jun 23 7.07pm

This Sunday (June 11), explore the significant spots in Penge and Anerley that tell the story of the first Crystal Palace Football Club on a walking tour. Discover the fascinating lives of the local pioneering footballers that helped establish the modern game. Book your place: [Link]

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 25 Jul 23 3.05pm

I've got a facsimile of the infamous 1906 CPFC handbook. You will see for yourself the multiple times it refers to the club's first season. It does not say anything about an amateur club.

Manning says: "When the professional club published its first handbook in 1906, having joined Division 2 of the Southern League, it listed some of the internationals who had previously represented the club, including Alex Morten in 1873 and Arthur Savage and Charles Eastlake Smith in 1876, showing that they recognised themselves as a continuation of the original amateur team."

Did they? He doesn't say is that this is buried in a list of general football 'Records and Facts' on the last page of the handbook. Manning has ripped this line out of context.

Attachment: CPFC 1906 handbook.pdf (33,548.68Kb)

 

Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Can we adopt our 1861 date of birth?