You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 9 dead in USA Church Shooting.
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

9 dead in USA Church Shooting.


Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 4.00pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.25pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?

Of course I'm bothered. How do you work out that I'm not? The difference is that the 35+ murder victims were killed by criminals. The one innocent person will have been killed by the state. Unless you think the state should be held to the same standard of behaviour that applies to a murderer then you have little choice but to take my position on this.

Edited by sydtheeagle (22 Jun 2015 3.25pm)

Actually only 12 of those listed in the BBC details were convicted of murder, and not currently in prison.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 4.02pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.06pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm

How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty.

Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 2.56pm)

I would say that if a single innocent person was executed, ever, then you have all the reason you need for not having the death penalty.


Objectively you need to weight the risks against the returns, if enough lives are saved by the loss of one innocent life, then objectively, and regrettably, the decision has to be the loss of innocent life.

We do this all the time with military actions and policy.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 22 Jun 15 4.04pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 2.35pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 2.03pm

Your entittled to your opinion Syd and i welcome it.

Your right the families have found it in their hearts to forgive Roof but at the end of the day in regards to threads like this it is all about opinions.

My brother and sister are against the death penalty but i am for it in cases like this.

i make no apology saying Roof should be put to sleep because that's what he deserves in my opinion.

Re: point 1, ditto. Your view pains me but it's your right to hold it and yes, it is about opinions.

Even if you are pro the death penalty, and I concede that everyone has the right to form their own opinion on that question, I would still prefer you not to use language that equates the value of a human life with that of an animal. You may think this is splitting hairs but I think the distinction is important.

We (people) are sentient in a way that animals are not. We are capable of thinking and changing ourself and self-analysis and introspection to degrees that appear not to be available to beasts. Cogito, ergo sum was not penned by or for a cow -- Cartesian dualism is not the backstop of the animal world. In other words, there isn't moral equivalence between humans and animals and the way you state your views should -- I think -- be chosen more carefully than appears to be the case.

That Dylan Roof is scum is true beyond any shadow of doubt. But he's human scum and that's how he should be treated.

If you want to equate him with an animal (which would mean his possessing significantly less intelligence and critical faculties than the average human being) then almost by definition you would find it inappropriate to execute him since he would be too mentally limited to know any better with regard to his actions. And we don't execute the mentally subnormal (thank goodness.)

Only if you conceive of Roof as a thinking, sentient human (not animal) could you possibly conclude that he is responsible for his actions and should, therefore, be put to death with that in mind. So in a way, your language contradicts your conclusion. Why? Because you're writing emotionally rather than thoughtfully, I suspect.

The death penalty is a complex and difficult subject, however simple you and others may wish to make it. When it comes to deciding to kill people, even if you think it's right, we should always take more time than less. There is no going back, ever.


Point taken Syd,yeah maybe i should'nt use the term put to sleep describing Roof.

I know we are a nation of Animal lovers,i like Animals although i don't have pets anymore.

Animals are better than Roof.

Roof should be punished while animals put to sleep.

there you go i'm not all bad.

 

derben Flag 22 Jun 15 4.10pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 3.59pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.37pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 3.23pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.06pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm

How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty.

Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 2.56pm)

I would say that if a single innocent person was executed, ever, then you have all the reason you need for not having the death penalty.


Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?

Its gone up? You shouldn't count manslaughter as murder. Killers and murderers are two very different things.


The point is you and syd seemed more concerned about the death of a murderer than you do about the victims of murder. You Jamie spent what must obviously taken you some time on convoluted refutation of various statistics. If I could be arsed, I expect I could come up with some refutation of the refutation, but I'm not. (Gone up? BBC no doubt has played down the figures anyway - bound to be more! It said they had killed after release, didn't say how many, I expect there were some multiples.)

Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 3.41pm)

I'm currently studying Psychology and Criminology with the Open University. I don't view the victim or the perpetrator as being more important, I see both objectively. It doesn't matter how takes your life unjustly, state or individual.

My concern is that the ideology of 'they won't do it again' is as much as risk to innocent people, as it is a protection of them. If executing people delivered something like a 10-20% reduction in murder, then it might be something to consider (even then the execution should by for a greater good, such as execution by organ harvesting).

A 0.002% isn't worth the risk.


Hmmmm.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 22 Jun 15 4.13pm

For what it's worth, I'm personally opposed to the death penalty, as I've always said I'd only support it if I could pull the lever myself.

That said, the real reason for the post was to come back on the methods discussion earlier - as far as humane methods, what is the problem with the Dignitas method (barbiturates, I believe?). If it's humane enough to do voluntarily, why not for executions? Is it simply because the drug companies won't supply the drugs for use in executions but will for voluntary euthanasia?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 4.17pm

Quote npn at 22 Jun 2015 4.13pm

For what it's worth, I'm personally opposed to the death penalty, as I've always said I'd only support it if I could pull the lever myself.

That said, the real reason for the post was to come back on the methods discussion earlier - as far as humane methods, what is the problem with the Dignitas method (barbiturates, I believe?). If it's humane enough to do voluntarily, why not for executions? Is it simply because the drug companies won't supply the drugs for use in executions but will for voluntary euthanasia?

Yes, choice is the key phrase. Dignitas won't kill you unless you can a) pay their fee b) terminally ill or suffering terribly c) capable of making the decision yourself.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 4.18pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 4.04pm

Point taken Syd,yeah maybe i should'nt use the term put to sleep describing Roof.

I know we are a nation of Animal lovers,i like Animals although i don't have pets anymore.

Animals are better than Roof.

Roof should be punished while animals put to sleep.

there you go i'm not all bad.

I never thought you were all bad, and I tried to respond to your comments respectfully as in general I've enjoyed your posts on a wide variety of subjects. I also agree (even though your tongue was in your cheek) that animals are better than Roof. But intentionally or not, you are right about punishing Roof (merited) while putting to sleep animals (something entirely different.)

Beyond that, I simply cannot reconcile myself to it ever being justified to take a human life, whether you do so as a murderer or as a state-sanctioned executioner. Killing someone, to me, is killing someone. It's never justified and there aren't any degree of justification either. The arguments barely matter to me; I just think it's wrong. I know you disagree and I'm not trying to change your mind; I'm just explaining my own viewpoint as clearly as I can.

For the record, I'm not religious so there's nothing neo-Christian about my position. I just think it's immoral and dangerous to allow states (which by and large abuse power in one way or another on a daily basis) to have the power over life and death. If you get a slippery slope (and that is a slippery slope) sooner or later you'll fall over.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Stuk Flag Top half 22 Jun 15 4.22pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.06pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm

How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty.

Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 2.56pm)

I would say that if a single innocent person was executed, ever, then you have all the reason you need for not having the death penalty.


Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?

The option isn't simply kill them or release them. There's the third option of not letting them out, to kill again.

 


Optimistic as ever

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 4.23pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.37pm

The point is you and syd seemed more concerned about the death of a murderer than you do about the victims of murder.

Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 3.41pm)

I can't speak for Jamie but you are wrong about me. I am not more concerned about the death of a murderer but I am equally concerned if (and only if) his death is the result of an action by the state. If Roof had died in a car accident as he fled the scene of the crime, I'd be saying "good riddance to bad rubbish." But he wasn't, and I don't think the state has a right to cold-bloodedly kill him. As the families of the victims of Charleston have courageously showed us, a life is a life. The loss of a criminal life does nothing to better the lot of the victims of a loving one.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Stuk Flag Top half 22 Jun 15 4.27pm

Quote npn at 22 Jun 2015 4.13pm

For what it's worth, I'm personally opposed to the death penalty, as I've always said I'd only support it if I could pull the lever myself.

That said, the real reason for the post was to come back on the methods discussion earlier - as far as humane methods, what is the problem with the Dignitas method (barbiturates, I believe?). If it's humane enough to do voluntarily, why not for executions? Is it simply because the drug companies won't supply the drugs for use in executions but will for voluntary euthanasia?

Yep, PR backlash and the related aggro is the only reason.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 4.35pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 4.22pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.06pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm

How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty.

Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 2.56pm)

I would say that if a single innocent person was executed, ever, then you have all the reason you need for not having the death penalty.


Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?

The option isn't simply kill them or release them. There's the third option of not letting them out, to kill again.


I think you have to have some capacity by which 'society forgives and freedom' can be earned, even allowing for very serious crimes. Only those who have given a whole life tariff should arguably face the inevitability of death behind bars.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jun 15 4.38pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 4.27pm

Quote npn at 22 Jun 2015 4.13pm

For what it's worth, I'm personally opposed to the death penalty, as I've always said I'd only support it if I could pull the lever myself.

That said, the real reason for the post was to come back on the methods discussion earlier - as far as humane methods, what is the problem with the Dignitas method (barbiturates, I believe?). If it's humane enough to do voluntarily, why not for executions? Is it simply because the drug companies won't supply the drugs for use in executions but will for voluntary euthanasia?

Yep, PR backlash and the related aggro is the only reason.

I think in the US there is some issue as well regarding executions using 'drugs currently used in medicinal treatment', ie you can't kill them with a drug used for medical purposes.

Bizarrely, you have to also give them an antiseptic swab and use a clean sterile needle (as if infection is something of a concern).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 22 Jun 15 4.42pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 4.18pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 4.04pm

Point taken Syd,yeah maybe i should'nt use the term put to sleep describing Roof.

I know we are a nation of Animal lovers,i like Animals although i don't have pets anymore.

Animals are better than Roof.

Roof should be punished while animals put to sleep.

there you go i'm not all bad.

I never thought you were all bad, and I tried to respond to your comments respectfully as in general I've enjoyed your posts on a wide variety of subjects. I also agree (even though your tongue was in your cheek) that animals are better than Roof. But intentionally or not, you are right about punishing Roof (merited) while putting to sleep animals (something entirely different.)

Beyond that, I simply cannot reconcile myself to it ever being justified to take a human life, whether you do so as a murderer or as a state-sanctioned executioner. Killing someone, to me, is killing someone. It's never justified and there aren't any degree of justification either. The arguments barely matter to me; I just think it's wrong. I know you disagree and I'm not trying to change your mind; I'm just explaining my own viewpoint as clearly as I can.

For the record, I'm not religious so there's nothing neo-Christian about my position. I just think it's immoral and dangerous to allow states (which by and large abuse power in one way or another on a daily basis) to have the power over life and death. If you get a slippery slope (and that is a slippery slope) sooner or later you'll fall over.


Thanks Syd,i also enjoy your posts as i do Jamiemartin and others.

i meant what i said about animals i used to have cats whom i love.

it's just people like Roof sicken me which maybe make me say things that i should'nt.

i should'nt refer to Roof as an animal as it's disrespectful to animals,i still believe people like Roof should be punished for what he did,i saw a picture of him and he looks pure evil.
.

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 22 Jun 15 5.03pm

Quote suicideatselhurst at 21 Jun 2015 12.35pm

i think you make some good points Ray, the full admendment regarding milita, which was brought in to fight the British being one of them....however I still think a republican has a chance in 2016 even more so if Clinton is the running democrat, but do you really think that gun control can be brought in by public preasure, the NRA have huge sums of money to throw at anyone trying to change laws and perception


The NRA's ability to directly impact political debate is almost non-existent these days. A study of the results of the races in 2012 in which the NRA supported a candidate showed that their candidate lost almost 100% of the time. Now this may be a little skewed because they probably spent money to bolster struggling candidates rather than just spreading it around, but it does show that they do not move the needle by their mere presence.

Where they do maintain influence, though, is in Washington, where the candidates simply don't have the balls to go against them despite a litany of opinion polls that show the NRA's stance to be the complete opposite of the majority of the country. The poster child being universal background checks which the NRA opposes and about 97% of the country - including a sizable majority of NRA members - supports.

American politics is a mess; polluted with a endless pipeline of money. Gun control is where the the broken system is at its most obvious (with climate change running it a close second).

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Jun 15 5.09pm

Quote black eagle. at 22 Jun 2015 4.42pm

Thanks Syd,i also enjoy your posts as i do Jamiemartin and others.

i meant what i said about animals i used to have cats whom i love.

it's just people like Roof sicken me which maybe make me say things that i should'nt.

i should'nt refer to Roof as an animal as it's disrespectful to animals,i still believe people like Roof should be punished for what he did,i saw a picture of him and he looks pure evil.
.

That Roof should be punished -- savagely so -- is beyond doubt. To me, justice has to serve the dual purpose of both punishment and, in so far as possible, rehabilitation but the punishment comes first. He should serve life without parole and the early part of that sentence should be unremittingly and mercilessly hard, whatever that may entail. At some point the punishment element has to be considered largely discharged simply because it makes no sense to have a human being that you don't make some effort to rehabilitate but he has to suffer for what he's done wrong before any attempt should be made to encourage him to do right.

Roof sickens me but -- and you may dislike this -- just as society takes credit for the good it creates so the evil it produces is also a reflection of the society as a whole. Roof didn't emerge from his mother's womb a fully formed hatred machine; society at least helped to shape him. That is not to let him off the hook or blame society for what he did. No way; he alone is responsible for his actions and he alone should pay for them. But as a society, it would be irresponsible not to ask ourselves "where does race hate come from?" If we don't ask the question then we miss the chance to address the problem.

Is Roof pure evil? It's an interesting question. I doubt it. When I look at his photo I see pure stupidity; a child masquerading as a man, hiding under the iconography of race hate as if that somehow bestowed on him adult status and legitimised his view of himself as a "freedom fighter" (sic), an emancipator of his race. Evil in one way yes, but confused, stupid, low IQ, easily led, almost a cartoon villain in another. Roof is the answer for a village in search of an idiot.

He, it seems to me, lacked the wit to even articulate his position as a mass murderer to any great effect; he's ended up as just another dumb southern white kid with a gun. Evil? In one way, yes. But more witless, pointless and ignorant in another. I doubt Roof is really clever enough to be evil. That, if nothing else, requires guile and intelligence. Like most people who do stupid things he probably just wanted attention and lacked the nous to even go about something that simple in an effective way. He's two-bit scum, but not even really capable of evil; just rank, base and utterly destructive idiocy.

His story is a mixture of ignorance, tragedy and despair. I hope he burns in hell, but not at the behest of the state.

Edited by sydtheeagle (22 Jun 2015 5.12pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Stuk Flag Top half 22 Jun 15 5.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 4.35pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 4.22pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.06pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm

How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty.

Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 2.56pm)

I would say that if a single innocent person was executed, ever, then you have all the reason you need for not having the death penalty.


Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?

The option isn't simply kill them or release them. There's the third option of not letting them out, to kill again.


I think you have to have some capacity by which 'society forgives and freedom' can be earned, even allowing for very serious crimes. Only those who have given a whole life tariff should arguably face the inevitability of death behind bars.

If someone goes on a rampage with either a gun, machete or any other weapon that should be a starting point for a whole life tariff regardless of how many people they killed or injured.

I'd put those who plant bombs in the same bracket too, regardless of their "cause".

 


Optimistic as ever

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 22 Jun 15 5.15pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 11.47am

Expensive though. Also a significant number of murderers have killed again after being released.


Nope. It is far LESS expensive to try, convict and lock up someone for life, than it is to go through a trial for which the death penalty is being sought, then the protracted appeals process, all the while housing the convicted in specialised death row accommodations.

I'm also curious as to how you reconcile your support for the death penalty with your religious beliefs. In my study of the bible as a kid, the New Testament - i.e. Bible 2.0 - is pretty solidly on the side of turning the other cheek and only casting stones when without sin. It's pretty unequivocal about it.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Stuk Flag Top half 22 Jun 15 5.21pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 4.38pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 4.27pm

Quote npn at 22 Jun 2015 4.13pm

For what it's worth, I'm personally opposed to the death penalty, as I've always said I'd only support it if I could pull the lever myself.

That said, the real reason for the post was to come back on the methods discussion earlier - as far as humane methods, what is the problem with the Dignitas method (barbiturates, I believe?). If it's humane enough to do voluntarily, why not for executions? Is it simply because the drug companies won't supply the drugs for use in executions but will for voluntary euthanasia?

Yep, PR backlash and the related aggro is the only reason.

I think in the US there is some issue as well regarding executions using 'drugs currently used in medicinal treatment', ie you can't kill them with a drug used for medical purposes.

Bizarrely, you have to also give them an antiseptic swab and use a clean sterile needle (as if infection is something of a concern).


Don't think there is, they just can't get it in the US as the company refuses to provide it and the EU banned exports of it from this end.

The sterilisation procedures are in case they get a last minute stay of execution. They had the thing in someone's arm once before he got given one.

 


Optimistic as ever

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 22 Jun 15 5.28pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 1.27pm

They've got no lethal injections, can't get anymore and electrocution is only an option if chosen by the criminal.


Unfortunately, various States are now trying unproven cocktails of drugs, from sketchy, secret sources to get their executions done. It's leading to chaos and horror.
[Link]

It's also quite possibly unconstitutional. When the death penalty was challenged in the Supreme Court, the resulting protocol was that the administration of three specific drugs in precise amounts and in the set order, was deemed not to be "cruel and unusual" punishment. What the States are doing now is ad-libbing, so it is once again challengable in the Supreme Court, and this is being done.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 22 Jun 15 5.32pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?


What if that one innocent person was you?

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 9 dead in USA Church Shooting.