You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The McCanns
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The McCanns


Page 11 of 16 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 20 Mar 19 2.13pm

Kate's eyes and face, have always looked haunted to me. Gerry's eyes and mouth have always looked aggressive to me, like he's fiercely defensive, or going to lash out.
Appointing a PR firm and trying to discredit the Portugeuse police early doors, did them no favours.

The story is too complex now with theories, and discrediting of witnesses and destruction of evidence for a viable outcome to happen.

Someone breaking ranks will be the only way this gets cleared up. If I were a betting person, my money would be on Kate letting slip

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 20 Mar 19 2.59pm

One part of the Portuguese theory that never made sense was that the Tapas 7 are supposed to have helped cover up the crime.

They were holiday friends so the McCanns only saw them occasionally why would any of them owe the McCanns anything and risk jail time. Quite frankly if any of my family came to me to help cover up a death I would call the police immediately.

Lying who was driving when your caught speeding is one thing. Covering up the death of a child for someone you barely know! I don't believe it. I don't think those people have a clue what happened if they did they would have spoken out by now.

 


One more point

kent675 Flag Bromley, Kent 20 Mar 19 4.27pm

I'm 3 episodes in and have just seen the clip of the cadaver dogs which I never knew before.
It's telling that the Inspector from CEOPS dictated an open letter that Gerry had to write 'to the abductor' to admit any mistakes, but was actually directed to Gerry himself.

I used to be sure that they were innocent but am re-considering this - the power of decent documentaries!
Maybe one day there'll be a breakdown in someone's relationship and the truth will out.

This was 100% neglect.

 


Four wheels drives the body - Two wheels drives the soul

Spiderman Flag Horsham 20 Mar 19 6.14pm

Originally posted by Badger11

One part of the Portuguese theory that never made sense was that the Tapas 7 are supposed to have helped cover up the crime.

They were holiday friends so the McCanns only saw them occasionally why would any of them owe the McCanns anything and risk jail time. Quite frankly if any of my family came to me to help cover up a death I would call the police immediately.

Lying who was driving when your caught speeding is one thing. Covering up the death of a child for someone you barely know! I don't believe it. I don't think those people have a clue what happened if they did they would have spoken out by now.

I agree. My wife has an interesting theory (call it female intuition). We have watched the first episode she found the following strange:
Kate making a big play about Maddie having spent a tiring day at the kids club and she could not walk home I had too carry her as she was asleep...why mention this:
When Kate ran back to the restaurant she said "Maddie has been taken" why not say "Maddie is missing or where is Maddie"
She would not have washed the teddy (unless trying to hide something)
My wife believes that the friends are not involved, her theory is that Maddie had already died before they met for dinner and had been carried to the boot of the car (by Kate and that is why she mentioned the tiredness) Perhaps the parents hoped one of the friends would make the discovery.
All just theory but not beyond the realms of possibility. I doubt we will never know the truth

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 20 Mar 19 6.20pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

I agree. My wife has an interesting theory (call it female intuition). We have watched the first episode she found the following strange:
Kate making a big play about Maddie having spent a tiring day at the kids club and she could not walk home I had too carry her as she was asleep...why mention this:
When Kate ran back to the restaurant she said "Maddie has been taken" why not say "Maddie is missing or where is Maddie"
She would not have washed the teddy (unless trying to hide something)
My wife believes that the friends are not involved, her theory is that Maddie had already died before they met for dinner and had been carried to the boot of the car (by Kate and that is why she mentioned the tiredness) Perhaps the parents hoped one of the friends would make the discovery.
All just theory but not beyond the realms of possibility. I doubt we will never know the truth

I haven't watched this show, one question I am not clear on is when was the last time Maddie we seen other than by the McCanns?

I have read some reports and the timeline comes from then but how do we know that Maddie was alive, as your wife suggest something may have happened a lot earlier before they went to dinner?

 


One more point

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Mar 19 8.27pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I haven't watched this show, one question I am not clear on is when was the last time Maddie we seen other than by the McCanns?

I have read some reports and the timeline comes from then but how do we know that Maddie was alive, as your wife suggest something may have happened a lot earlier before they went to dinner?

But surely it was the surly, scruffy foreign type? He looked shifty to me.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Stirlingsays Flag 20 Mar 19 9.39pm

Originally posted by Badger11

One part of the Portuguese theory that never made sense was that the Tapas 7 are supposed to have helped cover up the crime.

They were holiday friends so the McCanns only saw them occasionally why would any of them owe the McCanns anything and risk jail time. Quite frankly if any of my family came to me to help cover up a death I would call the police immediately.

Lying who was driving when your caught speeding is one thing. Covering up the death of a child for someone you barely know! I don't believe it. I don't think those people have a clue what happened if they did they would have spoken out by now.


Yep, I've always found that to be a problem and unlikely to be apart of the solution......As we know the more people know something the less likely a conspiracy holds.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jeeagles Flag 20 Mar 19 9.46pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Not right; but getting distracted is a bit different to intentionally being a selfish
See you next tuesday.

Are you always this charming?

 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 21 Mar 19 12.32am

One of their party managed to block book the tapas restaurant for 7 nights for dinner for 8.30 pm

One of the party identified a strange man carrying a child

No one was surprised or thought to question why Mrs McCann was worried about her twins breathing/sleep after one was snatched.

They may have got away with accidentally killing their daughter and disposing of her body.....They maybe totally innocent but in this case the jury will always be out.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 21 Mar 19 6.57am

Originally posted by Badger11

I haven't watched this show, one question I am not clear on is when was the last time Maddie we seen other than by the McCanns?

I have read some reports and the timeline comes from then but how do we know that Maddie was alive, as your wife suggest something may have happened a lot earlier before they went to dinner?

THat s a very good question and one that hopefully will be answered

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 21 Mar 19 7.08am

The timeline of events for Maddie is probably massively distorted, if we only have K&G's word about 'checking on the children'. When was the last time she was seen, other than by K&G ?

The fridge in the apartment that was disposed of,..would that have traces of sedatives in it, where medication was stored ?

G always seems to look aggressive to me
K looks under immense stress, Who wouldn't be, after losing a child ? and potentially keeping a lid on what really happened ?

I've always wondered , if G got taken out of the equation, would K be free to tell of the real events ?

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 21 Mar 19 7.47am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Are you always this charming?

Normally I’m more charming but that wasn’t at you jeeagles.
It was at that sweaty pair of selfish tnucs.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 21 Mar 19 8.25am

The Sun , reporting on the latest instalment of Netflix today. Theories are discussed as to:

*Whether Maddie wandered onto some wasteground, looking for her parents, and climbed into one of the many storm drains in the area. WTF ?

* whether her body got buried in a workmans trench that was being backfilled in the locale. ?

I think most of us have an inkling by now of what is likely to have happened. Either by fluke or design, it just so happens that there is very little evidence of anything, let alone a body.
Whoever did it, has likely got away with it, as a result of destroyed evidence, police failings, and (false) accusations, misdirection and incomplete statements.

Why would parents leave their kids alone, night after night, in an unlocked apartment ?

I would love to see how Columbo, Jessica Fletcher or even Poirot would solve this.

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (21 Mar 2019 8.30am)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

eritheagle Flag Erith 21 Mar 19 11.24am

Originally posted by Spiderman

I agree. My wife has an interesting theory (call it female intuition). We have watched the first episode she found the following strange:
Kate making a big play about Maddie having spent a tiring day at the kids club and she could not walk home I had too carry her as she was asleep...why mention this:
When Kate ran back to the restaurant she said "Maddie has been taken" why not say "Maddie is missing or where is Maddie"
She would not have washed the teddy (unless trying to hide something)
My wife believes that the friends are not involved, her theory is that Maddie had already died before they met for dinner and had been carried to the boot of the car (by Kate and that is why she mentioned the tiredness) Perhaps the parents hoped one of the friends would make the discovery.
All just theory but not beyond the realms of possibility. I doubt we will never know the truth

I thought it was reported at the very beginning that one of the friends did check on all the kids. I may be wrong though.

 

jeeagles Flag 21 Mar 19 11.55am

Originally posted by cryrst

Normally I’m more charming but that wasn’t at you jeeagles.
It was at that sweaty pair of selfish tnucs.

OK. Thought it was a bit of a leap in the conversation.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Mar 19 8.56pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

I thought it was reported at the very beginning that one of the friends did check on all the kids. I may be wrong though.

Yes but he went to the apartment but did not open the bedroom door!

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 22 Mar 19 3.01am

Originally posted by JohnB

All speculation but this is worth a read:

This sounds a bit far fetched to me. The fact it includes so many publicly known individuals makes it sounds like someone dreamt it up. Not as though I know what happened either. I'm not convinced we'll ever know for sure.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 22 Mar 19 6.14am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Yeah, but then if your the kind of parent who'd go to dinner and leave their kids in the room, alone, and 'check on them every 20 minutes or so', you're probably more concerned about yourself than your kids.

If the police turn attention to you, then their focus will shift from looking for a missing kid, to trying you, Portuguese police don't seem to be very proficient - the usual UK policy is to divide the investigation into two separate approaches (one for the family and one for the search).

If they did it, the real question is how did they dispose of the body, in a short time scale, so effectively as not to be found - I can't imagine they had much time between going to dinner and reporting her missing.

I think if they did it, she was dead and disposed of before they went out to dinner, possibly the night before. The cover of being 'poor parents' is quite a good one (because you get blamed but your not seen as guilty - just being negligent).

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 22 Mar 19 6.22am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Yeah, but then if your the kind of parent who'd go to dinner and leave their kids in the room, alone, and 'check on them every 20 minutes or so', you're probably more concerned about yourself than your kids.

If the police turn attention to you, then their focus will shift from looking for a missing kid, to trying you, Portuguese police don't seem to be very proficient - the usual UK policy is to divide the investigation into two separate approaches (one for the family and one for the search).

If they did it, the real question is how did they dispose of the body, in a short time scale, so effectively as not to be found - I can't imagine they had much time between going to dinner and reporting her missing.

I think if they did it, she was dead and disposed of before they went out to dinner, possibly the night before. The cover of being 'poor parents' is quite a good one (because you get blamed but your not seen as guilty - just being negligent).


Surprising really that neglect is not a crime. I mean in the pc world we live in. If for instance a babysitter decided to pop out down the pub for a few drinks only returning every so often to check and leaving the house open, how would that be viewed?
I can’t believe a baby sitter behaving like that and then a kid disappearing would just walk free would they?
So what’s the difference?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 Mar 19 7.18am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider


Surprising really that neglect is not a crime. I mean in the pc world we live in. If for instance a babysitter decided to pop out down the pub for a few drinks only returning every so often to check and leaving the house open, how would that be viewed?
I can’t believe a baby sitter behaving like that and then a kid disappearing would just walk free would they?
So what’s the difference?

I might be wrong but I thought I have read somewhere that leaving kids alone is not seen as a crime in Portugal, therefore the Police could not act. With regard to previous post, Maddie was at the kids club during the day she disappeared, but there was a window of probably 3-4 hours before the dinner.

 

Page 11 of 16 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The McCanns