You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > De Boer set for talks about future
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

De Boer set for talks about future


Page 11 of 13 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 28 Aug 17 5.12pm

Originally posted by dazza

You say these are problems that needed to be addressed from last season and it is not FDB fault then as a manager whose fault is it.

If BFS was in charge we would probably of had 2 wins by now I am sorry but we are deluded if we don't think FDB is part to blame here.

The change of system has not helped either if BFS had stayed this would have been resolved it's the same as upfront why again have we gone into the season with just 1 striker we just never learn again surely FDB should have got one in back in August.

Look at Sam's record without Sahko. 0.85 points a game over 13 games! That's relegation form.

Ward and Kelly are both liabilities, and we've had to play them far too often due to a lack of any squad depth.

The issue is deeper than simply a change of manager.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Aug 17 5.16pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Look at Sam's record without Sahko. 0.85 points a game over 13 games! That's relegation form.

Ward and Kelly are both liabilities, and we've had to play them far too often due to a lack of any squad depth.

The issue is deeper than simply a change of manager.

Yes I totally agree.

 

est1905 Flag 28 Aug 17 5.19pm

Originally posted by dazza

You say these are problems that needed to be addressed from last season and it is not FDB fault then as a manager whose fault is it.

If BFS was in charge we would probably of had 2 wins by now I am sorry but we are deluded if we don't think FDB is part to blame here.

The change of system has not helped either if BFS had stayed this would have been resolved it's the same as upfront why again have we gone into the season with just 1 striker we just never learn again surely FDB should have got one in back in August.

If Allardyce had the same personnel available I think we would probably still lost the first three games. As Mr Willo pointed out it was individuals making errors that led to the goals. Neither Allardyce nor FdB could do anything about that.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 28 Aug 17 5.20pm

Originally posted by Willo

Yes I totally agree.

I don't get why so many people on these boards are focused on one person as though changing him would solve a long term deeper issue.

Our record (and it needs to be said again) without Sahko was awful. Sam averaged 0.85 points a game despite spending 30m. That is 32 points over a whole season.

Sam Allardyce, who is supposedly streaks ahead of FDB was in relegation form with the exception of one player (who is no longer at the club). That should speak volumes to supporters.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

dazza Flag Wallington 28 Aug 17 5.20pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Look at Sam's record without Sahko. 0.85 points a game over 13 games! That's relegation form.

Ward and Kelly are both liabilities, and we've had to play them far too often due to a lack of any squad depth.

The issue is deeper than simply a change of manager.

I agree but with a full pre-season BFS would have soughted this out, I think people forget that when BFS came in yes he had a slow start but he had no pre-season or time he had to use League games to asses his problems, FDB had a whole pre-season to see where his problems were and if the club can't support his changes then you play a system that works and change gradually.

I am sorry bu FDB is just as much to blame or are we going to say that the problems at Inter Milan were not his fault either.

Just ask one question are you seriously confident as things stand of palace winning in the next 5 games?


Edited by dazza (28 Aug 2017 5.21pm)

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 28 Aug 17 5.22pm

Originally posted by Willo

Yes I agree with a lot of this.
I would add that individual defensive errors have contributed to our downfall in the first 3 games.We have given away some poor goals.

My feelings too. We haven't lost because of any system. We've lost because of stupid individual errors, just like we did under Pardew. Need better defenders and a keeper, ones who can concentrate preferably.
But hang on a minute the pundits (failed or never were managers) have said otherwise, contradicting what even our own Jimmy Mac has said. Know who I'll listen to.
If the system is to blame can someone tell me why I've never noticed us playing it at home for the last four seasons?

Edited by Dangermouse (28 Aug 2017 6.06pm)

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Aug 17 5.27pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

I don't get why so many people on these boards are focused on one person as though changing him would solve a long term deeper issue.

Our record (and it needs to be said again) without Sahko was awful. Sam averaged 0.85 points a game despite spending 30m. That is 32 points over a whole season.

Sam Allardyce, who is supposedly streaks ahead of FDB was in relegation form with the exception of one player (who is no longer at the club). That should speak volumes to supporters.

Well done to Allardyce for ensuring our safety but we only secured it on the second to last game and we lost 4 of our last 5 games last season so we hardly finished on a 'High'.

All we have spent is £8 Mill on a permanent signing and brought in 2 inexperienced loanees so is it any surprise that we haven't started well ?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Aug 17 5.28pm

It's both. Or it's the players and forcing a formation that we can't select 11 players for, so play a few out of position, and at this level you cannot get away with it. Maybe in Holland you can.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Aug 17 5.31pm

Originally posted by Willo

Well done to Allardyce for ensuring our safety but we only secured it on the second to last game and we lost 4 of our last 5 games last season so we hardly finished on a 'High'.

All we have spent is £8 Mill on a permanent signing and brought in 2 inexperienced loanees so is it any surprise that we haven't started well ?

A good reason to go steady in a league and country new to the manager I'd have thought, rather than a radical change and easy areas for opposition to exploit (space behind our supposed wing backs, which is a joke in itself).

 


COYP

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 28 Aug 17 5.32pm

Originally posted by dazza

I agree but with a full pre-season BFS would have soughted this out, I think people forget that when BFS came in yes he had a slow start but he had no pre-season or time he had to use League games to asses his problems, FDB had a whole pre-season to see where his problems were and if the club can't support his changes then you play a system that works and change gradually.

I am sorry bu FDB is just as much to blame or are we going to say that the problems at Inter Milan were not his fault either.

Just ask one question are you seriously confident as things stand of palace winning in the next 5 games?


Edited by dazza (28 Aug 2017 5.21pm)

Look what happened to Inter that year. 4 managers in 12 months!

FDB got 12 (?) league games and got 14 points: this was despite the restrictions on the playing squad because of financial irregularities. That's poor by Inter standards, but apart from a short spell by the end of the season they were not much better off, despite two changes of manager.

No, but I wouldn't be confident with anyone else in charge right now either. There are too many players stealing a living at the club, and several who would get nowhere near most other teams squads, let alone first teams.

By the way, how do you know BFS would have sorted this out? That is conjecture, and his record was not great overall, if you took out our star defender. That problem does not automatically get fixed by better organization in pre-season.

I wanted Pellegrino or Silva, as I thought they would do the best with what we had. But the owners saw different, but have not yet really backed the manager with players.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Aug 17 5.33pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It's both. Or it's the players and forcing a formation that we can't select 11 players for, so play a few out of position, and at this level you cannot get away with it. Maybe in Holland you can.

As I mentioned before on HOL and got berated for it, I accept that Ajax hadn't won the title for a few seasons before FDB took over but they are an established top club with a famed academy and infrastructure playing in the Eredivisie.Bit different to our club playing in the far more demanding and challenging PL.

Edited by Willo (28 Aug 2017 5.33pm)

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 28 Aug 17 5.42pm

Yesterday I posted on the 5 FDB errors thread that we should give him or any manager the right resources to be competitive. After looking again at the recording of the match, I feel that even with the right resources FDB will not make it. He is learning on the job and was not the man to hit the ground running as Parish and others were convinced he would. FDB is a manger/coach out of his depth and class. Terrible hiring decision in hindsight, best to admit the brutal facts and move on. Parish and Co continue to make basic leadership errors though, so its not clear to me that whatever they decide will be a better solution. Frankly, the club is in a complete state of Leadership disarray, starting at the top. The Parish mentality stems from the days of survival, both financially and on the pitch. A bold new strategy would be required to stay in the Premiership. The idea that you wait to the last day to sign quality players is totally naive and makes the club mickey mouse in comparison to well run organizations.

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 28 Aug 17 5.46pm

Originally posted by dazza

I agree but with a full pre-season BFS would have soughted this out, I think people forget that when BFS came in yes he had a slow start but he had no pre-season or time he had to use League games to asses his problems, FDB had a whole pre-season to see where his problems were and if the club can't support his changes then you play a system that works and change gradually.

I am sorry bu FDB is just as much to blame or are we going to say that the problems at Inter Milan were not his fault either.

Just ask one question are you seriously confident as things stand of palace winning in the next 5 games?


Edited by dazza (28 Aug 2017 5.21pm)

BFS, had very poor results till he had Sakho, and I doubt he would have had much joy without Zaha. Zaha drives our offense, and system aside, his injury leaves a giant gap in any managers plans.

Maybe BFS would have ground out a 0-0 draw versus Hudderfield, but I doubt it --luck probably would have been the same and Mounie would have scored on a free header.

FDB has had one signing, and that signing played one game. This isn't the Hammers Bilic who has been in charge for a while, bought Arnautovic and Chichirito and they are still s***e. Or Bournemouth, who brought in Ake and Begovic and have been s***e.

You have to give a new manager more than 5 games, especially with a pretty lackluster squad, and laughable depth that gives him a bench that probably couldn't make the starting 11 in the Championship (bar Cabaye).

Edited by ThatPetrolRelation (28 Aug 2017 6.00pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Aug 17 5.56pm

Originally posted by radicalsteve

Yesterday I posted on the 5 FDB errors thread that we should give him or any manager the right resources to be competitive. After looking again at the recording of the match, I feel that even with the right resources FDB will not make it. He is learning on the job and was not the man to hit the ground running as Parish and others were convinced he would. FDB is a manger/coach out of his depth and class. Terrible hiring decision in hindsight, best to admit the brutal facts and move on. Parish and Co continue to make basic leadership errors though, so its not clear to me that whatever they decide will be a better solution. Frankly, the club is in a complete state of Leadership disarray, starting at the top. The Parish mentality stems from the days of survival, both financially and on the pitch. A bold new strategy would be required to stay in the Premiership. The idea that you wait to the last day to sign quality players is totally naive and makes the club mickey mouse in comparison to well run organizations.

Where is the firm evidence that this is a club strategy in terms of acquiring players ?

Often the process of securing one's targets can be really protracted and frustrating with various factors coming in to play so in many instances one cannot blame the club if targets don't 'Get over the line' far quicker.

I happen to believe that there will be a plethora of late signings, across the board as the 'Window' come to a close.Will be a busy week for a host of clubs.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 28 Aug 17 6.08pm

Originally posted by Willo

Where is the firm evidence that this is a club strategy in terms of acquiring players ?

Often the process of securing one's targets can be really protracted and frustrating with various factors coming in to play so in many instances one cannot blame the club if targets don't 'Get over the line' far quicker.

I happen to believe that there will be a plethora of late signings, across the board as the 'Window' come to a close.Will be a busy week for a host of clubs.

I think your're right Willo. Problem is that our disastrous start is placing us at a disadvantage compared to currently more boyant rivals such as Stoke or WBA, who are likely to be the preferred choice of players like Burke or Wimmer who we have already missed out on ( and yes I am feeling down!)

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 28 Aug 17 6.11pm

Like most seasons we have a very good 12/13 players, after that we are struggling. Until our bench improves and Wilf and RLC return any manager would struggle.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 28 Aug 17 6.18pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

I think your're right Willo. Problem is that our disastrous start is placing us at a disadvantage compared to currently more boyant rivals such as Stoke or WBA, who are likely to be the preferred choice of players like Burke or Wimmer who we have already missed out on ( and yes I am feeling down!)

Is there any evidence, and I don't include rumours in the press, that we were actually in for either of them?

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Petereagle Flag Brockley 28 Aug 17 6.21pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Is there any evidence, and I don't include rumours in the press, that we were actually in for either of them?

No, just 'rumours'. But in th etransfer season, there's nit much else to go on!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Aug 17 6.23pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Like most seasons we have a very good 12/13 players, after that we are struggling. Until our bench improves and Wilf and RLC return any manager would struggle.

Dangermouse

I think "Very good" might be over-stating the reality !
But I understand the sentiments.

Leaving aside the various arguments discussed on HOL regarding tactics,transfers etc etc maybe there are other issues behind the scenes.Don't know of the 'Chemistry' between FDB and the players and whether he he has 'Lost' the dressing room etc etc - I've not heard of any such issues.

Also I accept a picture doesn't always tell the whole story but I have seen shots whereby FDB is in conversation with Trustfull with Lee seemingly not involved.In a picture on Saturday, FDB is sitting next to Trustfull with Lee standing up at the end of the dugout away from them.Not sure of the 'Chemistry' between all three of them.

Is FDB happy at the club ? Has he regretted coming ?
Will he decide to step down ?

Just some other issues for consideration !

Edited by Willo (28 Aug 2017 6.25pm)

 

Tommyp151211 Flag 28 Aug 17 6.24pm

Personally I think all of this hysteria from fans and the media is just a storm a teacup.

The board will back De Boer this week. There'll be a little more strength in depth, some more work on the training ground and the more time he has the more things will improve.

De Boer has continually acknowledged the supporters and he has been let down by us.

McArthur's comments didn't actually scream of a dressing room revolt as reported.

 

Page 11 of 13 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > De Boer set for talks about future