You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 12 of 44 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
Barcelona Based Fan Flag No longer Barcelona, now living in... 08 Dec 16 3.59pm

We all know if Hoof was in a room on his own he'd still have an argument! ! Feed the beast and he'll chomp till the cows come home; )

 


TaxiMark
Sheffield Wednesday Fan
Posted 23 February 2013 - 07:49 PM
I don't mind palace to be fair. Much better club than tinpot Charlton and Brighton

7mins Flag In the bush 08 Dec 16 4.00pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

You need to butt out... there are moderators to ensure fair play and limit abuse.... but as usual you ignore your own failings and only comment upon instances that go against your union agenda.

Yes he is/was making stuff up and he upped the ante on the level of abuse so I upped my game... and I will continue to if he wants to play that game.

as for Jap's eye... he has been sniping away at me and others on multiple threads and deserves the abuse back quite frankly.

Withdraw or substantiate the comment about me making stuff up

 

7mins Flag In the bush 08 Dec 16 4.05pm

ASLEF win court case, strikes to go ahead.

My guess is, GTR will let the first strike happen, to see how strong the walk out is.

Will be interesting to see if DfT come under pressure to accept the scotrail deal. Massive climb down if they do.

 

Barcelona Based Fan Flag No longer Barcelona, now living in... 08 Dec 16 4.16pm

Power to the People lol

 


TaxiMark
Sheffield Wednesday Fan
Posted 23 February 2013 - 07:49 PM
I don't mind palace to be fair. Much better club than tinpot Charlton and Brighton

steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 08 Dec 16 4.27pm

Originally posted by 7mins

ASLEF win court case, strikes to go ahead.

My guess is, GTR will let the first strike happen, to see how strong the walk out is.

Will be interesting to see if DfT come under pressure to accept the scotrail deal. Massive climb down if they do.

Wonderful. Three days of no work for me and many others then

 

Stuk Flag Top half 08 Dec 16 4.29pm

Originally posted by 7mins

ASLEF win court case, strikes to go ahead.

My guess is, GTR will let the first strike happen, to see how strong the walk out is.

Will be interesting to see if DfT come under pressure to accept the scotrail deal. Massive climb down if they do.

I thought ASLEF were only doing no overtime, not striking.

 


Optimistic as ever

IMpalace Flag London 08 Dec 16 4.33pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

So should we make them more safe, for example have one guard per carriage?

Or are we at the "right level" of safety and if so who says so?

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (06 Dec 2016 4.21pm)

Indeed.

7mins as someone with the knowledge in the sector (don't want that to come across as sarcy, genuinely interested), LU runs with no guards and must have more (if not a similar) number of passengers on it's services. I assume there are other rail networks in the country without guards?

1) have they experienced significant safety issues not seen on southern as a result of southern having guards?

2) if this is such a material safety issue why aren't we seeing strikes across all those networks where guards don't exist?

 

Barcelona Based Fan Flag No longer Barcelona, now living in... 08 Dec 16 4.45pm

Originally posted by Ted the eagle

How the feck are 25,000 bods supposed to get to/from Selhurst next Wednesday night? Madness.

Might have to postpone this!
Despite it going to be difficult getting there I hope not.
It's the right time to play them plus they have a game Sunday after a long trip back from Ukraine.

 


TaxiMark
Sheffield Wednesday Fan
Posted 23 February 2013 - 07:49 PM
I don't mind palace to be fair. Much better club than tinpot Charlton and Brighton

Stuk Flag Top half 08 Dec 16 4.47pm

Originally posted by Barcelona Based Fan

Might have to postpone this!
Despite it going to be difficult getting there I hope not.
It's the right time to play them plus they have a game Sunday after a long trip back from Ukraine.

Not a chance. It's on TV don't forget.

 


Optimistic as ever

7mins Flag In the bush 08 Dec 16 4.49pm

Originally posted by IMpalace

Indeed.

7mins as someone with the knowledge in the sector (don't want that to come across as sarcy, genuinely interested), LU runs with no guards and must have more (if not a similar) number of passengers on it's services. I assume there are other rail networks in the country without guards?

1) have they experienced significant safety issues not seen on southern as a result of southern having guards?

2) if this is such a material safety issue why aren't we seeing strikes across all those networks where guards don't exist?

If Southern kept platform staff, they wouldn't have much of a problem. The CCTV is too unreliable.., rain makes it hard to see, the cameras are fitted with "low level light" warnings, so after dark 30% of the time, drivers were getting these warnings.., this meant the driver couldn't rely on it, also curved platforms meant on longer trains the driver couldn't see the back of the train.

Out of the last 10 trap n drags, 7 were DOO. Not good stats.

There is a system called "interlock", there is a micro switch above each door, when all doors are closed this creates a circuit that manifests itself via a blue (I think) light in the drivers cab, this tells the driver all doors are secure.. Unfortunately this is also unreliable, if a small child's arm or a scarf is caught in the door, it will drag the child/person along when train pulls off.
We had a old man stick a crutch in the doors of a train, it was a grey crutch, that blended in to the grey background, the driver couldn't see it on the CCTV, and dragged a of boy down the platform, he was lucky he fell backwards not forwards.


*the trap n drag stats are accurate at the time I left the industry.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 08 Dec 16 4.59pm

Originally posted by Stuk

I thought ASLEF were only doing no overtime, not striking.

ASLEF have withdrawn non contractual work (overtime and favours)
Then 8 days later they have the first of their strikes. The reason for the 8 day gap, is it gives time for negotiation... Southern decided to go court instead of ACAS.. They have now lost that case.,, I'm sure they will appeal, but they are running out of time for negotiating a compromise.
If you can't reach a settlement in negotiations, its important you leave good communication avenues for a later date...Southern (with the guards) stormed off and withdrew staff travel, even their employees kids lost their travel passes. They also stopped all staff swapping shifts...massive own goal... They had staff who swap for childcare purposes, also staff who are carers to disabled kids/parents... Shift swaps have zero effect on the business... But this pissed all staff off... It was hard to go back to negotiations after that, employees were pissed... They wanted to strike even more.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 08 Dec 16 5.00pm

Have to admit having to consider carefully how I can travel back from SE25 to North London at 10pm without the trains is stretching my sympathy.

Either a bus into london to pick up the tube/overground or a bus into East Croydon and then the thameslink into town.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 08 Dec 16 5.00pm

The only losers in this absurd, luddite-inspired dispute are the travelling public. Terminate GTR's franchise and sack the strikers who, frankly, have absolutely no right to f*** people's lives up to the extent they have.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

IMpalace Flag London 08 Dec 16 5.02pm

Originally posted by 7mins

If Southern kept platform staff, they wouldn't have much of a problem. The CCTV is too unreliable.., rain makes it hard to see, the cameras are fitted with "low level light" warnings, so after dark 30% of the time, drivers were getting these warnings.., this meant the driver couldn't rely on it, also curved platforms meant on longer trains the driver couldn't see the back of the train.

Out of the last 10 trap n drags, 7 were DOO. Not good stats.

There is a system called "interlock", there is a micro switch above each door, when all doors are closed this creates a circuit that manifests itself via a blue (I think) light in the drivers cab, this tells the driver all doors are secure.. Unfortunately this is also unreliable, if a small child's arm or a scarf is caught in the door, it will drag the child/person along when train pulls off.
We had a old man stick a crutch in the doors of a train, it was a grey crutch, that blended in to the grey background, the driver couldn't see it on the CCTV, and dragged a of boy down the platform, he was lucky he fell backwards not forwards.


*the trap n drag stats are accurate at the time I left the industry.

Right, so you're saying that the outdoor issues (being above ground and so susceptible to light conditions and being exposed to weather) and no people on station platform is specific to southern and no other providers?

I'm just trying to ascertain whether the conditions that the strikes are over occur elsewhere in the industry and are accepted or if this is a new issue that hasn't been tested anywhere else in our country before?

 

7mins Flag In the bush 08 Dec 16 5.08pm

Southern is run on a fixed cost management franchise. Essentially, DFT pay a guaranteed amount to Southern to run the services (DFT get ticket revenue). Any extra money made through cut backs in staffing levels is profit for Southern/parent company.

This makes it extra appealing to get rid of as much staff as possible. They were planning to push people in to online tickets, a oyster card type system... This would allow them to close ticket offices. McNulty report wanted post offices to sell tickets also.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 08 Dec 16 5.13pm

Originally posted by IMpalace

Right, so you're saying that the outdoor issues (being above ground and so susceptible to light conditions and being exposed to weather) and no people on station platform is specific to southern and no other providers?

I'm just trying to ascertain whether the conditions that the strikes are over occur elsewhere in the industry and are accepted or if this is a new issue that hasn't been tested anywhere else in our country before?

I don't know if other TOCs have problems... I don't even know how widespread doo is on over TOC's.
Southwest have guards, SouthEastern have a ScotRail type agreement.
My guess is.... Southern is being used as a test case (hence the DfT offering this industry unique franchise deal). What happens at Southern will be rolled out nationwide... That is just a guess thou

 

IMpalace Flag London 08 Dec 16 5.23pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Southern is run on a fixed cost management franchise. Essentially, DFT pay a guaranteed amount to Southern to run the services (DFT get ticket revenue). Any extra money made through cut backs in staffing levels is profit for Southern/parent company.

This makes it extra appealing to get rid of as much staff as possible. They were planning to push people in to online tickets, a oyster card type system... This would allow them to close ticket offices. McNulty report wanted post offices to sell tickets also.

As mentioned previously the system makes no sense to me. I assume in theory a lower cost more efficient network would reduce prices for customers and the above system would then makes sense.

What I assume happens is we get given inflation linked ticket price increases regardless of what's going on behind the scenes and various people walk away making more money off the network.

What really annoys me is I'm sure there are faults on both sides here, the only people not at fault are the customers and the people who are paying the price for all of it... the customers.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 08 Dec 16 5.29pm

Originally posted by steph_eagle

Wonderful. Three days of no work for me and many others then

My guess is... If Southern stopped using the courts and engaged in finding solutions via meaningful talks with unions/ACAS... Then the strikes would be suspended.

One thing I can say without any shadow of a doubt...management f***in hate the drivers... They see them as holding too much power. Southern drivers haven't been on industrial action in over 20yrs... I always thought the hatred was misplaced

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 08 Dec 16 5.35pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

The only losers in this absurd, luddite-inspired dispute are the travelling public. Terminate GTR's franchise and sack the strikers who, frankly, have absolutely no right to f*** people's lives up to the extent they have.

well said, CF.
concur.
Outrageous this has been allowed to go on so long.
Most of the basterds aren't strikers tho, they'call in sick'

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

7mins Flag In the bush 08 Dec 16 5.53pm

Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall

well said, CF.
concur.
Outrageous this has been allowed to go on so long.
Most of the basterds aren't strikers tho, they'call in sick'

Sick pay withdrawn unless you have a docs note. Docs won't issue sick note until you've been off for 7 days AND doc is convinced you're not fit for work

Edited by 7mins (08 Dec 2016 5.55pm)

 

Page 12 of 44 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong