You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What a JOKE this season . First FDB now Freedman
November 16 2026 8.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What a JOKE this season . First FDB now Freedman


Page 1 of 10 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Croydonlad Flag sydenham 21 Aug 17 4.19pm

Most already know about my thoughts on FDB and his ridiculous change of system without the p[layers to carry it out
Now today we have the appointment of Dougie Freedman.
I don't care about how he left the club back in 2012 , thats football and everyone is out for themselves , clubs and employees included
What I DO CARE about is that this appointment of a VERY AVERAGE CHAMPIONSHIP manager has clearly been put in place so that Freedman can replace FDB when he fails , as he will do , probably before christmas time .
The first few weeks speaks bucket loads of the ambition of Parish and the club . Clearly FDB was the only manager available that was going to accept the limited budget , and in doing so said that he wanted to change style . In not having funds definitely speeded up Big Sam's retirement and definitely left Tony Pulis feeling less than confident .
So here we are , bottom of the table , a team in confusion , manager without a clue ,no transfer budget , and a sporting director who's managed a championship side for a season and half.
What a joke
This time next year , Freedman will be manager , we will be in the Championship .

 

Far away fan Flag On the border of jungle 21 Aug 17 4.31pm

Agreed

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 21 Aug 17 4.31pm

And last season we had got Tomkins, Townsend and Benteke, people were saying how we could push for Europe and by Christmas we were hovering around at the bottom.

I can understand your thinking (though it's a bit negative!) and the signing of three youngsters (two on loan) doesn't exactly inspire confidence. I too can see FDB being sacked if it doesn't work out and Freedman drafted in as manager.

However, may be it will all work out. It looks like there are financial constraints and we have to hope it works out and get behind the team.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 21 Aug 17 4.40pm

Fair enough Fish
But that " we are Palace " mentality is getting really tiring
We are a London club , been in the Premiership for 5 years
We should be stable by now
But no , every year is a big dipper ride , and our excuse is , " ahh but we are Palace " yes we are , a London club with a supporter catchment of 50 thousand plus .
We deserve better from the club , much better !!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Aug 17 4.43pm

Originally posted by fish mitten

And last season we had got Tomkins, Townsend and Benteke, people were saying how we could push for Europe and by Christmas we were hovering around at the bottom.

I can understand your thinking (though it's a bit negative!) and the signing of three youngsters (two on loan) doesn't exactly inspire confidence. I too can see FDB being sacked if it doesn't work out and Freedman drafted in as manager.

However, may be it will all work out. It looks like there are financial constraints and we have to hope it works out and get behind the team.

God forbid.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Aug 17 4.45pm

Croydonlad, I'm very concerned with things in the 1st team squad but IMO you should perhaps wind your neck in a tad or you're going to confirm, if you haven't already, your bell 3nd status.

Your special brew drunken rants are a little premature. I'd wait until the window closes and we've played 2 of the next 3 league games. Until then you're polluting the forum with apoplectic noise.

Good day.

 


COYP

dorking Flag 21 Aug 17 4.45pm

One positive is that we looked a bit more solid in the Liverpool game, well in the first half at least.

All the players playing 'out of position' is a concern, as is the perennial decision to not make all our signings until the end of August, effectively reducing our chances in the first few games as we 'make do' with what we have got.

I'm not too convinced by FdB, but will give him 6-10 games to see what he can do, after that though, if we are still rock bottom, he's gotta go.

You do wonder if Sammy Lee could do something, he must have a good idea about the defensive foundations upon which the team was built last season.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 21 Aug 17 4.52pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Most already know about my thoughts on FDB and his ridiculous change of system without the p[layers to carry it out
Now today we have the appointment of Dougie Freedman.
I don't care about how he left the club back in 2012 , thats football and everyone is out for themselves , clubs and employees included
What I DO CARE about is that this appointment of a VERY AVERAGE CHAMPIONSHIP manager has clearly been put in place so that Freedman can replace FDB when he fails , as he will do , probably before christmas time .
The first few weeks speaks bucket loads of the ambition of Parish and the club . Clearly FDB was the only manager available that was going to accept the limited budget , and in doing so said that he wanted to change style . In not having funds definitely speeded up Big Sam's retirement and definitely left Tony Pulis feeling less than confident .
So here we are , bottom of the table , a team in confusion , manager without a clue ,no transfer budget , and a sporting director who's managed a championship side for a season and half.
What a joke
This time next year , Freedman will be manager , we will be in the Championship .

Best you go and have some medicine and have a little laydown before SP does something else to wind you up!

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 21 Aug 17 4.53pm

Holy f***! -.-' -.-'

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Stuart Shave Flag Hampshire 21 Aug 17 4.56pm

And the biggest joke of course have to be the Palace 'fans' who seem intent on wanting to destroy and knock everything good the club tries to do.

Of course nobody knows if this will turn out to be a good or bad appointment. The club clearly think it's a good idea that can continue building what Freedman actually started.

For Christ's sake stop knocking the club, board, manager and chairman and let them get on with the job they have managed to do pretty successfully so far. We are going through a transformation and it might hurt to start with, but at least give these people some kind of chance to make that extra bit of difference.

The truth is none of us know anything about how to take Palace to the next step, our finances or how the club is run. From the outside it looks a very well run club. Just trust people to know what they're doing. Imangine doing your job and people knocking you with every bit of good you try to do for the company. Just shocking support this season. Get a grip.

Edited by Stuart Shave (21 Aug 2017 5.29pm)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 17 5.07pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Croydonlad, I'm very concerned with things in the 1st team squad but IMO you should perhaps wind your neck in a tad or you're going to confirm, if you haven't already, your bell 3nd status.

Your special brew drunken rants are a little premature. I'd wait until the window closes and we've played 2 of the next 3 league games. Until then you're polluting the forum with apoplectic noise.

Good day.

Yup

I do wonder if the club decided pretty much to write off the first few games, knowing we weren't going to be competitive until after the last knockings of the transfer window. So we lose three League games and save goodness knows how much in our transfer dealings.

I am therefore expecting mucho exciteamento in the next two weeks but fully expect also that I may be disappointed.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Aug 17 5.11pm

Originally posted by Stuart Shave

And the biggest joke of course have to be the Palace 'fans' who seem intent on wanting to destroy and knock everything good the club tries to do.

Of course nobody if this will turn out to be a good or bad appointment. The club clearly think it's a good idea that can continue building what Freedman actually started.

For Christ's sake stop knocking the club, board, manager and chairman and let them get on with the job they managed to do pretty successfully so far. We are going through a transformation and it might hurt to start with, but at least give these people some kind of chance to make that extra bit of difference.

The truth is none of us know anything about how to take Palace to the next step, our finances or how the club is run. From the outside it looks a very well run club. Just trust people to know what they're doing. Imangine doing your job and people knocking you with every bit of good you try to do for the company. Just shocking support this season. Get a grip.

Agree with this in it's entirity

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 21 Aug 17 5.12pm

Originally posted by dorking

One positive is that we looked a bit more solid in the Liverpool game, well in the first half at least.

All the players playing 'out of position' is a concern, as is the perennial decision to not make all our signings until the end of August, effectively reducing our chances in the first few games as we 'make do' with what we have got.

I'm not too convinced by FdB, but will give him 6-10 games to see what he can do, after that though, if we are still rock bottom, he's gotta go.

You do wonder if Sammy Lee could do something, he must have a good idea about the defensive foundations upon which the team was built last season.

6/10 games very good of you.
Best go and support the valiants.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Mstrobez Flag 21 Aug 17 5.12pm

I Got stick for vocally wanting Pardew out so I know what it's like but seriously if this is how you act after 2 league games then you really are barely a supporter. Support and get behind the team, if by the end of October we're bang in trouble then you can laugh and say I told you so, but reactions like this early on are literally embarrassing. The name "Nigel's" comes to mind.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Mstrobez Flag 21 Aug 17 5.15pm

Imagine if Frank came onto these forums after being told by steve Parish that we have the best fans in England. I think we can safely say that title is well and truly gone. Bunch of spoilt over the top drama queens, get a f***ing hold of yourself.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 21 Aug 17 5.19pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Croydonlad, I'm very concerned with things in the 1st team squad but IMO you should perhaps wind your neck in a tad or you're going to confirm, if you haven't already, your bell 3nd status.

Your special brew drunken rants are a little premature. I'd wait until the window closes and we've played 2 of the next 3 league games. Until then you're polluting the forum with apoplectic noise.

Good day.

Yep. Rants based mostly on supposition and conjecture.

Squad does remain a concern but having listened to the whole of SP's time on 5 Live yesterday I'm hopeful for the next couple of weeks.


Originally posted by Stuart Shave

And the biggest joke of course have to be the Palace 'fans' who seem intent on wanting to destroy and knock everything good the club tries to do.

Of course nobody if this will turn out to be a good or bad appointment. The club clearly think it's a good idea that can continue building what Freedman actually started.

For Christ's sake stop knocking the club, board, manager and chairman and let them get on with the job they managed to do pretty successfully so far. We are going through a transformation and it might hurt to start with, but at least give these people some kind of chance to make that extra bit of difference.

The truth is none of us know anything about how to take Palace to the next step, our finances or how the club is run. From the outside it looks a very well run club. Just trust people to know what they're doing. Imangine doing your job and people knocking you with every bit of good you try to do for the company. Just shocking support this season. Get a grip.

Hush now, there's no room round here for sense and patience!

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Zschopautaler Flag 21 Aug 17 5.20pm

Sam Allerdyce was never for the long term.That in my opinion was the problem with appointing him. No disrespect to the man he did what he had to do. That has now left us in the same position as last summer with more money having been spent on players another manager felt he needed.
Hoping that Dougie is a good appointment oversčeong all levels of the playing staff to be on the same wave length allowing the mamager to concentrate on the first team.

 

PaddyMcPaddy Flag 21 Aug 17 5.21pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Fair enough Fish
But that " we are Palace " mentality is getting really tiring
We are a London club , been in the Premiership for 5 years
We should be stable by now
But no , every year is a big dipper ride , and our excuse is , " ahh but we are Palace " yes we are , a London club with a supporter catchment of 50 thousand plus .
We deserve better from the club , much better !!

I would guess there is 7 stable clubs in the Prem League. Everyone else is a bad season away from relegation. So no we shouldn't expect to be stable as you put it.

What we should be doing is slowly pushing towards being more of a Stoke or WBA. Although this takes years and is basically the aim of all the other 12 clubs in the league as well.

Also being a London club doesn't always help. You may have noticed we aren't the biggest fish in that Pond.

 

PaddyMcPaddy Flag 21 Aug 17 5.24pm

Originally posted by dorking

One positive is that we looked a bit more solid in the Liverpool game, well in the first half at least.

All the players playing 'out of position' is a concern, as is the perennial decision to not make all our signings until the end of August, effectively reducing our chances in the first few games as we 'make do' with what we have got.

I'm not too convinced by FdB, but will give him 6-10 games to see what he can do, after that though, if we are still rock bottom, he's gotta go.

You do wonder if Sammy Lee could do something, he must have a good idea about the defensive foundations upon which the team was built last season.

Ask Bolton about Sammy Lee as the manager then see if he could do something.
Obviously a good coach but lets just leave him to that. People seem to think he is some sort of genius.

 

Eewires Flag Guildford 21 Aug 17 5.30pm

Originally posted by dorking

One positive is that we looked a bit more solid in the Liverpool game, well in the first half at least.

All the players playing 'out of position' is a concern, as is the perennial decision to not make all our signings until the end of August, effectively reducing our chances in the first few games as we 'make do' with what we have got.

I'm not too convinced by FdB, but will give him 6-10 games to see what he can do, after that though, if we are still rock bottom, he's gotta go.

You do wonder if Sammy Lee could do something, he must have a good idea about the defensive foundations upon which the team was built last season.


Sammy Lee has a history as a great assistant and a crap manager. He's failed everywhere he's tried, albeit that isn't many attempts.

 

Page 1 of 10 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What a JOKE this season . First FDB now Freedman