You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 5.29pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 12 of 166 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 14 Jan 18 9.21pm

The world of statistics means you can use them either way to argue your point that you are trying to make. Facts are hes a class player whos not getting the results he should have got or that we had hoped for as fans.
Roy is playing him because he cost 30 mill and we have no other out and out striker.
Those who say give him more time to come good are ... well... running out of time faster than benteke runs on the pitch.

Not his greatest fan but want him to come good as im 100 % palace.

COYP

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 14 Jan 18 9.30pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

I support him as he plays for Palace and I want Palace to do well.
For Palace to do well we want our best XI on the pitch , he is one of them.
1 goal this season , well have a look at the season. first 7 games all were complete rubbish or impossible due to Frank.
Then Benteke was injured and returned I think at the end of the 2-2 draw with Everton. Then he came on at half time v Stoke and we won 2-1. Include that game he has played in 10 out of 11 and we won 5 drew 4 and only lost one. The Swansea game he did not play we looked a poorer side and lacked direction.
This suggests to me we are a better team with him in the side. Roy has picked him every time he has been available to him in this period , and said we cannot afford to carry players , therefore Roy must also believe Benteke is part of our best team.
You say he has not much choice but he would not play him if he was giving zero effort as you and others suggest.
Benteke would be wanted most of the bottom 12 teams and causes others teams of similar quality to us problems. We saw the two big lumps Burnley played yesterday I would take Benteke over those types and Shane long all day.
What I don't understand is why you and others just want to bitch and slag him off when Palace are having a great run and he is contributing to it . A little bit of quality wins some tight premiership games and he can provide it and when he adds goals it will be great for us , so why don't you support him until he does ?
You seem to want to see him run all over the pitch like a headless chicken so you don't have to look too hard to see what he contributes .
Anyway as you said we will go with what Roy decides to do , I have no problem supporting Benteke untilhe is no longer Palace.


Hear hear !

 

YT Flag Oxford 14 Jan 18 10.08pm

I admit I’ve only seen the highlights, but I thought Tekkers did some great stuff.

I’ve said before that footie is a team game. Tekkers is part of the team and the team is doing well.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 14 Jan 18 10.16pm

Originally posted by YT

I admit I’ve only seen the highlights, but I thought Tekkers did some great stuff.

I’ve said before that footie is a team game. Tekkers is part of the team and the team is doing well.

Nice and Simply put.

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 14 Jan 18 10.25pm

MK is absolutely correct. Benteke is key to our playing style. When he has not played our forward play has been totally without focus and when he has played , in the last 12 games he has contributed massively to us gaining the points. The fact that he has not put the ball in the back of the net does not make him a rubbish player, only a player not 100% on his game. There are plenty of examples of our team at various times not on their game but that does not make them rubbish players. Benteke will be key to us surviving in this league he has contributed massively to our recent run of success and just think how it will be when his goal scoring form changes. Every player at Palace deserves our support even when things are not going their way. As has been said many times form is temporary but class is permanent and Benteke has class.
COYP

 

mattteo Flag 14 Jan 18 10.30pm

Originally posted by eagle@ tn34

The world of statistics means you can use them either way to argue your point that you are trying to make. Facts are hes a class player

No, statistics are facts.

That he's a class player is just your opinion

 

chateauferret Flag 14 Jan 18 10.46pm

Originally posted by mattteo

No, statistics are facts.

That he's a class player is just your opinion

No they aren't! They're aggregates of selected facts.

 


============
The Ferret
============

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 14 Jan 18 10.48pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

I support him as he plays for Palace and I want Palace to do well.
For Palace to do well we want our best XI on the pitch , he is one of them.
1 goal this season , well have a look at the season. first 7 games all were complete rubbish or impossible due to Frank.
Then Benteke was injured and returned I think at the end of the 2-2 draw with Everton. Then he came on at half time v Stoke and we won 2-1. Include that game he has played in 10 out of 11 and we won 5 drew 4 and only lost one. The Swansea game he did not play we looked a poorer side and lacked direction.
This suggests to me we are a better team with him in the side. Roy has picked him every time he has been available to him in this period , and said we cannot afford to carry players , therefore Roy must also believe Benteke is part of our best team.
You say he has not much choice but he would not play him if he was giving zero effort as you and others suggest.
Benteke would be wanted most of the bottom 12 teams and causes others teams of similar quality to us problems. We saw the two big lumps Burnley played yesterday I would take Benteke over those types and Shane long all day.
What I don't understand is why you and others just want to bitch and slag him off when Palace are having a great run and he is contributing to it . A little bit of quality wins some tight premiership games and he can provide it and when he adds goals it will be great for us , so why don't you support him until he does ?
You seem to want to see him run all over the pitch like a headless chicken so you don't have to look too hard to see what he contributes .
Anyway as you said we will go with what Roy decides to do , I have no problem supporting Benteke untilhe is no longer Palace.

I support every palace player, providing they give 100%. Sadly I don't feel he is. Nothing would please me more than him getting a hatrick against arsenal and going on a good run of goals, but I just can't see it happening.

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 14 Jan 18 10.57pm

On this thread I have read that Christian is a member of the Palace Team and his being on the pitch helps. Football is a team game and getting goals is often associated with opposing players being in the wrong place. I saw Burnley setting three to watch and two to watch Christian. This gives other Palace players opportunities. COYP

 

mattteo Flag 14 Jan 18 10.59pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

No they aren't! They're aggregates of selected facts.


Everything is an aggregate of a selected fact.
The fact that I'm tall is an aggregate of my centimeters.
The fact that we eat 3 times a day is an aggregate of our daily habits.
The fact that they don't reflect the entire information about us as persons is another thing, but nothing ever gives ALL the information.

Still, statistics are facts.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 14 Jan 18 11.36pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

I support every palace player, providing they give 100%. Sadly I don't feel he is. Nothing would please me more than him getting a hatrick against arsenal and going on a good run of goals, but I just can't see it happening.

What would make you feel he is giving 100% ?
Would you prefer a forward running around ineffectively for 90 mins and not creating space and chances for others ?

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 14 Jan 18 11.59pm

Originally posted by mattteo

No, statistics are facts.

That he's a class player is just your opinion

in the past benteke was a class player. Just like in the past Maradona was a force to be reckoned with.

Whether Benteke gets back his form or ends up playing in the Championship will be determined over the next few weeks. By the Ides of March he will either be a hero or a zero.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 15 Jan 18 12.25am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

in the past benteke was a class player. Just like in the past Maradona was a force to be reckoned with.

Whether Benteke gets back his form or ends up playing in the Championship will be determined over the next few weeks. By the Ides of March he will either be a hero or a zero.

What happens on the 15th of March ?

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 15 Jan 18 12.52am

There is a pattern here..... Rogers bought Benteke for Liverpool on the basis of what he was like at Aston Villa which, was a beast of a player, powerful going forward and goals with both feet and head. Virtually unplayable at times. Failed to find anywhere near this form with the scousers and when Klopp came in gave him a chance but got rid to us for the same fee as they paid, so nothing lost.

We bought him based again on the same thing Liverpool did.... His stunning form at Villa. The thinking of both clubs being 'hope'.

Neither us or Liverpool paid over £30m and with wages of £120k for him to do the occasional great flick or pass. He was wanted to score goals and lots of them. I keep reading many posts in his defence ...... His 15 goals last season/he clearly has little confidence and once he gets one he will go on a scoring spree/the flick against Burnley etc etc.

If a player is short on confidence then I would expect him to knuckle down to the hardest work possible on the training pitch and graft with the results on display on the pitch. All great goal scorers did it.... Wright and Bright, Rush (look at the way he used to close down defenders creating opportunities). In short they and others used to work hard at their game. I have closely watched CB over the past 6 games and I have not seen any such effort, determination or focus. Instead I have watched a player being a shadow of his former Aston Villa self. Others have pointed to his lack of movement and a footballing brain so I am not going to go into that detail here.

Ian Wright on MOTD repeatedly picked out his weaknesses against Burnley, namely his positioning and inability to attack the ball in the air. Yesterday he could and should have got two maybe three goals, that's what we paid the big bucks for and he has been given every chance to prove himself but as I have said previously he is like driving a car with the hand brake on.

There is no desire in his actions or eyes unlike Sako who looks hungary and scares defenders. For that matter what about Kelly's incredible chase and slide tackle at the end if the first half.

I fear that we will never see the Benteke of old, he was hungary but has now been well and truly fed to the point where his thinking is why should I really put myself out when I have untold riches with no one competing for my place and a contract that protects me with another possible big pay day coming up, if sold.

Can you imagine what we would be like with a dynamic big centre forward who terrorises the centre halves and bangs in his fair share of chances?

Saying all this I would dearly love to see CB release the hand brake but fear this just too much to hope...there we go again!


 


Bring back Brolin

rattus2002 Flag 15 Jan 18 1.46am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

There is a pattern here..... Rogers bought Benteke for Liverpool on the basis of what he was like at Aston Villa which, was a beast of a player, powerful going forward and goals with both feet and head. Virtually unplayable at times. Failed to find anywhere near this form with the scousers and when Klopp came in gave him a chance but got rid to us for the same fee as they paid, so nothing lost.

We bought him based again on the same thing Liverpool did.... His stunning form at Villa. The thinking of both clubs being 'hope'.

Neither us or Liverpool paid over £30m and with wages of £120k for him to do the occasional great flick or pass. He was wanted to score goals and lots of them. I keep reading many posts in his defence ...... His 15 goals last season/he clearly has little confidence and once he gets one he will go on a scoring spree/the flick against Burnley etc etc.

If a player is short on confidence then I would expect him to knuckle down to the hardest work possible on the training pitch and graft with the results on display on the pitch. All great goal scorers did it.... Wright and Bright, Rush (look at the way he used to close down defenders creating opportunities). In short they and others used to work hard at their game. I have closely watched CB over the past 6 games and I have not seen any such effort, determination or focus. Instead I have watched a player being a shadow of his former Aston Villa self. Others have pointed to his lack of movement and a footballing brain so I am not going to go into that detail here.

Ian Wright on MOTD repeatedly picked out his weaknesses against Burnley, namely his positioning and inability to attack the ball in the air. Yesterday he could and should have got two maybe three goals, that's what we paid the big bucks for and he has been given every chance to prove himself but as I have said previously he is like driving a car with the hand brake on.

There is no desire in his actions or eyes unlike Sako who looks hungary and scares defenders. For that matter what about Kelly's incredible chase and slide tackle at the end if the first half.

I fear that we will never see the Benteke of old, he was hungary but has now been well and truly fed to the point where his thinking is why should I really put myself out when I have untold riches with no one competing for my place and a contract that protects me with another possible big pay day coming up, if sold.

Can you imagine what we would be like with a dynamic big centre forward who terrorises the centre halves and bangs in his fair share of chances?

Saying all this I would dearly love to see CB release the hand brake but fear this just too much to hope...there we go again!


Look at the front 3 that Klopp played against City and has selected all season, there is no traditional centre forward of Benteke’s type. He was never likely to be in Klopp’s plans due to the formation and style of football that Klopp played hence why he was available to us. To say he was therefore given a fair chance under Klopp is simply incorrect.


Edited by rattus2002 (15 Jan 2018 1.47am)

 

pssguy Flag 15 Jan 18 2.01am

Originally posted by rattus2002

Look at the front 3 that Klopp played against City and has selected all season, there is no traditional centre forward of Benteke’s type. He was never likely to be in Klopp’s plans due to the formation and style of football that Klopp played hence why he was available to us. To say he was therefore given a fair chance under Klopp is simply incorrect.


Edited by rattus2002 (15 Jan 2018 1.47am)

Agreed. He really didn't do too badly there. Only 14 starts in League and nabbed 9 goals. Only Firmino with 10 bettered him that season

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 15 Jan 18 8.40am

Originally posted by mattteo


Everything is an aggregate of a selected fact.
The fact that I'm tall is an aggregate of my centimeters.
The fact that we eat 3 times a day is an aggregate of our daily habits.
The fact that they don't reflect the entire information about us as persons is another thing, but nothing ever gives ALL the information.

Still, statistics are facts.

Defined as:

"a fact or piece of data obtained from a study of a large quantity of numerical data."

So, not necessarily a fact nor do they necessarily paint the entire picture. Football is so fundamentally subjective that any statistics produced will be flawed. The variables are so great that it is impossible to state many of them are indeed 'fact'.

The 'fact' is we're a better team with Benteke playing as demonstrated by the win/lose/draw stats and there (here comes the subjective) appears to be much less criticism of the team's performance compared with when he's been absent.

IMHO. he's been better of late but his confidence is shot - it was before the penalty incident & that has only made it worse. Maybe, just maybe, having Sako up alongside him will give him what he needs to get back to form? All I know is that Roy and the staff are far more qualified than any of us to judge what is best for the team. Fact.


Edited by Nobbybm (15 Jan 2018 8.41am)

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

YT Flag Oxford 15 Jan 18 8.51am

Originally posted by spartakev2

I support every palace player, providing they give 100%. Sadly I don't feel he is. Nothing would please me more than him getting a hatrick against arsenal and going on a good run of goals, but I just can't see it happening.

I can’t see that happening with most strikers in the world TBF.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

The Dolphin Flag 15 Jan 18 8.57am

My worry is that despite him helping the team it is not just that he can't score.
In fact he can't even hit the target!
It is not as if keepers are making great saves the fact is that he couldn't hit a cow's backside with a banjo right now!
That is a real concern.
Given the chances he gets he just plain misses the goal completely.

Edited by The Dolphin (15 Jan 2018 9.01am)

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 15 Jan 18 12.53pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

My worry is that despite him helping the team it is not just that he can't score.
In fact he can't even hit the target!
It is not as if keepers are making great saves the fact is that he couldn't hit a cow's backside with a banjo right now!
That is a real concern.
Given the chances he gets he just plain misses the goal completely.

Edited by The Dolphin (15 Jan 2018 9.01am)

But that helps the team by time wasting...

 

Page 12 of 166 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread