You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Sorloth thread
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Sorloth thread


Page 12 of 54 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
jimruss Flag Sidcup 01 Nov 18 9.42am

Originally posted by Willo

I believe we paid £9 Mill with add-ons could rise to £16.5 Mill for Sorloth.

If those add-ons include appearances, goals and winning a cup then we've nothing to worry about.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 Nov 18 9.42am

Originally posted by Bangell

Truly a 'not fit to wear the shirt' player - I cannot remember a Palace player with less passion and commitment.

We've had plenty of donkeys down the years, but it's disgraceful to see someone make it quite so obvious that he views playing for our team as a chore. Barely presses or pressures defenders, doesn't challenge for headers - even goal-scoring opportunities in the box - and makes lazy, petulant fouls rather than accepting any sort of defensive duty.

Benteke's laziness and unwillingness to put himself about pissed me off enough, but Sorloth is another level. Unless this arrogant kid gets a serious rocket up his arse soon, he'll be prancing into the CPFC Useless Striker Hall of Fame without even the qualification that he tried to put some effort in.

Agreed. He may not be "ready" for the PL but how does that excuse the lack of effort. We have had plenty of duds in the past but at least they ran around like headless chickens. For god's sake man show some effort.

 


One more point

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Nov 18 9.54am

He's come from Danish football where the pace of the game is different to that of the PL and English football in general, also it is a big step up for him.

Playing now and then from the bench perhaps won't help his adjustment and maybe he is a player who would greatly benefit from a Loan move in January to a club where he will play on a regular basis.Collymore went to Southend and he was a different player after that.

Edited by Willo (01 Nov 2018 9.56am)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Nov 18 9.55am

I think Sorloth's performances say more about the quality of Palace's scouting and recruitment than the player himself.

After nearly a year at the club and receiving a level of coaching way beyond what he had experienced before, there looks to have been no discernible improvement or progression from when he signed in January.


Of course a bigger club can afford to pay £9m for the potential and just loan him out and develop his game in that way. We can't do that, we need players that can quickly contribute. So far this has been a ' fail '

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Jacey Flag 01 Nov 18 10.00am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think Sorloth's performances say more about the quality of Palace's scouting and recruitment than the player himself.

After nearly a year at the club and receiving a level of coaching way beyond what he had experienced before, there looks to have been no discernible improvement or progression from when he signed in January.


Of course a bigger club can afford to pay £9m for the potential and just loan him out and develop his game in that way. We can't do that, we need players that can quickly contribute. So far this has been a ' fail '

But would he be an asset in the Championship??

 

Fatherken Flag 01 Nov 18 10.14am

no

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 01 Nov 18 10.25am

He just doesnt look to have the drive to be a PL player. Maybe thats just his demeanour and I shouldnt read anything into it but he lacks effort imo. And quality.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Nov 18 10.26am

Originally posted by Willo

He's come from Danish football where the pace of the game is different to that of the PL and English football in general, also it is a big step up for him.

Playing now and then from the bench perhaps won't help his adjustment and maybe he is a player who would greatly benefit from a Loan move in January to a club where he will play on a regular basis.Collymore went to Southend and he was a different player after that.

Edited by Willo (01 Nov 2018 9.56am)

Please don’t make comparisons with Collymore, who had Wright and Bright in front of him. Sorloth may of come from the Danish league, but that is no excuse for being totally useless.
I think even you would show more passion and desire, if given an opportunity to play, though you may struggle with the pace of the game.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Nov 18 10.32am

Originally posted by Painter

Please don’t make comparisons with Collymore, who had Wright and Bright in front of him. Sorloth may of come from the Danish league, but that is no excuse for being totally useless.
I think even you would show more passion and desire, if given an opportunity to play, though you may struggle with the pace of the game.

Yes I know he was behind Wright and Bright but when he did come on as sub he looked well short of the quality expected.I recall a game in which all he had to do was score from close range with the keeper stranded,he scuffed his shot and the ball hit the post !

Point I am making is that Collymore greatly benefited from a loan move where instead of bit-part appearances he was getting regular game time and this transformed his career.Perhaps this will happen with Sorloth.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 01 Nov 18 10.37am

Originally posted by Willo

Yes I know he was behind Wright and Bright but when he did come on as sub he looked well short of the quality expected.I recall a game in which all he had to do was score from close range with the keeper stranded,he scuffed his shot and the ball hit the post !

Point I am making is that Collymore greatly benefited from a loan move where instead of bit-part appearances he was getting regular game time and this transformed his career.Perhaps this will happen with Sorloth.

I agree with you Willo

Stan was pony at first, it wasn't that he couldn't get past Wright and Bright. He was our fastest runner yet looked disinterested and didn't work hard. He had a few opportunities, often from the bench, and was really poor. OK, maybe he just couldn't get into his stride. He certainly came back from Southend a changed man.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 01 Nov 18 10.37am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think Sorloth's performances say more about the quality of Palace's scouting and recruitment than the player himself.

After nearly a year at the club and receiving a level of coaching way beyond what he had experienced before, there looks to have been no discernible improvement or progression from when he signed in January.

Of course a bigger club can afford to pay £9m for the potential and just loan him out and develop his game in that way. We can't do that, we need players that can quickly contribute. So far this has been a ' fail '

I was thinking last night he seems to have gone backwards. At least he had enthusiasm in January

 

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Nov 18 10.39am

Originally posted by Willo

Yes I know he was behind Wright and Bright but when he did come on as sub he looked well short of the quality expected.I recall a game in which all he had to do was score from close range with the keeper stranded,he scuffed his shot and the ball hit the post !

Point I am making is that Collymore greatly benefited from a loan move where instead of bit-part appearances he was getting regular game time and this transformed his career.Perhaps this will happen with Sorloth.

A loan move will not improve the basic problem, that he is useless. He looks more like the Tin Man than a footballer, a sad indictment of Norwegian football.

 

20 Spaces Isnt Enoug Flag Bolton 01 Nov 18 10.41am

Originally posted by Willo

Yes I know he was behind Wright and Bright but when he did come on as sub he looked well short of the quality expected.I recall a game in which all he had to do was score from close range with the keeper stranded,he scuffed his shot and the ball hit the post !

Point I am making is that Collymore greatly benefited from a loan move where instead of bit-part appearances he was getting regular game time and this transformed his career.Perhaps this will happen with Sorloth.


I disagree....I and many others loved Collymore at Palace. It's a shame because of circumstances he was mainly used off the bench.....but we all could see the quality.

A reason for his departure may be that by his own admission, he didn't fit in in the dressing room and he as a 'newbie' from non-league was mocked for his dress sense and broad midlands accent.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 01 Nov 18 10.46am

What's interesting is ex-Arsenal striker Charlie Nicholas was saying last weekend that he thinks Sorloth runs around too much.

He appealed for him to: Stand still and be the target man your team needs and bring others into the game."

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Nov 18 10.46am

I don’t think think Sorloth or Ayew did themselves any favours with those performances last night.
There was no chemistry or link up play between them and I don’t think either had an effort on goal.
With Benteke’s injury they have had plenty of opportunities this season and neither have looked remotely a viable option.
In January I think we need to re-evaluate our strikers.
I don’t want us to take up the Ayew purchase option, would like Sorloth loaned out to a championship club in the hope there is potential there.
We need two new strikers in (one could be a loan deal).
Arguably one would suffice if Wickham can return to form and fitness.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 01 Nov 18 10.47am

It doesn't really matter where Sorloth came from. However it is absolutely clear that he hasn't got the aggression, determination, strength or guile required for the Premiership.
Last weeks cameo from the bench gave him a bit of space to run around in.
However last night he didn't win a single header in the box or have a shot either!
At least an inch taller and 4 years younger than Ayala he should have be causing aeriel havoc in the penalty box.
As it has been mentioned already been with us long enough now where's the improvement? I think that's it as far as he is concerned.

 

premier fan Flag BR4 01 Nov 18 10.48am

Originally posted by Willo

I believe we paid £9 Mill with add-ons could rise to £16.5 Mill for Sorloth.

9m for Sorloth? who the hell scouted him? they should be sacked immediately.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 01 Nov 18 10.49am

Would be better just to cut our losses and see about offloading him back to a European league. For the money we paid, we could have looked at a decent championship level striker (and lets face it they could have done any worse).

The same goes for Ayew, send him back in January if we can. There is a reason he has been relegated twice, he is not a goalscorer. Relying upon him, will get you relegated.

 

Skip Flag 01 Nov 18 12.47pm

Probably the worst signing since our promotion, although Kebe may run him close. Our options up front are pretty dire with an out of sorts Benteke, a disinterested Ayew and Sorloth who is clearly not up to it and doesn't even try to be.

Compare them with who we had in 2013/14 of Jerome, Murray, Chamakh and Gayle and I think it is clear that we were in better shape striker wise in our first season in the Premier League than we are now.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 01 Nov 18 12.52pm

Originally posted by Skip

Probably the worst signing since our promotion, although Kebe may run him close. Our options up front are pretty dire with an out of sorts Benteke, a disinterested Ayew and Sorloth who is clearly not up to it and doesn't even try to be.

Compare them with who we had in 2013/14 of Jerome, Murray, Chamakh and Gayle and I think it is clear that we were in better shape striker wise in our first season in the Premier League than we are now.

I would take Chamakh and Gayle any day over Sorloth and Ayew, any day.

As for Glenn Murray, letting him go was one of the worst errors Parish ever made.

Would take Cameron Jerome alone over Ayew or Sorloth in fact.

There is your progress.....

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Page 12 of 54 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Sorloth thread