You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson
November 16 2026 3.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson


Page 12 of 27 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
silvertop Flag Portishead 19 Dec 23 4.46pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Not at all.

I recognise the frustrations that people have with him, some of which I have myself, nobody’s perfect.

My position is clear ; when Hodgson was re-appointed this season did people seriously think he was going to change his methodology ? If there was to be a continuation of the shift towards more front footed football that we saw at the end of last season, well he’s simply not had the players available to do that. Still, gives people like you something to moan about.

Given his emphasis on team shape, he’s highly unlikely to place trust in youth over experience. Some on here were advocating the likes of Rob Street, Niya Kirby etc to be put in the first team when they patently weren’t good enough. Of the next batch of young players coming through, Ozoh is being developed, Jes will get game time when fit again and Franca continues to progress - let’s hope more can step up. As somebody that watches as many games as possible at U18 and 21 level, my view is that there isn’t anyone else that is ready to bridge that playing gap at the moment.

In conclusion, I value Hodgson and his coaching staff’s opinion over yours - and indeed over mine.

If I have changed my view of one person in recent months, it’s of Steve Parish. Not of Hodgson.

Pray expand.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 19 Dec 23 5.22pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Despite making Beardsley and Dowie look like sex gods, I agree with you.


He's definitely more of a Dowie than a Pardew but if that means there's no threat of him shagging any of the players' wives then I think it's a good thing.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

PatrickA Flag London 19 Dec 23 5.34pm

Perhaps too much emphasis is on the manager rather than the players available.

Think Vieira in his first season ; a fit and firing balanced midfield of Gallagher, McArthur and Kouyate all in form and pressing from the front which enabled us to play further up the field .
In their absence and towards the end Vieira became cautious, sat the team deeper and seemed to lose confidence leading to poor results and lack of efforts on goal.

Think Roy at the end of last season; Olise and Eze started playing well and confidence surged leading to improved performances from others in the team.
In the absence of Olise and Eze (and Zaha) this season, however, the team has lacked the craft to undo teams .
It’s likely we would have seen better performances (and better results) this season with those players available.

This is where I have some sympathy of those critical of Roy, and to an extent of Viera before him.
If you haven’t got the craft of Olise and Eze or the energy of Gallagher and McArthur you have to find other ways to threaten the opposition.
This could be through set pieces, more direct play, more crosses, 2 up front on occasions, more efforts on goal.
Not gung ho attack, but selective attacks targeting opponents’ weaknesses as opposed to trying the bore the opposition to death and occasionally nick a result.

To merely shrug your shoulders and say we haven’t got the players to threaten is an absence of taking responsibility.
Find a way to threaten.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 20 Dec 23 9.28am

If we don't get a result against Brighton then i think we should replace imo

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 20 Dec 23 10.49am

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

If we don't get a result against Brighton then i think we should replace imo

We'll probably have enough players available to get something from the Brighton game but shouldn’t be disappointed with one point.
Perhaps we need a few additional players more than a new manager but Cooper's current availability might tempt Parish to bring him on-board earlier than planned?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

cROYdonrogers Flag Leamington Spa 20 Dec 23 11.48am

I'm not convinced about Cooper. He might be good for the younger players. Any managerial appointment by any club has jeopardy. Why risk it now. Roy's Roy and everybody knows what they are getting.
If he's around in the summer then maybe. Rather him than Potter.
He might function better under a more steady regime.
Meantime I'd rather have Roy in charge tomorrow, cos I think he gets it.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 20 Dec 23 12.07pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Who ever does become the next Palace manager the board, must be able to seriously back him by boosting our senior squad with at least three ready to use players.
This could be Cooper , As Forest manager he has comfortably held us twice and beaten us once. That tells me he would want something over what we have.
His knowledge of youth football has to be second to none, except for to say that handling the very best of any age group is always a bonus, and quiet different to finding gems in a mixed group. Having said that he should know one if it’s there.
Give him an improved senior squad and I’d say yes because best of all he is very tactically astute .

I remember this same rhetoric when Peter Taylor was appointed, after managing this under somethings for England. The turned out to be absolutely useless, resorted to signing his son in law, who was useless as well.
Forget Cooper, 2 wins in 28 away games. He had many game ready players signed at Forrest, but couldn’t see the woods for the trees.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 20 Dec 23 6.42pm

Originally posted by Painter

I remember this same rhetoric when Peter Taylor was appointed, after managing this under somethings for England. The turned out to be absolutely useless, resorted to signing his son in law, who was useless as well.
Forget Cooper, 2 wins in 28 away games. He had many game ready players signed at Forrest, but couldn’t see the woods for the trees.

... he certainly got lost at the Forest! I'm open minded about Cooper but we don't need him at the present time.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Putitout Flag Oxford 20 Dec 23 8.41pm

Originally posted by Painter

I remember this same rhetoric when Peter Taylor was appointed, after managing this under somethings for England. The turned out to be absolutely useless, resorted to signing his son in law, who was useless as well.
Forget Cooper, 2 wins in 28 away games. He had many game ready players signed at Forrest, but couldn’t see the woods for the trees.

You could be right. No reason why. not, He done a brilliant job getting them up. Where have you heard that before.? Maybe it’s Burnley. Leeds that rather strange character every one buzzed about. Being the sort of club Palace are , the majority of candidates that would want the job are just not serial winners.
Unless Parish can fill a good solid winner, and they are rare anyway, with more than mere promises of a playing squad that stands a cat in hells chance of them taking us out of our present .levels. Personally for me it’s a Tobola, , problem is far too many actual good ones will say put me back in. To be honest Coopermight well not be one of those, if he did it actually says it all.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 21 Dec 23 9.01am

Originally posted by Painter

I remember this same rhetoric when Peter Taylor was appointed, after managing this under somethings for England. The turned out to be absolutely useless, resorted to signing his son in law, who was useless as well.
Forget Cooper, 2 wins in 28 away games. He had many game ready players signed at Forrest, but couldn’t see the woods for the trees.


Surely we're not saying that because Peter Taylor did badly for us 16 years ago we're not going to give anyone with a background in youth football a chance again.

Either we want a manager who will embrace our young players and academy or, if not, might as well stick with Roy.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 21 Dec 23 10.53am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


Surely we're not saying that because Peter Taylor did badly for us 16 years ago we're not going to give anyone with a background in youth football a chance again.

Either we want a manager who will embrace our young players and academy or, if not, might as well stick with Roy.

By '' embrace '' do you mean sticking the kids in for the sake of it ?

I think the way that Hodgson has managed the likes of Ozoh, Rak-Sakyi and Franca may have erred on the side of caution, but all three are in a position to contribute in the second half of the season. Outside of those players, I don't believe there is anyone looking likely to make the step up from Academy football anytime soon.

Roy always has the finger pointing at him for not picking young players. If you describe that as being risk adverse, well he's working for a club that is the epitome of that. It's all about preserving the place in the EPL.

I refer, once again, to a recent interview with Steve Parish. In response to a question, he said that Palace would be looking to loan experienced players in the January window. Roy also commented yesterday that by doing so they have to factor in the effect on those young players pushing for a place.

So just how much of a difference would a new manager make at this moment in time ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

southnorwoodhill Flag 21 Dec 23 5.18pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

By '' embrace '' do you mean sticking the kids in for the sake of it ?

I think the way that Hodgson has managed the likes of Ozoh, Rak-Sakyi and Franca may have erred on the side of caution, but all three are in a position to contribute in the second half of the season. Outside of those players, I don't believe there is anyone looking likely to make the step up from Academy football anytime soon.

Roy always has the finger pointing at him for not picking young players. If you describe that as being risk adverse, well he's working for a club that is the epitome of that. It's all about preserving the place in the EPL.

I refer, once again, to a recent interview with Steve Parish. In response to a question, he said that Palace would be looking to loan experienced players in the January window. Roy also commented yesterday that by doing so they have to factor in the effect on those young players pushing for a place.

So just how much of a difference would a new manager make at this moment in time ?

It's baffling. January sales, it's a time when a club tries to offload some overpriced and overpaid duffers onto a desperate recipient club. Palace of course fit the bill perfectly - Remi, Tosun, Batshuayi all spring immediately to mind.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 21 Dec 23 10.57pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

By '' embrace '' do you mean sticking the kids in for the sake of it ?

I think the way that Hodgson has managed the likes of Ozoh, Rak-Sakyi and Franca may have erred on the side of caution, but all three are in a position to contribute in the second half of the season. Outside of those players, I don't believe there is anyone looking likely to make the step up from Academy football anytime soon.

Roy always has the finger pointing at him for not picking young players. If you describe that as being risk adverse, well he's working for a club that is the epitome of that. It's all about preserving the place in the EPL.

I refer, once again, to a recent interview with Steve Parish. In response to a question, he said that Palace would be looking to loan experienced players in the January window. Roy also commented yesterday that by doing so they have to factor in the effect on those young players pushing for a place.

So just how much of a difference would a new manager make at this moment in time ?


No, of course not.

There is a clear middle ground between irresponsibly throwing young players in for the sake of it, potentially damaging them, and what Roy does.

The way that Roy plays requires discipline and experience, which is why he distrusts young players and prefers players like Ayew who might not set the world alight but will give you a solid, reliable effort every time.

An example of an occasion when this manifests itself to ridiculous effect would be the West Ham game, where Jairo Riedewald ended up on the left wing while Franca, Ebiowei and Ahamada sat on the bench.

If you want a compact, organised defensive team then Roy is your man. But we are clearly setting up the club so that the academy becomes hugely important and I don't believe that those young players are being trained to play in that manner.

I also don't believe that our system allows young players to come in and thrive. We've been in this league for over a decade now, is it not time to try and do something a tad more progressive?

Ultimately Vieira was sacked after taking 5 points from 11 games. Roy has taken 7 points from 11 games and with easier fixtures. We're sleepwalking into a relegation battle and if this horrid style of football isn't even guaranteed to keep us safe then why are we still suffering it?

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

PatrickA Flag London 22 Dec 23 10.45am

Some valid points.
If Roy's methods were delivering results and demonstrating evidence of progress then it could just about be tolerable.
However, we've won just 4 in 18 and only 1 at home with nearly half of the season gone.
De Zebri had an experienced bench yesterday, but still elected to play the young players and trust them to continue their development.
Roy would probably have played the experienced players as they were familiar with his methods and he wouldn't have the risk of the young players making a mistake.
It's probably right for Roy and his methods, but is it right for the club?
We're not getting the results or performances and the young players are not developing.


Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


No, of course not.

There is a clear middle ground between irresponsibly throwing young players in for the sake of it, potentially damaging them, and what Roy does.

The way that Roy plays requires discipline and experience, which is why he distrusts young players and prefers players like Ayew who might not set the world alight but will give you a solid, reliable effort every time.

An example of an occasion when this manifests itself to ridiculous effect would be the West Ham game, where Jairo Riedewald ended up on the left wing while Franca, Ebiowei and Ahamada sat on the bench.

If you want a compact, organised defensive team then Roy is your man. But we are clearly setting up the club so that the academy becomes hugely important and I don't believe that those young players are being trained to play in that manner.

I also don't believe that our system allows young players to come in and thrive. We've been in this league for over a decade now, is it not time to try and do something a tad more progressive?

Ultimately Vieira was sacked after taking 5 points from 11 games. Roy has taken 7 points from 11 games and with easier fixtures. We're sleepwalking into a relegation battle and if this horrid style of football isn't even guaranteed to keep us safe then why are we still suffering it?

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 22 Dec 23 11.13am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

{Roy has taken 7 points from 11 games and with easier fixtures. ]

Actually Roy has taken 18 points from 18 games We are only ONE point behind 12th place with another twenty to play

I remember Stoke City fans moaning about Pullis and his so called boring football so much so they got him the sack.

Be careful what you wish for!

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Dec 23 11.18am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Some valid points.
If Roy's methods were delivering results and demonstrating evidence of progress then it could just about be tolerable.
However, we've won just 4 in 18 and only 1 at home with nearly half of the season gone.
De Zebri had an experienced bench yesterday, but still elected to play the young players and trust them to continue their development.
Roy would probably have played the experienced players as they were familiar with his methods and he wouldn't have the risk of the young players making a mistake.
It's probably right for Roy and his methods, but is it right for the club?
We're not getting the results or performances and the young players are not developing.

Well now you are starting to see where I’ve been coming from.

Moaning about Roy is of course people’s prerogative. But did you seriously think he was going to change his tried and trusted methodology ? Did Steve Parish when he re-appointed him ? Rhetorical questions and the answers are a “no” in both cases I’m sure.

I think results have been impacted by injuries and the strength in depth of the playing squad. Take those factors out and you could lay the blame firmly at the managers door. Which some are choosing to do anyway.

Is it right for the club you ask - that’s a question for Steve Parish. The guy that recently said we will be looking to loan experienced players in January. Potentially blocking the progress of some of the younger players.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Dec 23 11.32am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


No, of course not.

There is a clear middle ground between irresponsibly throwing young players in for the sake of it, potentially damaging them, and what Roy does.

The way that Roy plays requires discipline and experience, which is why he distrusts young players and prefers players like Ayew who might not set the world alight but will give you a solid, reliable effort every time.

An example of an occasion when this manifests itself to ridiculous effect would be the West Ham game, where Jairo Riedewald ended up on the left wing while Franca, Ebiowei and Ahamada sat on the bench.

If you want a compact, organised defensive team then Roy is your man. But we are clearly setting up the club so that the academy becomes hugely important and I don't believe that those young players are being trained to play in that manner.

I also don't believe that our system allows young players to come in and thrive. We've been in this league for over a decade now, is it not time to try and do something a tad more progressive?

Ultimately Vieira was sacked after taking 5 points from 11 games. Roy has taken 7 points from 11 games and with easier fixtures. We're sleepwalking into a relegation battle and if this horrid style of football isn't even guaranteed to keep us safe then why are we still suffering it?

Leaving aside for a moment Roy’s methods which we are all familiar with.

Yes much has been of the new Academy. The infrastructure looks superb and the club can be rightly proud of it.

But once the players step onto the field just what is the quality of coaching they are receiving ? And as you say, usually the Academy teams follow the first team’s blueprint in terms of playing style - little evidence of that from the games I watch.

So I think it’s down to the short term thinking at the top which ( understandably ) has Premier League survival as it overriding priority.

If we do a comparison with Brighton from last night’s performance, it looks apparent that all of their teams are coached in the same way. But then they have been better at planning and implementing than Palace for a while now.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Dec 23 12.56pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Some valid points.
If Roy's methods were delivering results and demonstrating evidence of progress then it could just about be tolerable.
However, we've won just 4 in 18 and only 1 at home with nearly half of the season gone.
De Zebri had an experienced bench yesterday, but still elected to play the young players and trust them to continue their development.
Roy would probably have played the experienced players as they were familiar with his methods and he wouldn't have the risk of the young players making a mistake.
It's probably right for Roy and his methods, but is it right for the club?
We're not getting the results or performances and the young players are not developing.

I think you’re getting confused again, De Zebri used Lallana and Welbeck who couldn’t be considered young players by any stretch. He used Buonanotte a young player and Roy used Ozoh a young player.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 22 Dec 23 1.04pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


No, of course not.

There is a clear middle ground between irresponsibly throwing young players in for the sake of it, potentially damaging them, and what Roy does.

The way that Roy plays requires discipline and experience, which is why he distrusts young players and prefers players like Ayew who might not set the world alight but will give you a solid, reliable effort every time.

An example of an occasion when this manifests itself to ridiculous effect would be the West Ham game, where Jairo Riedewald ended up on the left wing while Franca, Ebiowei and Ahamada sat on the bench.

If you want a compact, organised defensive team then Roy is your man. But we are clearly setting up the club so that the academy becomes hugely important and I don't believe that those young players are being trained to play in that manner.

I also don't believe that our system allows young players to come in and thrive. We've been in this league for over a decade now, is it not time to try and do something a tad more progressive?

Ultimately Vieira was sacked after taking 5 points from 11 games. Roy has taken 7 points from 11 games and with easier fixtures. We're sleepwalking into a relegation battle and if this horrid style of football isn't even guaranteed to keep us safe then why are we still suffering it?

Agreed.

 

PatrickA Flag London 22 Dec 23 1.52pm

Not confused at all; it's more likely you've misunderstood the point.
De Zebri started two 19 year olds and introduced an 18 year old in the second half who changed the game.
This despite having an experienced bench.
Roy would not do this as he prefers experienced players who understand his methods of 9 behind the ball.
These methods have led to one home win all season and some abject performances.
The expectations are such that draws at home to Fulham, Brighton and Forest are almost celebrated and defeats to Bournemouth and Everton are almost accepted.
We continue to be overtaken by progressive clubs, who develop young players play on the front foot and will make innovative tactical changes during the game.
Roy is not soley responsible for the malaise at the club, but his methods and approach are surely part of the problem.
Neither the performances nor the results are good, we are not seeing the young players develop and the club gives the appearance of going backwards.


Originally posted by Painter

 

Page 12 of 27 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson